Immediately upon walking in Rock Hill Creamery there is a warmth and a friendliness that pervades…read morethe atmosphere. Somehow you sense you're in the right place. Ask for a sample---and you're met with a smile. And as for the homemade ice cream, well, THAT'S where it really gets good. Lovely flavors made with wholesome, fresh ingredients. A throwback to when food was really food. Don't take my word for it, try this delicious-ness for yourself, but be forewarned---you WILL be hooked!

Nice selection of flavors, delicious ice cream, prompt and friendly staff, that happy ice cream…read moreshop vibe. Located in the heart of Shepherdstown.

Ice cream was very good. The pricing was weird - albeit misleading…read more I got a small raspberry truffle cup. I got my husband a large sundae bc it was posted as 7.75 for a small or 8.00 for a large. I even questioned this. It was vanilla ice cream hot fudge with sprinkles. It's a sundae so you would expect toppings. It was 1.50 for the fudge and .50 for the "jimmies" aka sprinkles. Nothing on their signage indicates these charges. Will probably go back on occasion but seriously, the pricing needs to be clarified.

Our first visit to the new location on Foxcroft was ok. I…read morereally want to love this place but the experience overall was underwhelming. The positive: Large assortment of frozen treats and bubble teas. Shaved ice, handscoop and softserve icecream. Lots of flavors. Unique speciality frozen treats like flavor ice combos with softserve. Friendly servers. Colorful interior The not so great: Slow service- there were 4 workers, only one person in front of us, and we only ordered 2 plain icecreams and it took 9 minutes to get them Tables way to close together. Ordering/waiting area didnt have a flow. Quality of icecream/softserve average. Undecided if we will go back. My rating rationale +.5 Service +.5 Food~Taste/flavor/quality +1 Presentation +1 Atmosphere/vibe +1 Value

I love ice cream. The staff are very pleasant to be as busy as they can be. I have never had a…read morebad experience.

Very good Hershey's dipped ice cream. Very busy so plan to wait if there's a line. 2 Large sundaes…read morewere $14.89 which seems a bit high to me. Nice to have an ice cream place on this end of town.

4/5 My husband and I…read moredecided to stop by this cute gelato shop in Middletown around 1:30 PM on a Sunday. They had just opened at noon, so we were excited to be some of the first customers and check out the flavors of the day! The young lady working was super friendly, professional, and genuinely seemed happy to be there--which made our experience even better. She kindly offered us samples of several flavors, which helped us narrow down our choices. I ended up going with a scoop of Piña Colada and something new to me called Candy Dream--a purple gelato that surprisingly tasted like strawberries. Super refreshing and different in a good way! I got mine in a waffle cone, but was a little bummed to find out it was the last one already--only an hour after opening. My husband had to go with a sugar cone, which was still tasty, just not his first choice. We originally came in hoping for chocolate, peanut butter, or salted caramel, but learned they rotate flavors daily--so what's on the menu board isn't always available. Just something to know ahead of time if you're craving something specific. Overall, great little spot with delicious gelato and warm, welcoming service. We'll definitely be back to try more flavors (and hopefully snag a waffle cone next time)!

Yummy gelato! We were in town and the kids wanted ice cream. I ordered a medium cup with hazelnut,…read moreespresso and chocolate flavor! Delicious!! The hazelnut was my favorite. My husband got a pint of hazelnut and Creme Brûlée and the kids got a cup of Unicorn flavor since it's color blue. It was really good! Ambience was nice and service was good. If we were going straight home, I would've ordered more pints!

Ice cream and selections were outstanding! The service was great and they were extremely polite…read moreand patient.

GOOD for what it is, a simple stop for treats and nothing commercialized…read more GREAT as a way to support a small and local Veteran owned business.

The ice cream was most excellent, AND they had color-changing spoons which was super fun. Plenty of…read moreseating and quick friendly staff. Great selection of flavors. Also, went here for a midday iced latte that was fabulous and frozen lemonade!

For those who knew my grandma, she never turned down ice cream. So while in town last week for her…read morefuneral, my friend suggested we visit Amy & Alex's Homemade Ice Cream and Coffee. I'm not usually a huge ice cream person, but it felt like the perfect way to honor her. The shop itself was bright, clean, and welcoming, with several people already enjoying their treats. We grabbed a high table by the front window, which made for some great people-watching while we indulged. The menu immediately caught my eye. The range of flavors wasn't just broad--it was creative, unique, and full of options you don't see every day. That foodie spark kicked in, and I knew I had to go with a flight so I could taste a few. (Brilliant idea, by the way--four little cups of different flavors!) Our picks were: Grilled Lime Burnt Honey Crunchy PB Jelly Espresso Mascarpone Lemon Biscotti Brown Butter Pecan & Praline Each scoop came with a color-changing spoon (such a fun touch), and every flavor was creamy, consistent in texture, and absolutely delicious. My favorites were a tie between the Espresso Mascarpone (though I think it could stand strong without the lemon biscotti) and the Brown Butter Pecan & Praline. The Grilled Lime Burnt Honey was bright and unique, and the Crunchy PB Jelly was tasty but leaned a bit sweet for me. Overall, this was some of the best ice cream I've had--flavorful, high-quality, and true to its name. Add in the kind, helpful staff and the clean, cozy atmosphere, and it made for a really special stop. I left not just with a happy palate, but also with a new tradition: every year on August 22, I'll seek out a new ice cream spot in honor of my grandma. Amy & Alex's was the perfect place to start.

When they said lines go down the block? Yup they weren't kidding! Came twice and the first time? We…read morearrived 1:45pm and there were a few people already waiting. Second time? Arrived at 2pm and there was a good amount of people there. Yet the lines moved quickly, CASH ONLY spot, in and out, easy. Dude the ice cream?! It's soooo freaken GOOD! You can taste how fresh the ingredients are like they just made it in the back room! Def a spot you don't want to miss if you're in this small quiet town! Ohh did I mention I got the flurry, boys got 2 scoops each and total was like $12.50!!! That's just insanely cheap! A scoop of ice by me is easily $4-5 alone!

This is easily one of the best ice cream shops I have ever been too. Between us, we got 4 flavors,…read moreall amazing. Great milkshake. Great sundae. Great prices.

Amazing location, milk, cheese, beef available, count me in. Even paninis! I was disappointed by…read morethe lack of variety of ice cream flavors considering this is a dairy. Also, the portion was a bit on the small side. It was delicious but not enough. I plan on stopping by again to check out the atmosphere as it has a beautiful patio with amazing views. You also get to see the cows right as you drive up.

From the moment I pulled in, I knew this place was special and has been one of my favorites on the…read moreMDs best ice cream trail! Cows were free roaming right near the driveway-- close enough that I could snap a few adorable photos from my car. It immediately set such a warm, authentic tone. Walking inside, I was blown away by the selection. Of course, there's ice cream (and what a variety!), but they also offer meats, cheeses, paninis, chips, beef jerky, fromage cups, and more. And the flavored milks? Chocolate, strawberry, and even cookies & cream -- so fun and so fresh! They have both indoor and outdoor seating, so you can enjoy your treats rain or shine. I went with the Cheesecake Collusion ice cream, and wow... if you're on the fence about trying it, consider this your sign to do it!! Creamy, decadent, and absolutely unforgettable. This dairy isn't just a stop -- it's an experience. Between the friendly atmosphere, the variety of delicious options, and those happy cows greeting you at the start, I'd recommend this place again and again. Can't wait to come back!