The best pizza period!!! I have been going here for pizza for over 40 years and have never been disappointed!! A individual brick oven pizza with extra cheese and mushrooms please!portinoy from Barstool should do a one bite review! Blow him away! read more

Everything was great from the pizza to the service! I'm a retired chef from Boston and I was traveling from Delaware were I trying to enjoy my retirement! I had the best pizza that I remember in the USA! Congratulazioni! read more

was in the area so we finally came here. soon as h walk in you feel like your in a tiny grandmothers home. . we ordered a wood burning margarita pizza. was cooked good but still soggy. wasn't bad. sauce is good. just soggy we shared a chicken parmigiana. comes with a piece of garlic bread. had to order side of pasta. the marinara is very good very old school. service ok. they give you tiny paper plates to use and cheapest napkins. prices are very reasonable read more

See all

Incredible pizza. Salad dressing was just a cheap bottle of oil and a bottle of red wine vinegar because the waitress didn't inform us of what that had to offer. So when my southern husband asked for oil and vinegar he didn't realize he was going to be conjuring up 1982. It was so incredibly loud in there that my teen son and I had to step outside to take a long break. The place is a time capsule to when it opened in the late 50's and it is certainly worth going to; but just know if you are rowdy go later and if you are quiet go very early. read more

See all

The ambience is very retro time machine back to better times Great friendly service The food was great read more

Martio's Pizza - spaghetti, meatballs, garlic bread - Pizza Near Me - Nanuet, New York

See all

I've been to a bunch of different pizza places throughout my life as my job involves a lot of traveling. These slices are exactly what I look for in a pizza. Definitely go here read more

Such a staple in these parts having been here for DECADES. Who doesn't like a brick oven pizza?!? It's a time capsule of family style pizza parlor that's just scrumptious. I do appreciate the Americana mom and pop vibe of the restaurant and the service. It gives such warm nostalgia while enjoying good pizza. read more

Martio's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nanuet, New York

The large pizza and the Sicilian are really good and the meatballs are surprisingly amazing. This became my favorite place. read more

See all

The last time I went to this local landmark was about 25 years ago. As a resident of Rockland for 40 years, Martio's was the go to Pizza spot. Simple decent island food. It's a local favorite but some of the dishes are close to fast food now. The pizza is still very good. Though it's not the same Martio's of the late 80s it's still Worth the visit to try out read more

Martio's Pizza - Counter - Pizza Near Me - Nanuet, New York

Back in the early 90s folk used to rave about this place. The lack of parking and the cutesy outside kept me away, plus there were excellent pizza places everywhere back then. Cut to this week when I tried them for take out. Large pie was fine, flavor and proportions of cheese to sauce to crust were fine, but not quite crispy enough. Antipasto was fresh and decent ingredients, but very much on the small side. With all the horrible pizza places around now, I will most likely be back... read more

we have been going to Martio's for over 30 years, and it only gets better and better... Terrific brick oven Pizza, great hero's and wonderful salads, the staff is terrific, Highly recommend Martio's... The Ambiance is A1, you want a nice lunch, or dinner, Martio's is the place..... read more

5$ for a pepperoni slice, manhattan prices. The taxes dont add up to what youre spending. The employees are nice, professional. read more

Martio's Pizza - 5$ pepperoni slice - Pizza Near Me - Nanuet, New York

i love pizza, yet its so hard to find a good slice. As i have lives in the area for a very long time I don't remember ever coming here. Today i stopped and ordered a slice and an eggplant parm platter and a glass of chainti.i love eggplant parm as much as i love pizza. The oizza was very very good. thin crust a nice balance of cheese and sauce and the bottom of the slice was cooked giving it a nice crunch. I would definitely come back for the pizza. my eggplant parm came out in a silver casserole dish with two nice size pieces of garlic bread. eggplant parm is tough to fet right, and this one was very close. Ive been to Italians restaurant that charge way more than double of what they charge here ($12.50), and they dont compare to how good Martios is. Ambiance, i dont think has changed i tne 67 years its been here. classic dark wood, tiffany like lamps old artifacts on the walls and a few neon signs. classic but nice. you step back in time. Service, waitress were excellent. very pleasant. Good food, good prices, great service, a glass of wine for $6.25, cant beat it read more

