Is a negative stars rating possible? Lost, you were HORRIBLE tonight. You forgot most of the order, were extremely unhelpful when I asked you about it, and your guy at the counter was about as rude, entitled and disinterested as was possible. When the order finally came out (an HOUR later), it was screwed up and one of the two was room temp. Couldn't care, couldn't be bothered. Why have I been going there? No apologies... no explanation, just a here ya go, good luck! Why have I been coming back? I don't know.... let's try not doing that for awhile. Disappointing... sort yourself out. read more

Awesome place to eat . The staff is very helpful and polite I got the cheese sticks they were awesome and the chef salad read more

Lost Pizza - Cheese Sticks - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi

The food is delicious. It's great for big groups and on Mondays, there's 20% off for military. read more

Lost Pizza - Dessert Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi

Good service and the pizza was good I just didn't care for the taco pie (wasn't a bad pizza necessarily just not my cup of tea) but everything else was good read more

My wife and I went here after church and we ordered a pizza and cheese sticks. The pizza was delicious but that had to be some of the best cheese sticks I've had in many years. I will definitely be going back to this place read more

Ordered online and when I arrived the pizza was ready but the nachos and tamales were not... 8 min later they come out. Get home and the pizza is cold, the tamales are ice cold and the nachos are just warm... tamales are pre-prepared. It should not have taken much to heat up. Very very disappointed. read more

Wow just Wow ! Dropped in for dinner yesterday even, it was my first time at this local Columbus Ms Pizza joint. Thank God for CJ's Pizza being closed on Monday , now by me not from Mississippi, and my dad suggested CJs. It was maybe a sign . Well I was very impressed by the staff and slash customer service, 10 out of 10. Very polite and professional. The employee saw my military hat and asked if we were in the service or Veteran ( 20% off on Mondays ) so we were granted a discount. Now to the Pizza and Wings , OMG the Wings were to die for, just like I like them , sauce was delicious and enough covering them all. We ordered a medium Meat Lovers. Again to die for just right , enough toppings and sauce. I will be back, most definitely. read more

See all

We stopped at lost pizza co while visiting the area! Our group all concluded that this was the best food we had during our stay. The wings were tasty, saucy, and a great size! The pizza was delicious and our kids enjoyed the spaghetti and meatballs. We will come back to this establishment when in the area again. The restaurant was clean and the service was great, we had a short wait and they offered us free drinks. read more

Lost Pizza - a half eaten pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi

See all

Wonderful homemade pizza, great place to eat as a family! Good service. Good food. If you haven't been I would go!

The pizza was phenomenal!! I had their version of a supreme pizza, personal size and it was so good!! I got the thin crust and it was amazing, a few in my party for the regular crust and it looked great too but I'll still be going with thin all the way! It came out fast and the crunch of the pizza and the taste of the crust were top notch. 10/10 read more

Meatball sandwich had 3 meatballs, one of them was sour and super dark brown, and hardly any marinara or cheese on a giant bun The thick crust pizza was still doughy so i couldn't eat it to tell you how it was. read more

Lost pizza has seemed to go way down hill. After expressing concern that we paid $16 for wings smaller than our pinky finger, the manager was way less than helpful. He pretty much just said, "yeahhhh sorry. We just give what comes in our box." Would not give any more or a refund. So now we are at Pizza Hut for wings that don't let us down. So sad. read more

Lost Pizza - Sad, sad wings - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi

We came in after a bad experience at another restaurant and were immediately met with such great service! Eli took our order and was very helpful when we had questions! He delivered our food in a timely manner and was even super nice during our conversations!! The food was amazing (as always)! Definitely one of the best pizza places ive ever been to! read more

Food is consistently good and the staff is always nice. The lettuce in the salad we ordered was withered and old but Lost Pizza exceeds expectations when it's comes to the pizza. read more

First time trying Lost. I ordered a "small" build your own with EXTRA Pepperoni and onion. It was an $11 pizza and as you can see from the photo not worth it at all. The pizza was tiny and I had ONE...I REPEAT ONE piece of pepperoni on each slice except for one slice I had NONE. I paid $3 for extra pepperoni. So if you order regular pepperoni you must get one piece for the whole pie. Flavor was good but not worth the money. read more

Lost Pizza - two slices of cheese pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi

