Cancel

Open app

Search

Lizzys Sweettooth

5.0 (4 reviews)
Closed 8:00 am - 8:00 pm

Lizzys Sweettooth Photos

You might also consider

More like Lizzys Sweettooth

Recommended Reviews - Lizzys Sweettooth

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Brooke J.
303
15
11

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Lizzys Sweettooth

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Desserts 3,650 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Gisella's Sweet Treats

Gisella's Sweet Treats

5.0(38 reviews)
10.8 km

Jess was great to work with and made an absolutely beautiful 50th anniversary cake for a party. We…read moreordered a 8 inch round cake and a half sheet for about 100 people. The cakes were supposed to serve 70 people or so. We ended up having quite a lot of cake left- the entire round cake and maybe an eighth or so of the sheet cake. The round cake was pretty hard to cut due to the height so I think we should have had the venue slice this first - sheet cake was a lot easier to pack back up and transport. That sort of made me wonder if I should have even ordered a round cake but it was definitely stunning and added a lot in terms of aesthetics and looked great in pictures. Jess was great to work with and did a great job checking in when needed. I ended up sending her a design for the round cake and she made something really lovely. She also found some gorgeous real flowers for the cake and sent me all the different options so I knew what to choose from. She even ended up adding some details to the sheet cake even though these are often left plain just for serving. We had discussed not wanting the cake to be too sweet and I think it was probably a bit too sweet still for myself and most guests. The actual cake itself was perfect in terms of texture and also flavor and sweetness and was so much better than most if not all cakes I have had. However the buttercream texture wasn't my favorite and I found it to be a bit sweeter than expected. I also wanted there to be a lot more triple berry butter cream/berry flavor. Some of the issue was also deciding to add a white chocolate layer (our suggestion so definitely on us) which didn't help the texture or flavor. Ultimately a solid cake and the vanilla bean cake itself was pretty spectacular. If I order again in the future, I would just discuss ways to make the outside buttercream less intense and find ways to incorporate more of the fruit flavors of the berry buttercream filling. A bunch of guests did ask me about the cake and say they enjoyed it so that was good. I did shop around a small amount and the prices were competitive. I had a very positive experience overall. The cakes were also easy to pick up and well packaged - if you have some kind of large flat surface like a foldable seat or back of an SUV you should be good. I would definitely order again for a party but probably would opt for even fewer portions and would make those notes about the flavors.

Baby shower was yesterday and had to come and write a review, that's how good the cake was! We…read moreasked for delivery, cake was on time and setup was great and super quick, even put our topper for us. All everyone kept saying was how good the cake was. Flavors and texture were amazing like a freshly baked cake. This was my first time buying, but definitely won't be the last! Thank you!!

Photos
Gisella's Sweet Treats
Gisella's Sweet Treats
Gisella's Sweet Treats

See all

Skiff's Cakes - Beautiful artwork on cake!

Skiff's Cakes

4.5(519 reviews)
15.3 km
$$

Skiff is a little gem that you hope does not get so big and popular, it will loose the unique…read moremagic. This bakery does beautiful work. I was asked to order a cake for a Retirement celebration. Ordering a large cake for a grand celebration put a lot of pressure on me. Costco is nice and the pricing is great, but it lacks the wow factor that I wanted for this special celebration. We had co-workers that were retiring after over 20 years of service, one retiree had over 50. So this cake had to be spectacular in looks and taste. After researching and reading many reviews, I decided to stop by and speak with Skiff to see what they offered. The minute you walk into their quaint bakery, it definitely felt unique and warm. Speaking with the gal behind the counter who assisted me in answering all my questions on the cake, pricing and decorations to make the cake look very classy and have the wow factor. I wanted whipped cream for the frosting, but was concerned that it might be too soft. I have had whipped cream that has a marshmallow texture and is not too sweet. This is exactly what was given to me to taste test. It was delicious. Since this was going to be for about 50 co-workers, we decided on a white cake, fresh strawberry, custard Bavarian cream with whipped cream. The decoration was subtle and classy with touches of gold and white chocolate as decoration on the cake. I decided to order cupcakes to bring home to try their flavors. Each cupcake was unique and so delicious. So I knew the cake was going to be amazing. Picking up the cake, they helped me to my car and ensured the cake was not going to slide around through the drive. How thoughtful. And of course, the cake did not disappoint. They had white shaved chocolates with gold touches to look like flowers in the corners of the cake. It was stunningly beautiful, classy and just so delicious. This is an amazing, unique wholesome bakery. I just hope they stay small, personable and special. I would highly recommend ordering any baking needs from Skiff's Cakes. You will not be disappointed and will have a wow factor for your guest to enjoy during any special occasion or gathering. Or even taking a dozen cookies or cupcakes to any gathering. They will up any spread to compliment both visually and taste that all will appreciate and enjoy. Thank you Skiff!! I am so glad that I have discovered a bakery that I can rely on for any bakery needs that I will need for the future. Attaching a picture of the cake but erased the names for privacy purposes. The picture does not justify the wow factor of this cake.

There needs to be a number system. I went in today, 5/23/26. There was a girl working the front…read more She told my fiancé and I that she would be with us in a moment and we said sure thing. It took her quite a few minutes to finish up with the person she was already with, no biggie, she made eye contact with us again, another person walks in and waits too. Right when they were done, the girl at the counter immediately helped the person that walked in. Like what about us? We figured, okay let it slide, we'll be helped next. When they were done, the girl at the counter asked "who can I help next?" While walking towards other people and not us. My fiancé raised his arm and said "hey we were next!" She didn't even look at us. One of the other customers that walked in heard him. We walked out of there pissed. Not coming back.

