The service and food were excellent. Three of us each had appetizers and different meals. We all…read morefound the flavors were great. We ate on the patio. A lovely evening. The waitress was very patient with a difficult customer nearby.

We dined on the deck last night. Service a little slow but OK. Not thrilled with dinner - fish n…read morechips. So simple yet often so below par. In this case the chips were the wimpy dark brown kind without being crunchy ot crispy. The batter fried Pollock was almost adequate - - but, not - - oily batter crust and mushy fish. Probably fried too long in oil not hot enough.

Cute little spot in the heart of downtown Potsdam. 5 out of 5 stars across the board. For a pizza…read moreshop the staff of two runs a great restaurant as well. For being close to the oven on a hot summer day it was surprisingly comfortable in there. The woman running the desk was so pleasant and attentive despite taking orders and organizing deliveries. The cook sang right along to some classics making a great environment. We went with the standard pepperoni pizza and they nailed it, fresh as hell, just the right crispy to the crust, and perfect mix of some great sauce, cheese and pepperoni. Highly recommend it! The two of us polished off a large it was soooooo good!

Waayyy too greasy for me! The wings aren't even worth trying. You're much better off going to Pizza…read moreHut.

I was looking forward to ordering food from Sergi's since we moved here over 2 years ago from…read moreBoston. The place was definitely hopping busy so my hopes for the food were so very high. I love to find a mom and pop place I could be loyal to but I am afraid my first experience was just ok. I had no problem waiting a hour and 10 mins because they weee very busy. The staff were very nice when I came to pick up my food. So no problems like others have stated in past reviews. We all have good days and bad days so I never judge the experience on staff alone. The Food: The veal parm sandwich with salad was ok- the veal was prepared properly as it was soft and moist ( they must of soaked it in milk). The flavor- was ok and the bread was very good and held up as a sandwich. The Zucchini Fries were tasteless and a great deal of water came through every bite. They were not seasoned properly- it is almost like you have to over season to help with not just taste but to absorb the water from the veg. The combo appetizers were also not seasoned. In a good note, the cheese sticks were nice. The wings were very small and dry, not enough sauce on them. The mushrooms held up well. Would I go again, I think I will try because of the good reviews I have read on YELP. Also the pizza being made right in the front looked good. I hate leaving harsh reviews but maybe it could he taken not as negative but helpful.

Sergi's has always been known for their pizza and pizza rolls (especially around 2 a.m. but their…read moredinners are pretty darn good too... I feel like the waitress has worked there for 100 years, prompt, efficient and a really authentic Italian accent. We ordered veal parmigiana, veal Marsala and rigatoni for the meal. Warm bread and salads accompanied the entrees. It's always dark inside the dining room but the veal is flavorful and tender. Nice meal.

Went in on a Friday night and they were busy but we found a table right away. We were greeted…read morepromptly. The wait staff and kitchen were very knowledgeable about gluten-free. The burger was delicious and the salad was fresh with lots of veggies. Everyone at our table was pleased. Will it stop again.

Low staffed, manager walks around but doesn't help out, we waited almost an hour to have our order…read moretaken then walked out the one server on, tending to a full bar & 6+ tables wasn't getting any help from other servers or the manager. Seems like they can't handle a half full restaurant

Amazing! Food was great and for such a great price. Servers were very sweet and timely! I had a…read morenice cozy experience :)

Big selection of North Country comforts. I was bummed my pountine came with shredded cheese instead…read moreof curds, but the fries and the gravy were tasty. My dad ordered a chicken quesadilla, and it was amazing - jam-packed with chicken and cheese filling. It was probably the last thing I would have ordered, but now I want to go back just to get one for myself. Cafe 56 has a solid selction of sandwiches and tasty desserts. If you come with a local, you'll amost certainly bump into someone you know. Good food for a great value. The staff is friendly, and the vibe is laid back, super casual. Good eatin' happens here.

Was there in Potsdam for a meeting and stopped in on a Thursday evening. Even though it's a butcher…read moreshop and called Hoof and Horn, I actually went in for vegetarian options noted on Yelp. The space is minimalist and gives old fashioned turn of the 20th century vibes. There's obviously a lot of pride and a commitment to local foods here. We ordered the night's cocktail special the New York Sipper -yum- the Raquette salad, two of the small (not small at all) plates that were on special that night: the creamy barley risotto and the butternut squash and mushroom parpadella. As a main course, we shared the house-made mushroom burger, savory and flavorful. Everything was fantastic, with many earthy, fresh and delicious flavors and a variety of textures. We clearly ordered too much food, since the small plates were actually full portion-size. Skipped dessert, although the special was tiramisu. They're under a lot of pressure to compete in Potsdam, but they're doing something that shows classical training and a commitment to quality. Several Finger Lakes wines on the list. Prices are astonishingly low for such an excellent meal. Note: tip is included and there were no "lighter" meats like poultry or fish on the menu. Thus the great vegetarian options, I assume.

We stopped at Hoof and Horn for lunch during our recent visit to Potsdam. Based on what I had…read moreheard, I was expecting a more refined dining experience, but the restaurant felt a bit worn and run-down when we arrived. That said, our server was very attentive and took our orders promptly. My two kids both ordered the special of the day, a short rib ramen, while my wife chose the chicken salad sandwich. I ordered their take on a French dip sandwich. The food was good overall, certainly enjoyable and well-prepared, but nothing really stood out as particularly memorable. While I appreciated the friendly service, the overall experience didn't leave a strong impression on me. It was a decent lunch, but I'm not sure I would make a point of returning on a future visit to the area.

Food was great. I had ravioli and the red sauce was maybe the best sauce I have ever had…read more Restaurant is a bit dated with no A/C (at least when I was there) but still overall a very good experience. Will eat here again.

Mostly good food. Hit and miss. When it's good it's good. When it's bad, it's terrible. The…read moreatmosphere is absolutely fabulous... but the lighting is horrible. They apparently don't have a heating system. We have been here a few times in the winter and I have always worn my coat every time I've come. It's freezing inside here. This is really a shame because it's an awesome venue. It could be spectacular. Dire need of good management and ownership.

Stopped in to grab a pizza mid-week and decided on the spaghetti pizza. It's a pizza crust with…read morespaghetti and your choice of three toppings. It's a little sloppy but was surprised and happy with the flavor. I'd definitely get it again (and add a hot pepper for more kick). The place was fairly noisy as normal and the service was on par as expected. Great casual pizza place.

I love there food here been going for a long time expesually when I was younger it was lively and…read morelovely and even now its still nice just more nostalgic now but cozy and warm but the only other thing now is that the other patrons like to stare you down as soon as you walk in b/c you're not a "regular" or a "familiar" face. They definitely talk about you as you walk in too they start whispering to each other as if you're an alien. Love the pizza and wings and everything else personally. (everyone's taste buds are different and like different things but definitely recommend) I would order and go maybe to a park or something after if you're not from town is probably nicer than going in sit and have people keep looking at you half the time b/c they don't know you when it's busy and towards the end of the day.