See all

Completely overpriced for what you actually get and not worth the money. Garlic breadsticks were flavorless, dry, and inedible. Pizza was sloppy and falling apart as though they threw it together without looking. The salad, ordered by another member of my party, came to her incorrectly at first and then did not come back to her after being remade until nearly 15 minutes after the pizzas came to the table. There was also a mention of a rewards system for the Lost Pizza Company, but neither the Starkville or Columbus locations use it. Why is the rewards system mentioned or advertised in store then? We went to the Columbus location in the hopes it would be better than the Starkville location, where the dining experience and food standards were practically identical, but it was no better than Starkville. Needless to say, we were all severely disappointed. As of now, I would not recommend this pizza to anyone and would much rather go to Godfather's Pizza or Hungry Howies instead. read more

Pizzas were delicious. Had everything else been as good I would have given 5 stars. We were a large party and we had to put tables together. That would have been fine if the tables weren't wobbly and un-level. And overall the place was not really clean. IF I get pizza from them again, I will pick up. read more

Just had a door dash order from here and oh my goodness at the amount of food for the price!!! We had a pepperoni pizza with extra cheese... so so good! Also had spinach dip and tortillas (delicious)! However my favorite was the pulled pork nachos and a huge plate of them!!! Highly recommend!! read more

Absolutely love the pizza. Great cozy place, friendly staff and amazing service. Could not have found a better place to enjoy a nice evening in or out! Also love the beer on tap! read more

Love the pizza here and appreciate the 20% military Mondays. Good takeout and the dining area is nice too.

The bread sticks were awesome! I had a small Diablo pizza with thin crust it had good flavor but something in the sauce gave me hives and my crust was white not crispy like my husbands thick crust. He liked his pizza I may try again. The salad at lunch was a nice unexpected touch. read more

Pizza was delicious. Service was average. Nice atmosphere. Little pricey. Went during the lunch time rush and made it back to work on time. read more

Some of the best pizza I've EVER had. My husband likes the Cujo, and I dream about the Happy Hippie. Definitely thin crust.

We felt as though our pizza and garlic bread could have had more flavor. Atmosphere was nice with all the decorations and signs in there. The staff were friendly. I would come back and try again and see if it was a one time thing with the flavors. read more

Decent pizza joint. They need to cook the crust a little more on their hand tossed but overall was satisfying

The only place in town to get hand wrapped Delta Tamales. OMG they are good . The service was great and our order came out quickly. We had tamales, salad, and subs. Pizza takes longer. Live music by local musicians on Thursday night. read more

Lost Pizza - Tamales from the Mississippi Delta. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi

Pizza again... oh but of course. One of my all time favorite places to eat pizza. I love pizza. Everything was fresh, and cooked to order. I love the combination of toppings they let you add.. yummy pizza in my tummy read more

Lost Pizza - Custom Built Pizzas - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi

I really enjoy eating at the Lost Pizza in Columbus. The staff is amazingly friendly, and the menu is reasonably priced. I love that they have draft beer, too! I like to get a thin crust, individual style pizza - so far I've tried the one with chicken and spinach, and another one with chicken and tomatoes. Both were really good! High quality of ingredients here. The fried ravioli is good, too! I can't wait to try more of the menu. The different lines to order aren't labeled well enough. I ordered in a line that was for the to-go pick up one time, but the staff were good natured about it. It's kind of a weird combination of ordering and table service that works well enough. I haven't been there when they're super busy though. I do really like the decor, and that they have a room they can barn-door off. read more

Lost Pizza - Fried ravioli. Yum! - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi

See all

It sort of looks bowling alley-esque when you walk in, they have good bands/singers playing, but you don't expect much. Then they come out with your food, and you're completely blown away. Some of the best, most interesting flavors I've ever tasted, good sized portions, very friendly staff, and quick service. I love lost pizza, and will continue to come back. PS try their fettuccine Alfredo with angel hair. The chicken is perfectly seared and the sauce/ entire combination is unforgettable. read more

