First they said they didnt have an order for me then I showed I already paid then she went to back and got my pizza pizza is the worst pizza I have ever had id prefer Tony's dozen don't waste your time or money there read more

My husband and I went to Eddie's and we ordered personal pizzas to go . We have been here several times but tonight was just not a good experience . Our pizzas were extra sloppy and threw on top of our breadsticks and we both asked for Mariana sauce for our breadsticks , well we got nacho cheese sauce ( yuck) and our breadsticks were soggy from being under the hot messy pizza . And while we were waiting on our food to cook the guy in front of us his food was done and the lady at the register said oh that's not what you ordered he said oh it's ok I'll just pick off what I don't like . They should have offered him a discount but nope nothing he just paid and left with the food he didn't order . I think since the new owner has taken over it's went down hill and we drove almost an hour for this pizza read more

Eddie's Lakeview Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nineveh, Indiana

See all

Great pizza! My friends and I ordered during a late night and loved that it was thin crust. We got half cheese pizza half sausage and loved that it was thin crust. Great, quick service, so overall great experience and would recommend for a quick bite! read more

Eddie's Lakeview Pizza - Half cheese half sausage extra large pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nineveh, Indiana

Two pizzas ordered. The 100 pounder could not have had 100 pepperonis nor the pound of cheese. The Hawaiian pizza was inedible. Underbaked and totally limp. $48 plus tip. Never again. Delivery person was very nice. Only positive. read more

My wife order food today and it was wrong when we got it home she called and was like I still need this and they charged full price to replace our part of the order that was wrong. We hav been going here for 20 plus years but since new owners it has seem to gone down hill. I understand people complain I never have before today. read more

I'd rather eat cardboard boxes than anything from here. Just awful. The pizza is a premade crust and they pile on additional toppings to make it super soggy...also the garlic bread is just a slab of greasy plastic cheese on an even more greasy sloppy bread. I've not had anything edible here in the couple times I've ordered. Lesson learned and it's a shame because they could have something really great. read more

Really really good pizza and prompt delivery. We ordered extra cheese and it was fantastic. read more

Eddies has been an area favorite for a long time. I was hopeful the new owners would keep tradition alive. However our pizza and wings were gas station quality. The wings are now breaded and lack flavor. The pizza did not even resemble Eddies pizza. The cheese is a different color and consistency. I was so disappointed. Please for the love of all things delicious either put it back or change the name. You are no longer Eddies Lakeview Pizza. read more

Staying in the area for military training and we wanted pizza. We travel a lot and like to seek out local places instead of the normal chain places. Found Eddie's online and after reading the positive reviews decided to give it a try. Service was friendly. We took it to go so really didn't get to see the inside too long. Now to the pizza. We wouldn't buy it again. It was the most bland pizza I've ever had. No seasoning at all in the toppings or sauce. The crust is definitely the same prepackaged crust I buy from a store when I make pizza at home. That's not necessarily bad, as I like that crust, but you have to have the toppings and sauce seasoned right in order to make it all work. The pizza sauce itself had no flavor. It tasted just like tomato paste straight from the can. The works pizza had a ton of toppings, which we like, but again absolutely no flavor or seasoning of any kind. And, although we had to wait a couple minutes for it all to be ready when we came in to pick up the order, the works pizza was cold in the center (toppings) as soon as we checked it in the car. We also got a pepperoni pizza and it was the same as far as crust and sauce and no flavor. Overall glad we checked it out, but we definitely wouldn't order it again the next time we are in the area. read more

Eddie's Lakeview Pizza - The works pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nineveh, Indiana

save your money and go to dominoes its worth the drive bc this place is disgusting I had a 1 topping pizza and bread sticks and after not eating all day I still couldn't get myself to eat this if I could give it 0 stars I would read more

Always great food and fast delivery! Courteous delivery driver Highly recommend Eddie's Lakeview Pizza!

Love this place! I have been a regular customer since 1996! Eddie is a great guy! The pizza always hot, fresh and loaded with lots of toppings. read more

Excellent pizza and service. The quality of the food was great. The prices were good and we got our pizza very quickly. Living in a remote area like Nineveh it is nice to have a close place to go to for a good pizza. read more

I'm giving three stars because we didn't eat here but, here's why we didn't stay: First, there is no actual Lakeview - there's a tiny pond called Pepperoni Pond and we wanted to sit outside but the chairs and tables were wet and dirty. We moved inside where it was dark and the tables were also dirty. We cleaned off our table and turned on the lights. The restaurant was completely empty at 5:30pm on a Sunday. The menu really didn't have a lot on it that seemed interesting and the vibe at the restaurant was terrible. So we ended up cutting our losses and leaving. This is NOT a place to eat inside but maybe it's okay for takeout? read more

Only tired it once and frankly speaking onetime was more than enough. Crust was barely cooked (more like raw dough) sauce didn't have much taste; the sausage was like sawdust, cheese was bone white (again not cooked long enough) Maybe I just got a bad one, but once was enough for us. Service was okay, just a bad pizza. read more

Eddie's Pizza is a locally owned pizza joint that "rocks"! Besides the pizza, sandwiches, boneless wings, and all the food being fantastic, Eddie, the owner, gives back to the community! If you haven't tried Eddie's Pizza, you are definitely missing out! read more

I've been a customer for years and have had delivery every time and just recently was told I can no longer receive delivery because my drive way is " too dangerous to back out of " .... Yet I've given them so much of my time and money and support for several years. I'm disappointed and have received several complaints from people I know that are also locals to Eddies and they have told me how rude the owner is. read more

Eddies lakeview pizza has good food at reasonable price . they deliver to the lakes which is very hard to find out here.

