Interesting place. The one waitress was nice. Bison burgers seem to be their specialty and they've raised their own bison since like the 50s. I was disappointed that they were no longer serving breakfast foods at 11am. The restaurant is on the westward bound side of the highway. read more

Service was very good but the food left a lot to be desired. We stopped here on a road trip out of CO for a quick lunch. The servers are very nice locals that treat you right but the food leaves a lot to be desired. white bread, stale coffee, american cheese and soggy fries to name a few things. If you're starving or looking to meet some of the Easter Plains locals then come on in. Otherwise roll up the highway to the next exit that has better fare. read more

I stopped for lunch on the way from Iowa to Colorado, which turned out to be an excellent choice. had the bison burger & fries, finished with some apple pie a la mode. it was all delicious, service was friendly and fast, and my burger was cooked perfectly. Lucy's definitely has that local vibe, which almost always means the pie is great, which it was. I will be trying to make another stop here in the future, hopefully in time for breakfast, which occupies half the menu. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED. Fyi, follow the pin on the map and not the directions. as another reviewer pointed out, Lucy's is right next to I76 and not 3 miles to the south. just look for the red roof that reads CAFE and enjoy. read more

On our way to Denver we stopped for supper at this little diner (that almost looks abandoned). I had the buffalo burger (they raise their own buffalo!) and it was OUT OF THIS WORLD! I got spicy fries with it and they were awesome too. We also got the roast beef dinner that was perfect with excellent mashed potatoes and gravy. Lucy's Place was SO good I couldn't stop talking about it the whole trip, so we had to stop by a 2nd time on our way out of CO for breakfast (the Western omelette was awesome, but I would not recommend the biscuits & gravy...they are sweet biscuits, which is just not my thing). It's a family-owned business and it's run with love - walking in the 2nd time it felt like walking into my granny's kitchen, very familiar and homey and friendly faces, not to mention the smell of the delicious food. You've got to check out Lucy's! read more

This was a great diner with all the classics and a few extras. I was pleasantly surprised to find that they had a veggie burger, which I subbed on to the patty melt with an egg. It was delicious and the blt my wife got was very fresh and loaded. Great prices and service to boot. read more

Excellent place to stop and eat while traveling! I highly recommend to anyone driving on the I-76.

Found this place here on Yelp while driving from California to Pensilvania. This place was great. Like walking into grandmas house. The food was great and I would absolutely come back When driving through. read more

From Iowa and our way west to visit friends and family. Trusted Yelp reviews of Lucy's Place and wasn't disappointed. Great breakfast and not a chain. Customer service well above average! Would stop again if traveling I-76! read more

Amazing food, atmosphere, and people. Biscuits and gravy are legit and the omlete was incredible!

We ate supper here based on the reviews. The food was good, but I ordered the 3 piece chicken dinner and when it finally arrived the waitress, JJ, said, "That's the smallest chicken I've ever seen." And it was!!! I swear it came from a Cornish hen. Even after stating this she didn't do anything to correct it or make accommodations. It ruined an otherwise good meal. read more

Bison burger was a bit over cooked for my taste but the French dip was awesome.

Great old fashioned diner! Lucy's is a welcome treat in an area where there is not much other than chain restaurants. The people working there are locals. The food is yummy and cheap. They serve lots of comfort food that we all love. The sandwiches and onion rings are delicious. When I asked "What are Rocky Mountain Oysters?" I was given a sample of buffalo balls!!!! Our waitress was terrific. This place is a step back in time and great fun. read more

Food was decent. Service and staff extremely nice. Quality of food was average. Location is nothing fancy, but not much else around and I liked the small ma/pop feel of this place. read more

Great stop on the way to Denver from Omaha. Friendly locals, great service, and hearty wholesome food. Wife had the Buffalo burger that was great. Highly recommend it. read more

I love finding gems like this in the middle of nowhere! Amazing quality meat in the burger and the best Phili cheese steak I have ever had! Service was impeccable and prices were very cheap! Definitely a place I would recommend stopping if you're driving through! read more

Lovely breakfast and great coconut creme pie chaser! Nice friendly clean place, veg options and buffalo both on the munu!

Stopped for breakfast while on road trip after reading other posts and reviews I was excited to stop at this"hidden gem" as one person called it. I was less than impressed. The waitress was unpleasant and seemed annoyed while taking our order. Two older gentleman argued politics or something with constant profanity with no regards to our children. The only polite people were the women sitting in the booth next to us, who thanked us for coming in so I assume they had some affiliation with the diner. Got a massive plate of biscuits and gravy that was bland even with the addition of salt and pepper, the food was over priced spent around $45 for 2 adults and 2 very small children. Had to say I was less than impressed, but with no to little other options for miles it wasn't horrible. read more

Had a great meal at the tiny spot just of the Hwy. The restaurant was clearly a local's favorite, but our group of 6 travels was welcomed by staff and patrons alike. Great food and friendly conversation with our fellow diners. Would definitely stop here again. read more

Stopped for some breakfast on our way through Colorado. Not the fanciest of places, but the food & service was great. Will probably stop again when passing through. read more

Went to Lucy's based on yelp. Enticed by the idea that they raise their own bison. The bison burger was subpar, little flavor. Burger fries and shake all edible. read more

Great friendly service and traditional menu. Very reasonable prices. Special treat was the fresh buffalo burger. We plan to stop by whenever traveling I76. read more

We were working in the area for a while eating almost exclusively at Lucy's for breakfast and lunch for a couple months.... Excellent friendly staff and even BETTER food.... Try it! read more

Stopped at Lucy's on our way to Colorado. Staff was very friendly and the burgers were great! Surprisingly busy with both locals and travelers. I would recommend if you are looking for a local spot and a home cooked meal. read more

Breakfast stop on our way thru and so glad we did. We had breakfast at this old fashion country cafe with wonderful service and great food. Coffee was a little weak, but my omelette, my husbands biscuits and gravy and sons pancake were all really good. Get the sausage with breakfast, best sausage we've had in 1600 miles. read more

Lucy's place is amazing! My family and I were concerned about eating at a diner in the middle of nowhere and we completely 100% recommend it! Everybody was happy about what they ordered. Their breakfast chicken fried steak...awesome, roast beef with mash potatoes and gravy special...excellent and buffalo burger...aaaaaamazing!! Our waitress was also very attentive and super nice! They have these book at the center of the table that are hilarious for your enjoyment read more

This place was fantastic. I got the Buffalo burger, and it was amazing. Perfectly cooked. Tracy was my server and was extremely friendly and helpful. Couldnt have had a better experience! read more

Great diner. Good home cooking. The buffalo steak and it was great very gravy was wonderful blueberry pie was homemade and fresh. Service was excellent. Great place to stop on the way to Denver. read more

Great food, great prices, great service! Try a bison burger, leave room for tasty pie!

My brother & sister-in-law broke down on the hwy on their motorcycle in 115 degree weather. Someone took them in to Lucy's and Lucy's paid for all their drinks after they paid for the first ones. They even took my brother back to the bike to get their personal stuff while they waited for AAA to come. Lucy's really went out of their way to help. read more