Amazing food, super friendly staff and so accommodating for a large order. We will eat here every time we are in this area.

My family got 2 pizzas last night for dinner! I will give it an4 because my family loves it but I'm not a huge fan. I only like going because it's close to our house. I personally think our pizza is super bland. I even added crushed red pepper to just give it some kind of flavor. Maybe it's my tastebuds, but I don't think it's that great. read more

Evansville Twisted Tomato Pizza - pepperoni, cheese, and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

Great stroms, definitely took this title from Pizza King, the once untouchable king of stroms. These have gotten too expensive in my opinion, only get them when they run some sort of special. Believe they were about 8.50 when they opened, they run about $12 now. read more

It is unfortunate luck that we just can't have a good experience here. I don't recall if we've ever had an order completely correct. The pizza is fine but there is always something missing such as the cheese sauce that your order with the bread sticks. Tonight, we were told 45 minutes for a delivery. An hour later we called to get an update and were told the driver would leave in another 10 or so. For us, this was the last time. The pizza is good but the service, or lack of it, is what kills it. This is my first review of any business that hasn't been positive. read more

Evansville Twisted Tomato Pizza - The pizza that never was. - Pizza Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

Fast delivery, excellent food and the salad was very generous. Loved the sauce on the pizza. Highly recommended!! read more

Evansville Twisted Tomato Pizza - Cheese Pizza / Green Salad - Pizza Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

I've ordered from here several times now and ate dine-in once. The food is great, however, the customer service could be better. On several occasions I was unable to contact the business. It's possible they need a multiple phoneline phone. The time I dined in the service wasn't that great. They place wasn't busy and our waitress only checked on us once through the meal. At one point, we went to get our own refills. No big deal, but not definitely not normal table service. Also, I was told by an employee that they only deliver after 4 pm within a 5 mile radius. If you order delivery, just know it will probably take an hour to receive your pizza. Still worth they wait on nights I have a craving for una pizza. read more

For a small place in what seems like the middle of nowhere the food was great. I had the Stromboli, added mushrooms and banana peppers. It was cooked to perfection, good sauce and toppings. A great strom all around. Also had the breadsticks and cheese. I love dipping cheese and am always looking for the best. I'd say it was a 7.5 out of 10 (that's a good score from me for cheese sauce), good flavor and consistency with a small spice. It was cold which I didn't mind but it may have been a little better if was warmed up slightly. The breadsticks themselves were good too. I'd definitely return to try some pizza and other items from here. read more

Pizza was ok but arrived cold after being told 45 mins for delivery. 1 hour sand 15 mins later pizza arrived. WAY to expensive for a single ok pizza. read more

We found this place on yelp on the way to a concert. The food was delicious and served very quickly. Our waitress was phenomenal as well. We will definitely be back. read more

I just wanted to like this place so much. It is very close to my house, I pass it on my way home. and it serves pizza. However, after multiple times of eating here the food leaves me wanting more. The strom is bland in flavor and the times I got it, it was lacking in meat. The pizza was nothing impressive. I do not like the sauce, but they like to pour it on. The pizza could use more toppings and more cheese. If they just added some spices to the sauce it would make a world of difference. On a good note, the service has always been good. I dont give bad reviews unless deserved and I have given this place plenty of chances. I just wish I had better experiences here. read more

Wow. Just a little down the road from me and I just went for the first time. Best pizza I've had in a long time. Pleasant people and easy take out. I will definitely be back. read more

food is great, but prices are OUTRAGEOUS. prices are DECEPTIVE. 1000%. I got 3 pizzas, and price came to $65.

