YOU HAD ME AT PIE I drove 1 hour and 22 minutes to meet a friend here and it was worth the time and price of gas! SERIOUSLY! Don't underestimate PIE...LEGACY PIE as a reward for yourself no matter how far you need to drive to get there!! Do I have pictures? Sadly no. I gobbled my cherry hand pie down so fast that my Grandma Lucile would have chastised me for my rude behavior! My friend ordered the chicken pot pie and it looked so yummy I bought one to take home to my husband. I enjoyed the curry hand pie and boy - what a fantastic flavor in pie crust! Double Yum! My only regret today is I didn't buy a few more mini pies to take home to my freezer! Way to go small business! #pieisawayoflife PS The store is very cute and decorated with fun little gifts or treats you could make as a hostess gift when you stop to get a pie to bring for dessert. #DontwalkRUN! read more

I was impressed with this bake shop! I stumbled into it as I was looking for somewhere to get a chicken pot pie, but found a couple of other good things while I was here. I tried the hot and read buffalo chicken sandwich, and the pork green chile. I thought both were good. Definitely more emphasis on the bread in these than you would get somewhere else, but that is to be expected with it being a pie shop. I liked the pork a little bit more. They were more filling than I expected but also I didn't think about how much bread there was until after. Also got the key lime pie for dessert later in the day which I loved. Good amount of whipped cream, and had great flavor. Not too crumbly on the crust either. And finally I did get the take and bake chicken pot pie. Which I thought was excellent. Fair value for the size, I think. The large got me 3 meals but probably could have stretched it to 4. But it was so good that I just kept eating more. Had good amounts of chicken in it and good ratio with the veggies. I would definitely return here. Would definitely get the pot pies and key lime pie again. I wouldn't go out of my way to get them, but if I was in the area and needing something quick and easy to eat, I would get 1 of the hot and ready sandwiches too - I thought they were fairly priced too. read more

Legacy Pie Co. - Pork Green Chile hot and ready (top), Buffalo chicken hot and ready (bottom) - Desserts Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Bought a strawberry and rhubarb pie. I like the lattice crust. And I think it was good, but maybe not $30 good. I will try village inn on the next strawberry rubart pie I know they are about $17 read more

This place was at the top of my list to revisit after moving back to Denver. I panicked for a brief moment thinking they closed but the name just changed from Colorado Cherry Co. (thank baby Jesus). Everything I've tried is amazing but the chicken pot pie and cherry pie are my repeat go-to. Just walking in and getting hit in the face with the smell of fresh baked goods makes me happy. Friendly service and cute shop. This place will always be a favorite. read more

Amazing pies are made here! The street parking around here can be challenging, but don't let that deter you from coming! I ended up parking around the corner on a side street. There is a restroom available for customers. It is located in a hallway just outside of Legacy Pie Co. This shop is a part of the Colorado Cherry Company family. We first went to the Colorado Cherry Company in Loveland, Co. We got a great taste of the Cherry Pie! That slice was memorable. So, the next time I was back in the Denver area, I knew I wanted to get another Cherry Pie but didn't want to drive to Loveland. I opted to drive to Northwest Denver. I bought a Cutie Tart Cherry, a Cherry Hand Pie, & a Mini Apple Bourbon Caramel Pie the night before I flew back home to Los Angeles. I took the Cherry Pies with me and shared them with my husband the next afternoon. I was surprised that we both preferred the Hand Pie! I was certain the Cutie Pie would be better. I would definitely get the Hand Pie again next time... AND try whatever other variety they have available! I didn't get to try the Mini Apple Bourbon Caramel Pie ($11). I bought it for my daughter (in-law) and son. They enjoyed it. I'm sure it was scrumptious! They have Take & Bake pies, too! I'd rather buy them ready to eat and leave the baking to them! If you want a warm pie, get yourself and Take & Bake to take home! I want to return again and try some of their savory Mini Pot Pies & Lunch Hand Pies! read more

Legacy Pie Co. - Cutie Tart Cherry ($7) 10-22-2024 - Desserts Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

Such a lovely place for coffee and a treat. Their dessert hand pies are amazing and I love the seasonal coffee flavors. It's fun to sit by the big open window and people watch too read more

