Pizza never disappoints. It's pretty greasy which is the way we like it around here. Recently got a whole cheesesteak with extra meat, it was splendid. Hot Garlic wing sauce was a hit as well. Pizza Co in south Baldwin is a go to for us. read more

Pizza was very good! They do slices which was also nice. Service was quick and friendly

The pizza was great and so was Alyssa, friendly and outgoing to please the customer! Give her a raise Pizza Company she is a keeper!!!!!!!!

Hoping to find good pizza near me. This is not the place. Wings were fine but the pizza was burnt on the edges and was very salty and greasy and skimpy on the cheese. I won't return. read more

Ordered a medium veggie pizza. It was delicious. The delivery service was great. The pizza was hot and the cheese was gooey and yummy.

6/6 One girl w the piercing kept touching her eyes scratching her scalp and hair. She put a slice of pizza on the counter and heft it there, they are very clean and don't wash hands often. A bunch of kids making pizza no hair nets or gloves only manager had gloves read more

Rating: 4.6 Stars I have been eating The Pizza Company in South Baldwin for well over a decade. I came here back in the days of Tastee-Freez. Man, I miss those vanilla milkshakes and their amazing soft serve, including the vanilla soft serve dipped in blue goo! I'd get the cheese fries multiple times a month in high school. Fast forward to 32-year-old me... ...I am visiting Pittsburgh for the holidays, and my brother requested that we order some pizzas from here. We ordered a cheese pizza and a pepperoni pizza. Glad we did! Their pizza has been INCREDIBLY consistent over the years. It always has a lot of flavor, and the sauce has a nice sweetness. The dough has great taste and a nice texture. There is a slight crisp to the crust, which is great. The three-cheese blend is yummy and flavorful. They are generous with the pepperoni slices, which have great savory taste and a nice crisp. Importantly, the pizza slices have great flop. This is one of the best pizzas in Pittsburgh in my opinion, especially for the price. My only complaint would be that there can be a little extra grease at times--nothing that a little dabbing can't fix! Finally, their business website is quite nice! Furthermore, they do a great job with pick-up and following COVID-19 protocols to protect their employees and customers. Give them the business during this pandemic! read more

See all

I've only ever had the Philly steak and cheese hoagie. My coworkers love this place and eat here all the time. Their favorite is the Italian hoagie and pizza. Today they talked me into ordering with them and I ordered the Philly. It's a decent size hoagie, for $12 I expect as much. It was decent, but it had a unique taste. Not terrible but just odd. I'm trying to figure it out, maybe an artificial beef flavoring? I'm just not sure what it was. I still gobbled the hoagie down, but still spent the entire time guessing what the flavor was. Despite not being wowed, I'll go back again and try the Italian or pizza that my coworkers all love. read more

The Pizza Company - Baldwin - Opened cheesesteak with ketchup added. - Pizza Near Me - Baldwin, Pennsylvania

See all

It's been awhile since we've had Pizza Company. We didn't even realize that they delivered to our new house, but a neighbor told us that they did. We preordered a Greek, buffalo and cheese pizza to have for dinner with some family. We called ahead of time and asked for a 5:30 delivery. They were super friendly about accommodating us. Everything arrived on time, hot and delicious. The gentleman even walked out order around the back of our house when he saw us outside having a fire. I love their crust, love the flavorful toppings and the ranch dressing is one of the very best around. We will absolutely continue to order from Pizza Company when we have friends and family over or when I'm too lazy to cook. read more

Hello fellow Yelpers! A solid three stars here for us! Our friends picked up the order and they said everyone was really nice. The chicken wings are pretty tasty, they aren't the crispiest wings nor are they the kind that gets ovened and is soft. It's an interesting mix of both. The hoagies weren't bad either, we got Italian hoagies and Philly cheese steaks and everyone seemed to agree they were solid. Not the best, but the worst. We didn't really enjoy the pizza as much though. We think there's better pizza in the city. The crust was a bit flat and the pizza wasn't too memorable compared to others. Again a situation of not very good, not very terrible. We'd say a solid place If you'd like some friendly service and delivery and looking for a solid bite. Thanks for reading and taking time here! Have a wonderful day you amazing person you!! read more

I just moved to the Pittsburgh area last May and was desperately searching for the best pizza in our area. I live two minutes up the road from The Pizza Company and let me tell you....it's dangerous! This pizza is by far my number one favorite pizza place and almost tops my hometown favorites. The staff has been so friendly and their COVID regulations are super great! I am obsessed with their pizza! My only complaint is that their prices are a littttttlleeee high, however, for how much I love this pizza..it's so worth it. read more

The Pizza Company - Baldwin - Small Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Baldwin, Pennsylvania

Ordered a large for a Friday lunch delivery. I have other "Go To" pizza favorites but decided to try something new. The person who took my phone order and the delivery guy were polite and professional. Oh yeah--And the pizza was reallllly good! Pizza wasn't greasy and the crust was medium thickness which is my preference. I don't want a loaf of bread as the foundation of my pizza slice. Will definitely be going back. Order a Large pie or bigger as the large pizza Was not not that big--Seemed more like a medium to me. read more

