I wish I lived in Willoughby, OH. I'm from Illinois. I was having tests done at Cleveland Clinic and decided to try Manhattan Deli. I ordered a Reuben, onion rings and a virgin strawberry daiquiri. My meal was wonderful. The Reuben was piled high with pastrami, kraut, Swiss, and Russian dressing. The onion rings were huge, crispy and everything was delicious. The daiquiri was refreshing. When I get back to Willoughby, I'll be back at Manhattan Deli. read more

Super disappointed tonight. We ordered take out - three identical sandwiches, Midtown Ruebens. Each one was totally different. One was burnt, one undercooked, and one was missing almost all the meat. We ordered the extra lean corned beef, as we have before. This was very fatty and chewy and definitely not the quality that we've had in the past. read more

Manhattan Deli - This is the inside of the sandwich missing the meat. For $12. - Delis Near Me - Mentor, Ohio

Love the food but was surprised at what they did to me. I am doing low carb diet and ordered a 3 meat and cheese omelet and coffee. Told the waiter i only want the omelette - no toast or potatoes. When the bill came - was over $14 and I asked if I was being charged for toast and potatoes too and he said yes! I did not have time to wait for them to make it and bring home for the family. This was lack of communication and I did not appreciate it! I will continue to go to the deli but will be a lot more aware of how to communicate. read more

Never been disappointed . Breakfast always good today I,m going for lunch. Will let you know. Later gator

I was quite disappointed in our family's Christmas catering from this place. We ordered what was a rather pricy deli tray. When opened and ready to serve it was noticed the the salami was turning brown. When salami starts to turn brown at our house we get rid of it as it is no longer fresh. My mother who had been the person to place the order promptly called them to address the problem. They took a note and management called back right away. They proceeded to explain that oxygen is what makes food spoil. (As if we didn't understand that) Instead of offering to remedy the situation they did nothing and told us it would be fine to eat. As far as I'm concerned the customer service was pathetic and I would never spend money there again. read more

I've been coming here for years and never disappointed. Great combo of food items plus a bit of Lebanese as well. Reubens and sandwiches the best. The deserts are also fun but you'll need to take them home after being stuffed. Carrot cake is my fav. read more

Can't go wrong no matter what's on the menu. Our go to place whenever we don't know what to eat.

Will never get take out again; food was terrible and not the first time...it's never been great takeout but we like to support local business, however, we've had it. Latkes were under cooked and not warm, corned beef was slightly dried out, pasta was way over cooked and tasted like it was made in the morning and kept all day-served in the early evening, chicken was rubbery/did not put in garlic bread that is supposed to come with entree...shall we go on? read more

Best thing in the house is the Matzo Ball Soup. It's worth a trip just for that. But the Trump Tower sandwich is a bogey that kinda turned my stomach; why not give it a less controversial name? Go figure. read more

I found myself nearby and in need of lunch the other day, and Yelp efficiently found me Manhattan Deli. They have a lot of options, and the employees seemed really friendly. They made my order really quickly, which was definitely a plus. I liked, but didn't love, my "Vermont Gobbler" sandwich. The turkey was definitely good quality and the cream cheese was a nice touch, but the bread was a bit dry, and I wasn't a huge fan of their honey mustard. It was HUGE, which justified the high price point, but I wish they offered a half sandwich option. I will say the fries are excellent, especially if you ask for extra crispy. This is the kind of review that's three stars because I didn't love the place, but would definitely give it another shot if I'm in the neighborhood. read more

We went in for breakfast and won't be back. The atmosphere is nice, the server, Mary was very good too. But when the homefries came out...Rotten - I'm not kidding - I showed them to the server and she saw the rotten parts and the other parts were rubbery... what would make a potato rubbery??? I don't know. Usually if the food isn't great we will smile and say things are okay - why start drama, right? But this was gross. All I ordered were eggs, toast and homefries... so 1/3 of my meal was gross. Mary immediately got us more potatoes... they were not rotten, but again had that rubbery texture...can anyone explain that to me?!? Ugh. So we didn't eat those either. We kindly told Mary that this would not affect her tip because she was a good server and wasn't responsible for cooking the food. The manager lady was told about our situation by a server. She said she heard we didn't like "That style of homefries...!!" I told her the problem was not the Style, but the fact that they were rotten. She didn't want to admit that the quality was 0% so she blamed it on our taste buds... Classy. Anyway we won't be back for those reasons. In this area there are so many great breakfast spots that its no big deal to forget this one. read more

Not really sure where to start this review because my mind is spinning thinking about all the great things Manhattan Deli has to offer! I've been frequenting MD for years now and I can say that you'll find one heck of a corned beef sandwich here! Definitely one of my go to orders, but I've also tried their turkey sandwiches, soups (the matzo ball is to die for!), and their Mediterranean goodies (I'd list my favorites, but that would be all of them). Oh and I'm pretty sure they put something in the pickles because they are addicting and oh so good! So basically, if you're in the mood for a killer corned beef sandwich (or any sandwich for that matter), then head here because you'll walk out one satisfied little foodie! read more

