Wow. I can not believe how little meat they give you. I even paid for double meat and it it less than you would get at subway or Jersey mikes original amounts. I even asked if it was double meat and was told yes. Normal is just two slices of meat for an 8" sandwich. I also got their macaroni salad and it was so sweet you couldn't taste anything else. Save yourself time and money and go somewhere else. read more

Tommy's Subs - Italian meat sub with double meat that is missing meat. - Sandwiches Near Me - Mentor, Ohio

The past 2 times that my husband and I stopped here, the young man making subs made change ,and then handled food without changing gloves! They need to be trained better . After we asked him to put on clean gloves he did, and food was pretty good. read more

Great service great subs what else you need to ask fast n fresh always ,very clean establishment very kind employees read more

Tommy's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Mentor, Ohio

Of all the cheesesteaks I have tried, Tommy's is the best. Love their potato salad. The toppings have always been fresh. The staff is friendly. read more

Good portion size for the prices. Got a lot of meat, toppings for what you pay for. Will go back again

I ordered a grilled chicken salad and I found a piece of undercooked chicken. I've called multiple times to let them know but they didn't answer any of my calls. I would've driven back there but I was unable to. It sucks cause I used to order from them all the time. Never again!! read more

Tommy's Subs - Found a piece of undercooked chicken in my salad - Sandwiches Near Me - Mentor, Ohio

I reall enjoyed my Philly cheesesteak. The guys at the counter were friendly and quick. Appreciate the old fashioned atmosphere as well.

So. Damn. Good. We're in town from Pgh for a hockey tournament and found this place on Yelp. We usually try to avoid chain-type places, and this place is why. It ain't fancy, but our subs were so good. The sign in the window says "best subs in town". It's not wrong. read more

Haven't been here for a couple years, heard there were new owner's and wasn't sure what to expect. Shouldn't have waited so long! Our subs were delicious! They also fresh slice the meat when you order. We got my favorite, the cold Italian, and the Romanburger. Enjoyed it very much and the guys running the place were very nice. VERY reasonable prices too. We'll be back! read more

Great tasting subs and great service! Definitely recommend this place! Restaurant is clean with tables to sit at if you wish to fine in.

Best cheesesteaks around. Staff always friendly and fast. Never ate in but it's very clean.

Wanted subs for a party. They come in 18" so I could cut six smaller but nice sized sandwiches from a sub. Because I wasn't serving them until later in the evening I had to do the cold subs but man, did those hot subs look delicious! I did the Italian and the turkey to please the crowd and they did just that. The meats were sliced fresh as the subs were made and all of the sides like, pickles banana peppers and sub sauce, were nicely packed up for me so as not to make my subs mushy by the time I served them. The people working there or so friendly and accommodating. One thing that I found disappointing was that they advertised whole wheat buns but when I got there they only had Italian white. They had mentioned that the baker they purchased from wasn't making the whole wheat anymore. If you like a good sub I would definitely try Tommy's! read more

Excellent every time. The hot italian and philly cheesesteak are the best. You will not be disappointed.

New owners still tasty buty cheese steak was lite on the meat more bun than steak not like the old owner gonna try Charlie's cheese steak sorry to say read more

The best Philly cheesesteak subs in Mentor. Everything I've gotten from here has been good. The staff are friendly and even when busy the wait is not long. read more

Incredible Philly!! Would choose over Jersey Mikes, Firehouse, Subway, JJs, etc. EVERY TIME

I'm not one to reach for subs often, but when my mom and I noticed this place today, we had to come in! An independent, mom and pop place with locally sourced ingredients, including buns freshly baked at a nearby bakery. She had the philly cheese steak and I had three corned beef reuben. SO good! We will definitely be back! read more

Stopped by the UPs store and noticed this old school sub shop. Something intrigued me to check their menu and try them out. I liked that they are not a chain. Ordered the Philly cheese steak. It was excellent! Crispy toasted bun and super fresh ingredients cooked to perfection on the flat top. Give this place a try! Family owned and well worth stopping by. (Across from the mall in the Titans Gym plaza. ) read more

okay so this place is insane. in a good way though! a small business and they slice the meat individually per sub. i was just very impressed with the service and subs. read more

