Lenny's Bagels has officially entered the rotation as this was my third trip in less than two months. The assorted bagels are freshly made and have a soft yet chewy texture. They have the usually varieties but "my ex", (jalapeño and cheddar), "my 2 sons" (poppy seeds and sunflower) or "bad boy" (egg, poppy and onion) are three flavor to try if you are feeling adventurous. The menu has lots of options, breakfast sandwiches, breakfast bowls, panninis, salads and wraps. Whatever you choose to eat, you won't be disappointed. I'm a wrap girlie. Grilled chicken w/ pepper jack cheese ( I swapped out the cheddar), sautéed onions, peppers and avocado is my go-to. The heat from the grilled chicken and sautéed veggies, combined with the avocado to make the wrap creamy and flavorful, no mayo necessary. I ordered a cold coconut latte w/oat milk which paired well with my wrap. The staff is always patient and accommodating. Stop in for a visit if you are in or near the Pelham Manor area. read more

See all

Such a shame. The food tastes good but the employees are extremely rude. Never had a good experience here and they want to charge for the air you breathe in there. If I want one fried egg, I'm charged $6 as an egg sandwich. Doesn't make sense. read more

I've never had a positive experience at Lenny's and we've given them a fair share of tries. Today we ordered three very basic sandwiches. Note the tuna salad sandwich on a roll STARTS at $9, adding lettuce is another $.75, adding cheese is $1 and adding tomato is $.75. You're looking at a $12+ tax tuna salad sandwich. The biggest issue is the tuna salad is so unbelievably DRY. They must use basically no mayo, no celery and no seasoning. The lettuce as you can see is hilariously poorly cut and portioned. Black iced coffee is $4, plus $1.50 if you want a splash of milk. I don't know where they get off charging prices like this. Service is also incredibly slow and the servers tend to have an attitude. Go to Remi's down the road, WAY better, significantly cheaper and friendlier staff. read more

Lenny's Bagels - Tuna Salad Sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Pelham Manor, New York

They repeatedly miss items or put wrong items in your delivery orders. Ive never complained until today. I normally request credit as things happen. Today multiple items were missing. When calling, the so called manager was rude, didnt want to hear what was said for improvement. Even after we indicated we like their food, perhaps they can improve. Instead he gave us attitude and said "youre getting credit correct?" Who the hell do you think you are? You should be grateful to have customers in this economy. Needless to say, they will NEVER get another cent from our household. Ungrateful jerks. Are they even up to code? Lets see. read more

I'm actually not the biggest fan of their bagels, but I've had a lot of great burritos and paninis here. My favorite are the burritos, which are always filling and not too greasy. There are always some people eating here. I appreciate the light, with windows on two sides. It has a deli feel. Orders are done quickly if you're picking up, but I don't recommend using any food delivery services. It's just always uncertain when they'll deliver, especially at busier times. read more

Lenny's Bagels - Breakfast burrito 1. Chorizo, Cheddar and Hash Brown - pretty good! - Bagels Near Me - Pelham Manor, New York

See all

Worst place ever - rotten bagels that stinks . And when you speak with the workers they don't care. NEVER waste your time here. read more

Lenny's Bagels - Worst Bagel ever - Bagels Near Me - Pelham Manor, New York

Ehhh these guys aren't that bad, I've had the bagels and so far they're pretty good. I'll try more things in the future

Came in here one rainy morning - service was disappointing. I was next in line, and right when it was my turn to order, the counter clerk left to go help making bagels and whatever else. I ended up leaving because it was just taking too long. 1 * for cool bagel names that I didn't even get to try! read more

Lenny's in Pelham: The Food: Fresh and Delicious - the Bagels, Generous and Authentic; The Service: Patient, Polite and Personable; The Ambiance: Clean and Inviting; The Problem: On HOLIDAYS, they ALWAYS SELL OUT of the FAN FAVES...(such as but not limited to, Cinnamon & Raisin, All Flagels, and almost every other flavored Bagel that is Not Plain). If you LOVE it, they will NOT have it (after 10 am); The Solution: Show-up way too early on the Holiday (which for most is a rest day) OR, wait for it...Lenny's Pelham can Prepare for the Expected and Make More of the items that SELL OUT FIRST and/or FAST ON HOLIDAYS. IJS read more

