For Amsterdam NY, this place is likely very good to excellent. Definitely good if you're hungry. Service is definitely NOT "express" ... very, very slow. Ordered slices from the case and it took 29 minutes from the time or order to the time it came out of the oven. Been going to pizzerias for 35+ years in NYC and that never happened. If in the area, I'd recommend. But don't, y'know, go out of your way. read more

We've been working out in the Amsterdam area recently. We were in the mood for pizza. We found is place and we weren't disappointed. We've ordered from there twice now. Both time we ordered the chicken and broccoli square pizza with ricotta added. It is delicious. The place was clean. And the service was great. We will definitely order from there when we are in the area. If you're looking for good pizza, this is the place. read more

Manhattan Express Pizza - Chicken and broccoli square pizza with ricotta added. - Pizza Near Me - Amsterdam, New York

I am going to add that a lot of the negative reviews are 5 years old or so. We have been getting consistently good pizza and subs from Manhattan Express for at least two years. As well as good delivery service with Slice. Just tip 20% They deserve it and orders are always early. read more

I had my first experience with Manhattan Express Pizzaria today placing an on line/delivery order. I have been in the food and beverage industry all my life and often leave positive reviews. Rarely I will make a negative review citing they perhaps had a bad day however I could not overlook this experience today because not only the order came wrong but I had to deal with young people who clearly was over their head with my questioning and dissatisfaction. I ordered two subs and some soda. When the order was delivered there was one sub and a styrofoam box of romaine lettuce and Italian dressing. I looked at my original order and noticed there was only one sub on the receipt and an order for antipasto salad, below this order was my instructions for the 2nd subs, extra onions, dry . When I called to explain the problem he ignored me insisting that the instruction under the antipasto salad were for the 2nd sub and clearly there was something wrong . I made it clear I was not going to pay 11.99 for a box of cut up romaine and he asked me to send a pic of the salad to him but I could not figure out how to send that. He then said since I refuse to send the pic, there was nothing he could do. I will never do business with this place again and I suggest all of you out there considering to order online with this establishment to double and triple check your order before you place it. They may have screwed me out of 12 bucks but in the end, it will cost them business not only with me, but others if they continue to ignore making things right with decent customers~ read more

This is THE best pizza in amsterdam. Good service, fast deliverys, and amazing food. 10/10 would reccomend. Theres a reason why this has above 4.5 reviews on mealeo and slice. Evreything was on point read more

Whatever you do don't order eggplant cuz you're going to get spaghetti in a thin layer of eggplant not satisfied at all

Tried this place a handful of times. With each time the service and food gets more disappointing. A month ago, we ordered delivery and were told 45 minutes. When it was 15 minutes late, we called to inquire about our food and stated that it had been an hour since we ordered. We were told "It's only been 55 minutes not 60" in a rude tone. No "I'm sorry it's late, let me check on that for you." I would've been completely understanding, as I work in food service myself. But the attitude, that's not okay and way more disturbing to me than a late order. We seriously regretted leaving a 20% tip. Nonetheless, we ended up waiting an hour and 45 minutes for our delivery. The food was cold, the garlic knots were burnt and oily, and the breaded mushrooms were oddly wet. The pizza and Chicken Alfredo were okay. Tonight, we decided to give Manhattan one more shot. We figured maybe the other times we caught them having a bad day. My boyfriend ordered what he liked - Chicken Alfredo. I decided to second that. We were told delivery would take 90 minutes, which was totally acceptable for a Friday night. It ended up being 45 minutes this time. It was looking up! I thought the Chicken Alfredo was pretty good, the chicken a little weird (breaded not grilled?), and tiny bits of what seemed to mushrooms, but it tasted fine. I hadn't made it halfway through my meal when I bit down on something small and sharp. A little thorn that pierced my gums. Even the complimentary bread that comes with the meal, which seemed to be the only part I enjoyed in past, was hard as a rock. The knots were burnt again and the wings were low quality. Unfortunately, we're calling it quits on Manhattan. read more

Manhattan Express Pizza - Burnt, hard, and oily - Pizza Near Me - Amsterdam, New York

See all

Their pizza is ok but their customer service sucks. Late with deliveries and id say 8 out of 10 orders are wrong.

We couldn't even get our food before receiving terrible service. To be visiting for the first time from out of state I would expect respectable service. The cashier was short, rude, and not helpful. Attitude does not make for a happy customer, and I was absolutely shocked at the blatant ignorance. Here's a tip if you can't be a descent human being and exude customer service don't work in the food industry. read more

There is not much to say about this pizza honestly just a classic New York City style slice and taste. It was very crispy but bland needs more flavor. 7.1 / 10 Ranch was good as well read more

Ordered from there weekly sometimes a few times a week for the last year plus! They screw up my order when I get the same thing every time (not the first time)when I call to ask them to remake it and tell them I'll bring back the one with rocottia cheese in it an Italian guy gets on the phone and tells me I didn't say no rocottia cheese the girl who took the order says so! Thing is I'm allergic to rocottia not to mention two other people in the room heard me! Pretty poor business when I've spent I'd say over thousand in the 1.5 years! I love there chicken garlic parm pizza but no more. Not smart to save what 5$ or so to remake it when I will spend hundreds more! With an attitude no less! Good pizza terrible owner and staff not to mention some times you wait double the amount of time they tell you for your food. Hopefully that slice place is good I need a new spot! read more