Photos
Skiff's Cakes - Vanilla butter cream with chocolate cake and strawberry mousse. Side gold leaf

Vanilla butter cream with chocolate cake and strawberry mousse. Side gold leaf

Skiff's Cakes
Skiff's Cakes

See all

Frost It Cakery - Frost It Cupcakery custom cakes, wedding cakes, dessert bars & more

Frost It Cakery

4.3(134 reviews)
12.1 km
$$

Let me just say, I'm a big fan of Frost It!…read more My hubby & I started coming here for their amazing cupcakes when they opened. Quickly, we became regulars. I can't even name all the flavors that we fell in love with, but red velvet, lemon, strawberry, salted caramel & chocolate peanut butter just to name a few. We were sad when we found out that they were transitioning from a cupcake store to a by-appointment cake shop, but I understood why. My husband & I vowed that when we got married, we would use them as our wedding cake baker. So, when we decided in July 2015 that we were getting married, we set out to make an appointment in a few months. Our appointment was scheduled for June 2016. Our friends who were visiting us, one of them was a bridesmaid, came with us for our cake tasting. My bridesmaid also paid for our wedding cake as a gift! I was blown away at such an extravagant gift ($800+)!!! We ordered for a 3 tiered ombré cake based on our wedding colors... sapphire, emerald & turquoise. The cake was supposed to be sapphire on the bottom tier & slowly transition to emerald & transition to turquoise. The flavors we picked were lemon, white velvet & chocolate. The cake was beautiful, but not quite the ombré cake I was expecting. There wasn't a seamless transition in color, which is what ombré cakes are known for. The flavors were right, but were not on the their assigned tiers. I didn't bother to complain as we were already on our honeymoon when we realized that our cake contract didn't match the cake we actually got. The cake was beautiful & delicious, so I didn't care at that point. Unfortunately, many guests didn't get the chance to even try out me cake as the cake cutting didn't happen until much later in the night & it started to get very cold. The venue saved most of our cake & we took part of it to eat with our of town family leaving the next day. They all commented that it had been one of the best cakes they've tried. So, nonetheless, I was still happy with the cake, even with the mistakes & that is my reason for 4 stars & not 5. Check out their Instagram page, you will get a much better idea of the kind of cake artistry they are capable of. Beware, you'll get hungry looking!

I still think about our wedding cake and only wish I was able to eat more of it! We highly…read morerecommend Frost It Cakery! They used all of our reference photos and delivered the exact cake we expected. Not to mention how delicious and moist the flavors were! We went with a 3-tier cake for our fall wedding and decided on the white velvet with raspberry and white velvet with blackberry with salted caramel buttercream and then pumpkin spice with cream cheese buttercream and caramel drizzle on top. They really stood above their competition, we were so happy we found them!

Photos
Frost It Cakery
Frost It Cakery
Frost It Cakery - Custom turtle topper for cupcakes

See all

Custom turtle topper for cupcakes

Sweet Arleen's - Was easy to cut and serve

Sweet Arleen's

3.6(559 reviews)
15.4 km
$$

The banana caramel cupcakes are to die for.... Literally…read more Emma is the sweetest! Every time I come in she gives amazing service

Had them for the first time on my birthday, though definitely on the pricy side…read more But they're so beautiful! Accidentally held one cupcake sideways just as I opened the door home, so the frosting got smushed but obviously didn't affect the flavor. I think this review will be heavily biased by user error thus the 5 stars though my feelings are more on 3 stars. Since we were all busy, we'd have to eat them around 10+ hours after buying and to make sure nobody accidentally ate them before my birthday; we stored them in the fridge instead of room temp which clearly did something to the frosting and cakes. Family's average favorites in order are red velvet, the confetti, cookies and cream, smores, and strawberry. The red velvet is pretty good, it's pretty rich and moist compared to the other cupcakes and the cream cheese frosting is so nice. S'mores has a strong dark cocoa flavor but also was dense and a little dry. Strawberry and confetti had nice fluffy frosting but due to the fridge mistake, it was kinda like eating chilled whipped butter. I strangely really enjoyed that. Confetti also felt and tasted like corn bread; I wasn't there to choose or see the flavors, but it was a fascinating surprise when I kept chewing and felt grit between my teeth. I didn't expect the birthday cupcake to taste like a southern take on fairy bread? But it isn't bad! Overall, I feel like they're a nice place for a little treat--the red velvet is definitely their signature for a reason. But for ~$7-10 a cupcake the flavors we chose seem to lack a reason to come back :( Unless you have dietary restrictions! I didn't try them but they have keto, vegan, and gluten free options; I know how hard it is to find a bakery that honors all 3. I also got my cupcake in one of those adorable birthday boxes (bearer of the unfortunate frosting carnage so no photo) but the butterfly is so cute! They're definitely worth a visit once, the bread puddings looked fun too, but unfortunately it seems the cupcakes are just not my cup of tea.

Photos
Sweet Arleen's - Wedding Cake Received

Wedding Cake Received

Sweet Arleen's
Sweet Arleen's - Wedding Cake Received

See all

Wedding Cake Received

Lizzys Sweettooth - desserts - Updated June 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...