Legacy pies is a nice stop for a nice day strolling around Tennyson. Staff is great and they have a huge selection. One disclaimer for this review is that I'm not a huge pie guy but do enjoy an occasional savory pie. Their chicken pot pie hit the spot! The crust is flaky and buttery and was not soggy when broken into. The gravy and filling is very savory with shredded chicken pieces. The pie was piping hot and fresh! Though I won't go out of my way to get these pies (since I live in the opposite direction), I would definitely make this a stop if I'm in the area Curry pie was the perfect size if you're in between meals. The curry filling was hot and savory, tho I can say some areas of the filling was lacking the curry spice. The veggies were cooked to perfection and fell apart well. The establishment is simple and filled with buttery aroma. The staff gets 5 stars for their work ethic and kindness. You can't go wrong with legacy pies if you can't decide what to eat. They have an expansive selection of pies, sweet and savory to meet everyone's needs. read more

Legacy Pie Co. - Curry pie - Desserts Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

My family loves Legacy Pie, Co! Our favorite is the cherry hand pies, but the key lime, apple, chicken pot pie, and several others are all delicious. We think Legacy makes the best pies in Denver! We have given Legacy pies to friends who are under the weather and to new neighbors. We also celebrate my mother-in-law on her birthday which is "Apple Pie for Breakfast Day"! The holidays always include Legacy Pies too! We love all the different sizes available. read more

Legacy Pie Co. - Apple Pie for Breakfast Day! - Desserts Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Legacy Pie!!!!! What have you done to me ?!!! Obsessed with this place I dream about the banana pie lol Place should be called Legendary Pie... There was a line out the door but the wait was no longer than 10 mins ... super worth it !!! Staff were sooooo nice and made the experience that much better . Love the store line on the wall, made the process feel a lot more personal. The feel of the place felt very joyous You can either take it to go or you can enjoy it there at the location !! Looked like they had sweet and savory pies ... Will be back again and again read more

See all

I can't seem to get enough of this hand pie shop lately. It was only a few weeks ago when I made a quick stop at this place early in the morning to grab a few savory ones. Today's on a chilly Saturday afternoon, this Sunnyside neighborhood was busy with so many people doing their out and about, street parking was almost impossible. Once I managed to find a spot to park my car several blocks away, I rushed to this place to get me a few of those savory ones to satisfy my mid afternoon hunger. This shop is always clean and adorable. Service is also always good and friendly. The lady behind the counter was very patient with me while I was being indecisive (lol!!) What I got me today were Pork one and the veggie curry one. Like I have tasted several different savory ones in the past the pies were nice and flaky. Dense and yet never oily. What's in the center of each pie was so flavorful. They just simply make the bestest hand pies in town. The remedy to my hunger was instant. These impeccably made hand pies never seem to disappoint me in any way. And they will stay fresh overnight so I'm so looking forward to eating them again tomorrow morning. read more

See all

It's been a year since I did a review here. It continues to be an amazing place for pie! Such a sweet spot with sweet people ! Ash is so sweet and helped us out today. I used some coupon deals we had and she was so patient and kind to both Ryan and I ! We are at home enjoying our caramel apple pie and tart cherry pie and I even ran back inside before we left to buy some vanilla ice cream to go with it. It's a cute spot with great deals pies and treats both sweet and savory. There's even spots to sit in and eat or take home like we did. It's very cozy and clean and well taken care of - lots of TLC! We continue to highly recommend Legacy Pie Co on Tennyson Street! read more

See all

Very delicious Bison Pot Pie and dessert! Very beautiful shop and staff to match! I fell in love with the customer service and felt right at home in Grandma's Kitchen! read more

Oh the pies. I love me some pie. This is the place for it. Amazing cherry pie but love all the other kinds of pie available - they even have savory option and hand pies . Love this place! Great ambiance, excellent service - must try! read more

My new favorite place! Such a cute little pie shop. I got the mixed berry, caramel apple crumble, and the French silk. My favorite is the mixed berry, it's sweet and tart and has juicy strawberries and is just incredibly delicious. The French silk is also incredible. I am excited to return so I can try their savory hand pies :) read more

Legacy Pie Co. - Desserts Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Their Chicken Pot Pies are Fabulously Delicious. There is a bottom and a top crust that tastes so buttery and the gravy inside with the chicken and vegetables is Delicious. Also, their fruit pies are Incredibly Delicious, as well. I especially like their Key Lime Pies, but all of them are very Delicious l. I also got a Chocolate Chip Cookie tonight and it was the "Best" read more

