Extremely Poor Property Management Experience - Fort Myers…read more Marshall Reddick did a very poor job managing my property in Fort Myers. I relocated to California for work (RTO) and left the property in August, giving Marshall Reddick full authorization to manage everything--including tenant placement and payment of utility bills. This was by far the most horrifying property management experience I've had, and I own properties managed in other states. Over several months, I was instructed to reduce my rent five separate times due to what they claimed was a "poor market," yet the company changed real estate agents 3-4 times without my consent. Each time, they failed to run the live Facebook marketing campaign they had explicitly promised. Most alarming, I was later informed that power to the property had been shut off for three weeks before Marshall Reddick notified me. I was told this occurred due to a lack of funds, and only after the prolonged outage was I informed of a potential microbial growth issue--a serious risk to the property that should have been addressed immediately. Despite providing a 30-day notice for non-performance, Marshall Reddick ignored the notice entirely and continued to demonstrate a complete lack of accountability, communication, and urgency. This experience showed a complete disregard for: Basic property oversight Timely communication Tenant placement execution Utility management Owner fiduciary responsibility I would strongly caution any property owner--especially those managing remotely--before trusting Marshall Reddick with their investment.

I've had a great experience with the Florida branch of Marshall Reddick so far. They've been…read moreresponsive to my requests and proactive around lease renewals. There has been a lot of turnover recently, but generally the staff has been pretty easy to work with

Joe and his team got my property rented faster and without any of the hassles, we've experienced…read morewith other companies. No need for my wife and I to look further for our property manager needs. Thanks Joe! The Masons

Joe and his team did a great job helping sort through property offerings. He is communicative,…read moreknowledgeable and willing to do the work. I'll definitely be looking to Joe for any future property needs. A+ Service.

Kingfisher is the best property management company in the island. They care about the owners as…read morewell as the renters and it shows in their service and responsiveness.

We loved Captiva and Baybarlyn. We've been to Captiva many many times and stayed at Baybarlyn…read moretwice now. It's our favorite house and will definitely be back. Kingfisher is VERY good!! They remedy any problems so fast and are extremely friendly and professional. Thank you so much for making our stay perfect!!

Nancy/Tom May recommend this site highly. We have stayed at this site for almost 30 yrs. Since…read moreretirement, we have continued to stay for 4 weeks when we can afford. Leslie has been so welcoming and the site is the best in condition of all our many years. Knowing many, we have recommended over a hundred to the site. We are already set for this Jan/Feb with help of Leslie. Wish we could stay longer prior to our arrival. Fixed incomes for oldies is not good!!! However, SAW is outstanding.

We have been coming to Sanibel Arms West for over 25 years. We love that the condos are two…read morebedroom, 2 bath with a large open living area, screened in lanai for outdoor dining and washer and dryer in each condo. Each condo has been clean and well-stocked. We have looked at other condos on the island, and they don't compare to Sanibel Arms West. The beach and pool are perfect for a family getaway or a winter escape. We were so excited to get back to Sanibel Arms West this past winter after spending one winter vacation in Marco Island and one on the east coast. WE LOVE Sanibel and Sanibel Arms West. Leslie and Becky are great to work with.

They are slum lords tenants do not have heat or ac and live in filth…read moreThey buy distressed properties with investors and make no improvements - several county code violations

Don't even CONSIDER living in one of their properties unless you want to live with the regret…read more Island Communities is nothing short of a slumlord. They overcharge for everything and then even charge when you pay on their website with your checking account. Then they charge you for services you don't even receive. And forget about trying to resolve an issue. No one answers the phone nor do they respond to emails. Once they have your lease agreement, you are screwed.

The home being rented was sold and changed ownership. We were unaware of a new owner and sent the…read morenext months payment to Coastal Shores Property Management as always. Instead of directing the payment to the new owner where it belonged, they accepted the payment. Leaving the new owner, as well as ourselves, without the money due. Still trying to resolve this and have them return the money., so far to no avail. Will update this review if they do the right thing and return the money. UPDATE - Coastal Shores has Followed through and the issues have been corrected.

From the owner: Your Trusted Partner for Property Solutions! Are you a…read moreproperty owner seeking peace of mind and optimal returns on your investments? Look no further! We are dedicated to providing exceptional property management services tailored to meet your specific needs. Expertise and Experience: Our team of professionals possesses extensive knowledge of local markets, regulations, and trends, ensuring your properties are managed efficiently and profitably. Comprehensive Services: We offer a comprehensive suite of property management services designed to handle every aspect of property ownership. From tenant screening and leasing to rent collection, maintenance, and accounting, we handle it all, so you can sit back and relax while we take care of the day-to-day operations. Personalized Approach: We recognize that every property is unique, and we tailor our services to match your individual goals and requirements. Tenant Satisfaction: Happy tenants are the key to successful property management. Our team is dedicated to providing exceptional customer service to both property owners and tenants. We promptly address maintenance requests, ensure timely rent collection, and foster positive tenant relationships, resulting in higher tenant retention rates and reduced vacancies. Transparency and Communication: We believe in open and transparent communication with our clients. You can count on us to be responsive, proactive, and accountable every step of the way.

Have rented multiple years and multiple condos through Select for many years. They are always very…read moreresponsive and great to work with.

Over the years we've worked with Select Vacation Properties to find appropriate rental properties…read moreon Sanibel Island in Florida. Each time, the personnel are wonderful to work with in helping us meet our needs each time. Once in the rental property we have always been impressed with the availability of staff to address any issues as they turn up. Staff are friendly, professional and always helpful. Special shout out to Kelly!

Me and my boyfriend would always be a couple days late with rent so I would give the benefit of the…read moredoubt about little things but once we found black mold in all the vents, roaches and broken things I'm now pissed. They they keep most of our deposit and when I sent pictures showing it was like that before we got here they didnt care I explained to them we where in a really tight spot for money that way we had to move out and was really on our security deposit they still didn't care so don't go through them

Three years later and they are still providing excellent service and advice. House in ggood…read more shape and on time checks I've had a few repairs done that were taken care of quickly and warranty honored.