Wonderful Food, Cute Decor, Town & Family owned & ran…read more Homecooked food, hand breaded Country Fried Steaks, Scratch made potatoes!

Had the home made biscuits & gravy and they were probably the best I've ever had! The biscuits were…read moreso fluffy !!! Highly recommend

Just a couple from Indiana -If you want a good helping of food for the price this is the place to…read morego. My Husband had the 3 way basket and it was more than he expected , bursting with flavor and the amount of food was enough for 2 to share. I had the 1lb crab legs with fried Okra and cajun rice . Delish! The atmosphere was nice with so much to look at. Our server was Cheryl and she was very sweet. We will definitely be back.

Super popular and very busy place. The staff really did their best to serve our party amongst an…read morealready packed house. It was however a very underwhelming experience for the food itself. Hands down the fried catfish was amazing - though it wasn't what I ordered. Unfortunately the seafood boil dinner was lackluster in presentation and they were out of several staple items for that night (We did get alternate items at no extra charge). I don't usually splurge on cuisine like this too often but when I do I hope for it to be nearly perfect, worth every penny and worth bragging about. The crab leg I've attached to this review was small and had almost no meat to it.. almost as if it were the last bit of crab they had left. The drinks came out very slow, had to ask a few times about drinks we had ordered and they were out of options (beers on tap) that night as well. The restaurant was really fun and full of character. But being an out-of-towner I was disappointed that I've had better sea food at chain restaurants vs a local establishment. Can't say I'd never come back, I would probably order something else and come on a less busy night...

This is one of our favorite places to go when we want to grab a quick bite…read more They have an amazing Patty Melt Burger, and they also have great grilled chicken sandwiches!

Very American Diner. Lots of nostalgia and American pride. All the waitresses were super friendly…read moreand right on top of everything. Super service. I had the burger melt with fries and a malt. Everything was very tasty and good.

Great tasting burger! If it's a lunch rush it can take 30 mins to get your order so be patient and…read moremake some conversation with the locals. Everyone is very nice. Favorite is the double burger with grilled onions!

Edit. Restaurant is under new ownership and it much better than it used to be. The pork tenderloin…read moresandwich is the best.

We stumbled upon this. We wanted bbq and saw the smokers out front…read more We were greeted with shots when we walked in (great idea on their part) we ended up staying for 3 hours, playing pool (free up until 6 p.m.) had several of those yummy drinks. The food was amazing. Smoked Mac n cheese was out of this world delicious. Can't wait to take friends when they come to visit

Stumbled on this place when looking for an easy dinner after driving from Houston. The staff is…read morevery friendly, and the atmosphere is energetic. The drinks prices were very reasonable, but the pizza was bit doughy. Regardless, we'll probably stop here again when we are back in the area.

This place is amazing! Cards, Uno and if you're lucky a TV on the wall at your table. Bathrooms are…read moresuper clean, warm and has a spectacular wall mirror. Food portions are HUGE!! If you're hungry this is your restaurant as you will not leave hungry or without a to-go box! Servers were SO attentive and kind. You must RUN not walk to McGarity's!! I'll def be back as it's FIRE

This was our best meal in Eureka…read more On our final day in town we decided to try this spot based on the great Yelp reviews. It was the experience we needed after a host of poor service and unwelcoming attitudes at other ES establishments. McGarity's is everything you would expect an Irish pub and restaurant to be. There is a leprechaun out front for photos, super friendly and attentive staff, and a menu chock full of feel good and filling food. We started with an appetizer of cheese curds. Get these for the table. They were cheesy goodness with light batter and were delicious. For our meals I got the burger and the kids got shepherd's pie and chicken alfredo. Both looked great and there were plenty of leftovers. Portions are huge here. My burger was cooked the way I liked and had a great beefy juiciness offset by fresh lettuce, tomato, and onions. The thing I didn't particularly like must be some sort of Arkansas or Eureka rule because everyone does it. Condiments were in little packs on the table. I would prefer that at least the mayo be added in the kitchen so I am not disassembling my burger to squeeze mayo on the buns but every restaurant was this way. Despite that, this was a great experience. All oher Eureka Restaurants can take a page from McGarity's and the place would be much happier.

Used to be the go to but quality is dropping. Just an example is hamburgers and patty melts sent…read moreout pink and barely room temp in the center. Service is still great with welcoming attitudes. Just not worth the drive anymore!

This is a must stop for outstanding food in a beautiful setting. The staff was first class all the…read moreway. I will be bringing my friends next time we're in town.

Love this place !! It tastes as good as it looks…read more The coffee is excellent too. They have a couple of locations. We always go to the original on 265. Enjoy

[July 2025] This place is a huge tourist attraction. Parking is very difficult. We ended up having…read moreto park across the street at a neighboring business' lot that wasn't open yet. I had Gail's Famous Omelet - Ham, mushrooms, cheddar jack cheese, onions and green and red peppers. The omelet was perfect in thickness and the toppings were balanced. They omelet paired well with their garlic hot sauce. I had hash browns and wheatberry toast for my sides. My brother ordered their infamous 14" pancakes. Their bacon is crispy and thick. Their coffee was good too! My mom had a BLT with fries. Everyone enjoyed their meals and we definitely will be back when we are in Branson again.

Food was very good! Serving size was great for the price. Services as expected for the type of…read morerestaurant. Good atmosphere.

Brisket is delicious. Atmosphere is great. Friendly staff. Great amount of food for the money…read more Fries are some of the best I have had.

Friendly service, quaint setting, reasonable prices, good-sized portions. The menu is hilarious to…read moreread through. I had "Bill's Favorite," a biscuit with sausage gravy paired with hashbrowns covered with a scrambled egg, and topped with cheese ($1 extra). Filling, warm and tasted okay for what it was. We'll probably be back some time.

This place was a very nice surprise. We wanted something off the beaten path that was for the…read morelocals. This did not disappoint. Warm, friendly greeting. Very clean! Loved the old pictures lining the walls. Bathroom was spotless. Food was good and the biscuits were WARM!! Seems like nobody serves warm biscuits anymore. Would definitely go back.