Food: We have gone 5 times now and honestly cannot wait until our next visit. The food is real! Homemade, with authentic taste, texture and has been consistent. We have had spaghetti, meatballs, chicken parm, lasagna, baked ziti, manicotti, bruschetta, tortellini and salads and with absolutely no complaints, not one. All food has always been hit, fresh and delicious. Service: we have had every server and they each carry the owners idea of what a business should be, they are responsive, in tune and hustle. Service with heart, compassion and a smile. Price: For the portion size the price is on point. read more

Once again back at our home away from home, Mamma Mias Italian Restaurant!! And for the record... we just had the best Stromboli I have had since I left Florida!!! Head over as soon as you can! And tell em, Tony Cannoli sent ya!! read more

See all

Incredible Italian food. Probably the best Chicken Florentine I have ever had. Stromboli is awesome too!

We've loved Mama Mia's even before they were in this newer location!! We love their pizzas, calzones, garlic knots, lasagna and Greek salads Also love that they deliver to our area! Highly recommend! read more

The restaurant is very nice. Employees are very friendly. Service was fast and efficient. This restaurant was the closest we have found so far to our hometown in western ny. The pasta sauce was very good. The garlic knots were delicious. Only negative was the chicken was swimming in sauce which normally I would love but the sauce was incredibly salty. Think someone went crazy with the addition of salt.. the sauce wasn't lemony as I would expect. I have rather high expectations of what we called chicken French in my hometown. Hometown is well known for the dish and this one did not hit the spot. I gave the rest of the meal to my husband who ate it figuring it was senseless to let it go to waste. I won't ding this review for a bad version knowing I am comparing to original version of the dish. I did try my husbands Alfredo and my sons pasta. Both were very good. Think next time we come I will skip the chicken and choose something else read more

See all

Went here today for the first time and or food was so good and or my service from Grace was nothing short amazing She definitely the best.... 10 stars read more

Guys! I remembered to take pictures of lunch- after a few bites! Mamma mia's italian restaurant in Seymour is so good. Had a little snafu with our order to go, but made it right and sent free garlic rolls too. I had the deluxe calzone, hubs had a gyro with onion rings and of course the rolls! All excellent tasting and we had a picnic at the park so it travelled a few minutes and was still 100% awesome. Nice folks too! read more

See all

Made the trip to Seymour and glad we did. The location is in a strip mall next to Kroger so if you forgot that they don't serve wine yet stop in there first, worth the $3 corking fee for BYOB! We were greeted right away and seated very quickly in the dining room area. Brightly lit, a mixture of tables and booths. They serve you garlic knots when you sit down. Our waitress was friendly and attentive. She answered any of our menu questions and was very helpful with letting us customize our order. My husband ordered angel hair pasta with marinara, which came with a salad (pretty big for a side salad). I ordered eggplant parmigiana and asked for angel hair and Alfredo (and salad). Food came very quick, portions were very large and food was very very good, the seasoning was perfect! Prices were so reasonable. We will definitely go back! read more

See all

Nice friendly casual place with real Italian food (I'm looking at you Gondolier) I had mussels with garlic and olive oil. My wife had a grilled salmon dish with spinach We will return Net time Pizza! read more

You want excellent Italian food?! Awesome feast! The best you can ever get. Friendly, clean and comfortable setting. Went Valentine's Day had the $44 special. Too much to eat had to bring half home for later. read more

Food, service, everything!! The atmosphere is friendly, warm and very comfortable. The music was also very nice. A lot of times, Dean Martin Italian songs..... read more

We had family get together here. Service was amazing and the food was good. First time there, only 2 little things. When I ordered the mamas trio (don't remember the exact name) they were out of the manicotti, fine they sub with ravioli but they put under the cheese of the chicken Parm and i thought it wasn't there but I found it eventually.2 our second round of roll were a bit under done. But the kids still ate they tasted amazing just a bit under done. Even with this the meal was amazing read more

Food was really good but price was pretty high. Food alone gets 5 Prices alone gets 2 That's why they get a grand total of....3 read more

Disappointed. The restaurant was not clean... disheveled. Just not pleasant experience. Food was b- at best.