This place has a good homey feel and very good food. The Lebanese platter was really good and literally some of the best hummus I've ever had. She must add some hint of citrus or something. And the Baba was great too. Got the Farmer in the Deli breakfast with Spicy Fries. Both amazing and their ranch is homemade and idk how they get it to be so good but it is. All in all just a great restaurant highly recommend it read more

One of my top favorite places to eat. Friendly staff, great food and amazing prices. I recommend their breakfast beagle and their chocolate moose cup. read more

We had a late lunch. Waitress was nice and I had the Pastrami Special Sandwich with Chive Cream Cheese. Some awesome onion rings as well. Big and crunchy and not greasy. Really entire this place. read more

Manhattan Deli - Pastrami Sandwich with Cream Cheese. - Delis Near Me - Mentor, Ohio

When I hear the name Manhattan Deli, visions of real east coast deli come dancing through my head...but alas I was mistaken. The food is not bad, nor can I go out on a limb and say it is good. It is average, and far below most NYC area delis. I have eaten here more then once with the hope, that by some freak of nature the Deli fairy visited and improved the food. One can dream can't one? But, sigh, unlike my optimistic dreams, I was left with only the dream. The dreams and the memories of real rye bread, real corned beef and real NYC mustard. I dreamed for the Deli fairy doing its work, but the dream, just like those of my youth, it was just like the Tooth fairy, instead of a real good sandwich all i found was a lousy quarter under my pillow(actually it was dried up corned beef, on the floor under my table). Why I didn't rate the restaurant a little higher, is for as the food is average, the service is usually far below. read more

Absolutely disgusting. Not only was there a 6" hair wound through both halves of my sandwich - the edge of the cheese had mold on it. It looked like a sandwich that your blind, senile, 90 year old grandma would try to serve you. Gross and will never be back. read more

This place is amazing but the older ladies that are serving are quite mean ! The sandwiches are huge and had I of know this I would have split a sanswhiche with my husband ! I ordered the matzo ball soup as well so I was totally full after are meal ! I had no room for dessert ! One nice thing my husband like is they served beer and wine ! Nice added feature to a deli ! We also took home there home made grape butter. Sweet but good on toast !!! read more

Sit down, sit down, you look famished! Doesn't your mother feed you? Oy! Prepare for a sandwich experience. From the free fresh and pickeled there pickles to the pounds of meat between bread so succulent you could eat a loaf on your own, the Manhattan Deli is one of the best sandwich shops in Ohio. Have never been to NYC, I can't compare it to a real Manhattan Deli, but I can tell you this, you won't leave hungry. The sides are terrific and I wouldn't pass up the potato salad, even though I really do despise mayo. It has too much flavor to be missed. You can't go wrong with any choice, from their bagels with lox (oh.. so tasty) to their Ruben, stacked high with corn beef and sauerkraut. The price is right for the amount of food, and I'd think they'd be losing a profit on some of the sizes of sandwiches I've seen... But come, sit, sit, let me get you a little 'nosh. read more

Used to eat here every Friday for their fish. Over the last year the fish servings keep getting smaller. The owners are super friendly but they need to improve the fish served. read more

Always a great stop for breakfast and lunch, very clean and fast. Best sandwiches in Mentor. The Cleveland over Philly is the best. Great daily specials. read more

Manhattan Deli - Cleveland over Philly sandwich, da best - Delis Near Me - Mentor, Ohio

See all

Great Deli quality food and great service. My open face combo was wonderful and my sister's breakfast omelet looked so good. Latke's were good. Winner was Matzo ball soup great broth very flavorful. My only complaint is they need bigger coffee cups because coffee was so good. read more

We love the Manhattan Deli. Best Matza ball soup and tabouli. Yum. They treat you like family. Love the bakery, too

Manhattan Deli what can I say. Been eating here for 40 years. Food has just went all to hell. Last breakfast I had I broke a tooth on a piece of the grill, cost me over $1,000 at the dentist. Last two Saint Patrick days wanted corned beef or did it it was cold pre-sliced pre-packaged after I specifically asked they said they could not keep up. If that's true you should throw in the towel do not ruin anyone Saint Patty's Day this year 2020! read more

The best place to get matza ball soup and a reubin because it is so delicious and very nice people work there.

I am so confused as to why Grand River Cellars doesn't have 5 stars!! This is one of my favorite places to eat! I have lived in North East Ohio most of my life and for the past few years lived in Charlotte NC! And STILL this is a place I made a priority to come to when in Ohio on visits and is still one of my top 5 favorite places to have a great meal. Even my best friend who moved back to KY a few years ago says how much they miss this place when we chat. I always send her a bottle of white fox as it's her favorite. It's the best! The food is always great quality and never disappoints. The service is always great! Tonight on my visit J.D. was exceptional and made the night even more enjoyable with prompt and attentive service. Be sure to ask for him the next time your in! All around great place. Never, never disappoints. read more

Best corned beef hash in town! Friendly wait staff, very courteous and prompt. Best to go early and beat the weekend church crowd.