LOVE LOVE LOVE their barbecue chicken pizza! I always request extra BBQ sauce and pineapple to make it more of a Hawaiian/ BBQ hybrid. The pizzas are a great size at a reasonable price. The breadsticks and spicy cheese dip are good, too. They also deliver in the immediate area, which is great, though delivery time can be a bit lengthy on weekends and evenings (to be expected). read more

Convenient to the lakes and just good pizza. The cheese is phenomenal! We order a few times a year when we are in the area- never disappointed. Typically just a pepperoni pizza- but very solid and generous with the toppings. Dining area is a little dated but 1) Independent and 2) food make up for decor! read more

Delicious pizza and perfect for a quick pick up dinner on the way to the lake. Their pizza is always so fresh and delicious and they have interesting types of pizza and calzones which is nice to mix up your palette. It's worth a stop by if you have the time! Also a great place for teens to work over the summer if they're down here full time! read more

Great food and great service. Came here on a whim with my kiddo and it was exactly what we were looking for. read more

See all

Best pizza ever! 100 pounder is awesome and meat lovers is perfection. Service is outstanding

Exceptional food and service. We highly recommend their 100 pounder (100 pepperoni pieces and a pound of cheese) and their salads. (Update in 2016: I've had some requests for a photo of their 100 pounder pizza. I moved away from the area over two years ago and unfortunately I didn't snap a photograph of the delicious beast. Even now after all these years it is one of the best pepperoni pizzas I've ever had. Highly recommend!) read more

Frozen pizza crust. Frozen. Pizza. Crust. I can't--if you don't outdo a grade school cafeteria, then why are you in business? And they're not cheap either. Not expensive either, but if you're not expressly trying to be cut-rate then why cut the corner? Learn to make pizza crust. Unfortunately nothing in Edinburgh was worth the drive. You poor Hoosiers. read more

Round pizza cut square? Frozen nasty pizza crust with cheap cheese and cheap sauce.. Elios pizza in my school cafeteria was better..

Best pizza and wings in town Good service reasonable prices makes your mouth water just thinking about it

Very nice pizza pie. Thin crust with lots of toppings. Delivery was fast too. I'll be back. read more

Eddie's Lakeview Pizza - a pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Nineveh, Indiana

Many in the family really like this place. Pizza is good, but sauce is a bit too sweet to me. Thankful they are in the area and deliver.

You control the entertainment! The calzone is amazing. The pizza is great. Great secret spot! read more

Eddie's Lakeview Pizza - a pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nineveh, Indiana

Ordered pizza and breadsticks online. Said it would be ready in 45 minutes. Well, 69 minutes later, still waiting. No explanation for the wait other than they are busy. Restaurant is closed because of covid so I guess online orders are booming. Happy that they are busy in current environment but would like a little honesty on how long it would take to get our order read more

We love Eddie's! The sauce is amazing and the staff is friendly. We get consistently good pizza every time we order -- and that's a lot!

My family has been eating here for YEARS and we always enjoy it. When looking at the outside we spit on unbelievers looks like just a bunch of nothing but it is truly a hole-in-the-wall kinda place. Good place for quick lunch or dinner. Service is also amazing. read more

Wish this place were closer but well worth the trip!! We stumbled upon this place one day and have been talking about it ever since. As pizza enthusiasts, we always set the bar high when we try a new spot. After all, my husband manages a pizza place and we absolutely love the pizza there. However, we do like to try other area haunts. Well this one did not disappoint! From the time we went to the door, we were greeted by the owner and another member of his staff, Hank. Both very engaging characters. The place itself is an unassuming, but we find that many of these places pack the biggest bunch. We couldn't decide what to try first. We decided on a half meats/half cheese pizza and an order of breadsticks. As breadsticks go, these were right up there with some of the best of them. However, the pizza definitely was the star. Loaded with toppings and rich with cheese we couldn't have been more pleased. I know this business has been around for many years now and we expect that this isn't about to change anytime soon! As for this family, we'll be back very soon!! read more

When I read the reviews, I thought the pizza would be good so we were willing to give it a try. Disappointed they didn't deliver (we are 15 minutes away). The pizza was dry, charred black around the edges and mostly tasteless. And luke warm. No way again, and the pizza wasn't cheap either. I should have bought a frozen pizza. read more

The supreme pizza is outstanding!! Lucky to have a local business and delicious pizza located on our lake. Please support Eddie's Pizza!!

Very pleasantly surprised with this little place. Got the family special 100 pounder pizza and breadsticks. Pizza and crust was awesome, breadsticks were good, only complaint was was the cheese dip didn't have much flavor. Not enough to stop me from visiting again though. read more

Eddie and Alicia are amazing! Any chance we get, we go to their place to eat! The food is always fresh and tastes awesome! Nothing beats my hometown pizza place! read more

Eddie's pizza has good tasting pizza and also some good subs, with a great staff to serve you. I don't think I've ever had a problem at Eddie's. Eddie's Pizza supports local baseball teams and the local fire department. Keep up the great work! read more

Every pizza we have had from Eddie's has been delicious. Our kids love the 100 pepperoni and their BBQ chicken. Delivery is great!