I ordered carry out from Lost about on Sunday. We choose not to dine in right now, since COVID. We order carry out often enough, usually as a treat to the kids. I went to pick up my pizzas and the cashier pulled up the order. On the register you could see the order total and the amount due. Amount due was 0.00. I told her that I paid online and the other girl gave me my order. As I was walking away, I heard her ask the girl that gave me the order, "How can you tell if they actually paid online?". Offensive but nevertheless understandable. I proceeded to walk out of the restaurant. As I get to the door, she yells, "Ma'am, your order did not go through!" Very embarrassing as there were other patrons dining in. I told her that it did and I had a receipt. She continued to follow me out of the store and told me to pull up the receipt. As she walked out, I told her that the cash register's amount due read 0.00. I pull up the receipt and show it to her, she says. She cannot find the 4 digit number that she is looking for, an authorization code of some sort. I tell her, that is the receipt that I received. She continues to tell me a long, what I interpreted as a lie, about how the systems went down etc. She offered to run my card back into the store and swipe it for me. After telling her multiple times that I paid, I, then, had to pull up my personal information (bank account) to show her that delivery.com debited my account on behalf of Lost Pizza. Not to mention she touching all over my phone, in the era of COVID, to look at the emailed receipt and my bank account to confirm payment. The whole ordeal was humiliating and completely avoidable had she understood from the beginning that the balance due was 0.00. read more

The man was very unenthusiastic and uninformed about the menu items and made it seem like taking my order was a burden. Unprofessional. Train your staff to use proper phone etiquette. read more

Buddy and I went here tonight. I got a medium meat lovers thin and it came out hot! Nice scenery and good location.

The pizza just doesn't taste that great. The crust is mediocre and honestly it's much more like MOD pizza than any real pizza. The spinach artichoke was really good but I would rather go to a chain then buy a pizza from here. read more

No stars. Pizza was missing toppings. One side mostly bread. Workers not concerned with it neither. This pizza was supposed to be half pepperoni and half ham with double cheese. Barely had cheese on the pizza. Added picture of pizza to Facebook page. Go there to see what the pizza looked like. read more

This POS offers "curbside" during covid, except either you have to wait 35+ minutes to receive cold food after the person answering the phone says they'll bring it right out or after calling repeatedly for 20+ minutes with no answer, you go inside to receive cold, gross, wrong good. That's pathetic even by Columbus, Mississippi standards. Worst service in town. read more

Craving pizza when we rolled into town after a 12 hour drive and were very happy with our choice. Had a pizza with their regular thick crust. Very yummy! Sauce had great flavor. Reasonably priced. Order at the counter and they bring it out to you. Decent beer tap selection too. read more

Lost Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi

Because of the low stars and bad reviews here, I missed out on Lost Pizza for the first two years I lived here. I wish I had tried them sooner. The pizza is the best around. The options are extensive enough to accommodate anyone's palate. Lost Pizza is a little pricey for this part of the country, but the quality is high enough to splurge on from time to time. Give them a try and enjoy! read more

First of all, I must point out that the customer service is top notch. I gave mediocre review on here and someone immediately contacted me and sent me a gift card so that I could come back and try again. This time, I was not disappointed. The pizza was delicious and the order was correct and timely. Lost pizza Company has a thick crust that is a "slice" above the rest. I ordered the Kujo and the toppings were a perfect choice. My pizza also had a perfect sauce to cheese ratio. Overall, I would definitely recommend this place to anyone in Columbus who wants a premium pizza and a fun atmosphere to eat it in! read more

Your view of Lost Pizza -in my opinion- is directly tied to how long you've been in Columbus. While I'm not a particular fan of any of the pies you'll find in this town, this place isn't bad. I say that in a way that makes sense after you've been here a while. Chances are you've had better, and chances are "better" is at least an hour's drive away. That's great for you, but you're stuck in Columbus. So Lost delivers a pretty solid option for what it is. The bigger brother of CJ's pizza, and a local chain that tries to keep that local place vibe. They do a good core of pizzas, they do wings, plus a pretty decent beer selection. But nothing boils down to a single unique quality being the reason for their success. The truth is, they do everything with a pretty damn good quality. For those of you that do the military thing, they do a pretty generous discount off your check (And extra on Mondays). That is, however, my only major criticism, as this place is a bit on the pricey side of a casual dinner. Pretty much a solid definition of four stars, with no major reasons I could give you not to go. Enjoy your pit-boss pizza. read more

Uninspired, go hum and meh, are adjectives I would use to describe this overprice Digiorino pizza look alike. Nothing bad to say but nothing good either. Had high hope of a good piece of pizza, the location and building were great but they didn't invest in the recipes and they designed it to be assembled by high school kid. read more