The whitefish spread alone is worth the stop But we also…read morebought smoked whitefish, smoked trout and Chicago flats (crackers) which are the best crackers for all of the above They have a small fee for credit cards so bring cash if you're able (this is common up here) Nice guy behind the counter but not incredibly knowledgeable about the products so look it all up online before you come

Very pleasant and helpful staff. The lake trout cream cheese was lovely, but the smoked whitefish…read morewas the best we have ever tried! Moist, not overly smoked to the point of dryness. Wow, super good. Highly recommend this place and the smoked whitefish. We will have to try other items, but we will definitely get more smoked whitefish, too.

3.5 star restaurant. This is restaurant we visited before travel to Mackinac Island. The restaurant…read moreis next to ferry. This restaurant is the higher rating in this area. We were here for the perch fish. We got the fried perch fillets. It comes with a salad. The fried perch comes with 4 pieces and hush puppies. The perch is very fresh since the fish is next to lake that harvest it. Overall we enjoyed it.

Terrible service. Sat at table for 20 minutes and had to ask who our waiter was twice. When he…read morefinally came over to take our drink order waited another 15 minutes and nothing. Left! Do NOT recommend !-

Katie our server was absolutely amazing, it was only her 3rd week working here and she absolutely…read morecrushed it, the food was delicious. We definitely recommend the white fish tacos.

The location was perfect. Sat on the back deck for lunch. I had 1/2 plate of Nachos. My husband…read moreenjoyed white fish tacos. I would highly recommend a stop for a meal.

Delicious food! I had the Patty Melt with their famous Rum Runner, which is a frozen slushie type…read moredrink. They had a fun summertime topper of a pink pony duck to make your drink a "Quacktail" instead of a "Cocktail". FUN! Sit outside if possible for their gorgeous view of the water!!

Pink Pony is an absolute must when visiting Mackinac Island. The servers are great, the food is…read moreexcellent, and the vibe is relaxed. There is almost always a wait to get seated so get there early to get your reservation in. They will text you when your table is ready. Today, I had the Apple, Brie, and Walnut Flatbread and Boneless Chicken Wings with Mild Buffalo sauce. I typically order a salad with the flatbread but trying to be cautious right now with the lettuce issues. I rave about this flatbread - it has never disappointed. The taste is so good combined with the honey drizzle on top. The Wings were good - fried perfectly - and the Buffalo sauce complemented them nicely. We will be back on our next trip to the island!

After a strenuous morning of walking and shopping, we decided to have lunch and selected the…read moreCarriage House. We were seated with a great view of the docks, where you could see all the ferry boats delivering new visitors to the island. The French onion soup was OUTSTANDING! The tea was fresh brewed and our server, Jackson, was very diligent without hovering. Both the steak sandwich and the ruben were excellent! The table service was excellent and other than Jackson coming back a little quick for the check, it was a fabulous dining experience.

We ordered the white fish sandwich on focaccia bread and the Greek salad. The white fish sandwich…read morewas a disappointment, the focaccia was cold and I feel it would've been better toasted, the fish itself didn't look fresh or appealing really and lacked in flavor overall. The side dish with that was a carrot slaw of some kind with a ton of raisins, not crazy about that, dry bland and too sweet for the dish in my opinion. The Greek salad was fantastic, jam packed with fresh lettuce veggies and very filling. The mocktail was refreshing. The patio here is fantastic and the aesthetic is adorable every preppy girls dream for indoor and outdoor dining.

Stopped in here after the 8 mile bicycle ride. The young lady recommended it when we turned the…read morebikes in. Scored two seats at the bar. The Doud's Ale was excellent. Ordered wings and an order of chips (fries). Both were excellent! Bartender offered us more blue cheese dressing without us asking. Small thing, but nice touch; her service was excellent. It's very "pubbish" and comfortable. Great vibe. If you go to the island, I highly recommend this place. The prices were actually less than I thought they would be...a big order of fries was five bucks. Beer on tap was eight bucks. After, go to Kilwins for a cone and sit on a hotel porch.

