First time visitors from Eau Claire. Place was clean and welcoming, friendly young staff. They have beer and wine , also Old Fashioned in a can and Carbliss which I enjoyed. Husband enjoyed Leinie's beer. We shared a pizza fry with marinara as an appetizer. Very cheesy but lacked garlic flavor. Plenty to eat and have as leftover. I had the personal size chicken bacon ranch pizza on the thin crust. (Not as thin or crispy as I would have liked but still good). Husband had Lasagna with garlic cheese bread and loved it. He had the single size & took plenty home for leftover. Signs said they have pizza and salad buffet on weekdays. Seemed like carry out business was booming also. (They may have a drive up window). Definitely worth a stop if in the area. read more

See all

We stopped here on our way East across Highway 29, having been on the road for 6 weeks! We were craving a good Pizza, after "Yelping" Pizza places nearby we found Martino's, & happy we did!! Parking lot was busy (& large enough for our truck/trailer!), always a good sign!! Shelly greeted & seated us, we wished she could have stayed to eat with us!! Server Allie took great care of us, & Owners Megan & John stopped by to visit. What nice people, we enjoyed their time! Antipasto salad & "Martino's Supreme pizza" were delicious; beer & ice tea yummy!! Very reasonable prices, awesome customer service, & crave-able lunch - just wished we could have stayed longer to visit & enjoy!! Thank you Martino's!! read more

Quality of food has gone down hill since new owners took over. Bread sticks were bland, and pizza was luke warm. Plenty of staff in the kitchen, but none were eager to wait on customers. Wait time was 15 minutes from being sat to receive drinks and to order food... definitely disappointed.. used to be a top notch place read more

Martino's is a local restaurant in our small town of Stanley, WI. This restaurant has excellent food and great service. The pizza's are awesome but the pasta is to die for. read more

DELICIOUS PIZZA! We stopped in with our family while visiting in Wisconsin, who told us this was the best place in Wisconsin to eat pizza. They were completely right! The servers were so friendly, the pizza was SOOO yummy, and there were even tables to eat outdoors at. We highly recommend stopping in here for any meal, any day. 11/10 we're coming here next time we visit Wisconsin! read more

The food was lacking. Pass on the Caesar salad, the chicken was dry and cold. As well as the breadstick. The shrimp fettuccine Alfredo was just ok. read more

This place is a little hard to find but it's worth looking for The prices are fair The Pizzas we had were really good and the Soup was incredible They also had a nice little Salad bar. I really enjoyed the food and the wait staff. They were extremely friendly and helpful. I would highly recommend this place for their lunch buffet. read more

Fairly priced, with tasty food. Interior was clean and the staff were friendly and attentive.

We were on the highway and stopped off because we were in a hurry and they had a pizza / salad / soup buffet. Every flavor I tried (5, don't judge) was great. Salad ingredients were very fresh and the chicken dumpling soup was great as well. Will stop again on our trips to St. Paul. read more

Best pizza in Wisconsin! Every time we travel to the area we stop for some! Very friendly staff! Such a hidden jem!

Best salad bar around! Pizza is always great and i love all the different pastas! Service is always good and fast. Love this place

Great food, great prices, very friendly service - delightful meal. If you are in the area highly recommended. I haven't had the pizza, it looked good though on my Aunt's plate. Here is what I thought about the food - I had the mostaccioli and it was fantastic. I loved the sauce because it was light and tasty. It was baked with cheese on top, which was good and just the right amount. Their salad bar was nice, lots of veggies. Their lemonade was really good too. My mother had the raviolis and those were very good as well. The server was wonderful and we gave him a lot of specific wants, i.e. buttered noodles and my aunt wanted no sauce on her pizza, plus extra cheese - there were no complaints about the special orders. We even got to talk to the owner, very friendly. For this area I still feel this restaurant deserves a 5 star - put it in Chicago and you'll have a mom and pop with 3.5 star for service and food. read more

Love the pizza! When we lived in the neighborhood (Sauganash) ordering a family sized pizza was a monthly occurrence. And even though I no longer live within their delivery area I still make the trip to pick up a Martino's Special. read more

im my previous review ,I rated the restaurant 3 out of 5 stars and I wanted to change that to a 5 star rating . The coupon issue isn't the restaurant's fault. Plus they always mail a coupon for your Birthday with is awesome so I'd say Martino's Restaurant is the best restaurant that Stanley, Wisconsin has . read more

You won't find this restaurant easily. It's a block off of the highway and in a nondescript office-looking building. This is definitely worth the trip though. The pizza is extremely good with a buttery, chewy crust and cheese so fresh you think they have a cow in the kitchen. We went for the Sunday buffet, had some standard salad bar fare, the wonderful selection of pizzas, and a really decent dumpling soup. read more

