I found what I can only describe as food heaven. I went to Kristi's Bagel Cafe at 1215 Mamaroneck Avenue, White Plains, and everything I ordered was incredible. Hands down the best rugelach I've ever eaten, and the iced caramel macchiato was absolutely delicious. And this place is so much more than bagels -- omelettes, salads, 12 different types of homemade bread, sandwiches, heros... honestly, there's something for everyone. Do yourself a favor and go hungry. read more

The food is good but it takes FOREVER! 20 min for a cold sandwich. They have to get faster especially because there are so few parking spaces. Does not give a bakers dozen. Cream cheese not weighed and a small container only filled 1/2 way. Also, the flavor of the chicken salad is very good, but I would prefer it with chunks of chicken versus pureed. read more

In addition to what I got in the picture, I got a hot chocolate that was not good. It was similar to Starbucks hot chocolate which I do not like, I find it too bitter. Not creamy enough flavor-wise. I also got bread that was unlabeled that I thought was sourdough but turned out to be Rye. On me for not checking but hard for anyone to even be sure at that point when nothing is labeled! I also got a bagel and it was normal, nothing crazy about it. Not great or terrible. The cherry cookie was alright, the Italian cookie was fine and the linzer tart was okay, just personally prefer the filling without seeds. The Italian rainbow MUFFIN however, was by far the best thing I ate from here. I would come back just for this. It was a bit heavy and big especially for a breakfast because it was more like a cupcake but the middle has raspberry and tasted exactly like a good Italian rainbow cookie (even better than the cookie that they actually had)! read more

Kristi’s Bagel Cafe - cookies and Italian rainbow muffin - Bakeries Near Me - White Plains, New York

It just opened (few days new) but the family agrees it's worth returning to. Bagels were fresh out of the oven. They had fresh baked goods and pre-made gift-wrapped plates of mixed cookies (great for visiting someone or while holiday visiting). The rainbow cookies were made on-prem (even the jam) and were tasty! The iced coffees were flavorful and they had a variety of different flavored hot coffees (including espresso). Still new and getting ready for a fully stocked open, but definitely give it a try! read more

See all

Great location. Need to step up speed of service. I'd rather go to Brooklyn bagels in mamraroneck bc they are in and out. I'll give it a little more time to give them a pass. 3 months from now we expect faster. 20 minutes plus for two bagels and cream cheese , two becs on rolls. And the order was messed up - no bacon just egg on rolls. I'll give it a other try someday. Good luck read more

Love it. Great bread, coffee, rugelach--- nice people who take pride in what they're putting out!!!

Kristi's is a great new bakery in town!! Super friendly staff, family owned! Great variety of baked goods, bread, and lunches! Everything is made fresh and in house. Rachel and Rachel at the counter are amazing and very welcoming. Try it out if you are nearby! read more

See all

New. So giving benefit of doubt. It's slow. Cashiers struggle to input the order, and produce about 5 slips of paper for each order, goodness knows for what. Gathering a dozen bagels to go took literally 10 minutes to fulfill . Bagels are ok, not too dense; the everything was missing onion and garlic so not really everything. Counter staff looks like they've never worked in a kitchen before. Most menu items not yet available. No seating. Some of pastries looked good, some looked "aged." Really want this place to be good and successful because it's so convenient, but they need to step it up. read more

The wait staff was ok....My family loves the everything bagel and we found their bagels were lacking the everything toppings that other bagel shops put on their bagel. Very sparse!!!!!!!Have tried the Cafe twice thinking that they first opened and had to get their act together but still very disappointed with the everything bagel. Needs to have the bagel maker put more mixture on top. Please put more toppings on the everything bagel! and I'll be back again! read more

Great new Bagel Deli Cafe opened up on Mamaroneck Avenue, very good Bagels and sandwiches, the pastrys and cakes are soo delicious and very tentative to go for, variety of coffees as well hot and cold beverages, once you get in for the first time you can't wait to return, I recommend this place as a great new spot to visit. read more

Great new spot for bagels and baked goods. Chicken cutlets are thin and crispy - highly recommend.

Been going there for a few weeks since they opened. There were a few growing pains in the beginning which is totally understandable but they seemed to have figured it all out. Sausage Egg and Cheese on an everything bagel was amazing! Also had the coconut cold brew iced coffee and it was so good, rivals any boutique coffee shop. Blueberry muffins are also delicious, my kids are obsessed! Pastries and cakes, there too many to list but a personal favorite is the Black Out cake (perfectly light and chocolatey). Would recommend to everyone! read more

Stopped by for coffee and a bagel. Brand new place, just opened and they're doing great! Coffee was fresh, bagels were delicious and everyone working there was so nice. Will absolutely return to try some of the bakery items and the pastrami. read more

The bagels are not fresh, and the service is slower than expected. Super hard to park. I am sorry to say the juice is not worth the squeeze

we won't be going back. their "bagels" are just bread in the shape of bagels. no texture, no flavor, no crust to speak of. so disappointed. we will keep going to our regular bagel place. read more

I have been eagerly awaiting the opening of Kristi's, since I can walk there from my house. My husband and I went yesterday for breakfast. Our first surprise and disappointment was that there is no seating there at all! It is only take-out. Rather surprising since calling it a cafe implies that customers can actually sit down and eat. Also strange since they have things like pancakes on the menu; I don't know who would buy pancakes to go! We got some bagels, which were still warm from the oven and very good, although the everything bagels that we prefer weren't really everything and had mostly sesame seeds on them. I got some tuna fish, which I did not like the taste of; not sure what was in it. There were a few pastries which looked OK; there are definitely places further down Mamaroneck Avenue that have much better looking pastries. There were also some packaged snacks. There is a huge coffee bar taking up most of the floor space. It would have been better to half the size of that and put in some tables! All said, it was somewhat disappointing, although I would probably go back to buy bagels, mostly because it is so convenient. read more