Delivery is always a little slow but the food is good. We got a good portion size for the dinner and the pizzas (although cold by the time we got them) were tasty. read more

We recently moved to the other side of Amsterdam and we couldn't be happier at our new options for pizza! First- I appreciate that they deliver. Our only option in our pervious home was always a last resort- but as we've had Goodfellas a couple times now, we feel much more excited about ordering delivery than we used to! They're friendly when you call, and never make you feel bad for using a card. The delivery guys are also friendly. Most importantly- the pizza! We have tried three versions: Chicken Frescura (which has a white sauce), chicken alfresco (with Alfredo sauce) and a sausage pizza with the regular red sauce. Each pizza held their own with flavor. Very distinct, but equally delicious. The crust on all 3 was also great- soft and fluffy but just a little crusty. Absolutely delicious! I'm also appreciative of any place that keeps the pizza bubbles in tact! I also go Their wings are super crispy, and the mild has just the right amount of kick. The garlic park wings were a little less "parmy" than we like, but ultimately it still tasted good. We look forward to ordering from here for a looooong time!! read more

See all

Go to their web site and prices say one thing. Go to pick up the food and the price is double. It's not like I could not afford it but that's just false advertising. If I order again I'll ask how much it is before ordering. Not a good way to do business! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Amsterdam, New York

See all

It's a nice little spot in Amsterdam, the pizza isn't anything special it had decent crisp and the pizza was just a little bland in general also where they keep the slices is not the most sanitary they keep them in a non closed case on wood . The ranch was pretty good Rate: 6.2out of 10 read more

waited for a pizza delivery for 1:40 minutes When I call the girl told me 10 min 30 min later I called the shop and he said 20 min more. Will never order from them again read more

Ordered for the 1st. time and very prompt delivery. Very satisfied with pizza and antipasto salad.

Love there pizza , calzones and subs, and they are right around the corner, we always order our party pizzas here always fresh and hot ,

Headed through Town to the thruway .... Went in to grab 2 slices and a blt and stood there for 10 minutes , along with another customer, while the girl at the counter ignored us and took 4 phone orders. When she finally got around to us we ordered and was told "the blt is going to be a while ... there is a 45 minute call in order time". We walked out. read more

Out on the road on vacation with the family and I found this place by Yelp. It is off the beaten path but definitely worth the extra few miles driven off the thruway. Very receptive greeting from the person working. We called ahead for our order and it was ready right when we arrived, as he promised. The reviews were right and the food did not disappoint. The place was able to easily accommodate our party of 8. The wing sauce was amazing! The pizza was delicious too. So glad we took a chance with this tasty business. read more

Love this place , don't order from nowhere else, acting goofy on the phone you'll get the same energy right back a great place ,great pizza, great wings, great service #I'mOut read more

Ive held off on updating, hopeful that the last few times were isolated incidents. After today, however, I gotta update: Very Disappointing! Pizza toppings were pathetically skimpy. To charge $2 for onion and only get a few pieces is insulting. Wings: I don't think they were chicken. Too small. maybe sparrow? And Waaaaayyyyy overdone. But the biggest complaint today is that they add a surcharge for using a credit card, a practice that is not at all customer friendly. Oh, there's a sign at the counter about it, but bring your glasses if you want to read it. Next time I'll roll my pennies and use those to pay. At least I'll avoid their surcharge. read more

Good food is seemingly hard to find in Amsterdam NY, but this is the best pizza I have had here, I give it a 7 out of 10. I had 2 slices one pepperoni, one sausage. read more

I eat there once a week. Love the boneless wings in the hot sauce. BEST HOT SAUCE around. Highly recommend this place. Pizza is amazing and rates up there with the pizza i used to eat when I lived in Brooklyn. My favorite is 12cit Sicilian! Stop in its a great family place with amazing food! read more

The pizza meat lovers was real salty. Don't order it lady was rude my call to complaint

Pretty good pizza, probably not the best I've had but it's up there. I have also ordered a sub from there before which was surprisingly good. Defiantly worth ordering from. read more

Best pizza in Amsterdam. The guys making the food do a fantastic job and are always on top of things. Very friendly, inviting atmosphere and always clean. The pizza is nice and thin and slices are good size. Just the right amount of grease on the pizza as well. I've had it both with and without toppings and everything I've had here is great. The antipasto's are delicious as well and the small one will last you a couple sittings. The location kind of sucks because it's not really central to much but if you live in the area it's worth the extra couple miles of driving. I'm jealous of the people who live on the nearby streets within walking distance to this place. read more

I eat here at least once a week! Great menu and great food! The best pizza in town. Extra crispy hot wings are to die for! Home made potato chips are also amazing! Check it out you will not be disappointed. read more

I was looking for a decent pizza place to eat, in a small city loaded with pizza joints and they recommended Goodfellas, when I walked in I noticed they had won awards for their pizza & wings from a local magazine Capital Region Living Magazine...this was a good start) so I proceeded to order just that pizza & wings and was not disappointed at all. The wings were crisp & not soggy, the wing sauce was just hot enough but also flavorful(not just franks red hot poured in a bucket). The pizza was good as well not overly greasy from too much cheese & the sauce was good as well. If your in the area I would suggest give Goodfellas a try. Oh did I mention their homemade potato chips(these are a must)!!! read more