New owners as of 2023. I don't get the name change. It's not a diner and they don't sell diner…read morefood. Pizza was very meh. Nothing special but did give a lot of toppings. Appetizer sampler order was wrong, did not receive mushrooms. Breaded wings were overcooked and dry. Will not be back anytime soon

Definitely one of the better pizza places in the area - keep in mind no parking out front but there…read moreis some up and down a block or so (meters). Tried Chip N Rocks for the first time tonight. We ordered two xl cheese pizzas and a whole Italian hoggie. Pizza review: red sauce is really good - sweet side but not too sweet. Kids liked it - especially the one that is not a fan of red sauce. Italian hoggie: good taste - just needs cooked a little more for my liking. Know to ask this for next time. All in all ... good pizza joint and will be back..

We get their party pizzas all the time for events, and enjoy their pizza. This week I ordered a…read moresmall pizza and hot pepper cheese balls... I paid $8.50 for 12 of these... they could at least fill the bottom of the container?!

I ordered their mushroom pizza a couple of times. The last time it was made with barely any…read moremushrooms on it. I called to complain and offered to show pictures. The owner was so put out that I was unhappy. He said he would give me a free pizza...reluctantly. I had 30 days to come get it. I called and just tried ordering my pizza and he literally 'HUFFED' in my ear. The WORST customer service. It was his establishment that did not make the pizza as advertised and he had an attitude with me. Will never go back!!

Pizza never disappoints. It's pretty greasy which is the way we like it around here…read more Recently got a whole cheesesteak with extra meat, it was splendid. Hot Garlic wing sauce was a hit as well. Pizza Co in south Baldwin is a go to for us.

Pizza was very good! They do slices which was also nice. Service was quick and friendlyread more

I went here with the Pittsburgh pizza passport when I was in the area. Got to meet the owner who…read morestarted the company with his father, and there are only two locations -- both in the South Hills. Both along Highway 79. The owner was extremely friendly and even gave us more pizza than what the passport allowed for. And we were impressed with the homemade garlic butter sauce. The food is inexpensive in the ambience is very casual. Stop by for a quick bite.

Good food nice people. Close by and smells good nice atmosphere…read more Walked into this place and it instantly smelled like garlic, tomato, and a wood-fired oven. Small spot, maybe 8 tables, counter service, but clean and busy in a good way -- always a solid sign. Staff was quick, friendly, and didn't blink when I asked for extra red pepper flakes. Ordered a large cheese and a pepperoni to keep it classic. The crust was thin NY-style with a nice char on the bottom, crispy edge but still foldable. Sauce was bright and tangy, not sugary. Cheese had that perfect stretch without drowning the slice. Pepperoni curled into little cups with crispy edges. Good job

The best part of this place is their employees do crack! When you give a business $300+ of business…read moreyou'd expect no complaints, especially to your face. However, crack hinders one's judgement. Also loved the woman at the register giving away free food to her drug dealer in front of us, while he mentions the lovely whore houses of this area! These Yankees got some problems! Good food. That's about where the good review ends. The service was okay, for 6 workers our large order might have been too much.

Ordered artichokes & got anchovies. Ordered a large wedding…read moresoup & got an almost empty soup container with a melted lid (from the microwave) in a soaked brown bag. The soup had random Lipton soup noodles & something else funky. Straight into trash. I didn't even bother to complain. One more customer gone!

Greats service ,called in my to get an Italian hoagie for pickup, the young lady was polite, when…read moreshe took my order. Gave me the price, and said it would be ready in 15 minutes.

I'm sad this place doesn't have a better online presence. We've been on the hunt for our favorite…read morepizza place since we moved to PA. This is a really good contender. The sauce is not too sweet or acidic. The outer crust is fluffy on the inside and the perfect crunch on the outside. They told us our delivery would take up to 45 mins but we got it within 30 mins.

Absolutely the BEST Calzone I've ever had! Seriously!! Asked for a pretty specific order, and it…read morewas just Perfect!! I'm a regular of at least once a month, and it's always,always excellent!

Anyone know what's going on with Pizza Marsala in Irwin? There food used to be really good. Last…read morethree times we ordered pizza, it was burnt, hard and hardly any cheese. Two of the pizzas were red sauce one a white pizza. I find them a little pricey but it used to be worth it, no more. I don't know if they have new people cooking or what. We will be taking a break from them for awhile!

First time here since they moved in. This is a good pizza place. I haven't had their pizza in a…read morelong time. Pizza is thin and tastes great. Had breadsticks and wings. All was very good and affordable. I will order from here again.

I've tried the pizza a couple of times and every time it had an odd spice added into the sauce. I…read moregave up on ordering it again.