The best buffalo exchange. I used to live in Williamsburg and would frequent this location often…read more This week I stopped by while on vacation and scored some gems. The pricing is quite fair. The staff are doing research. As a buyer, you'll pay as much as or slightly less than what is being sold on Poshmark or Depop in my opinion. Sometimes you'll get lucky and a limited piece will be priced at what similar items for that brand would be priced ... and that's the thrill of it all. Great quality items that you get to try on and feel. A lot of new with tag items.

Despite my horrible experience with the Chelsea location, this Brooklyn (WILLIAMSBURG) Buffalo…read moreExchange completely brought back my love for thrifting--and for this company in general! I was actually on my way to Beacon's Closet when I took a wrong turn and boom!--Buffalo Exchange appeared right in front of me. I figured, why not check it out since I'd never been to this one before? This location is definitely on the smaller side, but don't let that fool you--you'll find some beautiful pieces here. The staff is absolutely amazing: super friendly, professional, knowledgeable, and best of all, honest. And when I say honest, I mean it. They're very upfront about how low the company's buying percentages are. So if you think you're getting $900 for your $1,400 Balenciaga sneakers, you're sadly mistaken--but they'll tell you exactly what they can offer and even suggest other stores that might better fit your item's value. That kind of integrity and transparency means everything to me. It shows they genuinely care about you and your items. I've already visited twice, and I can confidently say this little Williamsburg shop is hands down the best Buffalo Exchange location. Chelsea and NoHo should definitely come take notes--this is the kind of service every location should strive for. Buffalo Exchange corporate: if every store had this same energy and approach, your brand would truly skyrocket. Thank you, Williamsburg Buffalo Exchange team, for making both of my visits such a great experience. I'll be back in a few days--keep up the amazing work!

This is definitely a curated vintage store and not a thrift shop, and the pricing reflects that…read more They have lots of cute photo opportunities like a neon sign and tv that has a camera in the window. They had a really awesome selection of vintage tshirts. They also had a bunch of really cute skirts. My friend got some new doc martens there that were so cute. The girl who helped get her size was super nice and checked in to see how she was liking them. I would definitely recommend checking this place out, but be sure to go in with the mindset that it is curated vintage and not thrifting as far as the pricing is concerned. They know what their stuff is worth and charge that.

Super cute store in Williamsburg. Lots to pick from a really cute jewelry too.! A must !!read more

The staff is amazing. I wanted a hair clip and dm them. Pics were sent of a few styles and the…read morepurchase was made on Instagram. Excellent communication Custom hair clips

Just happened to stumble in here because something in the window must've attracted my 11year old…read moredaughter. Pretty nice items inside. However, the young woman behind the register didn't even bother to greet us when we walked in and when I said "Hello" she looked up and just said "hi" like it was a bother for her. Didn't make me even feel welcomed and I am BIG on making me feel like I am wanted. It's too bad cause I seen a few items that I would've purchased had the woman been nicer.

I personally wasn't a fan of a lot of the clothes they were selling. Lots of work overalls and…read moreshirts that looked like they needed a wash but I know it's a style choice a lot of people love, just not for me. This place is on the pricier side where you consistently see prices of $50+ which wasn't quite what I was looking for. The old sign above the building said it was a bagel store so it was a little confusing to find as the only other sign indicating it was raggedy threads were the signs on the windows.

The vintage clothes tend toward collectors' items, like original rock tour shirts or ancient auto…read moreshop uniforms, and some of them are more ragged and stained than I've seen in any shop. The proprietor seems to have a special eye for beautifully ruined clothing, and her selectivity is reflected in high prices for a few items. There's new clothing as well, including the softest T-shirts I've found anywhere.

I accompanied my friend to this thrift store to inquire about a pair of shoes she had bought…read morerecently. I'm short, the soles of the shoes popped off the very first time she wore them. When she brought this to the attention of the manager, she was incredibly unapologetic, cold, and offered no compensation for the broken shoes. When you make a significant purchase from a curated consignment store, you expect a certain level of reliability and quality from the products. We were incredibly disappointed with the customer service and durability of this store's products and will certainly not be going back again.

I liked the clothes but some of them were a bit pricey and when I pointed out that there were holes…read morein one of the items, I got sass that it was a good brand in return. I don't expect vintage stores to be this snobby. I would really like it if they were a little more passionate and nice to their customers. My cousin and I were trying to be friendly and said we were looking forward to coming back to the lady and she replied "yeah".

The selection was nice. For some the price made sense but other basic pieces were over inflated. It…read morewas hard to find any pieces over a size 10. It's not just not inclusive sizing, it seemed intentionally petite. It felt aggressive to not include hardly any pieces in L or even a size 12 in this day and age. I was looking and ready to buy for an important occasion. I was really excited to explore the collection but with every flip of the coat rack, I felt a voice saying ' you don't belong here'. I expect more from an independent store in Brooklyn. I'm used to stores having limited stock but none at all was certainly a shock. More so, I wasn't given any attention by the person running the store I felt it was because it was clear I wouldn't fit into any of the garments. It was icy and I felt unwelcome in the space which is awkward because the space is small.

Definitely my favorite vintage boutique in Greenpoint! I'd spent the day hitting vintage and…read moreconsignment shops in the neighborhood without much luck until I went to Mirth. I love the calm color palette and the fact that you can actually buy an outfit! Not just items here and there you hope will work with something already in your closet. I got an Anne Taylor skirt suite and some perfect fitting wool trousers. I was told they also have a location on Bedstuy I'll certainly be checking out :) My subtraction of one star is because some of the items are a little over priced but overall such cute stock

DO NOT BUY ANYTHING FROM THEM. This shop is closed! They recently resurfaced on Instagram (2026),…read moredoing story sales to sell vintage furniture. I remembered shopping in this store and figured it was legitimate but they never delivered the item I bought and stopped responding to my messages for updates or a refund. Posting this here in case it helps to prevent others from being scammed.

Not much interesting things were available. Perhaps because of Christmas rush? I found the…read moreHarlequin across the street had amazing vintage things. I completed all my holiday shopping there

This place is a reminder as to why I hated coming to bushwick. Nowadays everything is just fake…read morevibes and pretentious wanna-bes. I walk in, see a group of other customers and I then go ahead and look around. I was trying to figure out what I needed to buy, there was nobody there to greet me - nothing. Couldn't get help if my life depended on it Then I see this girl sitting there on her phone. I literally approach her snd way "wow nobody greeted me and I need help" she responds with "oh yea" laughs a little and returns back to her game Sorry to bother you ma'am. Didn't find anything and went to the next shop where I did F*cking hate these hipsters and their need to waste my time.

A great little gem of a store. It always has a cool, interesting and unique selection of curated…read morevintage clothing. Prices range from thrift store cheap to higher end vintage prices- all seem fair for the items. Its cute and fun with a truly fun selection that is always changing. Every time I pass the window, I usually gasp at the new show piece and immediately want to go in. Staff are cool and friendly. Highly recommend popping in here on the regular for great vintage finds.