We come to Newyago once every summer and make sure to stop in every time. The pizza here is unlike…read moreanything I've ever tasted. While the service can be a little slow, the food is always fabulous and absolutely worth it.

Friday evening 5:30pm surprised no wait for table for 2. Started with a glass of Hard Apple Pie…read morecider $8, nice flavor. Unusual for me to order a sandwich, bourbon Chicken $15, upgraded to side Caesar salad $2. Very good, chunks of chicken breads, apples, bacon, spinach, melted smoked cheddar, bourbon BBQ sauce in nanny bread. The side Caesar was disappointment, no romaine lettuce but them mixed greens. Husband tried the smoked tacos, $15 with side of tortilla chips. The flaky paratha shell was unusual and really good, kind off a deep fried soft flaky bread. 2 large shells filled with tasty smoked shredded pork. Pineapple salsa, jalapeños crisps, mexican cheese. Very filling.

Looking at past reviews, i think this place is worth a try…read more Friday @ 7pm, winter. I ordered small Supreme pizza, Italian Salad...was told ready for pick up in 25 minutes. First, I hate when establishments pad the time or always give the same time to pickup. The reason I'm picking up and not having it delivered, is because I want to eat HOT food. So I arrived earlier than told, and the pizza clearly had been ready for at least 8-10 minutes before they predicted it would be ready. Second. I was impressed with the size and quality of there Italian Salad. Great price at $9.99. Galaxy Supreme $14.99, outside of toppings. Good price. Only disappointment was it sat waiting for me, due to being told too long it would be ready, so it wasn't hot when I got home. Btw...mushrooms on pizza are sliced fresh ones...I forgot to ask...I'm one of those people that only like canned mushrooms on my pizza.

I've been going to Galaxy Pizza since I was a kid, there's nothing like it. Best pizza you can get…read morein Newaygo County by far.

The vibes were SO nice! They had yard games, beautiful lake views, and the option to pull your boat…read moreright up, which made the whole experience feel fun and relaxed. The one-of-a-kind footlong hot dog was SO good and definitely worth trying.

Nice ambiance. Limited parking. Decent service. Very disappointed in the pizza. Cheese, sauce and…read moretoppings were all pretty good. The dough/crust was absolutely awful ... Had one and a half slices and gave up. Avoid the pizza.

WOW! They have the best chicken bacon ranch pizza I have EVER had. The bread bites were so fluffy…read moreand buttery and so GOOD. The staff was very attentive and friendly and happy to fulfill our requests. Food came out very fast. Definitely check this place out!!

Great Gem! Excellent pizza and cool atmosphere…read more Really great decor and cool car vibe. Must try! Great service

Okay.... A three only because the atmosphere is creepy! But the pizza is great!!!…read more If you're a tRumpf fan, you'll be right at home. Too bad they have to have creepy cardboard stand ups and him peeking behind the booze. Service was very good. But I'd Be Leary if you are the slightest bit brown.

Try some unique pizzas. Today we had one of the state…read morepassport pizzas- boil dinner on a pizza.

Best pizza in the world.With lot's of competition around.Its hands down the best around.read more

Silver Lake Pizza was on a Yelp top 100 pizza list, and was the only one from Michigan. I had it on…read moremy list to try, but it didn't live up to the hype. I can see how they would be amazing after a long day at the beach, but so would a bag of Cheetos. The pizza was thin crust. We tried the pickle and a margarita. I wanted to get a schooner with coke and no alcohol, but they said no. We also ordered an appetizer that they never brought out. Felt like a tourist trap.

Pizza was so good! Had a supreme. I am what they call a pizza expert and this sauce was superb!…read moreAlso the cheese clearly isn't old it's fresh. Kids working the register were good in person but not friendly on the phone. Glad I was picking up because the ambiance of the place was straight outta 1980. Will be back for carry out pizza again VERY soon!

This is a place that truly represented what a family restaurant was to me. It's changed a bit now…read more The giant painting of the city of Palermo no longer hangs on the western wall, the Italian colors in the form of curtains have been replaced. The exquisite fried zucchinis my uncle would buy me when I was a little boy have gone extinct, can no longer be found on the menu. But most importantly, the booth in the corner is empty, the booth where you would find the owner smoking a cigarette almost every night. Unfortunately he passed, a very serious fellow but he could cook wonders. A truly authentic feel and taste. The roast beef sub was in my opinion, the best in the region. And their chicken Alfredo was super creamy, a real delicacy. The Italian bread was the secret I believe. A very nostalgic place to me that is no more, the changes have been drastic. They say change is good but there's always an exception. The roast beef sub was perfect, it didn't need to switch from Swiss to cheddar cheese and definitely didn't need bacon. I did ask for the original which they gladly made, the taste was a bit off though. The Alfredo was a bit watery and the flavor was very mild compared to the rich, sharper flavor the older one had. The pizza wasn't bad, didn't change much. Service was pretty decent, no complains there. The updated menu was a real game changer for me, will no longer be dining here.

always fresh, hot, and delicious! The breadsticks are definitely the best I've ever had of any…read morerestaurant. I often am asked to pick up the breadsticks on my way out of town to deliver the friends and family in either the Muskegon or GR area. The pizza is also amazing

Breadsticks and sauce WHEN warm are fire, very good. But pizza is very mid and very over priced.read more

Amazingly fresh pizza. Two guys working really hard. The register guy was really nice and had it…read moreall under control. We'll be back.

Their pizzas are always cooked well. Very delicious. Also they are always prepared in a timely…read moremanner!