More of a swap meet than a flea market. Lots of knockoff clothing. Not really people selling stuff…read morefrom their home, more people selling goods they purchased from China. Some decent stuff here and there

The guy with the ponytail -don't know his name- was very mean with me, I just wanted to sale some…read morethings that I don't use.... They let me waiting for more than 40 minutes just for treat me very bad... I was there because I thought that place is a flea market...I was wrong... with just saying sorry we can't help you with that, it would have been enough...terrible experience , not recommended at all

I would recommend buyers come prepared. You will need some sort of bag to store your finds. After 2…read morepm entrance is free but most vendors would be packed up and gone by then. We got here at 12 and many vendors were beginning to shut down tables and starting to pack. I would recommend getting here before 11 to properly get your moneys worth. I would return earlier. They have food trucks and tables in the front to eat. They offer wagons to wheel items throughout the field (note: they will need to be returned prior to the parking lot). Ages 12 and under are free.

What can i say? The traffic was backed up for a mile and there was a bad accident at the U turn…read morejust to get into this place! I went Sunday morning and have to say that parking was easier than i anticipated based on the volume and no one directing the lot. Positives were the layout pretty much made sense so you could go up and down each aisle in order. Also i like how the food was arranged around the perimeter. Tons of port a lets also! Reasonable $4 entry fee. This particular Sunday just didn't seem to have an interesting selection. But i guess thats what keeps people coming back!'

Fantastic place plenty of parking charging only three dollars a car. You can find some great plants…read morehere and flowers too.!

Lots of unique finds at the flea market. They sell books, car collectibles, old vehicle plates,…read morerecords, etc...

Shop lives up to its name with gorgeous couches, lamps, even jewelry. Got a homemade card for my…read morehusband and my friend for a print. Docking a star because the owner can be a little cold, but other than, he's got such an eye and has a lovely shop.

I stopped at Treasures before the holidays and purchased a beautiful Sansoucci teacup for a friend…read more Unfortunately the cup didn't survive the ferry ride and trip back to Long Island. I called to see if they might be able to send me a replacement, and it is scheduled to arrive Monday! Saving me the trip back to CT. Dana was SO accommodating, literal "service with a smile". I will make Treasures a regular stop on my visits to Connecticut.

Redwood just feels like home. It's cute, close to the house, and you truly never know what (or who)…read moreyou're going to find there. Some days it's the usual suspects with sneakers and sunglasses... and other days, it's little bursts of magic. We always stop by the sweetest lady who sells fresh fruit--her plums? Chef's kiss. Five bucks a bag and worth every cent. But what I really love are those Friday/Saturday vendors who come out of nowhere with tables of old, random treasures. No rhyme, no reason, just hidden gems priced like it's 1994. That's the thrill of it. It's not fancy, but that's the charm. People are out, chatting, soaking up the sun--it's just a really nice vibe. Definitely worth stopping by if you're in the area. You might leave with a bag of fruit, a vintage trinket, or just a smile.

Year round. Rain or shine! Don't use the bathrooms. There's…read morea sketchy ATM if you forget cash. Great fruit/plant selection. Parking is $2 in their lot, free if you park at the little diner nearby.

I never leave this flea market without too many things! Hardest job is trying to get through all…read morethe stalls before closing time. Great variety and prices for second hand items

Too many tables of clutter. Have to look hard and know what you're willing to pay for…read more Some of the service providers don't even acknowledge you in their space.

So much fun wandering through this little shop. You walk in and it's so beautifully laid out and…read moresmells wonderful to boot. There's a mix of antique stuff, flea market finds and home goods that are new but made to look old. Jewelry, old postcards, clothing, paintings, they have them all here. Prices were quite reasonable.

I'm a huge fan of well-curated shops. The owner/buyer goes frequently to the flea markets, white…read moreelephant, estate, tag, yard, garage, etc. sales that I could never make time for. I've been in the shop several times, and always find a piece for my hardly-furnished home, or a light fixture that is totally unique, or a butter mold of some wonderful thing. Some of the items in this shop are new creations by the craftsman-in-residence, and a few a consignment, but mostly not. There are vintage, industrial, fiber arts, small furnishings, glassware, figurines, jewelry, and so much more. I'll try to get down there to take a few pics. I have one complaint-echoing what another reviewer stated (albeit with much more passion than I could muster): the hours are inconsistent. The owner/buyer did tell me that she hired a shopkeep for the times that she's off scouting, so I expect the catch-as-catch-can hours will improve greatly. Thank you for increasing the foot traffic in the Stony Creek. Now I just need to find the public house (aka Pub)!

This is a beautiful shop. I happened to be walking by after stopping in next door at Tous le Jour…read more Very enticing displays from the window drew me in. Items are displayed by category throughout the store. They are also made into really cool "room" areas. For example, the kitchen area had items like a stove, dishwasher, and all the utensils you could need. The staff were kind and helpful. One of them helped me measure a chair to see if it would fit under my desk. There are all sorts of designer clothing and handbag items too. I really liked the photography exhibit with all of the projector slides! Whatever you are looking for, you can find an amazing variety of vintage items at this special shop.

Really nice selection of antiques & vintage items. They have very reasonable prices. Parking can be…read morea pain at some days/times

Amazing vintage finds with numerous vendors. Great place to find unique gifts and collectiblesread more

This is a waste of time shop! The first area in the shop as you walk in is supposed to be owned by…read morea designer. It looks as though it is an obstacle course, you cannot easily walk in and look around. This is the nicest area in the shop! The other areas are just basicly junk! I would better describe this as a flea market!

It was my first time on Shelter Island and this was one of the places we stopped. There is so many…read morethings but also so many unique things. I enjoy going to thrift and antique stores. It was very unique experience, and Marika was very nice! I found a cute drawing prompt book. Would definitely visit again. She made my first trip to Shelter Island memorable!

Don't be confused by the 24 hour open that Yelp lists. Many of the items are always outside so I…read moresuspect that this the explanation. The shop inside the building does have hours. A unique assortment of just about everything with an emphasis on recycled furniture, carpets and other large items that might be useful. Check out the Blues Brothers statues in the parking lot and enjoy!