BOGO lobster rolls (and other lobster dishes)?!!!? It's real! My friend and I got cold lobster rolls with cole slaw. The lobster roll was legit and loaded with well dressed meat. The cole slaw was well dressed also and tasty. The lobster bisque and clam chowder were not the best, but I can recommend the lobster rolls for sure. BOGO available ordering through Uber Eats. This place is nothing for atmosphere but the best deal on lobster no doubt. read more

Loco Lobster - Cold lobster roll and slaw - Seafood Near Me - East Moriches, New York

See all

My experience was not the same as others I see, then again, judging off all these reviews they seem inconsistent at best.... Consistently inconsistent? Pretty disappointing honestly. Mushy fries & bread, bland everything else, not such a great spot at all if you ask me. I wouldn't give them another chance, and I think they might as well close their doors. Make way for something decent. read more

See all

Food was on point. I personally liked the flavor of the cold roll better. Service was fairly quick. We also went when they first opened so not many ppl there. Also had the stuffed salmon (well seasoned inside n out) and crab cakes (decent size nice flavor not a lot of filler mostly crab) Ooooooo also the shrimp n crab egg rolls were super dope read more

Loco Lobster - Hot lobster roll with fries - Seafood Near Me - East Moriches, New York

See all

They blocked me on social media because I said their food wasn't really that good! I went multiple times being a local and was hoping the hype was real but it's not. read more

I could not be more disappointed! How can you screw up lobster bisque a lobster sandwich and coleslaw? Let's start with the coleslaw. It was 100% mayonnaise! Disgusting. The lobster bisque had very little lobster and it was full of salt! The lobster chicken sandwich had a large fried piece of cold chicken and very little lobster. And sadly, it was buy one get one free so I had to throw them both away and keep a tiny bit of lobster. This place was highly recommended and I don't know why? AND! Under my lettuce for some reason was a smashed french fry... How's that for gross? Where came from? read more

See all

Speedy delivery, ahead of targeted schedule, and very delicious crab cakes. Will certainly reorder!

Hands-down, the best lobster roll on Long Island. The chunks are huge tail, claw and knuckle. All three Lobster mac & cheese is cutting edge.!!!!! on top of it all now they're offering live Lobster steamed to perfection with all the trimmings !!!! read more

I am very torn with this review. My mom heard about the bogo on lobster rolls (and other items) so we came here for lunch. We ordered warm lobster rolls, clams oreganata, New England clam chowder and lobster bisque. The warm lobster rolls were not warm at all. Just pieces of lobster on a toasted bun. It was a generous amount of lobster, just wasn't hot. The fries were super crisp, the way I like them...but they didn't have any seasoning at all on them...not even a hint of salt. Clams oreganata were really good. My mom was disappointed as there wasn't any "sauce" that baked clams normally has as she wanted to dip her toasted bun from her lobster roll. Lobster bisque was the star of lunch! I really enjoyed it and was shocked with the big chunk of lobster that it came with. New England clam chowder was also good. Service was just alright. Nothing overly special. I did tell my mom I'd come back here, so..until next time.... read more

See all

They say the key to success in most businesses is the employees. Today (August 22, 2025 between about 3-4pm) I had the unfortunate displeasure of crossing paths with a very rude employee at Loco Lobster's order counter. She was a Latina with a hat on and braces on her teeth. I made simple inquires about items on the menu and her responses were very dismissive and rude, as though I was keeping her away from her phone. Her attitude was such a turn off I was going to leave, but I drove a nice distance to get here. I placed a significantly sized order and she only gave me two tiny cups of tartar sauce for the double order. I asked for some more tartar sauce, ketchup and cocktail sauce. She barked at me "THAT COST EXTRA". I calmly stated I have two large seafood dishes here, why do I have to pay extra for condiments. She barked at me again that it was extra. I left her with some choice words and exited the place. I have been to many seafood establishment in my life time, and was never told I would have to pay extra for the basic condiments that come with a seafood order. Do yourself a favor people go else where, You can get good seafood on long island at "Monster Crab" located at 173 Morris Ave, Holtsville, NY 11742 or "Voodoo Crab" located at 1759-G Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720 each restaurant has a few locations just google them. And yes you can go to these other places and receive better customer service, and not be barked at. They are also not penny pinching on the standard basic condiments you get when order seafood, Tartar sauce, Cocktail sauce, Ketchup, Lemons... hot sauce.. etc. I hope the addition 50 cents your trying to make of condiment is worth this review... Tony. Don't eat at Loco Lobster. read more