Their pizza is usually very good. In my opinion among the best I've ever tasted. I would recommend the pizza. The chicken wings are pathetic, little things that are overpriced. $8.99 for ten tiny wings. The wings sold by their local competitors are about twice as big and for less money. I would definitely skip the wings at this place. read more

Manhattan Express Pizza - Tiny little chicken wings. - Pizza Near Me - Amsterdam, New York

And the award for the smallest most pathetic, overpriced chicken chicken wing goes to this place. Personally I would be embarrassed to accept any amount of money for these bulimic little wings. 10 for $8.99. read more

Manhattan Express Pizza - Tiny little chicken wing. - Pizza Near Me - Amsterdam, New York

Pizza is very good, BUT pick it up yourself. Have never had any problems with inside counter staff.....but delivery drivers is another story, Some have been rude, sarcastic...one even THREATENED me when I did not tip because pizza was so damn late Owner needs to read these reviews and oversee who he is paying to deliver pizzas and represent his business. read more

It means a lot to me to support local businesses. I understand that it's difficult to keep up with demand. Multiple times I've ordered only to, at best, have it picked up or delivered late by over 30 minutes. There have been multiple instances where my order has just been forgotten, but it sure goes through on my credit card. The oversight is laughable. I know that working in the service industry is difficult. I truly do, but there needs to be some level of accountability. read more

I got up off my lazy ass and actually picked up my pizza, not once, but twice! Both times, the pizza was great and even better the next day. Quality food and love the lunch special. read more

I read the reviews and so we decided to try it. We ate in because there is nothing like eating pizza fresh out of the oven. The pizza was good, but not great. Crust was very good. I prefer broadalbin pizza supreme^s square pie. read more

We had a big order and it was delivered within an hour, hot, and every order exactly as we wanted right down to the four ketchup packets. Also, the cheesecake was surprisingly the best cheesecake I've ever eaten! read more

I'm a New York City guy and Its always hard to find the best pizza and wings anywhere you go. Manhattan pizza gets 10 stars. Always the best no matter when I'm ordering. The name says it all!! They don't call it Manhattan Pizza for no good reason. Its literally Manhattan pizza in Amsterdam Ny. Amazing. You all are awesome love this place. To everyone who works here you guys do such an amazing job. My family and I thank you for being here to feed us through it all!! read more

Who doesn't love a good slice you bite into! We do and so far this place has delivered, wants Jamaican patty? Yup they have them just tell them how you want it with or without cheese. If you do Oder from them check out the wings! read more

Our firehouse orders from here about once a week, and we're usually pretty happy with what we get. Delivery has never been a problem, the pricing is reasonable (and about on-par with other places in the area), and there's a fair amount of selection. There are several gourmet pizza options. Our meat-eaters have really enjoyed the meat-lovers pizza, and our vegetarians have been getting the eggplant bella. There are a few other vegetarian options as well, meaning your veggie friends don't have to settle for "just cheese" again. So that's nice. The pizzas are a reasonable size: about the same as fresh basil. They're larger than pizza hut by a fair margin, but smaller than bottistis or riverside. From my experience, you're getting a pretty good deal for the price. read more

This place is the place to be lunch time 2 slices and a soda for 5 bucks lots of choices to pick from .. try the Buffalo chicken or the chicken bacon ranch both are a good slice .. read more

I have been here a few times and usually it is decent. Last night they forgot my wings, which luckily I realized before getting to far and went back to pick them up only to find out they hadn't been made. I wait for that, and when I got home I found that the fettuccine Alfredo I ordered was filled with mushrooms which I am allergic to. I called the location and was told rudely by the girl there that is how the pasta comes. I let her know online it does not list mushrooms as an ingredient and she said well that's how it comes u less you request it without. I am just disappointed at the rudeness and overall experience- with COVID there are a lot of local places that need business, which I will be going to from now on and not Manhattan pizza. read more

The owner trying to pass off being from NYC and Italian which he is not. We are from NYC and requested that our pizza be cooked well done, the pizza was brought out and requested that it be cooked for an additional time. He refused and sent the pizza back to us saying it was fine and we eat what we get refusing to cook the pie for an additional time. Confronted him on this and he refused, then reluctantly agreed to put it back in saying that my mother-in law didn't know what she was talking about. I said to him that in 3 months he will be out of business. Will never set foot in this establishment ever again. It is sad to see a foreign person act like this and think he can treat and speak to his customers any way he likes as he was in his own country. read more

I grew up in Staten Island and have been recommended several pizza places, which to me were all garbage. Too doughy and no flavor . The one downtown we ordered a pie and got a wanna be sicillian for a regular round pie. For me this is the closest to city pizza I've had since we moved up here. Great pie. I can't speak to the other food but as far as pizza goes in my opinion in Amsterdam this is the place to go to. The only other comparable was F&A in Rensselaer . read more

