Fantastic Italian food! Its our regular place we go every week seriously i cant get enough! Lasagna and pasta Roma their spaghetti with meat sauce and their crabcakes are divine read more

Amazing food, great customer service, clean tables and bathroom great place to come. Yucycycycy

Food was delicious, service was awesome, and the atmosphere was idyllic. We couldn't eat ALL the food we ordered, it was very filling and even better on day 2. I highly recommend going but go hungry because you will be full afterwards. read more

See all

Waited for over 30 minutes and then told us they wasn't taking any more customers after telling us they was going to seat us

Everything was Great! I had the Lasagna and my wife had the ziti. We visited for lunch and the portions were large. Excellent! read more

Little Italy Restaurant - Lasagna lunch portion - Pizza Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

Unless you have the entire evening free skip this one. Been here an 1.5hrs and still waiting on my food. I ordered spaghetti and meatballs‍ I ate my salad 45min ago now. Even if the food was good - NOPE NEVER AGAIN! Edit..Meatballs cold - but the nuked them to make warm. Food was ok not worth the wait. read more

Great reasonably priced food!! I miss their manicotti but they have other Great dishes. Service is always on point. Great staff

The food was wonderful, fresh breadsticks with pesto oil delicious. We got the rigatoni carbonara, all meats pizza and a Buffalo chicken pizza - which were all great when it came to flavor and overall taste. What I could say about the service is it needed some assistance. While I understand staffing shortages your server shouldn't be unprofessional and commenting on other tables while working with you. We had to ask for silverware, water refill (of the pitchers), and for 4 pieces of pizza was brought two large pizza boxes. Moral of this review is if you want delicious food and don't care about service this is your spot; if you want it all (good food and good service, maybe order carry out and serve yourself) read more

See all

This was a pleasant surprise and an enjoyable experience. The food was fantastic. The portions are generous and the prices are reasonable. The staff is friendly. The building is modest but dinner experience was grand. read more

Awesome place. Food was fantastic. Definitely going back soon. Large portions. Clean and great service.

We stopped in for lunch with friends and had an amazing experience. The lunch size portion was just right, it was fresh and filling! We even tried the tiramisu which was perfect! The staff was friendly and attentive as well. We'll definitely visit again soon! read more

Never heard of the place until 6/7/25. Great food. Worth the drive over. Bread was excellent, baked ziti was great. Wait staff on top of things. Plus clean restrooms. read more

The food was fabulous! The best Italian I've had in this area! Services staff friendly!

This is a very quaint place. The service was excellent, fantastic food. Very comfortable atmosphere. Would highly recommend. Oh great sweet tea by the way. read more

Friendly service; great food for a good price. I added vegetables to my order and it was cooked perfectly.

Little Italy is hands down the best Italian restaurant in evansville. Service is first class. Attentive without being intrusive. The food portions are large and the breadsticks with the olive oil and herbs dip is awesome. read more

My first time trying Little Italy and I brought family along. We had Dale for our server and he was great! The food was great as was the desert selection. It was very busy but we had reservations and got seated quickly. I am going to go again and take more family with me! read more

Little Italy Restaurant is a good place for pizza. I have had better, but I have also had worse. Service is good and the place overall is a pleasant experience. I would definitely recommend a visit here. read more

We're bigger people and requested a table, they said they only had booths but the entire back wasn't being used with tables available

Solid pepperoni pizza fluffy pizza, service really fast, she remembered our order and got our free bread right away, it was nice and cool inside, plenty of tables to choose from, and booths read more

Little Italy Restaurant - It's really yummy, really great sauce and cheesy - Pizza Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

Excellent food and service and just a cute place that serves real Italian food ! Waitress was sweetest also !

Very good food. I had the Chef Salad with Italian. Not sure why there are only 2 choices for the salad dressing - Italian and Ranch. And wow!, the breadsticks - hot and delicious. Fresh out of the oven. A treat with the pesto basil olive oil dippin sauce. Service was very good. Staff was not only helpful, but very friendly. It seemed very genuine. read more

My wife and I went to Little Italy a second time and we were NOT disappointed. Both of us have Italian heritage and comef rom the North East where there are plenty of Italians and Italian restaurants. Not only do we cook Italian food in our home, but we have also had the pleasure of traveling to Italy. I can say without any fear of contradiction that, outside of the Italian dishes made in our home, Little Italy has the absolute FINEST and authentic Italian cooking in all of the Evansville Tri-state bar-none. We highly recommend that you go and enjoy! Molto Bene! read more

Friendly service. The same server each time we visit. Owner/chef has come to our table to inquire as to how our was. We have tried several dishes and never been disappointed. read more

The food is phenomenal! If you want good service, this is not the place to good. Waiters chat too much. read more

Little Italy Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

Great food and service. We ordered the spinach and cheese ravioli, chicken parm, shrimp Alfredo and the rigatoni carbonara with chicken. They were all very good but my favorite was the Alfredo sauce it was delicious. We also had the lemon cream cake and the tiramisu which were both awesome. We had the lunch specials and the portions are still huge. We will be back. read more

See all

The food was excellent and the service was great with patient servers and manager. The ambiance was a comfortable setting in a rainy night.