Loco Lobster - BAD SERVICE, NO CONDIMENTS FOR YOU ! - Seafood Near Me - East Moriches, New York

Ordered through uber eats and picked up but sat inside and ate. Uber has buy one get one on select items it was cheaper for my husband and I to do it this way. The seafood trio is a large portion we could have shared it but we got 2 this was offered on the buy one get one items. Everything was delicious king crab legs were my favorite. Prices were fairly good considering seafood is expensive. They don't offer table service but when we decided to eat in they provided utensils and you have to walk up to the counter if you require additional service. It's clean a few options for seating on the inside. Looks like a typical takeout food place. Will visit again when I am craving seafood. read more

Loco Lobster - Lobster trio - Seafood Near Me - East Moriches, New York

See all

These are honestly the best fish tacos I've ever had! They're so fresh, crunchy, and generously filled. read more

Loco Lobster - Fish taco - Seafood Near Me - East Moriches, New York

See all

Service was not good, had a girl on her first day and her English was limited so I had to point to things on the menu! The food was good. I don't like that it's such a causal restaurant. We are outside and it just lack ambience. read more

Porterhouse steak was overcooke, crab legs were dry and had no meat, the baked clams were the absolute worst i have ever had. worst place to get seafood from ever. when calling to question them I was hung up on. read more

Convenient, solid sea food, friendly, secluded area to park. Great choice of seafood.

Great concept,terrific location,quick service ,great food and fair prices. Stopped for lunch, parking lot full which is a great sign for a new restaurant! My wife and I split 2 lobster rolls ( one warm,one cold), fries and a drink with tax and tip was $60! The rolls were stuffed with a generous amount of lobster meat and I actually enjoyed the warm one more but both were excellent. Plenty of fries and Cole slaw was very good! I know this place is new and I'm sure they are still working out the bugs but I would strongly suggest a liquor license. A $30 lobster roll doesn't exactly go with a bottle of Mountain Dew. The cardboard boxes they serve everything in is fine for takeout but I would rethink for dining in! Other than that a great experience and worth another trip! read more

See all

We ordered from this location on 10/4/25. We ordered the lobster roll combo, shrimp dinner, and clam oreganata. I should've check the bag before leaving because they didn't put the clams in the bag. When I called back to mention this, I was hung up on twice. This is not professional. Sad thing was that I was looking forward to this place and this was our first time visit. They will never get our business again read more

Came across this place and decided to give it a try. I'm glad I did. We tried three different items. The fish and Chips (a really nice piece of what seemed to be Codfish), the Shrimp and Chips (nicely done, fresh and not over-cooked) and what turned out to be the highlight, the Clams in white wine and garlic. 12 fresh little necks, bathed in a garlicky wine and butter sauce. Looks like the place opened fairly recently and the staff was well-trained and helpful. Moderately priced, next time we'll try the Lobster Rolls. It earned a repeat visit. read more

See all

Heading out to the farm stands, we saw this place with advertising flags flying, and we decided to stop and check it out. Large store front, newly open and clean. We chose to snack and sample. 2 young ladies at the counter were welcoming and pleasant, but clearly still in the training stage. We ordered the fried shrimp, fried clam strips, and a lobster roll. The shrimp were a nice size with a crisp, fried batter. Very enjoyable. The clam strips were tasty. The Lobster Roll was very good and flavorful. The cole slaw it was served with was delicious as well. We believe they need to work on the cocktail sauce recipe, as it had a very weird taste; sweet, no taste of horseradish, of any. They do serve Ken's Tarter sauce. Maybe they should consider the cocktail sauce as well. Prices were very reasonable for the portions. Next time we're in the area, we look forward to trying other menu items. read more