Well this was my Christmas present from Mentor, OH. Thank you Thank you!! My first time in the area and my hubby and I wanted something affordable and Good. Well this place won. First of all the very humble look of it and the simplicity of the place was cool. Everything looks and tastes fresh!!! We got the buffalo chicken and the Philly steak hot sandwiches. Wow what a merry Christmas I had!! Customer service was great and not slow at all even though they had at least 7 people in line. Amazing! Would go again:) read more

See all

This Family has been very very good to me . Been going to Tommy's for many years.... Excellent Subs & friendly Professional Customer Service! They will always take Care of you all the time ...... read more

I'm a pretty picky sub eater and just from our first visit, this place is my second favorite sub shop. I got the hot Italian and it was delish! Everything tasted really fresh and the staff was very pleasant. read more

Tommy's Subs - Small hot Italian - Sandwiches Near Me - Mentor, Ohio

See all

Subs. As long as it's not subway it's already good, but this place... man... this place.... lets just say if it wasn't an hour away from my house I'd be here a lot more. When you first walk in you're greeted by the always welcoming sight of a deli meat cooler. The sight of big chunks of deli meats is always appetizing to me. I ordered a buffalo chicken and a Philly cheesesteak. While they aren't the fastest sandwich producers in the industry the wait is definitely worth it. The subs are basic and very visceral. They are incredibly simple yet so filling and just gut-satisfying. The buffalo chicken sub had crispy fried pieces of chicken AND slices of chicken on top. Double chicken! And they offered ranch or blue cheese with it, JUST LIKE EVERYONE ELSE WHO OFFERS BUFFALO SANDWICHES SHOULD!! Seriously... the philly was juicy and also super basic. Had no extras that you didn't need and was lacking in nothing. Just right. No other way to put it. Would I eat there again? YES would I recommend it? YES Do I wish they catered weddings? YES read more

I am from Florida and I am only visiting Ohio for 4 days and I must say... the Philly cheesesteak is probably best one I've ever had. I've had the sandwich 3 Times already. May I remind you I have only been here for 4 days. My friends had enjoyed their sandwiches as well. Tommy subs.. we shall return when we visit again! Great service as well. read more

Best subs in Mentor, hands down!! Have been going there for years! The people are the best! Super friendly and courteous! A-1 customer service! read more

This Family owned establishment is As good as it gets, Fresh Bread and Meats!!! I haven't ever had a Bad Sub from this place, EVER!!! I just finished an 8 inch Lean ,fresh cut toasted Capicola and hot pepper cheese Sub. It was out of this world with Lettuce, Tomatoes and Mayo. Sprinkled over some salt and Pepper with a dash of Oregano!!! If you like a spicy Italian meat please try this one just the way I ordered it. Thank you Tommy's, For MAKING LUNCH GREAT AGAIN...... read more

This was fantastic. Great price and one of the best hot Italian subs I've ever had. They slice the meat for each sandwich and the staff is so friendly. I came in as they were closing (which I hate to do), just about left.. but the woman there reassured me that it was no problem at all, had a conversation with me and told me that she would see me soon. It's nice to see a small shop with that family mentality. They've got my business for a long time, that's for sure. read more

Favorite sandwich shop. The cheesesteak has a juice that is a mix of meat and cheese that I dream about. Soda game is spot on. Styrofoam cup + self-serve fountain. Perfectly calibrated. #1 Dr Pepper fountain in Mentor, for sure. read more

We have been coming here for many years. This place is an old Jersey Mike's, but with better quality. It's locally owned and the sub's are huge! read more

Went here for lunch, I got the hot Italian. Over all the sub was good, I've just had better. I'd return for lunch. Prices are decent, and interior is typical deli. read more

Gnawed down a hot Italian sub. Really good with their fresh veggies and good pickles.

Best subs wish they were open till 8 like it says tho! Got the club sub and they really make it look like the picture.

Hands down THE BEST SUBS I'VE EVER EATEN! I don't know what the hell they do (apart from cutting all the meat and cheese for your sub when you order it) but you just have to try them to understand what I'm talking about. (They murder DiBella's if that helps give you a frame of reference.) Anyway, there are essentially only 2 subs to get there. The others are good, but the 'best subs ever' title comes from the Super Philly and the Hot Italian. If this will be your first time order one of those two and you will forever stop going to any other sub shop. (Also, the establishment is nice and clean and you can see everywhere your food is prepared, and every staff member I've met has been super friendly.) read more

Really great subs! Generous sandwiches at good prices. I especially love the Italian burger which is the amped up and improved version of the Roman burger. Top notch! read more