Lenny's Bagels - A Bagel with Butter - Bagels Near Me - Pelham Manor, New York

It's a shame that this place is so bad. The bagels are just horrible here and I'm not sure what it is. I wish that I could support my local bagel shop but Lenny's just isn't it. read more

As I pulled into the parking lot at Lenny's Bagels there was plenty of parking with disabled parking available. I entered the bagel shop and they were busy. The sign posted stated, Buy a dozen bagels get six free. I ordered several dozen. The server then explained only six free bagels. read more

Lenny's Bagels - Lenny's Bagel policy - Bagels Near Me - Pelham Manor, New York

My 2nd time ordering this sandwich. The bagels are Always good. However. I think it's awful to charge $10 and put one slice of turkey bacon cut in half. They split one slice of cheese. Never again. read more

Lenny's Bagels - 9. Turkey Bacon and Smoked Gouda Sandwich. $10 they split one slice of turkey bacon in half. One!! This is the 2nd time. - Bagels Near Me - Pelham Manor, New York

Ordered a lox cream cheese spread bagel, which is my usual at bagel shops. This, my friends, was not splendid, at all. The spread had a grainy consistency and taste that made for a unpleasant taste. The bagel in and of itself was fine but I couldn't separate it without tasting the distasteful spread. Wouldn't order from here again. read more

Lenny's Bagels - Lox Cream Cheese - Bagels Near Me - Pelham Manor, New York

See all

I haven't been here in years! I wish I would have read the reviews before coming. This place used to be the place to go many years ago. Today I ordered a turkey bacon egg and cheese on an everything bagel...it was gross! The whole sandwich was wet. The eggs had no flavor, the bacon was limp and wet like it was boiled instead of pan fried. I won't be coming back. The other dings for here are they literally will walk around with your food on a spatula walking between everyone running around behind the counter. There is only one point of sale machine, so you have to wait to check out and get in where you fit in when your order is ready. Just some advice: have one person taking orders and collecting payment before the order is made, people having to jump in front of those waiting in line is rude. I had to pass my card pass a customer ordering his food. Also the place is dirty. When you walk in there are coffee stains on the walls and dirt and grime along the floor--I should have walked out at this point, but hey it's NY! However, after my meal, I can only imagine what the back looks like...I will not be retuning for this reason as well. read more

Came in on a Saturday morning to get some bagels. Lines can be a little long in the morning but the staff does a good job of moving them along. Great selection of bagels with a lot of options of different types of cream cheeses. Coffee is very good. Great breakfast spot. read more

Seriously? One and a half slice of bacon on a bacon and egg sandwich? And they want to charge almost $7 + tax for this? Get outa here. I've ordered from them in the past and also experienced disappointment in their sandwiches. Maybe their bagels are better but I was never really into bagels so I wouldn't know. I won't be wasting my time and money with this place again. read more

Lenny's Bagels - This is their bacon and egg sandwich! - Bagels Near Me - Pelham Manor, New York

See all

Their breakfast burrito is the best in town! Worth every penny and the staff is always friendly even through this pandemic. Please support this business! read more

Lenny's Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Pelham Manor, New York

Gross. The avocado is literally brown. Why would you knowingly include rotting food in an order. ? Toast or bread usually comes with butter or some kind of spread. Nothing. Just dry ass toast. Way too much Feta in the omelet. I was a priority customer so why was the food cold? So disappointed. Thumbs all the way down. read more

Lenny's Bagels - Rotting avocado - Bagels Near Me - Pelham Manor, New York

Amazing service, food and vibes! This is the bagel ex-boyfriend jalapeño bagel with cheddar chorizo hash brown roasted peppers with ketchup and hot sauce. read more

I ordered lox, because the lady suggested me. She said if I take their breakfast special sandwich with lox will not be good, they will give me so little lox because of the price it cost $6, but if I take Brooklin lox then I will get good amount of lox. So I said ok, but I got more tomato's in my special Brooklin sandwich than lox. My husband took morning egg sandwich and it should come with free coffee, but no they decided to charge us!! No, we do not recommend. For two average sandwiches and one tea, one coffee $30 read more

My first bad review, I normally let it go. However, first time here, the rudest most condescending worker I had ever encountered. Disgusting behavior, absolutely unacceptable. Called him on it and he looked and me and said 'whatever'. Will never go back. read more