Good pizza buffet. Love the cheese bread and the candy pizzas. Busy on Sundays but does have plenty of seating. Great for kids. Good deal on the kids lunch prices read more

Ate there twice so far during my trip to my hometown Stanley!!!! First day I had the chicken alfredo, it was great! And for dessert chocolate cookie sundae, also fab!!!! Left so full!!! Today went for lunch and had the salad bar and soup, it was good nothing crazy awesome lol. I also got the fried ravioli, can I say Wow yummy.... u gotta get these. I also had the chicken bacon pizza and it was great too. Next time I kind of want to try the loaded baked potato pizza, sounds crazy but good. And the dessert pizzas, wow don't leave without one. read more

Went with a friend who has family in the area. This review is for the buffet only as that's what we ate. 2 complaints- The buffet did not get updated regularly, so I only had 2 kinds of pizza. Also, the plates were very small- you could only fit 2 of the little slices there on a time unless you piled on the pizza in stacks. However, the pizza was fantastic! It was very fresh, and the ingredients were of top quality. The meat lovers (Ron's Special) was amazing and I did enjoy the sausage as well. The cheese bread was also good- not very doughy and the cheese shone through. The dessert pizza was great too! I really liked the apple cinnamon one- it was full of flavor and not too sweet! I would absolutely come here again if I was on the area, though I would likely order off the menu to get the kind of pizza I wanted. I really was looking forward to buffalo chicken, which did not make it on the buffet while I was there. read more

I get to Stanley on business usually once a month. Martinos is a must for lunch, serving an all you can eat pizza buffet with a fresh salad bar. The pizza is absolutely fantastic. I have found nothing in this part of Wisconsin that compares. Staff is friendly and accommodating.Love this place, I could not recommend higher. read more

I stopped by while I was in town for business. I got a small original crust pizza with pepperoni and onion. It was delicious. It had the perfect amount of every ingredient. I haven't been able to find good pizza by me in KC and was so excited to finally have a good pizza. If I was in town again I would go out of my way to stop here. I also got the cheese curds. From what I understand WI is the place to get cheese curds. I thought they were ok. But it was my first try and I have nothing to compare them too. I felt they were a bit bland and maybe were not hot enough when I ate them. Overall it was a great experience. The team working there were very nice. I suggest to stop by and give it a try. read more

Great pizza with a real nice salad bar!!! Dine in or pick up. We pick up once a week. Love the fun varieties of pizza. Dessert pizza is amazing. Love not having to cook. Lunch buffet is quick and delicious! read more

LOVE this place! Some of the best pizza I've ever had! Stop by for lunch and try the pizza buffet, then you can try a variety of specialty pizzas. They also have great dessert pizza! read more

I would recommend looking elsewhere for a meal. The food tasted like it was heated from frozen. The device was extremely slow. Worst of all the seating was very uncomfortable. They seated four tall adults at a tiny booth near s window that had a crossbar underneath that prevented caused all of us to have bruised knees. The protruding window ledge kept poking 2 of us in our upper arms. We regret choosing this restaurant. read more

We've had the pleasure of eating at Martino's several times over the years. We, my wife, daughter, and I, enjoy the pizza very much. Our last visit was yesterday and my wife and I decided to try something other than pizza. My wife had just the salad bar which was fair. Not too much variety, but OK. Also, most of the lettuce was rusty. I went with the Martino's Club. It boasted of having roast beef, ham, and turkey with the special blend of cheese. I will say the bread and cheese were great, however it really lacked flavor...hardly any meat on it. Kinda disappointed there. Service was friendly and efficient. I'm sure we'll go back, but I'll be much more hesitant to stray from the pizza. read more

not the best but not bad. dessert pizzas are cool. try them out. The thing to get is the buffet.

When we visited earlier tonight we walked in at a bad time with several other customers and only 1 waitress. The waitress took our order quite timely, however getting our food took about 45 minutes. I ordered the fettuccini Alfredo with shrimp. The shrimp were salad shrimp and there weren't very many of them. I think it would be better to charge more and give some good chunks of well seasoned pan seared shrimp. The sauce was a bit heavy for me. I also ordered the soup and salad bar. The salad was fresh and had a nice variety. There were dressing packets which was a bit disappointing. I had some of the chicken dumpling soup. It was home made and very, very good. A nice home made house dressing would have kicked things up. My husband had pasta with marinara sauce that was very good however he asked for Italian sausage and couldn't find any. In summary, this was a solid meal that could be even better with a few changes. The kitchen shows potential. Other customers ordered pizza and it looked GREAT! Waitress was adequate doing the best she could while being understaffed. read more