So good! I'm not typically a huge pie person, but Legacy Pie Co might just change that! We've tried the key lime, mixed berry, and French silk so far. All delicious! The key lime was probably my favorite, followed by mixed berry. Having the smaller sized options is a great way to try different flavors. The staff was super friendly and helpful. I'll definitely be back and can't wait to try some of the other flavors. read more

See all

The rebrand (or buyout) is interesting! Still holding strong to those well-deserved 5 stars on Yelp. Also love that Legacy Pie is opening up a second location in Wash Park. I'm obsessed with all the fresh pies they have available on a daily basis. Definitely follow them on social media for more mouth-watering photos & videos of their bakes. On this visit, I had the Pork Green Chile hand pie, which uses pork from Post Oak BBQ next door. Omg amazing. Normally I don't get savory pies, but it was lunchtime, and I couldn't resist. For dessert, I ordered my usual Apple hand pie. Got a Mixed Berry pie to-go for a dinner party that evening. Perhaps I should make it a weekly tradition to come here! read more

If you're looking for the best pies you've ever had in your life, they're here at Legacy Pie Co. You may think this is a dramatic statement, but my husband and I love this place. We visited the area for the whole month in January and bought 13 items over the course of that time. We couldn't get enough! Even took a pie on the road-trip with us to go back home. Fast forward to a couple months later and a big move to the state, we had to revisit our favorite pie spot! The staff members are always so warm, welcoming and friendly and the place is impeccably clean. They bake their pies fresh in the back so you know once you step in the door, the aroma is heavenly. There are even frozen pies in the fridge off to the side so you can take and bake them yourself at home for later! The selection is amazing and you can't go wrong with any of the daily and seasonal flavors. The crust is dangerously good - so flakey and buttery! We were able to get our hands on a Strawberry Rhubarb yesterday when we stopped by and I honestly don't have the words to continue talking about how these are the best pies ever. Great to share, but you may not want to. read more

See all

I wish I could give LPC a million stars. Their savory pies are perfect for keeping in the freezer and heating up for when you need an easy meal. I recently tried their thanksgiving special and it was absolutely delish. read more

Legacy Pie Co. - Gluten-free chicken pot pie - Desserts Near Me - Denver, Colorado

I was finally able to stop by this place!! Meeting a colleague and his wife near here to drop off gifts for them, gave me a reason to visit this strip. The shop is really cute and clean. The lady behind the counter was really nice too when I told her it's my first time in. She gave me a brief overview of the pies. I was salivating look at all the delicious pies in the cases. They have a lot of flavors from sweet to savory. They have different sizes of pies from regular sized to mini sized to hand pies. I wished I had all the money in the world to buy each and every one that day. Lol. I ended up buying 1 cutie key lime pie, 1 apple hand pie, and 1 savory green chile pie. Dang it! It was so darn scrumptious. The sweet pies were not overly sweet. Just perfect. The savory pie was absolutely delicious. The pies were full of fillings and you can actually taste what's in it. Even the small one too. The best part I love about the pies is the pie crust. I love it that when I bite into the crust and breading of the pie, the light crunch, flakiness, and softness of it takes me to heaven. Mmmm, I can still taste it as Im writing this. Lol. I am definitely a fan of this fabulous place!!! This place is Pie Heaven. You gotta at least have one tiny pie before you die. Life's too good to miss out on pie. I'll definitely be coming back! read more

See all

If you are looking for a place to get your pie fix, Legacy Pie is it! Run to get their Wild Maine Blueberry Pie. No one ever uses Maine blueberries, and they are so much better in a pie than regular ones. We have done the take and bake twice and they turned out delicious, and are so easy to bake. We tried cherry last time and that was great too. You can do mini pies as well, but if you want a few days worth of dessert, go for the larger size. Staff is always friendly as well, and very accommodating. Looking forward to the next visit! read more

Legacy Pie Co. - Take & Bake 10" Tart Cherry - Desserts Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

We were thrilled to have Legacy Pie Co. at our Annual Morgan Adams Concours event, and they truly exceeded expectations. They showcased a beautiful and absolutely delicious array of pies, from the rich, savory options to the perfectly balanced sweet ones, everyone loved them. Not only was the presentation stunning, but the quality was obvious. Legacy Pie Co. brought flavor and a touch of charm to our event--we can't recommend them highly enough! read more