It has been awhile since I ordered from the pizza company in Baldwin and I have to say it will be in the normal rotation from now on for the kids and I. The pizza was cooked perfectly which I find to be half of the battle these days. So many places are under cooking their pizza...this was done perfectly. The flavor was also great with a sweet but not too sweet sauce, good amount of cheese and crisp pepperoni. We also ordered some chicken tenders which the kids said were some of the best they had. They looked and tasted like pizzeria chicken tenders. Also scoring some big points in my book for not giving packaged ranch and blue cheese. Homemade is the only way to go. Nice Job Pizza company in Baldwin! read more

This location never disappoints!! We got the 8 cut pizza with pepperoni & bacon, and banana peppers on half. The bacon and pepperoni are both really crispy and really make the pizza! The crust was also cooked perfectly. I am very picky about pizza and I love this pizza! It is always consistently good, which is really important to me when finding a good pizza place. We also ordered the Italian hoagie and the sweet and spicy wings. Each were equally good!! The staff is always friendly on the phone and in person. We drive from bethel to pick up always! read more

Placed an order for a small white and small pepperoni pizza for delivery. Food was sent to the wrong address and the order was incorrect. Didn't receive the white and instead got a xl plain. Both pizzas were just ok, much better out there in the Pittsburgh area. The owner did credit me back for the inconvenience but I don't see myself returning in the future. read more

Outstanding food and service!!! Really enjoyed our food order. Thank yo all again!!

I'm a regular at Pizza Company! Seriously, the pizza and breadsticks are so delicious, and the dipping sauce that comes with it is so good!!! They always deliver hot and fresh, and I've never had any issues with this place. Pizza company is my go to! read more

Had an order of 6 wings today...little over cooked, more expensive than they should be @ $8.99 plus tax, and not to mention they were the smallest skimpiest wings I've ever seen....got an 8 cut 1 topping pizza (medium at best) for over $11.00 and change...not much taste compared to other places around the South Hills....won't go back again...over priced and barely average food quality...my 2 cents read more

The food is extremely overpriced. $15 for what looked like a small pizza. 8 tiny slices. When I called to ask if they sent me the wrong pizza, I was hung up on. I called back and the manger told me that she hung up on me "because it was Friday night and they are busy". Then she had the nerve to comment that I didn't tip the person that delivered the food. The reason I didn't tip is because I didn't get a bill! I don't keep cash on hand all of the time. I tip very well, but I've never not received a bill to sign. This is the worst experience I have ever had with a pizza shop. We will NEVER order here again & would not recommend them to anyone. Extremely rude manager & way overpriced food. I told them to come back and get their food & they refused. read more

Would have loved to try The Pizza Company but after trying to get past their busy signal 75 times, I gave up hope. I get Fridays are busy nights for pizza places. Get call waiting and maybe you'll get more business ‍ read more

The Greek salad is the best salad you can get from a pizza place, maybe any place. This is the forth or fifth one I've gotten, the lettuce is always fresh, generous amount of feta cheese and olives. Pizza and hoagie are great too read more

The Pizza Company - Baldwin - Yes, I ate half of it before I took the pic. - Pizza Near Me - Baldwin, Pennsylvania

Not pleased with the large mushroom extra sauce pizza I ordered which cost me near $16.00. I don't mind paying any amount for a good pizza but this one was far from that. Almost no sauce, plain tasting & maybe 5 mushrooms on the whole pie. Not a happy customer. Will not be back to this place. read more

We ordered a takeout order (ready in time specified) and got an Italian hoagie and a cheesesteak/steak hoagie. Both were superb. The guy running the joint was friendly. What more could a hungry fella ask for? I'd definitely return. I'm curious about the pizza, but the hoagies are a "go"! read more

I ordered a large buffalo chicken with extra sauce and a pepsi for delivery. It was delivered in the time said but the pizza was cold, the pepsi was warm and there were no extra sauces that I paid for. I called the store immediately but all I got was a busy signal for 30 minutes. I called the next day and talked to a girl that did not work the night before. She was rude and told me the owner who worked the night before would not do anything to help me! I was told pretty much "too bad". I have never had a problem with them before but I definitely would not recommend this particular store afyer the way they treated me and my complaint! read more

I live in Ohio but visit Pittsburgh on a regular basis. Everytime I visit I order pizza from The Pizza Company - my family and I love it! Their food is top quality and their customer and delivery is second to none. Highly recommended!!! read more

Lived in Pittsburgh for 10 years and this is the best pizza I've ever had here. Highly recommend trying their ranch as well.

Their pizza is great but a little on the greasy side. Love their hot wings just be sure to ask for sauce on the side. Sometimes they come with only a little sauce and other times they're drowning in it. read more

The pizza here is usually so very very good. We ordered a pepperoni feast pizza today. The basic crust was great as usual. I was just totally shocked about the amount of pepperoni. The slices had only 6 pieces of pepperoni on them! Come on! Is this a feast? The pieces were small like always. No problem. Thats why we got the feast. We lose...they win. read more

Just moved back to south hills, so it has been my mission to find the best pizza places around. i'm still searching but I think this is definitely one of my top choices. Really good stuff, all of it. The dough is cooked perfect, soft inside. Good cheese blend, do i detect cheddar? Great wings, nice n crispy, a little small though. Like little baby chickens, maybe midget chickens. Check it out read more

Frequent customers-have not had a bad experience yet. The food is always tasty and the employees always friendly. Definitely one of the best spots in the area read more