Oh man, what a great find! Was turned on to this place by friends and family, and I am super happy with their recommendation. The store is pristine and inviting, the employees are friendly and professional, and the food... the food is simply amazing! Yes it is a little pricey, but to support a local business that offers great food, I am 100% fine with stopping by here. I have and will continue to recommend Legacy Pie to as many people as possible. read more

Legacy Pie -Wash Park - Chicken Pot Pie, amazing and delicious! - Bakeries Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Stopped by the Legacy Pie booth at the City Park farmers market, they were sold out of everything except frozen chicken pot pies. On a whim, I bought it- and WOW was best decision all weekend. I'm glad I asked- you do need to prep some time, cause the pie takes 70-90 minutes to bake. But when I tell you the incredible scent of flakey, bitter goodness that wafted throughout my house- it was delightful!!!! Can't wait to try more pie goodness! read more

See all

I got a mini bison pot pie to go and cook at home and it was great! It's big enough for probably 2 people I would say. The flavor was great. The instructions were super simple. The location is small and cute and has parking! Big win in my books read more

Legacy Pie -Wash Park - Bakeries Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

New flavor alert! Or maybe I simply didn't know it had existed for a while. On Sept 1, 2025, when I made a quick stop to get me a few savory hand pies at this Wash Park location of this legendary hand pie place with so much legacy, what I spotted in the showcase simply wasn't something ordinary. And it was none other than "Reuben!! They truly perfected the Reuben hand pie making. Inside of the flaky pie, it sure was Reuben with a noticeable amount of sauerkraut! There aren't many places where they make this type of hand pies (at least I don't know any others) but these guys are a true expert in that regard. I like all of their savory pies but this Reuben might rank at the top of the list. It's that good so if you are a Rueben fan, this is a must-get item. For sweet side, I did see the Ube pies (like I saw them in one of the newsletters I received from Legacy recently.) I behaved today though; I simply saved that sweet pie for my next occasion. Hopefully they are not available for limited time only. Please be there when I get there next time!! The store is as adorable as it always is. Clean and neatly organized. The young lady who assisted me was most pleasant. Service is another element which they stay on top of. This place simply never disappoints. read more

See all

I consider Legacy Pie the best pie in the Denver metro area! The crust is delicious and flaky. My husband and I love the tart cherry hand pies, but we have many other favorites, such as the key lime pie, the French silk, apple, pumpkin, blueberry, and the chicken pot pie. Oh, forgot the mushroom pie! Today, I had an iced coffee with half & half, which was perfect, and I tried the egg and bacon hand pie. It was so good and very filling. I would consider us regulars at Legacy Pie's two locations. I love the look and feel of the Wash Park location, but I wish they had some seating. With such good coffee and breakfast items, it would be fun to go with friends or family. We always get our holiday pies at Wash Park because they have the best parking. The service has always been very friendly and accommodating. There is no better place for pie at this family-owned business with so much history. read more

Legacy Pie -Wash Park - Holiday pie line up - Bakeries Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

We tried several pies. I loved the cherry best. The all time hit was the key lime ( very tart) though 5 peeps over ruled me as best. Good service. Pleasing place. Returned a second time while in town. read more

Michigan is the home of the Montmorency cherry which has a delicious, firm, tart fruit--perfect for pies. "Great grandma" Katherine opened a roadside pie stand in 1929. Her children moved the pie company to Loveland in 1960 as Colorado Cherry Company. The next generation opened shops in Lyons and Estes Park. The great grandchildren expanded to Denver in 2020 as Legacy Pie Co. The original Montmorency cherry pie is still featured, although the menu has expanded to other fruits, cream, and savory pies plus cookies and scones. The pies come in Cutie (single serving), Mini (2-3 servings), and 10" sizes plus very generous hand pies. I'm a frequent flier at the original store on Tennyson Street, but I'd forgotten this location on Alameda Avenue had opened about a year ago until I saw the sign while visiting a neighboring business. This is a cute space with a large selection of the pies and other baked items. The bakery is in the back and everything is made fresh, from scratch. This business is also noted (in my mind) for delicious, bottled cherry juice. I noticed they have expanded this sideline to a number of varieties of cider. You can't beat the Montmorency cherry pie, in my view, but the many other offerings are also tasty. I do think these guys have a bit of a heavy hand with the crust--particularly on the fruit pies. The crust is well-made, but I'd prefer a bit thinner, lighter crust. Unlike Tennyson Street which offers drinks and has quite a bit of seating, this location is takeout only. This is a small shopping strip with only a few stores and a good-sized parking lot which is great since parking in the neighborhood is difficult. read more

See all

My kids surprised me with a Tart Cherry Pie from here on Father's Day. A la mode in the park. I'll have to check out your savory pie flavors as well!! Delish! read more

Legacy Pie -Wash Park - Tart Cherry. So Delicious! - Bakeries Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Great looking pastry and execution! Chicken was seasoned perfectly, thick gravy on top that did not spill out everywhere or make the pastry soggy, and loved the herbs on top. Just picked up but staff were super friendly and informative. There is no seating inside so just keep in mind it is just to pick up/take out! read more

