Best comic book shop in Suffolk County by far. Very helpful and knowledgeable staff. Nice place to…read morego nerd out for a few hours. Amazing selection of fairly priced slabs. Parking is horrible; be careful crossing that road; the drivers are all speeding badly.

Best comic shop on long Island in my opinion. Jason is the owner is awesome…read more A legitimate comic store - tons of keys CGC slabs, magic cards, Pokémon cards, toys, funko, statues. Magic the gathering game night on Sunday's. Can't go wrong in here -- I highly recommend

Brought my Pokémon psycho son in, and the GREAT guy there both knew Everything about Pokémon packs…read moreetc, but when we bought one of them special $11 packs and pulled something which is apparently a great card, the guy (Nathan? I'm sorry I'm bad with names but you're the man!) and my son celebrated TOGETHER. Like, this guy was TRULY happy for my kid, and exciting him even more about it. So much so, my kid asked to take a pic with him and the "awesome pull"

Great selection. Lots of sports cards. Staff is really helpful. Answered all our questions and let…read moreus take our time checking out all the cards. They were very knowledgeable and were super nice. We had a great experience shopping here.

If you can't find at least one item at Milo's, it's hard to imagine why. They offer a wide…read moreselection--ranging from toys, cards, and video games to DVDs, VHS, and vinyl--all priced fairly. With frequent restocks and constantly changing inventory, there's always something new and worth checking out. Plus, be sure to talk to Mike--he's the best and always great to deal with.

When I talk about a great toy store only one comes to mind. Mike and Lauren who run Milo's are…read moreamazing people and are super knowledgeable about all toy lines. Whether you collect vintage or modern they probably have it! Milo's also trades as well. I highly recommend them!

Owner is very nice and always knowledgeable! Threat guy and live his Star Wars collectionread more

I'm so surprised this hidden gem of a store has so few reviews. The staff is friendly and helpful,…read moreand very knowledgeable as to what is in the store. The selection is a high point: they have a huge amount of back issues and other comics, including some really fairly priced key Marvels. This store also has some toys from various collections and decades, and I was surprised to see things like Willow merchandise. It's worth a look and a drive.

Great place. My buddy said they were good people and he was 100% right. The place was a bit on the…read morecramped side and it was pretty packed, assuming it was a MTG night. Prices were really fair and the employees genuinely seemed to take an interest in their customers and enjoyed having them there. I will totally be coming back!

Super-nice owner Bill. Let me talk his ear off about comics for several minutes. Small collection…read moreof comics but cool collection of comic art and some good older comics. Definitely going back.

Unfriendly. Lies about condition. Doesn't mention damages to comics on their eBay and mecari…read morelisting. And even though u are nice and friendly enough to give 5 stars but mention they should me mention any damage in title and description, they leave lies retaliation claiming u r unfriendly when it's then who were unfriendly. Had I seen the feedback sooner I would have returned the book for a full refund and maybe even torn a page for their sleaziness. I'm guessing they are struggling financially bc only people who have hate in their heart would be unfriendly and rude and lie about condition of their merchandise then leave retaliation feedback. Well sir I hope u go bankrupt and have to sell ur entire collection to a place like dirt cheap just to pay your house mortgage. If u have a family I feel sorry for them. U just lost a long term faithful customer bc even though there was damage, I would have still purchased from u but just paid closer attention to your photos bc I didn't notice the damage in the photo but I read the entire description. U r a liar and a cheat and I feel sorry for you. I cannot WAIT until comics go only digital on WEB3 like Veve (Marvel) , Candy (DC) and Virtua Vanguard (Dynamite) and put crappy comics shops like u out of business ​​

Super dope comic book store right on Main Street. They opened about 7 months ago and have been a…read morehuge hit to Pop collectors everywhere. They bring in convention exclusives! If you're a collector or just looking for a gift this is the perfect shop. They have everything! The comics are nicely organized and the store is filled with all sorts of toys, plushies, cards, board games, piggy banks, mugs, everyyyything to feed the nerd in you. So far I've bought something every time I've stopped in. It's hard not to! They have a card that they mark off for every $10 you spend when you fill the card you get $10 off. Deff pay them a visit!

To be honest, I'm not the comic book fan/collector, my hubby is. But I always go with him. On this…read moreparticular day, he unfortunately is working but it's Free Comic Book Day. I'm here to gather up some goodies for him. The shop is set up nicely and is very organized. The owner & his staff are always friendly and willing to answer any questions. There are always customers browsing and buying. There is a large selection of comics of both collectibles and the everyday ones plus more. So if comics are your thing then it's worth your time or if you are just curious about comics -- its's just fun! Enjoy it!

I usually go to Midtown Comics to pick up my usual subscriptions, but I was around the way and…read moredecided to check this place out. Just by driving around the area, you can easily miss this spot because it's in between a couple of spas. The businesses around it kind of throw you off. Luckily, I was driving slow and happened to see it. It's a small place. It wasn't busy -- I guess because it was raining. Upon entering, I saw one person working. There were tables set up and the person working -- who I found out that day is the owner -- was setting up for a Magic Card Tournament. I ended up buying more than I needed to from there. While he was scanning my stuff, we just had a small chit chat. I just wanted to know how long that store's been around...all that good stuff. That's when I found out he was the owner. Great guy. He put us on to some other conventions and events at his store. I recommend dropping by if you're around the way. Great store...and the owner is down to earth and pretty knowledgeable.

This is a great store. I can't believe some absolute jabroni wrote a negative review because of…read moretheir lighting being too good. And, I'm sorry, if you can't figure out parking in this area, you are an absolute idiot. Great store. Great website. Staff is very helpful, but also happy to let you browse on your own. Support small local businesses! Don't be like Matthew C.!

Awesome comic store just off of Main Street in Sayerville…read more The store is decent sized and the young lady working there was very pleasant. They have a decent selection of mostly newer comics and toys as well. They did have some vintage Star Wars toys and some other vintage stuff too but they mostly have more recent comics and toys. Definitely worth stopping in if you're in the area