Recently discovered (even though we drive by everyday) by my wife, I was pleasantly surprised and found the pizza to be very good. It's thinner and lighter than other pizzas but very tasty and enjoyable. We usually order once a week and this will become our "go to" pizza place. The staff was a bit quiet (they should smile more and a little friendliness can't hurt but what do you expect? They are working in a hot pizza joint all day. It's not the best situation. Inside restaurant is clean but very small. I wouldn't plan on bringing the family as they are best suited for take out. read more

I will agree that aesthetically this is not the best looking place when you walk in. And I was a little bit taken back when I walked in and one of the workers said "customers here". However of the guy that came out from the back to prepare my slice was actually preparing the fresh ingredients to be put on the pizzas, he was actually "cutting the cheese" which as funny as it may seem, you can't make pizza without cutting the cheese. I ordered a slice as I was in a hurry and it was a super thin crispy crust style slice of pizza that I really enjoyed. I did need to add some salt and pepper to it but overall a great slice of pie and at $1.60 after-tax, probably the best deal in the county read more

Mamma Mia's Pizzaria - a view of the counter - Pizza Near Me - Hamburg, New Jersey

I'm not really sure what has happened to this place over the last few months but it's no longer our pizza place. A few times we ordered they forgot to deliver and we waited over an 1 1/2 hours - it's always cold and this last order the other day was the worst by far. It's like they said fuck the cheese, you'll get a little crappy sauce and we'll over cook the hell out of these pies, just for them to sit around and get cold. It was so bad the kids wouldn't eat it and they eat everything. Go elsewhere. read more

So we mostly get pizza delivered from here and it's good 9 times out of 10. Once in a blue moon the pizza comes very oily and makes me wonder if the regular pie man was out. The few times I went for pickup they barely acknowledge you. You wait while one girl is constantly answering the phone , clearly overwhelmed, and the place looks dirty also. For that reason I don't go there anymore. It's better not to look behind the curtain and just get the delivery read more

So far so good, I've gotten takeout here a handful of times. First off, the pizza was great, I think it's the best I've had in that location. The cheese was rich but not overly greasy, the sauce had a nice flavor, and the crust was thin and with a nice texture, and decent cook. What really stood out for me was the taste of herbs in the sauce, it added a nice depth to the pie and really reminded me of something I'd get in the city or further south of here. If I was to be really critical, I'd tweak the crust a bit, the texture and thickness was on point, but the flavor was a little flat. However it really really tasted awesome in the fantastic stromboli I had which had nice fresh vegetables and enough meats that made my mouth was very happy. The cheesesteaks are definitely the best around. They are huge and the meat is really flavorful, although if the meat was cooked a little less it would be better, as a few pieces got a bit dry. Antipasto is what you'd expect, pretty standard fare but I like that there was some giardiniera in it as well, sometimes you don't get that. I was mildly disappointed at the ripper dog, though I admit I am a hot dog elitist who was eating Callahan's dogs before I had teeth, so it's hard to compete with that. Lasagna was good, but not stellar, and lacking the meat that I wanted to see there. Sauce and cheese were flavorful and generous, portion was good, noodles a bit limp. I was really just missing the meat. What the lasagna lacked, the pappardelle bolognese made up for, with its rich meaty sauce. You can tell there's love in this sauce. Side salads are done nicely and fresh with a few different vegetables, and the dressings are the good kind. Oh and the blue cheese is real and tangy and not that icky sweet blue cheese I find at 89% of places, kudos for that. The wings were reaaaaally good. I've found that buffalo wings fall into a few main categories. These were the 'wet and saucy' category. The wings are a decent portion for the price, they are fat, juicy, flavorful, and totally drenched in this delicious franks-based sauce that's super vinegary and peppery. I would say these are pretty classic wings, which surprisingly are the only place in the area I can think of that makes them this way. I will add Cammerino's to one of my top 3 wing places in the area. Burger was juicy, cooked perfect, and had a great grill taste, also accompanied by generous toppings. And the loaded fries... made my mouth weep with joy even louder then my arteries were weeping with sorrow. I have to comment on the value of the food as I think the prices are really reasonable for what you get. I'm happy I found this place and overall I have to say that this place is the best pizzeria in the area. read more