Legacy Pie -Wash Park - Chicken pot pie - Bakeries Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Not for Thanksgiving!! We preordered and waited over 45 minutes outside in the cold. The walk in line went much quicker. I will NEVER do this again we had an assigned time and those behind us waited even longer!! Awful planning for this company!! read more

Best savory and sweet pies I've ever had and I want a bakery, but we don't make pies and I wouldn't want to compete with these. They're the best pies I've ever had. I love tart cherry, and the bison one is a 10 out of 10. read more

This spot just opened up on our way to school and we were excited for an after school snack. It is cute and clean on the inside but I was a little disappointed that there is no place to sit and share a pie! On to the pies- variety, flaky crust, savory or sweet- lots of options! We had the mixed berry and the bourbon apple- ooooh that topping was yummy! Both were delish! This is a local company so I always love to support a small business! They even have black bing cherry cider, which if you know- you Know, and if you don't, it's a Colorado think not to be missed! I used to have to drive to Estes Park to get that juice but now I can stop on the way to school, yay! read more

Legacy Pie -Wash Park - Bakeries Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Five stars and three "Mmms"! Recommend getting their bison bacon mushroom mini pie. So freakin good read more

I'm a huge fan of the tart cherry pie - it's sweet and lightly tart but has such a good balance. The crust to filling ratio is also great. I'm looking forward to trying more of their things. Interior doesn't have seating, just purchase only. read more

The free cutie pie coupon incentivized me to come here and man...the pies are gooooood. The tart cherry is perfectly sweet and tart but it's not overly skewed towards sweet or overly tart. Just a nice mild balance. I also love their savory options, like the buffalo chicken hand pie. Also, they keep giving me coupons so unfortunately they keep taking my money!! Will certainly continue to be a customer. read more

If you are looking for a place to get your pie fix, Legacy Pie is it! Run to get their Wild Maine Blueberry Pie. No one ever uses Maine blueberries, and they are so much better in a pie than regular ones. We have done the take and bake twice and they turned out delicious, and are so easy to bake. We tried cherry last time and that was great too. You can do mini pies as well, but if you want a few days worth of dessert, go for the larger size. Staff is always friendly as well, and very accommodating. Looking forward to the next visit! read more

Legacy Pie -Wash Park - Take & Bake 10" Tart Cherry - Bakeries Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

I picked up a take and bake chicken pot pie, cutie key lime pie, and a cutie apple crisp. The crust on the pot pie was delicious but we both agreed the shredded chicken opposed to cubed was an odd textural element and while it guaranteed chicken in every bite, we prefer some bites to be just filling and veggies. The key lime pie was clearly very fresh but slightly too tart for me. The apple pie was really good but the crust was a bit hard to break and thus made it a little challenging to eat! read more

I love,love, love legacy pie. They have the most amazing pies I have ever had. Everyone in my family loves them and it's a must on any celebration. The best is that the pies are always stuffed with fresh fruits and they don't cut back on the ingredients! read more

Tried their apple pie. The. Rust was good but the apples were soft (overcooked?)) and almost like applesauce. I think the apples could have used a bit more seasoning they were actually somewhat bland. I would have used a firmer apple and enhanced the seasoning read more

My daughter took me for a lemon meringue pie on Mothers Day but at 11:30 am they were already out. So I chose a coconut cream mini pie instead. The graham cracker crust was too sweet and it had a lot of cinnamon that just didn't seem to go with coconut. However, the custard barely had flavor. It was flat tasting, had very little coconut, and honestly, if it weren't for the odd crust the pie would have no flavor at all, not even hints of vanilla. Very disappointed this time around. I don't know if I'd go back. read more

I got an email a few days ago indicating they had Palisade Peach pies. I went by today. The full size 10 inch pie is $35, but mini's were $14 each. I got the Palisade Peach and the Tart Cherry mini's. My housemate ate 1/2 of the cherry pie. It had lots of cherries. I also got a blueberry packed scone for Sunday morning. Service was quick. The inside display counter and case was clean. They have 1 picnic table outside on the west side, but no inside seating. read more

See all

I ADORE YOUR PIES. Tonight I came and got a Chicken Pot Pie for dinner. I Love all the Chicken Inside and the Double Crusts ;-) But, Tonight, you needed More Sauce because it was rather dry. The spice in the pot pie was delicious, but because of it being so dry, is why I only gave 3 stars. Thank You. read more

I love Legacy Pie Co. I love being a micro investor community member and receiving a discount on my favorite pies and new pies! In Denver if I'm going to meet up with people or wanting to share something sweet with coworkers, I just bring pie from here! The key lime pie is so super zesty and in the winter I love sticking up on their savory frozen take and bakes! Their thick buttery crust is to die for and the chicken pot pie is so creamy and chunky. Yum! Recently I tried their seasonal s'mores pie which was so velvety!! Loved it. I love that they opened up in the Wash Park neighborhood which is my side of town! Their Tennyson location is more sociable for cafe style dining with friends over pie and coffee but I am also fine with picking up new pie flavors and trying them at home from Wash Park! read more

