Saw the good reviews, so we decided to check this place out. The N/A Negronis we started with were…read morethe closest we've had to the real thing so far. The arancini balls are as good as others have posted about. The squid ink pasta was so-so. The Cacio e pepe was my favorite of the two. Loved that they offer "scarpetta" to mop up all the great flavors of the pasta. That allowed me to get a teaser of the sourdough that must make it in to the pizza, too. Finished off with a tiramisu, which had rich flavor. Looking forward to the next time! Our server was attentive, but not too much. We sat outside, which was quite pleasant.

Every time I come here, I say, "oh, this is the best thing I've had so far!" And I come here often…read more From the savory, melt in your mouth meatballs to the Linguine alle vongole, you can't go wrong. Even rye Squid Ink Pasta is extraordinary, but beware, it can be spicy. And then there's the acacia e Pepe which is so satisfying (pro-tip: add capers, pepper flakes and pancetta, and it's like a little flavor burst of goodness). You can even customize your dish (or at least they've allowed me to when I dine here) to how you want it. The wait staff and bartenders are attentive and extremely customer service forward - so make sure to tip them well when you come here.

What a fun place, terrific food and people. Fun art on the walls…read more Ordered 2 different focaccia pizzas to go: caramelized onion & walnut, chili garlic mushroom; and the absolutely delish goat mountain salad. Would most definitely recommend this unique pizza place.

Fans traveling for the Taylor Swift concert in BC filled our downtown streets last night, so we…read morewent hunting from restaurant to restaurant, looking for a place without a long wait. Lo! We saw some people exiting Goat Mountain and were able to snag their empty seats at the bar. Lucky us! And not only for the seats. We've never been here before, and we had a great time. We ordered the Goat Mountain Salad--huge! A bargain! Varied! Delicious! And I, who has never met a beet that I didn't dislike, was delighted that ingredients were grouped individually so I could avoid those. Wonderful salad! And--for a mere buck--you can order a dressing on the side for anything you want. The buttermilk was delicious. I ordered a slice of the Apple & Bacon pie; my guy, Potato & Bacon. Upon their arrival, our notions of pizza were shattered. These were big slices of cake! (Website says Roman-style--we've been to Rome, but these exquisite things were very different.) Totally yummy. As was the warm chocolate chip cookie--divine. (Funny story: I didn't have my readers on. I thought the price was $25. "That's quite a cookie!" I thought, imagining one as large as a pizza--which, incidentally, would have been more expensive than their full pizzas! I looked over the Happy Hour menu, planning a future return. The cookie on the HH menu was only $2. A savings, I excitedly told our bartenders, Miyuki and Montana, of $23!!! No, they told me: 50 cents. I hadn't been able to see the dot.) And speaking of our barkeeps, I am so glad we sat up at the bar. They were wholly delightful and friendly. We very much enjoyed chatting with them. We felt like we had just moved and this was our new "neighborhood bar." And their recommendations for food and drink were spot on. The Smoke in Mirrors was fantastical! Great place!

I'll start by saying I'm from NY...only to say I've had a lot of pizza in my life and have a…read moresubconscious habit to compare every slice to one another. This pizza (Square Pepperoni Dream w/ hot honey (add on)) was maybe the best pizza I've ever had. The medium was four big slices with a crisp delicate crust like no other, a mix of crunchy and slightly soft quality pepperoni, stretchy mozzarella cheese, and a perfect red sauce that wasn't acidic. The server (sorry, girl, didn't get your name) was helpful and honest about the build your own (gets pricey if you customize substitute). The ambience is very cool with great beer options. Located in downtown Bellingham by my hotel (Hotel Leo). Even has EV chargers in the lot. Hoping to return to Bellingham just to try more pizzas.

Called in an order for pickup and was ready right when we asked for it. We arrived a few minutes…read moreearly and had to wait, but it was ok! Ordered a large meat lovers and it was very tasty! The service was good and it was busy inside and outside! Had great toppings, thanks for a great pizza!!

How do we know the kitchen closes at 9...... I didn't care…read morefor this place the first time I was there- I wanted to try again. Arrived at 9:03 and was rudely told the kitchen was closed... "every night" the girl said like I was supposed to know. We won't be back.

This place is really cool and funky. A lot of college students come here. The seating arrangements…read morevaries from corner to corner as long benches to tables over whiskey barrels. The beer selection is overwhelming and the cooler runs the length of the whole place. But also have a cider room with large selection of ciders. There is also a large seating area in the cider room. We got here on a Friday night and the place of packed. They had 24 beers on top to add to the indicision... This place is an experience in and of itself... Do you want it Do you want it

Delicious. I could have had triple size pizza. It was so good and we enjoyed every bite. The…read morecookies were excellent that his wife makes. I can't wait to go back. The people were super nice as well.

The pizza was delicious and the service was also fantastic. I would highly recommend this place…read more We're from New Jersey and we know good pizza.