My mom and I found this jewel. The service really can't be beat! Every time we are here, we are welcomed in and thanked when we leave. The food is so delish and they even deliver! read more

Great pizza! You're able to call ahead and order, walk-in and order to go, or stay and eat there. The staff was really nice to us. It's a great casual place to enjoy some Italian food. Pizza tasted really great! We got the white pizza and the meat lovers pizza. My husband is obsessed with the white pizza. We have to get it every time we're in town. read more

Mamma Mias - Meat lovers - Italian Near Me - Seymour, Tennessee

See all

We were a little put off realizing this restaurant was in a strip mall, but OMG! This place was amazing! Our party of 9 was extremely happy with everything everyone ordered. Nick was super cool and Mamma's baklava was to die for. We highly recommend this place and would definitely come back again! read more

Second table in and the last to be served. Then the waiter blamed it on us. There were 4 tables that came behind me and we had simple dishes yet chicken parm and cheese burgers and fries came out ahead of shrimp Alfredo and pan seared salmon.... Give me a break. He wasn't good server at Mexican restaurant next door and he's worse selling Italian.. Sorry not sorry....... read more

Always amazing!! Never know what to order everything always tastes so great. Love having delivered and always arrives hot. Thank you

People are nice however when they "just opened" my fiancé and I used their Parmesan all over our food then after noticed there was mold in it. The quality of the food is not that good and the place needs a deep clean honestly. Usually I'm not one to write reviews, but I will say this place is not worth spending money at even with the limited food options in Seymour read more

Staff is super friendly! Food is authentic & delicious. The garlic knots are so good & the portions sizes are worth the prices, always come home with leftovers (that reheat to be just as good as the day we got them). Overall great family restaurant, way better than other Italian restaurants in the area! read more

I had lunch here, 2 slice and knots special! Pizza was ok, needed more sauce. The knots and marinara was great! I dipped the slices in the sauce and it tasted much better! I like the rest of the menu, I will be back to try dinner, the smell reminded me of the family pizza parlors on Long Island! read more

Had the gyro platter was very good! Take out order was packed nicely and on time! Will definitely will be ordering again

I visited Mamma Mia's for the first time tonight and I am so impressed!! Literally they deserve a 10/10. The food was so fresh and amazing, but my favorite part was the staff. You can tell they operate like a family and enjoy every minute of it. The owner and the older woman there were so kind and funny and made me feel so comfortable. Our server was amazing, and shout to the other waitresses who randomly stopped by to make sure we were always taken care of. Even though we were there late they made us feel welcome. This is definitely my new favorite restaurant and I will be back. I recommend them to anyone wanting amazing food, the best staff, and a friendly happy atmosphere. Also shout out to older gentleman the dessert was out of this word! read more

What can I say, came across this place and decided to try it out. The hospitality was awesome both times I've been here, that's right I've already been back and have recommended other people to go. The portions are more than you would expect and worth what they're asking for. I've left both times with leftovers. Will come back in the future, and will recommend for anyone looking for good Italian food. read more

Pizza is good but eat in dinner is not. Fried shrimp platter was warm not hot. Overcooked and tough. Salad was old rotten lettuce. They need a new chef. read more

This place was recommended by our waitress at breakfast. She lives around the corner from it and said it's great. SHE WAS NOT WRONG! Fresh, great tasting food. Sauces were excellent. The marinara tasted so good and alfredo so creamy. Everything is homemade and you can taste it. Will try and stop here again before we head home! read more

Mamma Mias - Smelled so good, I started to dig in before I took a picture! - Italian Near Me - Seymour, Tennessee

First of all, the food was absolutely spectacular. It was very refreshing to find such an authentic, delicious meal in such a commercial-food saturated area. My family and I have been staying in the sevierville area for the past few days, we're from out of town, and all of our dinners have been fast food or chains. But at mamma Mia's, you won't find basic, premade dishes. Anybody should visit for their homemade marinara alone. It is delicious, and unlike anything I've ever tasted. Second, the service was great. Our complimentary bread knots came out in a timely manner and everything else that followed was also timed perfectly. We didn't have to wait on anything. The waitress that served our food was very kind and attentive to what we needed. Go to mamma Mia's. It is a true treat! read more

Mamma Mias - Bread knots - Italian Near Me - Seymour, Tennessee

See all

We have been here several times. The food has always been great along with the staff. As of last night, our opinion has changed due to a roach crawling out of the to go box that waitress handed to us. We notified the waitress. Not sure if she told anyone about it. All she did was hand us another box. Not her fault, but the whole roach ordeal has ruined this for us. read more