See all

I am in the are for a job and was looking to grab a quick slice. Despite the reviews of this place I decided to go in and grab a slice. This was the worst pizza experience ever! Lady behind the counter barely said hello, I asked for a slice and she grabbed it with her hands and put it in the oven. Then I noticed that she had a little kid behind the counter and lord knows how much germ was on those hands. She didn't even let the slice get warmed up and she again grabbed it with her hand and served a cold slice of disgusting pizza to me. And I really don't like my slice hot, but I'd rather have it warm than cold. Would not recommend this place at all!!! read more

Food was good but delivery took a long time. Tipped the driver 5 bucks didn't even get a thank you. No longer my go to place for Italian

Again IMHO you all missed the point. The sub wasn't that good for the ten bucks I spent. You want to slice hairs about the cost I was trying to be nice. The SUB SUCKED! My Opinion now can we end this bs about minus the tax the food wasn't very good read more

Mamma Mia's Pizzaria - Pizza Near Me - Hamburg, New Jersey

I have ordered there about 3 or 4 times now. The pizza is a hit or miss. Today my whole order was not something I would be to proud of if I were them. The pizza doesn't look so great. I ordered a cold antipasto with no onion or artichoke and I get it with onion all over it. Then I look at my caprice salad that That I ordered over romaine and there is not one leaf of romaine. I'm not even gonna call to complain because I am hungry so I'll just deal with it but I will try again another time. If it happens again they will hear from me. ****Edited to add I just received a call from Aaron, just an hour or so after posting this review, who called to apologize for any problems and offer to rectify the situation. Very nice man and I will definitely be giving them another try. Thank you Aaron. read more

New to the area. We've tried every pizza place around and this is by far the best. Pizza is flavorful and crisp. Not floppy. Chicken Marsala is great. Flavorful. Fresh mushrooms. Not canned. Calzones nice and crispy. Quick delivery. A+ read more

Let me start off by saying that I never have a problem with this place the food is very good and their service is impeccable we order from this place at least three times a week I highly recommend them and I would give them 10 Stars if I could thank you for the all the good food Mama Mia's read more

Was curious about what I'd heard from my Daughter who ofte orders and pick up there , she told me about the gargantuan PIZZA that serves like 10 . I ordered one for pick up - w/ extra Cheese and pepperoni. I almost couldn't FIT it in my Car ! It also weighed like 8 pounds !! Seriously good as well . Great dough -hot and not to oily . just right . Price was amazing for all of that food! Get one and be prepared to be stuffed on two slices if you dare, Matt D, read more

Can't go wrong with Mama Mia's. We recently ordered pizza and some appetizers and everything was great and arrived hot and on time. We have never had a bad dish/meal from here. Always consistent and fresh. read more

I have been ordering from here for 2 years now and it is my favorite Italian food place and yes I am Italian and know my Italian food. Pizza is thin which is how I like it. The food is always great and the portions are worth the money. We have also used them for catering for parties and our guests love the food. read more

Don't waste your money on this restaurant. I waited almost two hours for some fries, a dozen wings and an over-priced stromboli. You can do better by ordering from just about any other pizzaria with a 15 mile radius. They used to be good when they opened, but they clearly don't care anymore. read more

Love this place food is delicious and reasonable my favorite are the specials I always want one of each! Owner is always so generous with a community and does a lot read more

Don't ever order to go food from here. Takes hours to get and is cold by the time it gets here. We have given this place multiple chances and every time it lets us down read more

I would never eat at this place. I saw all the workers standing around with no masks.

I have been ordering from this establishment on and off for almost 2 years. A couple weeks ago I ordered the thick crust pie & a eggplant parm sandwich. The pie crust was too chewy and the sauce was awful. The same for the eggplant parm. Several months ago I placed an order and the driver couldn't find my address. He kept calling me and even tried to deliver it to a closed bank. To make matters his English was awful. I normally order from 3 different places depending what I want. This place has been removed from my list. TJ's now gets most of my orders and it gets delivered much quicker. read more

We were regular customers until we had a very bad experience. Not only did they get our order wrong but then the owner was really rude to us when we called to have the situation fixed. There was also an unidentifiable piece of plastic in my broccoli rabe. We will normally tolerate their mediocre pizza and forgetfulness but not any more. Franks pizza is much better. We only ordered from here in the first place out of convenience but that factor is gone. Don't bother with this place. read more

I'm surprised at the bad reviews. This is the only pizzeria in the area that knows how to make a pizza and are consistent!! You never have to say "well done" - pizza is always cooked to perfection each time. Delivery is always timely and the Slice app they participate in is great. Keep up the great work!! read more