When you place online pickup orders it can take 10+ minutes to reach the workers at the location. Upper management needs to fix. So slow and doesnt have to be this way read more

great spot for linch or breakfast. great bagels and croissants. I wasn't a fan of my made to order egg sandwich it was not done as requested but the croissant made up for it. i had the coffee and it was ok. it's a cute spot They have tables and it has the feel of a small town bistro. read more

Bagels aren't that bad, BUT the owner is so CHEAP! They don't have sleeves for hot coffee, but when you ask for a 2nd cup because the coffee is burning your hands. the response is, "we are only allowed to give you napkins, because a 2nd cup is too expensive." How cheap! Not sure what will be cheaper when they get sued because someone burns themselves on the coffee. Other cons: they are super slow, it doesn't matter if no one is in line or it's a line if 6, they are really slow. Lastly, There are NOT CLEAN. They have pastries that are totally open(that people can actually touch). Will not be returning. Overall: CHEAP DIRTY POOR CUSTOMER SERVICE SLOW read more

The way they run the ordering line is kind of confusing and impractical but definitely the best breakfast by far in the area!! I frequently order from here. read more

I have to say I'm just not impressed. I really wanted to love this place but, it just isn't going to happen. Only go here if you're looking for a bagel, anything else and you're out of luck. I love their jalapeño cheddar bagel with scallion cream cheese, that's my go to. But, after having one of the worst panini and bacon egg and cheeses of my life I just can't justify going back here. The grilled chicken and cheddar panini is what I got... the chicken was tough and not seasoned. The bacon was also gross and there was barely any ranch. All the workers seem like they don't want to be there and are busy doing nothing. My boyfriend got the chorizo, hash brown, and cheddar burrito...he hated it, completely flavorless. We ordered a chocolate banana muffin to share and ended up getting a vanilla muffin with chocolate chips on top? Their hours are stupid, especially for a place that serves items other than breakfast. I'll find a better place. read more

See all

I do have to say, the bagels are great. That is about all I have in terms of pleasantries. This place is clearly being run on the absolute cheap, with an unclean facility, awfully uninterested (likely underpaid!) staff, and terribly high prices for many things. My girlfriend made a run for coffee one morning and decided to surprise me with some smoked salmon, and ended up being charged sixteen dollars for THREE SMALL PIECES. Yes they were tasty, but what a ridiculous cost. Sandwiches are fine, and coffee is good, but in the same vein, very overpriced. Pick up a bagel if you want, but head to Remi's Place down the street if you're feeling a sandwich - things go better over there. read more

This place is a good spot if you're looking for fresh bagels and are tired of mediocre bagel sandwiches. The bagels are warm with just the right amount of crispiness & soft on the inside. I ordered "The Westchester Sandwich" on a toasted sesame seed bagel. It is a sandwich consisting of chicken cutlets, melted cheddar, bacon and BBQ sauce. I was skeptical at first but the bbq sauce was light and added a slight Smokey flavor combination to the bacon and cutlet. I was also in the mood to be a little adventurous and try one of their more innovate bagel choices since I've only had regular bagels like sesame or everything bagels. With that in mind, I opted for the blueberry bagel with strawberry cream cheese. It was slightly sweet from the blueberries. The cream cheese was very smooth and light plus it had bits of strawberries in them. Yum! read more

Lenny's Bagels - Blueberry Bagel with Strawberry Cream Cheese - Bagels Near Me - Pelham Manor, New York

See all

Overpriced, Poor Service and Nasty Manager. Ordered online for 2 toasted bagels and upon Order Complete my pick up time was 1hr & 30 mins. Decided it would be easier to walk to the store and do the line. I did just that but when it was time for me to order, the associate refused to work on my online order. I asked to be treated as a walk in customer and she said she couldn't. Thats when another lady stepped in and basically said, it'll get done when it's done, 1hr and 30 mins. Seriously? Wtf? I made the line I'm giving you my order which you guys have, just start working on it while I wait? She refused and said to get back in the back of the line and wait again for her to work on my order. After arguing back n forth the associate felt bad and said she would work on my order. But I could see the manager in the back totally against this. Never again, rather go to DD . read more

Small, cute, bustling breakfast/lunch shop. Bagel with lox and cream cheese was delicious, everyone was super nice! read more

Lenny's Bagels - Lox and cream cheese on an everything wheat bagel - Bagels Near Me - Pelham Manor, New York

See all

Solid breakfast sandwiches and bagels. Quick service. Check out the French toast bagel for the kids. Egg burritos are delish.