See all

Took my granddaughter for crab legs. How on earth do you serve crab legs and not provide a cracker to get the meat out of the shell. Really disappointed. Not coming back read more

great food at a great price. The 2 for 1 special is the best on long island. Perfect place to order for anyone who loves good seafood but loves keeping money in your pocket more. The seafood lo mein is INSANE. A must try for any foodie. read more

the food was pretty mid, disappointing. my bf got a lobster roll he said it wasn't worth $20 it was small and the whole container was 80% fries. the fries had zero salt or flavor, i fixed them up put salt and some old bays to make them tasty. i got a lobster quesadilla it needed something else to it the cheese and lobster is too simple they just are there and not complimenting eachother. a chipotle mayo sauce or something else in there is needed it was boring but the lobster itself was good. everything else was just confusing and we spent $50 on a friday expecting something good. read more

Uber Eats App - gets you the 2 for the price of 1 - at Loco Lobster right now. But only for items highlighted on the menu (I took a photo for future reference). Lobster rolls were 25$ so I decided to get the shrimp cocktail. Nice sized shrimp, liked the cocktail sauce, no lemon. The cake slices - preferred the seafood - but nice that they have cake / dessert. The dining area is an open space, choose your owThe people working there were super friendly and helpful, very professional. read more

See all

This restaurant is run by thieves. Made an order on Uber eats for two steak dinners. They sent a message saying that they do not have steaks. Do I want lamb chops, I said no I do not eat lamb chops. Please cancel this order and they absolutely refused saying I need to reach out to Uber pretty much so they could still get paid for the order without making any actual food... now that Uber doesn't have a phone service I couldn't express that they would not fill my order so Uber eats sent three drivers out there that did not get paid to pick up an order that was never made and Loco lobster still got paid for this order without making anything at all. Shameful. read more

Delicious lobster roll chock full of lobster! Clean, modern decor. Very helpful servers! Just happened upon this place and I will return! read more

Exactly what they claim to be , everything lobster without premium lobster pricing , everything was. Ice and fresh , took a while tho

Today my husband and I went here, we were excited to try a new spot by us. We purchase a shrimp dinner, a lobster roll and sweet potato fries and clams oreganata. We tipped 15% too. We got home opened up the bag that was stapled closed to find that the clams oreganata was not in the bag. We called and spoke to the same girl that worked the register. She kept saying she put it in the bag. Guess what... it was not. She said please hold and hung up on us. We called back, she said we are busy and started getting nasty. She hung up on us again. The date is 10/4/2025 at 6pm . All we wanted was for it to be fixed. We were not rude on the phone at all. We're upset but we should've checked the bag before we left. The lobster roll that was supposed to be hot was cold and rubbery. The shrimp was overcooked. So ontop of extremely bad customer service from the girl , the food was not good and we had high hopes from the reviews & we're disappointed . Sad to say because of this experience we will not be coming back. read more

Had the porterhouse twice and loved it . Also loved the baked mac n cheese . I don't know what happened with the bad reviews but two porterhouse dinners for $50 is unheard of . Not only is it very affordable but it's really good too . read more

I don't know what these 3 star reviews are about. This food was awesome. Buy one get one free lobster rolls?!! Each came loaded with meat and their own side of fries... and no mayo so they didn't weigh you down . The lobster scampi pizza was also covered in meat and the flat bread held up well (bread might be premade but it was still good af). The calamari was crispy and the breading held on well, defying the odds of being steamed in a closed take-out container. The mac and cheese was rich enough that the portion was enough for 3 people. I don't know how long the BOGO deal will be going on, but we will be ridin' that special till the wheels fall off. Well done Loco! Welcome to the area! read more

