I've never been so excited for a restaurant to reopen! I stopped in for an early dinner and couldn't pick on thing for myself so I chose the three that caught my attention first. I chose the Porky Mac Balls ( you can get 3 or 6 so I chose 3 ) , the Chicken Tacos and the Smoked Mac N Cheese. The flavors are out of the world good! Everything was fresh , hot, and honestly just pretty to look at! Decor is very nicely done, restaurant was spotless , and the staff were friendly and informative. If I could give more stars I absolutely would ! Way to go Mia's Village Eats , WAY TO GO!!! I clicked $30-$50 , because I spent almost $40 for myself on these delicious items because I could not choose just one, so I want to say it's very reasonably priced I just splurged on myself !! read more

See all

I got a large 2 item pizza. One of the items was mushrooms. Good news: They put a lot of 'shrooms on that pie. Bad news: CANNED mushrooms! Pizza crust could have been crispier. It was ready when they said it would be. I'll be back, but not of if I want mushrooms as one of my toppings. read more

Mama Mia's Pizzeria - Large sausage and canned mushroom 'za. - Pizza Near Me - Spring Lake, Michigan

New owners...new experience. Ordered our usual pizza tonight and was disappointed. Something is different. Bitter aftertaste. Price increase. 22$ for 16 in Hawaiian pie. Sorry but not for me now read more

Overpriced food and a psychopath for an owner. He can't take criticism for being another dime-a-dozen high end restaurants in Sprint Lake. read more

Mama Mia's Pizzeria - Unhinged message from the owner after criticizing his overpriced food. - Pizza Near Me - Spring Lake, Michigan

New Owners... yay! "hey, I'd like to do a pick up. But your website doesn't describe what the difference is between any of the pizza's." Answer: "I don't really know". Me: "can you ask? i mean there's a bunch of names here with no descriptions". Answer: "well, I can read what a supreme says". Yes, dur, anyone can see the one pizza they have described. .... so I order, and this is the thank you "yep, will be ready in 10 minutes"....click. How about some phone manners? I hope the food is excellent or I'll be back... #teach your staff basic phone manners. read more

A great modernization of Mama Mia's, with their own flair and great food! The gyros and pizza are delicious.

Awesome pizza. The crust id thin and crispy and so flaky. Great variety of toppings. Locally owned. Best pizza around!

I have been eating here for almost 30 years. They made one of the best pizzas in the area. I couldn't wait for them to reopen. They promised they didn't change the recipes, they said they didn't change the recipes, but they did. The sauce is not the same on their pizzas. I was very disappointed. They insisted they didn't change the sauce, until I talked with the owner and she said well they "used a higher quality sauce and added to it" well that isn't the same sauce then. I am sad and disappointed they did not stick with the tried and true recipes. I will not ever order the pizza her again until they change back to the original sauce. I did have a sandwich however, the sandwich was very good. I may go back for the sandwich, but the pizza was but a shadow of what it once was. I implore the owners please please please change back to the old sauce. I'm not the only one, many people I have spoken to agree the pizza is not the same. read more

If you like thin crust pizza, Mama Mia's is the best in the area. A perfect balance of crust, sauce and toppings! Not as salty or greasy as the famous place in GH. We highly recommend it! read more

Before you think I'm a mean jerk with this one star review, look at my massive number of reviews and notice how few lousy ones I've given. I am a pizza chasing geek and will travel far to have good pizza, kind of like some people will drive all around trying new craft beer breweries. Here is the salient quote coming from someone with over 150 reviews: This is possibly the worst pizza I've ever had in my life. It was a salt bomb that had a poorly textured crust and no good flavors coming through. I virtually always finish every pizza I order, but I left most of this for the trash. I was at Stan's bar a few doors down and had this delivered after I'd had a few beers and it still didn't look, taste or smell right. I tried to give away my remaining slices at the bar and no one wanted them, so others seemed to be aware of this place because Stan's is a bar for locals. I would rather have a Little Caesars Hot and Ready or even a supermarket frozen pizza. I used to believe that even when pizza is bad, it's good. Well, not with this pizza. read more

I'm not a huge fan on thin crust pizza and maybe I didn't look at the website close enough to see how thin the crust was. The breadsticks also seemed like something you could get in the freezer section. My family enjoyed the pizza, but I would not go back when we are in town. If you like think crust though this place is for you. read more

Mama Mia's Pizzeria - a hand holding a slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Spring Lake, Michigan

Our pizza was delivered hot and 15 minutes earlier than expected. Their thin crust is our favorite and the sauce is amazing.