Been here many times but today disappointed. Order brick oven pizza it was a floppy jelopy should be crisp also ordered spaghetti and meatballs the meatballs were great but spaghetti made Al dente look like mush very very undercooked they are better maybe an off night. read more

Best eggplant parm hero in Rockland County. On toasted bread. It's so good. Cash business. Hard to park. But worth the ride. read more

Always a great pizza place, never fails and the ambience is amazing. The old world building is fantastic. Staff is always friendly and I always love their pizza as it is genuine, and consistent. read more

We just got a cheese pie and chicken Parm from here. The pizza was delicious and the chicken parm was good too. They had it ready in 15 min despite them being very busy which was great! read more

Pretty good pizza place I walk up to as a detour from my commute. Its a great place to distress or relax while only being a block away from the train station. When I come here I usually get the subs over the pizza simply because its just myself commuting from work. The subs are really nice though I would just the meatball parmigiana 9 out of 10 times. There is just something that "works" with a meatball over other choices. Besides the food I think what makes this a relaxing place is the theming. You got your neon signs, wall hangings and wooden furniture which makes this feel old timey yet distinctly Italian. I feel like this place could be in a Edward Hopper painting or something. read more

A masterpiece of a meal. Every detail was perfect--from greeting to goodbye. I'll definitely be back.

Great place! First time here and everything was delicious. It's a cozy little spot...kind of a throwback. Well worth the visit!

Maybe time has softened my recollection of the place but this hometown favorite still delivers the best tasting pizza that I've ever had. Their Neapolitan pie is amazing but it's their Sicilian with mushrooms and anchovies that cranks the dial on taste to "11" I've made far longer trips for far less reason and It still amazes me that with world-class pizza spinners so close, the corporate pizza chains still thrive - I suspect the convenience of delivery easily trumps authenticity. How unfortunate. Martio's is the real deal. read more

Excellent veal parmigiana Pizza is very good the staff is great not a long wait and very friendly I've been coming here since the 70s oh the calzones are still great read more

Aesthetic and vintage joint that seems to be operating their pizza restaurant out of what was an old school movie theatre. Their pizzas are made out of a fire oven that gets the crust nice and crispy. Each slice a little shy of $3 and was heated up quickly in a brick oven. Service was friendly and the business appeared to adhere to COVID guidelines wearing masks and providing sanitizer. This location looks like it would be a really cute date spot but for now, will settle on just taking a few slices to go. There are some parking spots on the street and it is easy to order ahead and just pick up. Pizza was really tasty, it had that char you look for when craving brick oven style pizza but was a little bland for my taste. read more

See all

So far...Best Pizza I've ever eaten!! So authentic & delicious. I burned the roof of my mouth eating it so fast. Great ambiance & nice service. read more

Martio's Pizza - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nanuet, New York

Interior: large, good for small and big groups. Dim lighting with great wood work embedded into the wall Brick oven pizza- We got this with pepperoni, sausage, and peppers. This came hot lightly burned around the edges ( this is how the brick oven pizza is suppose to be) the dough was soft with the perfect amount of each topping. Service: so fast! We were in and out within 20 minutes. They would always come in and check on us Unfortunately my camera was glitching when I took the picture of the pizza so it came out blurry and unclear. If I ever come back to New York I will definitely be coming back here. read more

Martio's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nanuet, New York

I brought my friend to Martio's Pizza for a small birthday outing on a Thursday night. Walking in, it has a nice, older charm to it. We were able to get a booth on the side of the restaurant and every other table was filled. Within the small space, what was about 30 people sounded like 80, but it only added to the atmosphere somehow. I was really excited to try their gluten-free pizza, so we put in our orders and opted for a glass of wine each. The pizzas came out and they looked absolutely delicious, perfectly cooked, and smelled heavenly. My gluten-free pizza was wonderful and I had to restrain myself from eating more of the slices than I should. I definitely have to recommend their gf pie and my friend said her regular crust was great, Martio's is a must, so grab a slice of happiness. read more

Martio's Pizza - Gluten free pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nanuet, New York

See all

What happened to Martio's, I ordered a wood oven pizza which was very good, I also ordered a sausage & pepper parmigiana hero, it came with two small sausages cut in half, it was like eating a pepper sandwich read more