My parents are "regulars" and the servers know what drinks to bring them before they sit down! The food is excellent, and the service is always friendly. I always enjoy stopping by whenever I am home! read more

Might be hard to find, but worth a trip! We have been going to Manhattan Deli for 20 years and can't remember having a "bad" meal. It is located in the corner of a strip mall on Mentor Avenue (same location as Malley's). The interior is not upscale and could use some updating, but the food and friendly wait staff make up for any lack of ambience. The meals are moderately priced and the menu is extensive. Our favorites include their homemade soups (especially the Clam Chowder), the Mango Chicken Salad, the Chef Salad, the Turkey Reuben and the Smothered Chicken dinner. And, if you are in the mood for a "real" turkey dinner, Manhattan Deli has it - no fake deli turkey here! The also have a great selection of delicious cheesecakes, cream puffs, and cakes, if you have room. Breakfast, lunch, dinner...it's all good! read more

This is as good as it gets in Mentor - Relaxed, friendly, huge sandwichs, Great waitress - Great Manager - Mark... All in all - I have been coming here for years! read more

I hate to write this review because my family has been coming here for at least 10 years. Yesterday my fiancé and I decided to get dinner around 7:30. I ordered the Caesar salad and he ordered the corned beef. First of all the waitress was VERY rude for no reason at all right from the start. We got our food and the Caesar salad was spring mix lettuce and not romaine. I've never had a Caesar with anything other then romaine and I don't care for spring mix so it would have been nice if they told us they didn't carry any other lettuce or I wouldn't have ordered it. The corned beef was basically all fat. My dog didn't even like it when we got home. When I went to pay for the bill, the server came back and turned her back to me, handed my fiancé MY credit card that I had handed her when I paid and blatantly ignored me with a nasty little smirk on her face asking if everything was ok? Forgot the boxes and then casually talked shit about us from the kitchen where we could clearly hear her and of course she pointed like a 5 year old. As we're still eating a lady comes over and literally runs a vacuum right next to us getting dust all over the food. For the service and meal it was ridiculously expensive. Mentor has much better pleases to eat at that are less expensive with better service. Would not recommend read more

Visited many times. Food has always been good. The staff have always been helpful and positive. Outdoor seating is great when the weather is good. Good variety. Overall good choice! read more

Truly offensive to be told "I can't give a booth to just one person during peak time" - so I pay differently at a 2 top vs a booth? The two people at the booth pay differently than they would at a 2 top? Way to go making a solo diner feel welcome! Food... OK. Interior... old. read more

I've been coming here for years with my family. It was St. Pat's and crowded and the waitress explained they didn't have time to make a salad. Only problem was, that's like the only healthy/vegetarian option they had available sans old hockey puck veggie burger. So I says to the waitress, not your fault I'll just let Tim and Mark know we're disappointed but we understand. So the waitress comes back later and asks my wife if she is just going to sit there and pout. WTF? My wife is always polite and never said a word. Then this mess of a waitress starts boxing the leftovers on top of the dirty plates she hadn't cleared. There was ketchup and food all over the bottom of the boxes. Rookie move. And there were other issues but I've piled on enough, you get the point. Come on Mark and Tim you work too hard to have some untrained waitress reflect on you guys like this. Please don't let this place go downhill. read more

Ok great potato pancakes and Russian T cakes bagels mordant ball soup and mishmash.motsaball and chicken noodle.

I got the Greek salad and Beef Shawarma Platter and both were fantastic! The prices are very reasonable and you get a lot of food. I will definitely be back and next time will definitely have to try the wine and the desserts! read more

I'm always disappointed in Manhattan Deli. Maybe because I grew up in New York City and I know what a real Manhattan deli is like; this place ain't anything like that. The food is always at best "ok" and I think it is overpriced for what you get. Their cold cuts, which I think should be the strength of a deli, are just OK, and they don't have a lot of my favorites, like tongue. read more

Every time I come here I have a good meal! I have tried so many different things and I have never not liked anything. They have a wide range of choices and I don't think you could go wrong with any of them. Growing up in the area I never went there until an old friend took me a little over a year ago. I wish I knew about it earlier!!! If you are in the area it is a must try! read more

Gotta try the latkes, they are the bomb and super filling. Besides that the typical club style sandwiches is whatchagonnaget.

This is a pretty good breakfast place. At first I wasn't really in to it but after going there a few times I've grown to really like their breakfast. They also have very good sandwiches. We have also had some really good service here. My girlfriend really likes their salads. Help support local businesses and give it a try I'm pretty sure you will like it. read more