LEGACY PIES ARE LEGENDARY Our friends are fans of Legacy Pie Co. that offers both sweet and savory pies. Purchase freshly baked pies or buy a Take and Bake pie to bake at home. Pies come in different sizes including hand pies. Take out only. Limited parking. We shared the Mini Apple Caramel Crisp and the Mini Mixed Berry (each $11.50). A rich streusel topping covered the well spiced chunky apple filling. The mixed berry pie was chock full of berries in a sweet thick syrup. The pies' crusts did not get soggy when the pies were warmed up in the oven. Another day, we had the Take and Bake Chicken Pie (10 inch pie $27). Wow - you are in for a treat if you have only experienced grocery store frozen pot pies. Follow the baking instructions and you will be rewarded with a delicious pie - the well sealed pie did not leak while baking. The chicken pot pie was stuffed with a lightly seasoned filling of shredded chicken and the thick crust was very flaky. The pie was dusted on top with rosemary. read more

Legacy Pie is delishhhh whether you are wanting sweet or savory. I have tried multiple of their items from breakfast hand pies, to mini pot pies, to dessert pot pies & a large chicken pot pie. They have all exceeded my desires. The crust is so delicious on all the pies. Would recommend if you want a quick hearty meal or a take and bake, home-y meal. read more

See all

The custom order Birthday pie was to die for and major hit with all the friends! We had an apple pie AND a key lime. 12/10 Legacy is the reason I say "my favorite cake is pie." read more

Legacy Pie -Wash Park - Birthday Apple Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Denver, Colorado

This place is great! As I understand it, the Denver operation (this one in Wash Park and another spot in Highlands/Northside) is the business of the younger generation of same family that still operates the Colorado Cherry Company up towards Estes. The products are fantastic - cherry pie, berry pie, apple pie, pecan pie, etc. Both large sizes as well as smaller mini versions. They also usually have all varieties available in frozen take and bake versions, as well as fresh-baked hand pies, both sweet and savory. Another specialty are their savory pot pies - chicken, bison, vegetarian, and a seasonal Thanksgiving pie. The shop also has a select array of other local artisan food products - coffee, ice cream, etc. Space is clean and airy, service is excellent, and they have an ample parking lot right on Alameda. They also are usually selling at the City Park farmers market, in season. read more

I got a chocolate pie and tried my friends fruit pie. We both agreed they were average. I don't remember exactly which pies.

I've ordered 3 pies from Legacy Pie: chocolate raspberry (February special), lemon blueberry meringue (April special) and bacon onion quiche. Each was perfect. The counter service is efficient and friendly. And that wonderful buttery smell when you walk in the door is intoxicating. These folks are the real deal - I should know, I've won county fair blue ribbons for my own pie. read more

Their pies are amazing! Customer service is great as well. You walking a very bright environment with very welcoming people. The pies are priced well and for a good price. I recommend the key lime pie. read more

I had received a coupon for a free cutie fruit pie and was finally in the area. Love that there's a parking lot! I got a hand held Buffalo chicken, chicken pot pie and the tart cherry cutie pie. The Buffalo chicken was very good and filling. Recs on the tart cherry were spot on. I could only eat half so I got to enjoy it another day. Can't wait to try the chicken pot pie and come back!! read more

My family loves pies, we have tried several of the flavors given that they offer mid-sized pies and mini's and they have all been great. I have also tried a couple of the meat pies and they are good as well, a bit decadent for too often. The staff are always very nice and the store is very clean. Would be great if they had a little bit of seating inside and out and some beverages if you want to meet up with someone for a dessert and chat. read more

I've seen Legacy Pie Co at the City Park farmers market, but I've always been there too late to get the flavor I'm most excited about... what a mistake, and what a gift that they have a storefront in my area now! The pie crust is EXCELLENT, and I had a vegetable curry hand pie - it was A+. The woman working the counter was friendly and didn't mind my many questions, and I can't wait to go back! read more

This is not about the quality of the pie but about customer service....also recognize this as a first world problem but when you pay for something, you expect to get what you paid for. I ordered the 12 mini pies a week in advance which is a selection of 3 flavors. when I went to pick them up, I was given a box with eight mini pies and two blueberry hand pies and was told I would just have to cut them in half and that they taste exactly the same. They said the mini pies were a special otder so I was curious how they made 8 but not the other 4. I was using it for a birthday and sort of had a presentation all figured out that didn't include having chunks of pie with filling oozing all over on the plate. Again, not the end of the world, but kind of disappointing. Thought they would do a better job. read more

Some of the best pies I've had since I have lived in Denver & love the little individual ones also.

Great pies. What else do you need to know? Both locations have good pie. 'Nough said.

Delicious pies. They do great for seasonal specialities too. Easy to park and friendly staff.

Kind staff great pie. Came for a birthday pie for my young son and they gave great recommendations and were thoughtful.

Love this place, great pies, easy in and out. Great service. Every thing I have tried has been great.

Delicious pies, both savory and sweet-we love that pies come in 3 sizes plus they have hand pies for a quick lunch or treat! Their cookies are delicious too! We have also bought cherry juice and preserves. This is our go to place! read more