Great flavors, huge portions and people who treat you like family (even if you don't have a NY accent)! It can be a little loud, like any open, welcoming environment. read more

Mama Mia's offers good pizza. I cannot say how the other things on the menu are, but the pizza was good. It was a nice find in the eastern part of Tennessee. I will give it four stars. read more

This place is delicious. The staff is friendly and helpful. We ordered the Italian Trio the plate was filled with food. Everything tasted fresh and homemade. We even stayed a little past closing to finish watching the basketball game. read more

They just moved locations and the food is better than ever, everything here is top notch and the owner is a great guy and takes such pride in what they serve. You can't find Italian restaurant quality food like this short of New York or Chicago. Definitely stop in and you won't be disappointed read more

Great little place hidden on some really cool back roads on the way to Pigeon Forge, TN. We were headed to Dollywood from Nashville. Looked on Yelp for a good Italian place and found this gem. It is next to a gas station on a rural road. Not to far from town and a pretty drive. When we arrived we were greeted with warm welcomes and happy faces. On the "specials board" there was a message. It read; 10% off with church bulletin. I LOVED this. It was a Sunday. We ordered the fried mozzarella sticks. We think they should be called "fried mozzarella LOGS!!" They were HUGE (see pic below). They were very good, but not as hot as they could have been. The marinara sauce served with them could have also been warmer. Our entrees were Cheese pizza, Fettuccine Alfredo with chicken, Chicken Parmesan and a Ruben sandwich. All were very good. The entrees were very hot and great portions. Our server was great. Super friendly and helpful. Speedy service with a smile. read more

Mamma Mias - Mozzarella "logs". HUGE mozzarella sticks. 12/19/2021 - Italian Near Me - Seymour, Tennessee

We went with friends for an early dinner. We had eggplant parmigiana, trio, salmon Alfredo and baked ziti with meatballs. Everyone enjoyed their meals very much. Server was friendly and kept on top of things without being bothersome. Basic decor but nothing special. Will definitely return read more

Food: the food was good. It wasn't perfect but definitely good. I had the chicken parmigiana diner and the chicken was breaded and served with the perfect amount of mozzarella. The calamari was also fresh but I didn't like the way it's breaded. Service: the service was great no complaints at all. Ambiance: it's in an old service garage which looked strange. Also it seemed like a cross between a pizzeria in queens, NY and a sports bar in TN. The tables looked like converted booths and it was difficult to move around the chairs. read more

First the service was wonderful- very sweet staff. Husband liked the marina and his mama's trio meal. Our salads had brown lettuce and big hunk of cheese just plopped in the middle very disappointing. I liked the marina too but my eggplant Parmesan tasted like it was cooked in dirty grease. The worst part of the experience is all the flies and gnats! I only ate a few bites because it felt so dirty being there. This was at the new location BTW I also went a few years ago to their location on Boyd's Creek and it also had the issue with flies. I so hoped this location would be different. read more

Just tried this Italian restaurant in their new location in Seymour (next to Kroger) and it was delicious! We had the lasagna and eggplant parm and both were soooo good!! The entrees were large so we left with tomorrow's lunch. The entrees also came with a fresh salad and warm garlic bread, served with marinara. Richard was our server and he was extremely accommodating and friendly....the best service we've experienced anywhere in a long time! We look forward to many more meals here! John & Sherri read more

We had dinner on our way to Dollywood. The food portions are huge. Everything we ordered were delicious. But the best thing about this restaurant is the cozy family atmosphere. Very friendly people. Exceptional customer service. We always eat here when we're in the area. read more

Mamma Mias - Mamma Mia Trio - Italian Near Me - Seymour, Tennessee

See all

Okay we have had a few meals here. We never had the pizza, so I don't have a clue if it's any good. I've been looking for a place that has good gyro meat, and didn't taste like that pre-sliced store bought stuff. The waitress tells me they have the meat shipped in, and it's one of the huge cone things you have on vertical broiler. I'm all in after hearing that. The gyro meat has a good spice to it. The tzatziki sauce is on the side which I like. Too often at other places the sauce is added way too much. With a dine in meal you get tasty complimentary garlic knots and marinara. I'm not a pasta eater, so I take my noodle sucking family's positive praise of their meals quality. For the dear readers of my reviews should know I look at all things at rating a sit down restaurant. Food=5, service=5, atmosphere=2 it's attached to a gas station, inside is blah, and it doesn't have any touch-less bathroom features. read more

See all