Food was FRESH & delicious! Antipasto salad was the BEST. Our pizza was amazing, cooked…read moreperfectly. Drinks were wonderful. Waitress was great too. Love this place

I must admit, I had no idea where Lorenzo's was in Amsterdam. However, I have been told by many…read morethat I should give it a go. Thank goodness for car navigators as I would be lost haha. I called late afternoon same day for an early dinner reservation as I had a hankering for something good. They were able to accommodate so off I went. When I arrived I did not know what to expect, and I was pleasantly surprised by the large casual establishment. I was seated immediately by a very warm and friendly server, and given menus to look over. I was torn over so many starters that I decided to have them as a meal along with their well known pizza. I ordered the calamari fritti, the eggplant stack the Italian nachos and a wood fired Margherita pizza. While I waited, I was given some good bread as well as some tomato pie and it was all so tasty. The portions here are generous and I had to take a good amount home. No complaints here though as it was all delish. I can only imagine how good my leftovers will be next day. This eatery is solid and what a nice place for some good Italian food!

Wings were phenomenal. Ordered the 10 piece - hot- and boy were they. Perfect & crispy…read more Ordered a large pizza. Pretty good as well. The guy that took our order when we called in was very friendly and helpful/ even gave us our total when we placed the order. Love that.

The pizza and cheesy garlic bread from Riverside was great! Walking in, the staff were super…read morefriendly and helpful. My order was ready when I got there. If you are driving through or live around the corner, stop in and give them a try!

We recently moved to the other side of Amsterdam and we couldn't be happier at our new options for…read morepizza! First- I appreciate that they deliver. Our only option in our pervious home was always a last resort- but as we've had Goodfellas a couple times now, we feel much more excited about ordering delivery than we used to! They're friendly when you call, and never make you feel bad for using a card. The delivery guys are also friendly. Most importantly- the pizza! We have tried three versions: Chicken Frescura (which has a white sauce), chicken alfresco (with Alfredo sauce) and a sausage pizza with the regular red sauce. Each pizza held their own with flavor. Very distinct, but equally delicious. The crust on all 3 was also great- soft and fluffy but just a little crusty. Absolutely delicious! I'm also appreciative of any place that keeps the pizza bubbles in tact! I also go Their wings are super crispy, and the mild has just the right amount of kick. The garlic park wings were a little less "parmy" than we like, but ultimately it still tasted good. We look forward to ordering from here for a looooong time!!

Delivery is always a little slow but the food is good. We got a good portion size for the dinner…read moreand the pizzas (although cold by the time we got them) were tasty.

Good food and service love their steak sandwiches and pizza…read more Glad they are in busines

Favorable score for it being a nostalgic pizza but it quite expensive, we paid $100 for 3 pizzas,…read morewhich are generally a bit undercooked and with a flavorless crust, plus this time we were told it would be a 65 min wait for pickup which then ended up being 95 minutes without so much as an apology or discount.

Tried this place last month after passing it for years on my way to Johnstown. There were four of…read moreus for an early dinner on a Saturday. The staff was definitely friendly, and very attentive. They were raving about their seafood bisque and brought a sample to share. Dipping their in house bread was great, and the soup itself was decent. I got adventurous and tried their "Italian Sushi". Not bad, an interesting idea. Jughead ordered a burger as usual, another ordered the ravioli, chicken parm and for me the drunken chicken. Everything was decent, but lacked a lot of seasoning, especially salt. I'd try it again but am skeptical.

Great service the food is delicious. Their bread is marvelous. I love going there anytime I can…read moreall my friends love it too. Pizza is terrific meatballs and sausage. Awesome. There isn't anything I don't like.

For Amsterdam NY, this place is likely very good to excellent. Definitely good if you're hungry…read more Service is definitely NOT "express" ... very, very slow. Ordered slices from the case and it took 29 minutes from the time or order to the time it came out of the oven. Been going to pizzerias for 35+ years in NYC and that never happened. If in the area, I'd recommend. But don't, y'know, go out of your way.

We've been working out in the Amsterdam area recently. We were in the mood for pizza. We found is…read moreplace and we weren't disappointed. We've ordered from there twice now. Both time we ordered the chicken and broccoli square pizza with ricotta added. It is delicious. The place was clean. And the service was great. We will definitely order from there when we are in the area. If you're looking for good pizza, this is the place.

I am in town visiting family and came here with my aunt Tuesday night. It has been 5 years since…read morebeing there and there has been some renovations since then. The ambiance was fantastic. It gave more of a homey feel. Our bartender/server was Jackie and she did a fantastic job! I have some unique food allergies, and she ensured that my meal met my dietary needs. I had the small antipasto. It was delicious! It was great to be back. If you are in the area, I highly recommend that you check it out.

They're Italian dinner. Specials are delicious. You can't beat the chicken parmigiana nor the…read moreeggplant. The dish is prepared with a generous serving of pasta as a side. It's really enough for two people and it's delicious. If you order one of their salads or antipasto you'll be shocked how much they give you. I had a small group at my house for dinner. There were four people. I got one eggplant parm and one parm and a salad and it served all four of us. Prices are very reasonable.

We visited them over the summer. We had pizza to go that took over an hour to be ready. The pizza…read morewas very good. The salad was also very good. Returned in September only to have the worst service ever. We sat there waiting for a drink for about 20 minutes while the staff were doing shots. We decided to have a drink to see if the service would get better. However, it did not. We waited 15 minutes after asking for our bill. Ordered some takeout on November 28, We ordered chicken wings, a tossed salad and buffalo french fries. The wings were definitely a triple fried, there wasn't any meat on the bones because it was fried off. The salad was welted and may as well have been just a little lettuce with two cucumbers, and that was it. The cucumbers were wilted. The french fries were soggy as to be expected for takeout, but there was nothing fresh about anything that we ordered. Will not be ordering again. We received a phone call 20 minutes after our order asking when we were going to pick it up because apparently they were closing early due to no business. Just not the best experience or what we were hoping for to get this place a third chance. Three times and that's it!

I really wanted to like this place, since I remember coming here as a kid. Our waitress wasn't…read moregreat. We sat for 5 minutes before being greeted, she came and got our drink order and came back 10 minutes later with only half of our drinks. The dining room is dirty, the carpets stained and the tables sticky. The food was just ok. The owner thanked us for coming and was very friendly. It's great to see this old place open and I wish they would clean it up a bit and fix the mediocre renovations that were done.