Spaghetti was tomatoes sauce and meatballs. Nasty!!! Don't see how this place got 4 stars from anyone. Evansville must have very low expectations for quality of food. It would explain why the health dept is hitting a lot of restaurants in Evansville. Waitress was attentive. The setting was nice. read more

Honestly, wasn't expecting much from this place but it exceeded my expectations. The inside looks a bit outdated, cute but outdated. Service was fine. We went during lunch hours & the place was surprisingly kind of busy but our food still came out pretty quick. Food was good. My husband got the pizza with a few different types of meat & green pepper. The sauce on the pizza was really good. I had the spinach ravioli with Alfredo sauce. I was thrown off when they asked if I wanted Marianna sauce or Alfredo. I went with the Alfredo. The sauce was extremely creamy & rich, a bit too rich for my liking but it was good. Finished the whole plate. You could tell that it was housemade. Had tiramisu afterwards and it was great. Not overly sweet & great favor. read more

See all

This is a great little restaurant to stop in for lunch. We went here with my 1 year old and it has such a great family atmosphere. Servers were fast and friendly. The food tasted like it was all made from scratch. We had the spinach ravioli in marinara and it was fantastic! Prices are great as well. We will definitely be stopping by again! read more

Outstanding!! The food and service is wonderful. The atmosphere is almost homie. Lots of dishes to choose from and must of sound as good as the ones we got. Can't wait to return and try them all. read more

Little Italy Restaurant - Eggplant Parmesan - Pizza Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

Food is very good! I love how it feels cozy and the staff is very friendly! Definitely recommend this restaurant

This place is tops. The service was too good and so attentive. The food is on a smack your mother level great. They treat you like one of their own family. I'd recommend this place over and over again read more

The service was amazing. Our waitress was on top of everything and she was funny and kind. Loved her. The food was also amazing, the shrimp special is perfect. read more

This little place is so adorable and they are so friendly! They have great pizza and pasta! The lasagna is great! We love going here and you can enjoy some good wine with your food also! read more

Always quick service and good food!!! Even takeout stays warm until home. Always a great choice

So, we were going to take pics of our meals but then the food came, the aroma insisted we taste it first and then... well... this is where we are. You will have to take our word for it - delicious! The crab cake over angel hair was heavenly. The bowl was the shrimp special we requested be adjusted for one of our friends who avoids gluten and so subbed the veggies and over rice. Great and not even a hint of a problem from Erin our server or the chef. Good times. read more

Little Italy Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

See all

You walk in and it just smells delicious. We were quickly seated on a Friday night and our waitress took our drink order right away. The side salads we had were fresh with a very good homemade Italian dressing. Our entrees had a lot of flavor. The Carbonara, Chicken Park, and Fettuccine Alfredo were all excellent. A little pricy, but worth the occasional splurge. BTW, the pizza looked awesome too! read more

Food is usually pretty good, nice customer service. The only reason I'm giving them 2 star rating is because they don't seem to be reinforcing customers to wear their masks properly when entering or exiting, and especially while waiting for a takeout order. The serving counter were food sits is right by the door where people wait for their takeout orders and wait to be seated if dining in, and so many people aren't wearing a mask properly (over their nose), some aren't wearing a mask at all. Enforcing the required mask mandate should be taken seriously, not just by the staff, but enforced on customers as well to ensure EVERYONES safety. Mask up Indiana. Get with it. read more

I visit Little Italy for the first time. Loved the decor and how it looked totally different from the previous Restaurant that was in this same spot. My server Polly was so nice and was able to answer the questions I had about the food. Off the Lunch Menu, I started off with the Wedding Soup, It was missing something. I am not sure I would order it again. I order the Gyro's Dinner which I found to be perfect in flavor and size. I would definitely order this again. I always love it when the Ice Tea is perfect just the way it is, with nothing but Ice added. Their Tea was very good. I finished off with a slice of Tiramisu, and a cup of coffee. I was very pleased with the flavor of the Tiramisu, rich! The coffee was hot and smooth. I look forward to trying something from their evening meal menu. read more

See all