Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Lake Varsity Diner

    4.0 (42 reviews)
    InexpensiveDiners, Burgers, Sandwiches
    Open 11:00 am - 7:30 pm

    Lake Varsity Diner Photos

    Business Info

    LAKE VARSITY DINER ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Quiet
    Casual
    Good for kids
    Good for groups

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Lake Varsity Diner

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Garlic mushroom burger with fries and partial pickle(my doing)
    Frank T.

    To start off, this is not my first visit to this establishment. Previous experiences however dictate my overall opinion of this place in this review. This was my third visit in the years since I've started my job nearby, in the middle of nowhere Ohio called Uniontown. This place is down the road in a tiny plaza in the middle of a Rite Aid and a State Farm insurance. Previous visits were subpar. I have a somewhat sensitive stomach, particularly when my body realizes food is either old or not handled properly. This was the case for the prior two visits in which I ordered salads and consequently became ill upon returning to work shortly after. But to focus on today's visit. I don't like to write off places where there is at least good service and hospitality, which this place definitely has. However, this visit would really make or break whether or not I ever come back here again. Place was empty when I came in, not very surprising. Ordered the garlic mushroom burger with fries and a water with lemon. They use paper cups for drinks. As I waited for my food, no one was around so I decided I'd take pictures, including the heavy handed God/"pro-cop" speech someone decided to type up and plaster on every booth in the restaurant. It was pretty cringe and based on others reviews, looks like they don't really care what people think or dont read these reviews anyways. Not surprising given the area we are in. Food came out greasy. Fries could have been down for a bit longer and the burger was mush due to not properly reinforcing the bottom from juices of the mushrooms and burger. Had to knife and fork the fries and burger. Not a fan of pretzel buns, but this one was pretty good. The bill came and I'm of the opinion that the meal, and menu in general, are overpriced based on the quality. The service was good at least. Overall, a typical grease pit of the area with hit or miss food that is overpriced based on the quality, ignoring the God and cop stuff they comfortably display in your vision as you eat. Strange layout, decent music. I haven't completely written them off, but I doubt I'll be craving this experience again any time soon.

    Food for Thought
    Sarah P.

    Down about an hour away from Cleveland for work and decided to stop in this place just because I was hungry. Came in and was greeted and sat right away, booths along the wall and tables in the middle. It's a pretty cute place, with a mix of sports and throw back decor. Above the booth was a "food for thought" little rant about current events. Food was really quick and PHENOMENAL. Burger was huge and came with a ton of fries. Quesadilla was loaded with chicken that was soooo good. Onion rings were good as well, but overall this food was definitely worth the price. Talked to the owner about the rant on the wall and he mentioned that some people got offended. I'd definitely drive an hour to come back here!

    Bill J.

    Open six days a week for lunch and dinner, the Lake Varsity Diner is decorated with a high-school sports theme. The widely-varied menu offers many items that have sports metaphors in the name. Gourmet burgers and the endless fries are a staple here, but the menu has expanded over the years to offer salads, chicken sandwiches, steak sandwiches, reubens, other sandwiches and even a few Mexican/Italian items. The milkshakes are excellent. Wings are hot and spicy. One nice touch is the Diet Dr Pepper available as a fountain drink. Any fans of Diet Coke probably hates Diet Pepsi, and it is good to have a diet alternative with the Diet Dr. Pepper. Each month, they offer a special sandwich and a special milkshake flavor, as well as daily specials. Friendly staff of young people, plus the owner or his wife will check in with you every time you go.

    Retro-style set up; great atmosphere :)

    See all

    10 years ago

    .20 for Water! $30 for 2 sandwiches and water is absolutely ridiculous ! The service was not very good either

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Lake Varsity Diner

    Review Highlights - Lake Varsity Diner

    The sandwiches are big and you get tons of (endless) fries.

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    CleaveLand Grill - Strongsville - Grilled chicken sandwich with the works

    CleaveLand Grill - Strongsville

    4.7(119 reviews)
    31.1 mi
    $$

    We came in for lunch on a weekday, soon after they began serving lunch for the day and they were…read moresteady with business. The guy at the register was very helpful with the menu and suggestions. They were quick to make our food and we enjoyed it there. They make smashburger style meat for their burgers and it was nicely seasoned. The texture was on the dry side though. The buns and toppings were great. There fries were also very nice, crunchy, and spiced well. This is mostly a carry-out joint, but they have a couple of tables inside to eat at. Overall, nice place for lunch.

    I'm still giving this a 5 even though it's more like a 4 star…read more First of all, I understand the lack of consistency, considering that two people can't work at the same place at the same time. But whoever is grilling the burgers at the other location is who is keeping me coming back. Other than that, other location is farther from me, it's worth a drive. What I really like about this place is the fresh meat and the disclaimer about the meats and how it's prepare. Well, I didn't like this time around is at the meat lacked seasoning, and the meat did not have that crispy edge or the juiciness in comparison to the other location. Unfortunately, I will not be back to this location unless I'm really thirsty for a good burger. If this is your first time at this location, then yes it's delicious. It's one of the best burgers in Cleveland. If you visit the other location first you're definitely gonna be disappointed when you go to this one.

    Photos
    CleaveLand Grill - Strongsville - Picnic seating.

    Picnic seating.