I wish I could give ZERO stars but I have to give 1 star!!! Never again will Manhattan Pizza get my business or my husband Robert!!!! WAITED OVER 2 HOURS FOR A DELIVERY!!! My son called to check was told delivery guy was already there knocked, waited 15 mins then left! My husband called right after and got the same thing and wasn't even offered to have the food re-delivered and was hung up on!!! I call while I'm in NYC and was told the same thing! I tell the man with a heavy accent, I have a dog that barks whenever anyone comes near the house let alone if there's a knock on the door or when someone rings the bell!!! Plus my son was sitting downstairs waiting! We also have the Ring Doorbell which shows NO ONE WAS EVER THERE!!! I was told it would be re-delivered and I'd be charged $20 for the order. Well guess what..... IT'S 10:24 PM AND MY KIDS HAVE NO PIZZA!!!!! I have our only car in NYC so I can't feed my family! My husband just had surgery and can't cook! My husband just ordered from here yesterday and had no problem!!!! We used to order several times a damn month!!!! NEVER AGAIN!!!! read more

Great chicken wings, they full size wings cooked to perfection and great HOT sauce. Pizza is one of the best in Amsterdam area. Location needs a little more inviting appeal, but Pizza and wings make up for their appearances. read more

We don't go to Manhattan Pizza very often, but do sometimes when in Ams. Pizza and wings always have been good.

It was edible, but not outstanding. Better off finding another pizza joint than going with this place.

I only left 1 star because I had no choice!!! I had been a long time loyal customer of this restaurant because I thought the food was alright initially , I ordered regularly and thought that I had found a gem. I was WRONG! A good restaurant doesn't only apply to food, it applies to customer service, management. I called with a problem regarding the food , I wanted to bring to their attention that we had ordered food the day before and unfortunately my family was really sick all night (I don't have to explain that, I'm sure that you understand) I made it clear that I wasn't seeking to be reimbursed . Anyhow the minute I said my kids got sick I heard yelling and defensive behavior calling me a liar and saying that's impossible and nobody else got sick etc.... he yelled at me and told me nobody gets sick there ever and that we got sick somewhere else... ARE YOU SERIOUS LOL.. I counteracted with the fact that I am not lying, why would I make this up. I told him earlier if he's worried about the money don't worry because that's not why I called, I called to make him aware that the family got sick. He continued being defensive and accusative, I was upset because I was highly offended that someone who should be professional in a managerial capacity had absolutely no class..NO professional in any public food service should ever treat you like that. Don't shop here for food, there's a chance that you may get ill , it's Ghetto trashy other than the girl who answered the phone (she was nice) and I would never have gone if I thought there was a chance I'd be treated so disrespectfully in a time of need. All he had to do was apologize or at last appear that he was authentically concerned, but he attacked and told me never come back ..Shame on you! read more

Placed an online order for delivery, it took almost 2 hours to arrive. I called to find out where it was and they offered no compensation. I ordered at 6pm and they delivered at 8pm, my kids bed time. The pizza was soggy and flavorless. read more

This is a pizza to fulfill your basic pizza cravings. It's pretty good and similar to pizza I've had in the city. They always deliver on time, and pretty hot pizza. Service is quick and efficient. However, I'm not able to attest to eating in the store itself. Veggie, broccoli, and cheese pizzas are delicious. BEST SAUCE TO CHEESE RATIO. Garlic knots are pretty great too! The sauce that comes with is mediocre. The wings aren't bad; my brother, who's a big wing person, likes them. I always order from them; better to support local businesses and people than big corporations. read more

Wings were crispy(my favorite) but needed a little more sauce. Pizza was just as good as anywhere else we've had it in the area. Customer service was fine. Overall, it was fine. read more

Really gross food and the owner and staff are not really person people. Bad location in bad neighborhood. Order somewhere else.

worst customer service we've ever experienced...took over 2 hours & repeated phone calls to get our order...wings were small and not as ordered...never again read more

Disgusting food I will never eat there again I order cheese fries and it was a slice of cheese microwaved on top of soggy fries. Steer clear of this nasty, hole in the wall. read more

It's hard to find a good pizza place in Amsterdam. I had Manhattan Pizza a couple of times before with great luck and generous amounts of cheese (which is important in our household). This last time their prices had jumped and everything had LESS cheese on it than usual. I spent over $75, and to top it off their delivery was about a half an hour later than the promised time. Furthermore the driver said he called us but we had no missed calls on our phone and it didn't even ring so maybe he dialed the wrong number. But based on this bad experience, I won't be ordering them again any time soon. The search for good pizza WITH GOOD SERVICE in Amsterdam continues. read more

Ok pizza, definitely better in the city. Do make sure that you pay attention to prices when ordering over the phone. Chances are you may be charged more for larger item then you actually ordered. Good luck. read more

it is nothing like real Manhattan pizza, lived and worked there for years, this is just awful, pizza has a weird flavor to it. I had it on 2 different occasions just to make sure. Amsterdam has the worst pizza and Chinese food. read more