Pricey! Worst pizza I ever had. I ordered the vegetarian with extra mushroom. The mushrooms were chewy they were real small pieces. The Pizza was loaded with green AND black olives you couldn't take one bite without it being loaded with olives. So you couldn't even taste the mushrooms. Scratch this one off my list read more

Terrible service. If they say 15-20 mins, that's mean it would be more than 30 mins waiting. Waitress look like not like to work lol.

we tried it out one night because we felt like getting a different pizza place it was delicious we had it delivered we enjoyed it really fresh for some pizza I'd recommend coming here and get some pizza or order online read more

Once we experienced Twisted Tomato, we have never went for any other pizza in town! The Mad Scientist is a must try! Today, we decided to try the Taco Pizza! That was the best Taco Pizza I've ever had! The staff is always so friendly and accommodating when we come in with a larger group! If you've never had Twisted Tomato, you won't be disappointed! read more

Horrible service. Hours say their open until 10pm, they close at 9pm. Just got off the phone at 8:20pm , looking to make a order for delivery, they said they stopped delivery at 8:30pm. read more

Our family absolutely loves the Twisted Tomato whether we are dining in or taking Pizza home. The food is amazing. They have excellent sandwiches and several great speciality pizzas like the taco pizza. The owners are very friendly. They have a nice salad bar. The overall atmosphere and decorations are warm and inviting. We take most of our out of town company there and they always ask to go back. If you go you must try their garlic cheese bread. read more

I have ordered their strombolis and had a pizza delivered. The delivery was very fast and the pizza is very good. The Wicked Stromboli is one of my favorites. read more

I have mixed feelings after my first order from Twisted Tomato. The breadsticks and cheese were phenomenal. Probably the best in the city that I have had so far. The pizza however was mediocre. I had the house speciality pizza. The crust and sauce were good. the toppings were not. Mushrooms from a can, sausage was bland. The pizza overall was bland. Not what I was expecting for the price. I will definitely get breadsticks again and maybe try something else with it. Hope to update this review with a better score in the future. I will give it another try. read more

We ordered pizza from twisted tomato a while back. It was SO GOOD! We have been wanting it again ever since. I wish their delivery area would expand, or they'd open another shop on the east side. It's a little out of our usual way to get it. read more

Love the pizza, especially crust and sauce. Always sufficient amount of cheese. Sandwiches are awesome. Delivery is always fast fresh and hot. Most servers are awesome. Don't let a full parking lot fool you. Park on street on side. They have plenty of tables. read more

Grabbed stromboli's to go. They had just enough spice and were delicious. Toasted bun had the right amount of crunch without being too crunchy or soggy. Will be visiting again. read more

Good and fast. Ordered take-out and it was ready a few minutes early. The wicked Stromboli really is spicy, but it's also delicious. I like the pizza, husband says it's too hard to bite through but I thought it had the right amount of crispiness. Sauce is a tiny bit sweet for me, but that was my only complaint. Will eat here again. read more

Excellent pizza and great friendly service!! The big pizza chain restaurants dont even come close to the tasty pizzas twisted tomatoes has! Close to home and delivered hot as well! read more

We found this place after a long day of travel softball on some fields nearby. My daughter wanted something tasting and filling and so did I. I got the Buffalo chicken sandwich and my daughter got the chicken bacon melt. We both also visited the salad bar. We were very pleased with our meal and the staff was very friendly and attentive. We'll definitely come back next time we are back in Evansville. read more

I ordered a pizza to pickup. I live less than 2 miles away and pizza was cold after waiting 20 minutes to get it. Ordered Mad Scientist pizza but didn't have all the ingredients listed. I won't be back! read more

Tried to ask a few questions about there strom, lady on the phone had no time to answer, she stated " i have customers" as if I was not a customer. Did not even get to order my food. Rude on the phone will not try there food. read more

We always look for local pizza when we travel. This pizza was great and so was the service. Really liked the crust. After we ate learned that they had only been open for four weeks. hope they stay open because they have great pizza. read more

A few friends and myself ate here. The service was good, but the food was mediocre at best. Was really disappointed in the taste and quality of the food so were my friends. There wasn't one parmesan cheese dispenser anywhere in sight in a pizza place mind you. Then when we managed to find one, a few tables over the cheese was molded. Also was extremely dissatisfied with the price we felt like we got robbed by the time we left. Wouldn't recommend this establishment to anyone. read more

Called and ordered delivery from Twisted Tomato Pizza for the 1st time. My husband and I were very impressed. They were here in the time they gave me and the pizza was great. Will not hesitate to call and order from them again!!! read more

The first time we ordered we had great service but I called 10 times on Friday and we couldn't get through so ordered Papa Johns. I called again today and got hung up on 3 time so I'm not sure we will try again. This is very sad because we liked it. read more