This is a must if you love real pies that have top notch ingredients. The key lime is off the charts and the people who work there are super friendly people. The shop has fun music and we enjoyed sitting and enjoying our medium sized pie which is perfect for 3-4 people to share. read more

See all

While shopping on Tennyson, my sister and I couldn't help but check out this adorable little shop. Everything looked so good, but I opted for the cherry pie. I'm not usually a crust girl, but theirs wasn't too thick and was flaky in all the right places. The cherry filling was tart and not too sweet. I know we'll be returning on my future visits to Denver! read more

Perfect pies!!! I stopped into Legacy pie to pick up some pies for a group gathering. It was super easy to order on their website for a specific pick up date and time. When I walked in I was greeted and helped right away even though there were other people still trying to decide what they wanted. I got a three pack of the smaller pies which was perfect for 6 adults to split. The key lime was my favorite but my friends agreed the French silk was theirs. I can't wait to try the savory pies. read more

Legacy Pie Co. - French silk, apple bourbon, key lime - Desserts Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

Amazing neighborhood pie place!! I got the mixed berry hand pie (~$5) and eating it was such a pleasant experience. The crust was fluffy and buttery. It made me question why I ever buy frozen pie crusts on holidays. They sell out if you end the night there so plan accordingly. Merch and coffee are also sold here. The atmosphere is open and has a diner feel. This place has sparked a fire in my soul for pie!! Will be ordering a pie for a holiday soon! read more

Legacy Pie Co. - Mixed Berry Hand Pie - Desserts Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

Delicious, well made pies. Easy to order and pay online so you just need to pick up. We've tried blueberry and mixed berry and both were scrumptious. read more

Such a great treat to end a meal. I saw the sign out front that mentioned their seasonal double chocolate peanut butter pie and I knew I needed to have it. The peanut butter filling has a rich and sweet and savory taste that was a perfect balance. The Oreo crust was perfect too. They have a huge selection of awesome flavors, the fruit pies look great too read more

Legacy Pie Co. - Special peanut butter chocolate pie. 10/10 - Desserts Near Me - Denver, Colorado

I am a pie person. Like "Last dessert before kicking the bucket will be cherry pie". Like the "break the ice" question is "you get one dessert - Cake or pie, which do you choose - Cherry pie, who would have cake when you can have pie?" Since what used to be my favorite Denver pie place closed (won't tell you what that was ....too sad), I have been on the hunt for the best pie. A niece brought a Legacy Pie Cherry Pie to a dinner party at our house and BANG. Now, there are several other killer artisan pie places in Denver (I may have reviewed one elsewhere in Yelp). Like Legacy, those places crush pies, BUT Legacy has THE BEST Cherry Pie I have found. Critically, they use Montmorency cherries. IMHO cherry pie should have to have Montmorency cherries to be a true cherry pie. Ok, fine, call it a "tart" cherry pie vs a "cherry" that isn't tart, but come on, everyone who wants a cherry pie wants a tart/sweet Montmorency cherry pie. Ok, I will get off the pedestal BUT in addition to the "right" cherries in the pie, it is awesome. Not "gel" like, it is the way you want the filling. The crust is awesome (I would prefer lattice, but I recognize it is way easier to make pies with all the same top.) (We got a 10" frozen one to bake later). We also got an Apple Caramel and Key Lime (I accidentally turned the Key Lime upside down, so the top is a little mangled) . (See photos) The fruit pies are killer, but also the savory ones! We got a "cornbread bison chili" pie and it was INSANE!! Get this pie and don't share. Amazing. Sorry no photos, we ate the whole thing in the car on the way home. My wife ate the buffalo chicken hand pie before I even saw it. I am putting our Thanksgiving pie orders in early. read more

Legacy Pie Co. - Desserts Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

Yum! Sour cherry pies at Legacy Pie Co.! Cherries have been a large presence for Jamie and I for the past 20 years. We have harvested and pitted large quantities of sour cherries. Over the past 4 years we have taken an easier approach - buying 80 lbs of pitted cherries. We have been getting mostly Balaton and some Montmorency. Both are great. We've been enjoying the Balaton the most. So, we were so excited to find Legacy Pie Co with their focus on pies, particularly Cherry Pies. We had the Cherry Streusel and it was fantastic. The cherries were delicious and chewy. Hmmm! Just thinking about them and writing this post makes my mouth water! Staff here are friendly and welcoming. Ambiance is all about the pies - of which there are several versions of cherry pies to choose from in addition to many other pies - apple, etc. Highly recommended! read more