Probably the best pizza in the area. Small hole-in-the-wall restaurant that gets sweltering in the summer. I suggest takeout to a local park on the water somewhere (you are surrounded by water in SL) and watch the boats. Or head to Stan's Bar down the road and have them deliver it there. Great crust and sauce. Good people. Unfortunately they do not deliver to GH Township :( read more

Mama Mia's Pizzeria - Mama Mia's Pie & Frosty in a booth at Stan's Bar down the street :) - Pizza Near Me - Spring Lake, Michigan

Canned mushrooms. Very little sausage. Disappointing. Quite possibly the worst pizza I've ever had.

We stopped by this afternoon and ordered a 1/2 baked 14" Sausage and Mushroom pizza as we saw someone else on Facebook posted that they really liked it. It's conveniently located a few steps from Stans Bar so he said it would only take 15-20 minutes (1 beer) so I said I would return afterwards. We took it home at 2:00 pm and tonight we proceeded to heat it up at 400°F for 15 minutes and it was AWESOME! Super thin crust and loads of mushrooms which is the way we like it. We are full time residents now but originally from the Chicago area where pizza is a religion so we have tried many others in the Grand Haven area and this one was really good. Similar to Vito & Nicks crust and loads of mushroom like Chesdans that our Chicago peeps would understand. Enjoy! read more

This is a classic Eatery in Spring Lake and I have been eating their pizzas and Pizza Sub (my favorite) for years. Still great, fast and friendly. read more

Best veggie sub I've had since Mario's closed in Grand Haven. Very good!!! Perfect crispy ness, will definitely eat back for another!!! Great job Mama Mia's read more

If I can offer one piece of advice to make your life better, do not order the cheesy garlic bread, it is either cheesy (I can see cheese, but it has no taste, and I'm not talking it has a little taste, no, it has no taste) nor garlic, it looks like they just put some cheese on a sub bun, and put in a box with some sauce; I might've given them three stars had it not been for the garlic bread. The crust is super thin, I give them credit for that, even those burned all the way around the edges. I don't hate the pizza, I hate the square cut, in West Michigan, we like triangles not squares. The sauce taste like tomato paste and basil, and nothing else. You do get your moneys worth on the onion, they put about a whole onion on my pizza, really odd, it doesn't work. I wish the pizza tasted good, because it smells amazing, just just because salt is inexpensive, doesn't mean you need to load your pizza up with it, I feel like I need to apologize to my blood pressure monitor after eating this. $27.60 seems a little expensive for what I've got, but if you don't try new things, you don't learn. read more

Mama Mia's Pizzeria - No, I did not order extra onions, this is how it comes - Pizza Near Me - Spring Lake, Michigan

See all

I've had mediocre pizzas, I've had pizzas that were not cooked properly, I've had skimpy pizzas that were way over priced for what I received. I've had pizzas from chain restaurants, pizzas from "one off" independents, wood fired, coal fired, grilled, "regular" oven pizzas. I really like pizza but this was the worst I have ever had - anywhere in the world (and I've had pizza in China). It looked bad, it smelled bad and it tasted terrible - I didn't even finish one piece. 4 days later and the smell is lingering in the car that was used to pick it up from the shop (right out of the oven). Did I just happen to get the wrong pizza on a bad night? I'm not sure but I will not be back to check. Let this be a warning... read more

Some of the best thin crust pizza around especially for Michigan it is a little mom, joint that is really really really good oh my God you got to try it read more

See all

Great local pizza joint in sl. Love the onions. My wife is very happy the have gluten free options.

