Decided to eat here on work travel and there really wasn't anyone else in there on a Tuesday…read moreevening at 5pm. The service was quick and friendly, and pretty attentive given there wasn't anyone else at the time. The ambiance was quiet and welcoming but I could see it getting loud if a lot of people were there. I order the chicken Philly Stromboli and I modified it to remove the pepperoni and sausage and I probably shouldn't have. The Stromboli was good but lacked distinct flavor. There wasn't enough chicken Philly meat in it to really drive home the experience. My fault for not wanting pork meat but overall it was still good. I would recommend.

202408021630 Nice…read morelittle place nestled in downtown Meadville, right near the theater. There's lots of community booths along the closed off street. The place is reserved out but because we're so early we're able to get seated as long as we leave before 6pm. The girls are busy, friendly and attentive. The Jumbo Ravioli is a little tough, but saucy good. The deep fried Calamari is nice and crispy. The medium calzone is enormous, crispy, cheesy melty. Enjoy1

My first and last time at BBM. The place was busy and smelled great. A blonde girl at the…read moreregister took my order, 4 xl pizzas with misc toppings. It came to $82. She gave me the change, which I put in the tip jar along with a "thank you". The girl didn't blink, didn't say "thanks", nothing. But, OK, it's busy, maybe she's having a bad day. Our 4 pizzas were up, I went to the counter to pick them up and the same girl was cutting the pizzas. I asked if I could have have a plastic container for chili flakes. The girl didn't acknowledge me for about twenty seconds and then said, "yeah, I'll be right back" and walked to the back. A girl standing in front of me asked, "what did you need?" I said, just a small container for the chili flakes" she reached over and handed me a 2oz plastic container, at which point, the blonde girl returned with a thimble sized plastic container... no exaggeration, thimble sized. The blonde girl literally tried to take the bigger cup out of my hand, which I held onto. I said, "I prefer the larger one, it's for FOUR EXTRA LARGE PIZZAS" and she looked me right in the eye and said, "No, unless you want to pay .50 for it" I pulled the cup away and gave the second girl a buck and told her to keep the change. The two employees who witness this interaction had a "WTF is going on" look on their faces. This was my first time, and obviously last time here, and I'm really not sure what was going on. The whole interaction felt personal. I don't know if she thought is was someone else or a previous bad customer, but I can just as easily drive a 100 yards down the road for a equally good pizza and at least a smile when I walk in.

We are new to the area and this was our first time looking for pizza. We live about 30 minutes away…read morebut it was worth the drive. They were wonderful about communicating that they are CASH ONLY when I was ordering and they were so nice and friendly when we arrived to pick up our food. They thanked us for coming and it added a layer of love for this establishment. The pizza itself was excellent. The sauce to cheese ratio was excellent and the crust was crispy and well made. Both of my kids enjoyed their pizzas and I will absolutely be returning!

The food is wonderful and even when not in store, you can tell that the food is homemade. The guys…read morein the back are so kind and seem to truly care about what they're making and the service they are providing to their customers. The wait time is a little long but it doesn't really affect you when you know that the outcome is going to be 50x better than the wait. Great things take time. I love the feel of the shop when you go in to eat. Even with little space, it gets you closer to the action. Love Coffaro's! They are vegetarian friendly and welcoming to all eaters alike :)

Pepperoni Pizza was excellent. I didn't care much for the…read more"hot" wings. I was in the mood for wings & they were disappointing .. not hot or much flavor to them. I look forward to getting other items on the menu next time. The menu looks amazing. We will visit again.

Food was delicious. However, it is pricey. Only negative comment is they are very stingy on their…read moreglasses of wine.

One of the MOST authentic home cooked home made pasta restaurants in…read more NW PA area. All the Pastas are made in house. The gnocchi are pillow airy delicacies. Going back again with some ITALIAN FOODIES.

Absolutely, The food is very good and the service is great, especially if you get Barb as your…read moreserver. She is very considerate, conscientious, friendly and kind. She goes out of her way for the customers. The restaurant is very clean and attractive.

If I could give negative stars, I would. I know this restaurant is located in Meadville, not NYCor…read moreChicagobut do yourselves a favor and go elsewhere if you desire actual 'Italian' food, or anything resembling the traditional fare you'd expect to find. It's definitely not located here. Lackluster, well, everything. I don't think I have been more disappointed by what has been presented to me while dining. NOT RECOMMENDED. 0 STARS.

Best pizza in the area. The service is quick and the employees are always friendly! Pizza, subs,…read morebreadsticks... it's all always good!

It was good. Nothing special and it wasn't expensive so I would probably go again but wouldn't go…read moreout of my way.

Consistent food for years. Whenever we visit the area this is a must stop. Ice cream shop is…read moreawesome.

A little slow on service but overall good food was a Friday afternoon when I went but will go back…read moreagain

I'm currently experiencing heart burn, but it was well worth it!…read more Surprisingly this isn't a review for the pizza. It may be in the name, but what I order has absolutely nothing to so with the pie. It's the tacos I come for! Since my hubby is a Meadville townie, he knows the secret, that these tacos are the best! They may have nothing to do with "authentic mexican" and I'm pretty sure the beef is flavored with some sort of Mexican powdered mix, but they are darn tasty! The cheddar cheese piled on top doesn't hurt the cause either! Bonus points for selling Boylan's Cream Soda!

Great pizza. Fast service. Friendly people. Home town atmosphere…read more They have been in business for a long time.