We order from here literally every morning. I always get the cinnamon toast bagel toasted with butter & Jelly . The bagels always arrive so fresh... also there iced coffee taste so good ! If you enjoy bagels and coffee this is the place for you read more

Think this photo speaks for itself... don't go to lennys unless you want an overpriced hockey puck for a bagel that's so burnt you can barely gnaw through it. Went straight in the trash. read more

Lenny's Bagels - Hockey puck - Bagels Near Me - Pelham Manor, New York

I used to go to Lenny's in both Pehlam and Rye Brook every week. Today, I experienced the most unpleasant and racists experience . I ordered online and apparently the first time it didn't go through. I order again and then they wouldn't get the order done. My poor mother was just being yelled at by the staff ( a woman ) . I called to figured out the issue and instead of helping me get the order they just said maybe you ordered somewhere else. My mom waiting now for an hour later just for 2 bagels . I was so frustrated with their hostility and I called again. The woman just yelled at me , said she had no time for me and hung up the phone. I can imagine how the customers were feeling with all of this yelling and hostility. I do not think people understand racism unless they express it. I say racism because this is now the 3rd time, my Mexican parents are talked in a hostile matter, speaking to them in such a hateful and uneducated matter.As arriving home my mother said she couldn't believe how someone could have a job with that hostility and unprofessional manner. My mother mentioned how even she was so shaken by this woman and afraid she would just target her if she asked her not to speak to her that way. May I ask how many Caucasians have been treated hostile there ? To top it off she gives me the order wrong , I didn't ask for the bagels to be toasted . But they are burnt And hard. So disappointed with the manners of this staff/ place . I tried to call back but they blocked my number / were not answering my calls. I have never experienced this in the one in the Rye Brook before. read more

Good quality, Reasonably priced BUT, not sure worth the wait. Spent 10+ minutes just to wait at counter to order and I was the only customer inside. read more

I love this bagel shop. I feel like whenever I have gone the bagels are stocked! They have fun unique bagels too. My favorite is the French toast bagel. The only downside is this place is normally always packed so the process always seems rushed and because of that I have gotten the wrong order once or twice but lucky for them, I am a bagel lover so I'll eat anything and not complain too much hahaha read more

God awful. I've grown up in Pelham Manor, and I used to frequent this establishment at least twice a week despite many terrible encounters. I had many dealings with this younger gentleman who would continuously patronize me. In addition, I was once bombarded with questions as to why I didn't order more food from them, and quite disrespectfully was told to purchase more items. Today I had valid questions in regard to the ingredients they use to make their breads because of my sister's allergies and instead of showing concern for messing up her order he just kept repeating to check his website and didn't let me get a word in by saying "babe" and "yea" to get me off the phone. I had high hopes for this deli, but not anymore. I hope those who are gluten, vegan or have any allergies stay VERY CAUTIOUS when ordering here. They do not care to accommodate you. read more

Who would have expected a really good bagel place in Westchester? And yet this place consistently impresses. The bagels are great: bready, just chewy enough but not so much that it will hurt your jaw, crisp on the outside. Toothsome, would be a good way to describe them. The cream cheese is always fresh and tasty, with the scallion cream cheese having just the right amount of scallion. I do wish that they'd take orders over the phone (it's in person and internet only), and they really should have an option to add lox to your bagel (rather than having to scroll all the way down to the sandwiches section for a "nova and cream cheese sandwich" that happens to come on a bagel), but these are pretty minor inconveniences. Overall, for the area, a very good bagel place. read more

Will not be returning to this over-priced place. I don't mind paying more than usual for a good bagel or breakfast sandwich, but they are so cheap with the meat on a bacon, egg and cheese, it's disgraceful. There's literally a piece of bacon cut four ways on a BEC, and their bagels? Forget about it. The everything bagel had less seasoning than I had ever seen and it was still doughy inside (undercooked). I know it's a quick bite in the area and their clientele has probably never had a NY style BEC, so they can't tell the difference, but I will not be returning. read more

A good, quick spot for breakfast/lunch on the go. Once in a while they'll get the order wrong, toasted vs untoasted etc, but otherwise it's okay. Good selection of bagels (some fun names, though not entirely descriptive) and salads/spreads read more