Loco Lobster - BOGO lobster rolls- lobster scampi flatbread- lobster mac and cheese- fried calamari - Seafood Near Me - East Moriches, New York

If you like seafood, stay away. Ordered fried shrimp which was overly seasoned with i don't know what and I was entitled to two sides but only received one. The lobster roll was small served on a greasy roll. Never again! read more

This is my third time here- I've had lobster rolls twice and now I'm doing the crab legs ; I gotta say the food here is terrific and price reasonably especially when you use the buy one get one on Uber Eats... This is the second time that I've seen the owner... He is very friendly and engaging and you can tell by the way he smiles when you bite in that he loves to feed people. I can't recommend this place enough. read more

I originally called to place an order for pick up and was told if I go to Uber Eats, they offered BOGO. But it wasn't truly BOGO, the second of the SAME item was $5 additional and by the time the order was complete it was much more than I wanted to spend. I ordered the lobster mac. It was good at first, but when I started seeing the bottom of the grease at the bottom of the aluminum container, I was really disgusted and had to stop eating it. The last time I went I ordered the crab cakes and enjoyed them thoroughly. read more

I ordered the lobster rolls via uber eats. The lobster tasted very bad, consequently I couldn't eat . I called loco lobster immediately to complain. I live a distance away and couldn't readily drive back. The girl took my call, but didn't apologize nor give me a credit. I told her that they need to check the lobster tray if they wanted people to come back. I will never go back as they didn't seem too concerned. I did not get sick the next day or I would have called the NYS health department on them. read more

They have a lobster and fried chicken sandwich that's so incredible. Good LAWD. I'm supposed to add at least 85 characters. So here's more letters read more

Loco Lobster - Lobster and Fried Chicken - Seafood Near Me - East Moriches, New York

Ordered twice here thru Uber eats picked up food was very good. Had lobster tails king crab and shrimp both times .

Lovely new place in the area, we order from Uber eats 2 for 1...crab cakes are huge and full of meat, scallops were jumbo size w broccoli! And lobster rolls come on a delish buttered toasted fresh bread! The seafood had big portions and 2 for 1 WIN WIN! Came here a second time and the girl at the counter is very super friendly and helpful! read more

The food was great seafood lo mein and the seafood fried rice. Fish quesadillas was good too.

DONT FALL FOR THE UBER EATS SCAM. They advertise buy one get one. when you get your delivery there is only one. You call loco lobster they say call uber eats. BS they know when they do the order it is a bogo. Plus, they lied and said they called me. really? there was no missed call on my phone. Uber eats will not honor it either. BOTH LOCO AND UBER EATS LOST MY BUSINESS. read more

I had to give this place a try after all the hype. So I ordered on Uber Eats. They had a 2 for 1 special so I ordered the 1 pound of crab legs ( which is anywhere from 2-3 clusters). Let's say when I received my order they were packed in 2 large containers. I was expecting 4-6 clusters instead I opened both to find 1 1/2 clusters in each. All they did was divide each order in half for the special. I would have rather paid for another order than get tricked by the 2for1. Glad I didn't get the lobster rolls as it probably be a served on 4 Hawaiian rolls!! Crab legs just came with lemon and drawn butter. I also purchased a side of seasoned fries that were good. Downside I had to order shrimp, corn and salad from another location to backfill and make a complete dinner plate. Maybe I will return once the summer's out. read more

Seafood lo mein was pretty damn good. I was very surprised by the size of the scallops and the amount of shrimp. And finally, there was even lobster. Very large menu and lots of good things to try. I will definitely be heading back again. read more

Loco Lobster - Seafood lo mein. - Seafood Near Me - East Moriches, New York

yeah im not sure about this one crab legs were ok, just some normal crab legs but dude this lobster roll was ........ not the move. straight up down atrocious. like come on it was 10% lobby and 90% bread yo this was not the move. no disrespect whatsoever but this lobsterroll was a bonefide scrub anyways yeah id come back if it was the last seafood restaurant on earth though so that's saying something. read more