    CleaveLand Grill - Strongsville - Double smash burger

    Double smash burger

    CleaveLand Grill - Strongsville - Smash burger and loaded fries

    See all

    Smash burger and loaded fries

    D & M Grille - Cheesesteaks & smoked mac & cheese

    D & M Grille

    4.1(10 reviews)
    0.4 mi

    Our company had a "picnic" at our facility and invited D & M Grille to cater our lunch. They…read moreoffered lots of options with sides, and I ordered the Gardenburger with fries. It was delicious and came with lettuce, onion, pickle, chipotle ranch. I added ketchup. There were 6 condiment options as well. The service was accommodating and friendly. The food came out within about 5-10 minutes. Very convenient for accommodating our organization. Definitely recommend for corporate or other events.

    I jump at the chance to visit D & M Grille every time I can. The food and service are high-quality…read moreand unmatched. My go-to order is their Signature Philly cheesesteak, which is made with shaved ribeye and topped with onions, bell peppers, banana pepper rings, and white American cheese. It's a big, delicious sandwich. I love it. You can't go wrong with anything on the menu here. One visit and you see why they consistently earn awards and accolades for the best food truck, best sandwich, best burger etc. If that isn't enough to convince you to try them, check out their dedication to supporting their local community. They spend Thanksgiving preparing and serving free meals to those who would have gone without a hot, fresh dinner. What other food truck does this? The owners are great people and a blessing to the community. If you see their truck at a festival, corporate event, or need a food truck for a party - be sure to give them a try!

    Photos
    D & M Grille - Cajun grilled chicken tenders, smashed redskins,  and fresh vegetables.

    Cajun grilled chicken tenders, smashed redskins, and fresh vegetables.

    D & M Grille - Pan seared salmon filet, steamed broccoli, organic basmati fried vegetable rice.

    Pan seared salmon filet, steamed broccoli, organic basmati fried vegetable rice.

    D & M Grille - Bacon wrapped scallops and vadalia onion toast

    See all

    Bacon wrapped scallops and vadalia onion toast

    Menches Bros Restaurant & Pub - Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap; 1. The "Pops" Double

    Menches Bros Restaurant & Pub

    3.6(133 reviews)
    3.4 mi
    $$

    I visited with a party of 8 at 1PM in the afternoon. I ordered a Buckeye burger smashed and tater…read moretots. My burger tasted wonderful and professionally well made. Since it was smashed it was crispy in the edges with little to no juicy meat but that is what I expected. Actually, I've never had a smash burger (two patties) before. The burger was made as described in the menu. I wish there was more ranch sauce in the burger because I could barely taste it. The bun did an excellent job holding everything together. The taste of the bun, burger, etc was amazing. The tots had a crunchy outside and soft inside--perfect. The service was fantastic. I loved the atmosphere. The dining area to the left of the entrance is where we sat. There were two 55" (?) tvs but no sound. The seated was varied with table and booth seating in the dining area were we sat. They could accommodate for a 10 person party or party of two. A must try if you love burgers.

    Meh. First off it smells like sewage in here which is a huge turn off. The speakers were turned up…read moreway to high considering there was only like 6 people in building. I had a turkey burger it was fine, but a bit salty. My husband and a California burger. He said it was good but had a flavor he couldn't pinpoint and it needed moisture. The fries they brought out were raw, like zero golden color. They tasted like raw potatoes. I asked if they could be cooked more and while the waitress said she would bring out fresh ones she did try and say it was because they were fresh cut. The fresh batch was better, but still not done enough for my liking. They weren't crispy at all just limp and greasy. We don't live in the area, and haven't been here in awhile, probably won't return for awhile either.

    Photos
    Menches Bros Restaurant & Pub
    Menches Bros Restaurant & Pub - Side salad

    Side salad

    Menches Bros Restaurant & Pub

    See all

    Table Six Kitchen + Bar - Lobster street tacos *****

    Table Six Kitchen + Bar

    4.4(958 reviews)
    7.7 mi
    $$

    This was great! I have spent many years eating on the road, and this visit Table Six remains as the…read moretop spot to stop

    We found Table Six through the Karpo app while visiting the Pro Football Hall of Fame, and we're…read moreglad we decided to give it a try. We were seated immediately upon arrival and greeted by a very friendly waitress. She explained that Table Six is a family-owned business, which we always appreciate because we love supporting local, small businesses. She also let us know that everything is made to order and brought out as it's finished. The only aspect we didn't love was that the food arrived as it was completed rather than all at once. While we understand that's part of their made-to-order approach, it's not our preferred dining style. We were unable to eat together without one of us having cold food. The food came out about 10 minutes apart. Based on our waitress's recommendation, we ordered the Roasted Brussels Tacos and the T6 Smash Burger. Both were flavorful and satisfying, and we were happy with our choices. For dessert, we ordered the Peanut Butter Brownie Sundae and The Elvis, a banana pudding dessert with peanut butter. We took both to go and discovered later that the peanut butter topping was accidentally left off The Elvis. While that was disappointing, the banana pudding itself was absolutely delicious and still enjoyable. Between the warm service, family-owned atmosphere, and tasty food, Table Six left a positive impression on us. Despite the small dessert mix-up, we'd definitely return if we're ever back in the area.

    Photos
    Table Six Kitchen + Bar
    Table Six Kitchen + Bar - Cheese burger

    Cheese burger

    Table Six Kitchen + Bar - Hall of Fame Tofu Lomein at Table Six

    See all

    Hall of Fame Tofu Lomein at Table Six

    Lake Varsity Diner - diners - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...