We stopped here on a trip to Canada for my grandmas birthday and we're so impressed…read more My cousin is vegan and she loved that she had meat and cheese options! We also had the McHale which was delicious. The only downside was that our small pizza was more lukewarm and their large pizza was almost too hot to touch, but both were still delicious. We also got some ranch to dip our crust in and it was amazing. The star of the dinner was the spinach salad tho!! The vinaigrette is absolutely perfect and not too sour.y grandma and I think about the salad all the time now, just superb!! The service was great and the restaurant itself is cute :)

Best pizza in town! Lots of vegan options…read more Outstanding service. Small space and can be rather busy in the evening. Patio when the weather is nice.

What s surprise this place is. Their twist seems to be to be an Indian slant…read more While there we saw another lady pick up an order of French fries, they smelled and looked amazing! Had a pizza myself there and quality was very nice. The eating area is small, a handful of tables, functional with little ambiance. The cashier who took order was very nice and friendly. Will definitely be back as really enjoyed their pizza, next time fries!!

Do not get delivery through their website my order sat for a half hour and took me calling to…read morecomplain before they figured out who was supposed to deliver it. it was over an hour before my food arrived.

McKays pizzas was good and their bartender / server was friendly and gave us suggestions to save a…read morefew bucks. We had their half Pesto Pizza and hawaiian w/ jalapenos. Was pretty good... especially when its hot from the oven. Their wings was decent enough for my son to devour it all. Their jalapeno poppers was standard. Their cesar salad was pretty good. Overall a suprisely good spot to have a few beers and delicious pizza.

Not great. Taco pizza was weird. Three topping pep, sausage, mushroom was pretty much missing…read moretomato sauce. Crust was doughy. Delivery was prompt and accurate, but probably would not order here again unless there were no other options. Definitely a step up from Pizza Hut or Domino's but only barely.

I've driven by Sliced many times on the way to the mall restaurants and figured it was some sort of…read morefranchise and the food would be meh. Big mistake. Big. I decided to try it on a Tuesday. Arrived during the hottest day of the year so far to find a nice cool, clean, classy interior. Was immediately greeted by a friendly hostess who seated me immediately. Restaurant was moderately quiet. Water and menu obtained, I perused the choices and decided Pizza was the thing. The pizza prices were a bit on the high side for a franchise place but the descriptions were promising with some interesting ingredients. Then I spotted it on the bottom of the menu...the Fig Pig. How could I not try it! About 15 minutes later it arrived, I took the first bite and Oh My Lord...when they redo the menu, it needs to be at the top. This is my new favorite pizza in Bellingham. Salty, crispy, meaty and sweet. It hits all the hot buttons. The crust is actually tasty, the pork is perfectly done. It was freaking delicious. Even better, once I finished half the pizza...it was that good...and a box and the check were delivered...the pizza was half off. I called the hostess over to ask if it was a mistake and she said all pizzas are half off on Tuesdays. I now know my Tuesday dinners. I've told a bunch of people now and will be taking my neighbors next Tuesday. Oh and turns out it's not a franchise but a family run restaurant.and it was staring me in the face the entire time. In the words of Arnold Schwarzenegger...I'll be back.

I love this place. My hostess was charming, thoughtful and sweet, helping me find just the right…read morespot to meet my needs and wants. Kaiya was my server. When I asked if the bartender might be talked into creating a mocktail for me--something not on the list, but bartender's choice, she said, "Sure! I'm the bartender!" She made me a lovely beverage that included ginger beer, cranberry juice, lime, bitters, not sure if or what else--but it was elegantly flavored and just soooo nice. She recommended the Greek pizza--omg! Perfect choice! I admit I do like salty, and some people might have found it so--I thought it was flavorful and perfect. Exquisite, really. I really liked the Caesar salad. It doesn't come across as very fancy as it does in other places, more high-end, but the flavor of the dressing is pungently perfect and I thought puts many I've had to shame. Pleasant place overall. I'm really glad for that one day when I walked across the Bellis Fair parking lot and tried it out.

We only order the gluten free pizzas here and they are by far one of the best pizzas in town. Staff…read moreis always friendly when we pick up our pizzas. We have never dined in but the place seems warm and cozy. My only complaint is how expensive the pizzas are even with coupons and ordering during happy hour.

We both ordered a create your own personal pizzas. Randy got the red sauce, pepperoni, tomatoes and…read moregarlic and Randy liked it. He liked the crust of it and wished the pepperoni was a smaller round but he really liked it. I ordered pesto with mushrooms, red onion and green bell pepper and it was good but too thick for my liking. I prefer a thin crust. I'm basically not a pizza person so the rating is based on Randy's assessment. We also had the cheeseballs - again Randy's assessment...he liked them. I'm editing this review to add: I didn't say anything about the excellent customer service. The young man at the counter greeted us when we walked in, answered our questions and went out of his way to help us figure out what we wanted and we watched him do it with everyone who entered. A great representative of this business.