Pizza and garlic cheese bread. The bread could of had a bit more garlic as far as I am concerned, however it was very good. The pizza was thin crusted and well done. I love it this way. Not sure if every one would enjoy this. I sure did! read more

Mama Mia's Pizzeria - Garlic cheese bread. - Pizza Near Me - Spring Lake, Michigan

See all

If you like crunchy thin crust pizza you will like this place! We were with a group of 15 High School kids, and they may not of been expecting a crowd of our size to show up all at once. Service was a bit slow, but we hit them hard with a lot of orders. Would visit again! read more

The food was great, however, there was no ice and we had to drink room temperature water. The manager was not very friendly-possibly a bad day but it was not a fun environment. The other staff were nice and friendly. read more

Got the garlic cheese bread, and pizza, very thin crust, tasty, but not worth driving out of town for. I'm glad to have a place close by. And I'll update on other items on the menu as they are sampled. read more

Their pizza is fair if you like thin crust. Last time I tried to order who ever answered the phone was rude hung up on me before I could tell him that I wanted it delivered. read more

After moving to Grand Haven from Chicago, I was happy to find a Pizza joint that makes a decent thin crust Pizza. While TV has everyone convinced Chicago Pizza means deep dish (not that there is anything wrong with that) Those who grew up eating Pizza in Chicago know every neighborhood has its own hole in the wall that makes super thin, cracker crust pizza with REAL cheese, REAL ITALIAN sausage (not those stupid rabbit turd crumbles of "meat") and just the right amount of sauce. Yes it costs a bit more than a PIZZA! PIZZA! because real ingredients cost more. Mama Mia's reminds me of that Chicago neighborhood style pizza. Not exactly, but pretty close. The only complaint I can think of is they don't always cut it in squares (a must) even if you ask 'em. (and I wish they delivered to GH Township) read more

Really good pizza and subs. The guy who 1 stared this place must be a local competitor. Because he couldn't be any more wrong! Awesome place with really good food and people. Definitely getting more pizzas and subs from this place. read more

A very distinct tasting pizza that is different, but still recognizable as pizza. I really love the flavor. Best in Spring Lake and a decent price. The staff is friendly and sometimes will upgrade your order on accident. HOWEVER, there is no air conditioning, so eating-in during the summer makes me sweat as much as my paternity test on Jerry Springer. Additionally, from what I have gathered there is no real "Mama Mia" this is merely an outlandish gimmick to make it sound more like genuine Italian. read more

Delicious thin crust pizza!!! One of the best local pizza places in town. A little on the pricey side, but for good pizza it's worth it! Very friendly staff. The dining room is small so take out is the beat option. read more

Alright pizza - but expensive. A small restraunt, only had 1 guy working at the time. Food came out just as fast as you would expect. No crust options, or at least he didn't give us an option. It just comes thin. The interior of the building was alright, nearly every bench seat was ripped though - and took a little from the eye candy portion. Has a small TV in front that we were allowed to flip through, - didn't use the option but the gesture was nice. read more

I like the pizza. While I am a deep dish type of guy, this thin crust pizza was good. It is cut into squares which can be a bit messy, and it is a bit greasy, but it does have a lot of flavor (if a bit salty). Give it a try sometime. read more

I ordered a meatball sub and it was absolutely wonderful, and by that I mean it makes Subway look like a dump. The wait times are average, but it makes up for it. read more

This pizzeria has crashed. Ordered a large thin crust half mushroom and pepperoni and half sausage and onion. Took over 40 minutes to complete. The crust was under cooked. The ingredients had no flavor. The canned mushrooms completely covered the one half obviously to hide the lack of pepperoni.When I called to voice my displeasure so that the owner could take corrective action the person who answered hung up. On calling back I was accused of yelling when I merely wanted to inform the restaurant of their issue I didn't even ask or want a refund. Have stricken this place from any further visits Based on my pizza I would recommend the worse frozen pizza from your local store before purchasing from this store read more

Ordered a pizza for delivery Wed night. It arrived burnt. The edges were totally black and a lot of the toppings were also burnt:(