See all

Legacy Pie company offers some of the tastiest pies around. Small or large, you can't go wrong. My Sweetheart thoroughly enjoys the French silk and I tend to prefer the caramel apple bourbon.....so yummy. The service is quick, staff always friendly and helpful. The shop is just the right size with a few tables to enjoy your selection on site if you'd like. Only drawback is the parking situation. Fully walkable from the surrounding neighborhood but beware if driving in, especially on a weekend evening. We've yet to try their savory options but may on a future visit. read more

After dining in the area we walked past Legacy Pie and decided to check it out. All of the pies looked amazing, as well as the ice cream, jams, pie fillings, and other goodies for sale. We had the cutie tart cherry pie between the two of us, and could have easily downed the larger mini size. They had an apple bourbon, mixed berry, pumpkin, chocolate mousse and peanut butter, as well as some savory pot pie options. We also had a cappuccino and latte to pair with the pie. They were very well made! read more

Legacy Pie Co. - Dining area - Desserts Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

Delicious pies we got apple, pumpkin, and cherry and they all were soo good. Busy during the holidays but definitely worth the money.

I always bring a Legacy Pie, usually cherry, to familyget-togethers. I've never had a bad experience up till now, and everybody likes pie, including me. I picked up the tart cherry pie that I pre-ordered, the Saturday before Easter. I was hoping it was OK although it lacked the sugar crystals that are usually on top of their fresh pies. Brought it to the table after the Easter meal, and I had a terrible time cutting through the bottom and the edge. Hard as a rock. The upper crust was just kind of limp. Ended up having a bit of a tense situation as people were nudging me offering to help, like I couldn't cut the dang pie. Embarrassing. I think the pie was several days old, at least. Note to self and everyone else, on the next popular pie holiday, pre- order a frozen pie and take it home and bake it yourself. That way you know it will be fresh, with a delicate crust. Don't get me wrong, I love Legacy Pie, and pie in general. I'll just use a different method next time for ordering preparation on a holiday. I will say that my pie was ready to go when I picked it up at the appointed time, which I appreciated. And the little cherry hand pie that I also bought was delicious, as was the French silk mini. I've left rave reviews before for this business but now I'm just going to takeoff one star. Because pie. read more

I have to say I was extremely impressed by my experience at Legacy Pie. The store is super clean and bright and the pies all looked amazing. We took home some handheld pies- the sausage and hash brown and the loaded veggie. Both are delicious. The crust is so flaky and good. I promised my son that after his first day of school in a couple of weeks, he and I'll go back for a pie treat because he was really disappointed that we didn't get any "sugar pies". The staff were super friendly. We were promptly greeted when we walked in the door and kindly treated throughout our interaction. All in all in excellent experience. read more

See all

I've only tried the Dutch apple bourbon pie but it was absolutely heavenly and now I can't wait to try more- It is just as delicious as it looks! read more

Legacy Pie Co. - Desserts Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Absolutely delicious. So skillfully created and wonderful to enjoy. I look forward to trying everything they have.

THE CHICKEN POT PIE IS WHAT DREAMS ARE MADE OF, Perfectly hearty crust, flakey, buttery... Creamy not runny insides. Rosemary forward flavor (I'm obsessed) All pies come in 3 to 4 different sizes Hand held Cutie Mini Regular For the sweet side, I'm partial to the key lime. So tart, so sweet Don't walk, run here. read more

Legacy Pie Co. - Mini Chicken Hot and Ready - Desserts Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

Tennyson Street is one of my favorite places to go for a walk on weekends which means I'm a frequent customer of Colorado Cherry Co. This is such a delicious smelling shop with that feels berry warm and welcoming. I especially enjoy walking in during the winter, they have a couch and some tables to sit at if you would like to stick around for a while. I can't resist a hand pie as a treat, and this is a great place to get one any day of the week. Hand pies go for $4.25 and mini pies for $10. My go tos are cherry, blueberry and mixed berry hand pies and my next step will be to expand my horizons to other baked goods in their shop such as savory pies, quiche and cookies. There's a lot to pick from and the staff are more than happy to help provide recommendations or narrow down choices. I'm excited for the next thing I get to eat from here! read more

Legacy Pie Co. - Mini pies ($10) - Desserts Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Mmm...some subtle nostalgia....really enjoyed the spread of delectable options. Their crisps and cookies are a must grab.