Pizza was amazing. Not too expensive either. Can't comment on the service or ambience; picked up the order to go. read more

Martio's Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Nanuet, New York

Ok, went to high school in Nanuet NY, and had to take a final pizza tour. My parents are selling their house and moving to Florida. Today was the estate sale. Of course I stopped by. This is hands down, THE BEST pizza joint in Nanuet and possibly LoHud. Worth a train ride or drive from the tri-state area. Nothing has changed in decades and I am thrilled about that. Too many memories here which adds to my affinity for this establishment. Let's start with charred crust. And then pepperoni "cups" which curl up with sweet delicious dobs of oil. Nostalgia at every turn. Very well run business. I wish this place another 100 years of healthy business. read more

Martio's Pizza - Nom nom nom. If this doesn't look good to you, we can't be friends. - Pizza Near Me - Nanuet, New York

I saw the sign for wood fired pizza I walked in and saw a wood burning oven I was served a gas fired brick oven pizza. Dough was ok sauce was wayyyyy too sweet.Staff very friendly. Restaurant appeared clean and had some d school nostalgia. read more

First time they sent home the wrong hero sandwich I let it go as a one off. The second time they sent the wrong sandwich leads me to believe they must develop a better way to verify what is being picked up. Too many other good places that are not making same error. read more

Wonderful business, as someone from Florida this place is truly a gem. The restaurant itself is very clean and homey. The atmosphere is comfortable but not claustrophobic. I had the pleasure of speaking with the owners whom are beyond kind. The food came out very quickly and it was absolutely delicious. Thank you guys for such a pleasant experience. read more

Martio's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nanuet, New York

We have had some great food and drinks here at Martio's. They make delicious Pasta Fagioli which is served with amazing garlic bread. We love their cold combo sandwich. It's absolutely one of our "go to" orders whenever we visit Martio's. read more

Their Pasta Fagioli is Amazing and comes with garlic bread but, the pizza is average at best. My instincts told me, not a place for sandwiches. I gave it a shot anyway and was brutally disappointed! (Pics). I ordered a Peppers and Eggs hero and I got a hero with a little bit of peppers and BURNT eggs. The cook, really didn't put any love into it. read more

Martio's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nanuet, New York

See all

The premier pie in Rockland County and in the same class as any elite pizzeria in Manhattan or Brooklyn. The undercarriage is a true treat. The pie is always cooked to well done. Piping hot when you eat inside, it cannot be matched. I'm on year 35 of eating Martios'. Thank the good lord baby Jesus for its existence every time! When you're done, treat yourself to a chocolate Italian ice. Game changer!!! read more

Martio's Pizza - Half Plain half pepperoni cups!! Marvelous! - Pizza Near Me - Nanuet, New York

One of the best pizza places, best pasta I ever had anywhere We come from Florida in the summer and can't wait to eat there love love love read more

I grew up on Martio's Pizza. The nostalgia is as delicious as their pizza, the family have managed to maintain their own pizza identity and continue to supply the people with what they do best. I haven't lived in Nanuet for several decades now, but it still is one of the deepest core memories for me growing up. The big wood filled room, eating pizza or splitting a bowl of pasta fagioli ... whenever I'm nearby I make sure to stop. Every time someone I know mentions that they're are headed in that area, I always point them to Martio's, no one has left unsatisfied yet. read more

Had the chicken parm hero. Very good! The pizza always hits the spot. Love the decor.

Service was good and the calzone I ordered was tasty. Crusty on the outside and creamy on the inside with riccotta, mozzarella and mushrooms. The accompanying sauce was perfect for allowing the calzone to shine. The ambiance is rustic and charming. read more

Very good pizza, arguably the best around, BUT..... the service is horrible. Waitresses are young, inexperienced and untrained. Waited almost 15 minutes after being seated with menus for someone to take our order. We kept looking over at the 'bar' area where we saw two of the young waitresses busily tapping text messages on their phones. This should not be permitted during working hours when the place is busy. I don't blame the young women, I blame the owners for not training them properly at this service oriented business. They're quick to clear a table but never look around to see if another patron needs anything. I hope another pizza parlor learns how to make a pizza as good as Martio's so we can say 'ciao' to this establishment. read more