Went in for a slice to check out the new ownership. Ordered, while waiting for my slice to heat up, I watched the owner drop pizza dough on the floor. Instead of throwing out the dropped dough, he put it on the side of the pizza prep area. As I thought, when I left the restaurant, I watched from the window and sure enough, he used the dough to make a pizza! Never will I go there again! Good luck not getting food poisoning read more

New Managment! The polar opposite of the previous owner! Delicious pizza! Courteous service AND fast! The best pizza in Sussex County hands down!! If you like pizza you'll love this place! read more

Last time I'll ever come here, Shity owner. Order lunch says 15-20 mins to come pick up. I get their front door is locked, not one person inside. Now I have been sitting here for 20+ mins now waiting to pick up my lunch order, owner shows up an didn't even start to make the food yet this is 45 minutes after I ordered food. This is a Shity way to run a pizza place, you do not close/lock your door during lunch. I will never come back lost me an my work as a customer! read more

A decent pie if you are a fan of your crust on the thinner side. They have a special (2 large 1 topping pies, a dozen wings, and 2L soda for $27) that is one of the best deals around. Also an excellent choice if you are catering a kids party with their 10 pies for $70 deal. read more

My delivery of three pies and some wings arrived TWO HOURS later than quoted and they would not refund me. Food arrived cold and missing items to boot. Prices may be competitive, but service is SH**. Plenty of better places in Hamburg. Don't waste your time. read more

Excellent, fresh food! Large portions! Great service! Conveniently located. Absolutely loved every bite!!

This is the second & last time my fiancé & I will ever be ordering from here. We ordered a couple of items off their menu & didn't receive 1 item. No big deal, my fiancé called & was told they would be delivered right away. Half an hour passes by & still we didn't receive them. When my fiancé calls a second time, now 2 hours after originally ordering, he asked to speak to a manager & told the manager we didn't want them & if they could refund the money, the manager proceeded to HANG UP on my fiancé. I nor my fiancé have ever experienced such rudeness & immaturity when dealing with someone who is supposed to be a professional. read more

It is 7:00 on a Sunday night. I called up to order a pie to go. Arrived and it was just coming out of the oven. I got this one with Sausage, Pepperoni, Green Peppers and extra cheese. I am now on my third of four slices. Not only are the toppings fresh but generous. I know I must pass at least 5 or 6 other pizza places between Sparta and Hamburg. Still, it is worth the trip. This is the pizza that years from now I will still remember. This is what pizza is supposed to be about. No cutting corners, no low quality cheese or poor dough. Fresh veggies and meats. Gotta go, I got one more slice waiting! read more

Go to quickcheck!!!! Went in at 7:49pm for 4 slices of plain pizza and was told I couldn't get them because all orders had to be in by 8:00pm cause they close at 8:45pm on a saturday. What pizzeria closes at 8:45pm especially on a saturday???? I'm assuming he was the owner cause he was rude and nasty the way he said it like this.... " are you picking up and order?" So we were like, no. Than he says "were closed!!!! " not only did he say it with such a nasty undertone but it convinced me to NEVER EVER GO BACK. Your in the customer service industry and you treat your customers like that? Clear indication that you probably shpuld be in the back of the house peeling onions not dealing with customers. Good luck nasty read more

Yesterday I had PlaCeD an order... If memory serves correctly, it was a large pie, Wings and Chessy Bread lolol... I BeLieVe his naMe was Josh, I think... He called, he was a little nervous cuznit was his first day.... but Myself as well as My Entire Household were EXTREMELY impressed by his level of respect, courtesy and professionalism.... Instead of just guessing where my house was, kept in constant contact with with me to ensure that my food got to me NOT only earlier that what was Quoted to me by the staff when I placed my order, but also to make sure my food was delivered earlier and still hot.... I totally understand how some customers can be a bit outta control over the tiniest things and dumbest things, if ya ask me lolol But Josh Is Awesome, He's an amazing ans true assest to yalls company and honestly, we'd request him as our delivery driver for our future deliveries.... Great Job JoShy, thanks for being respectful, for finding my house and being there at a time earlier than. Expected.... You rock bro and best wishes and luck to your new job there... Their Great Food Mixed with Your great attitude, Now that's a Business, I'll call first , EVERYTIME.... Best wishes and posts luck to ya their buddie... I hope that they see in you and appreciate the energy thatchu bring to this business and then to your customers out here on Delivery.... Again, thanks a bunch, be safe and Stay Golden Ma Dude. Peace read more

We ordered the godfather sandwich and caprese wrap. The wrap was homemade out of pizza dough! Really great sandwiches and fries that came with them were good too! read more