We went to the island for a quick trip with family. It was almost 2 pm and we were hungry…read more Initially, I put in for a table at the Pink Pony but that wait was ridiculous, almost 2 hours for a table for 6. So we went down to the pub and luckily we were able to get a table right away. I should note, we also chose this pub because it had Gluten Free options and we had someone with us who could only eat Gluten Free. We were provided water fairly quickly, but to order took a little bit, about 20 minutes. I would say there were only two waitstaff working on a busy afternoon. The pub is kind of small, with seating at the bar, along the sides and then two high top tables in the middle. Once we ordered our food didn't take too long to get. I ordered a Reuben, and got the vinegar coleslaw. Rueben was good, I wouldn't say great for being an Irish Pub. The coleslaw was actually cream based so based on the menu saying vinegar I was a bit surprised. Two others ordered hamburgers which they said were just ok. All in all, the dining experience was alright, nothing spectacular but because we got seated quickly and were hungry it was good for us.

After a full day of walking, biking, and convincing myself I definitely wasn't tired, Millie's on…read moreMain hit the spot. My daughter ordered the burger, and it was a winner. The patty was juicy, the bun was soft and fluffy, and somehow she still managed to have room for dessert. Kids are magical like that. My husband and I both ordered the pan-fried whitefish because, come on... you're on Mackinac Island. You have to. The fish was fresh, flaky, and perfectly cooked with a light, crispy crust that let the flavor of the whitefish shine. Exactly what we were hoping for. The restaurant has a fun, laid-back atmosphere that feels like the perfect place to recharge before heading back out to explore the island. The service was friendly, the food came out quickly, and everything tasted fresh. If you're visiting Mackinac, don't overthink it. Order the whitefish, steal a fry from whoever you're eating with (it's vacation, calories are on island time), and enjoy a great meal.

We stopped by here on a weekend in the summer- we were able to get a table quickly and were just…read moreasked to wait outside for a couple minutes while they got our table ready. Our server was excellent- very thoughtful and attentive. We shared the soup of the day (chicken and wild rice) and fresh whitefish chowder. The chicken soup reminded me of a soup you have when you have a cold and make some fresh soup at home. The chowder did not have much of a fish flavor. Our entire table devoured the whipped goat cheese with pepper jam and the fried green beans, however, there were mixed reviews on the beef pastie. All in all we really enjoyed our meal here; it was the perfect casual stop for us on our trip.

We decided to stop here for lunch on a busy Tuesday afternoon in July. We were pretty hungry after…read morespending the day enjoying the carriage tours and island tour, so we were ready for a good meal! Our group ordered the Pulled Pork Sandwich, Derby Burger, and Triple Crown Club, all of which came with a side of chips. The food was tasty, and the service was excellent. Despite it being a busy afternoon, everything went smoothly. If you're hungry and looking for a good lunch spot, definitely give Seabiscuit a try! We enjoyed our experience and would happily come back.

I knew I wanted to eat whitefish and chips while on Mackinac Island, and the menu at Seabiscuit…read moreCafe sounded pretty good. I was worried there would be a long wait, as it's a small spot, but Nate and I could grab a seat at the bar right away for a late lunch. The bartender was super friendly and we enjoyed chatting with her. I got a featured sangria with pear vodka which was delicious and refreshing. Their taps were out of order, but they have plenty of canned and bottled options. The fish and chips came with two large filets and plenty of fries. I even liked the coleslaw, which I normally don't really love. The batter was a bit thick for my taste but the fish was flaky and not dry. Nate got the waldorf salad, which was huge and had tons of toppings and a nice portion of grilled chicken. The space is quite small so I don't think this place would be great if you have a stroller or anyone in a wheelchair. I'm glad we checked it out and would come back - some of the other dishes I saw coming out of the kitchen looked great, like the fried mac and cheese and the Reuben!