This place never fails. The lines can be intimidating during the summer, but there's a really fast turnover so be patient and you can grab a parking spot to get some of the best cones and soft serve ice cream in the area. Area. There's also hot food over there which I've never tried, but maybe next time. They do have a walk-up freezer that has key lime soft serve which was fantastic. The service is always super efficient and all around great vibes around the area with all the families and kids enjoying some great ice cream. read more

Mary Jane's Dairy Bar - It's been awhile since I've been here, but they've done the update since someone crashed into the building - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Mary Jane's is the best! I moved to the area in 1998, the ice cream is delicious! The ice cream cakes were a must on my daughter's birthdays. Sometimes the lines are long, but it's worth the wait. The staff are friendly and very efficient. They have a great variety of delicious treats on the menu. If you're an ice cream lover, this is the place for you! read more

Went last weekend ice cream still as good as we remember after 2 years. Staff is nice and very friendly

Finally got try here for a change, since I drive by a lot with work and it's always packed no time to try. Wish they kept the physical menu board like I saw old pics rather than a QR code. To their credit they have a lot of flavors here both basics and creatively interesting, only my local place closer to me is only similar case of trying to go outside the box. My sundae was amazing and all the extra topping on it was great. Service itself was pretty fast and my wait was a lot less then pictured read more

Mary Jane's Dairy Bar - New remodel - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newburgh, New York

See all

Ice cream was...OK. It's really hard to mess up ice cream and they don't exactly mess it up, but it is not extraordinary. The quality of ice cream is lower than I would come to expect from a homemade ice cream, and the sugar cone was terrible. :( read more

Caramel Cookie Dough flavor is good, might come back there also they have so many food varieties. read more

Mary Jane's Dairy Bar - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Just paid $25 for 2 take home containers, probably quarts. Thought that was a bit much. A bit crazy. No more of that.

Got the Oreo ice cream and it just blew my mouth right off from how good it was and don't even get me started on the Smurf flavor

After the renovations, Mary Jane's is back and better than ever! I just tried some of their amazing Salted Pretzel ice cream and had great service and window art too. Definitely check it out if you haven't already! read more

Mary Jane's Dairy Bar - Salted Pretzel ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newburgh, New York

please get competent help !! and why serve hotdogs in stale rolls and hand people melted ice cream cones with a cup ? this new owner clearly didn't take direction from the previous owner idk how they remain open !! Not to mention the couter people do not know how to work a credit card unless it's a chip card !! read more

I think the best way to describe Mary Jane's is "small town soft serve." My friend overhyped this as "the best soft serve in the entire country" and I think that led to a somewhat disappointing result. Don't get me wrong, the soft serve is good. They make the soft serve with a 10% butterfat mix produced in New York State. This probably contributes to the creamy/fresh taste of the ice cream. That being said, when you smother it with rainbow sprinkles, it just tastes like above-average soft serve. Prices are low - It's about $2 for a small and they give you a nice portion size. But it's kind of off the side of the highway and I wouldn't drive more than 30 minutes out of my way for it. read more

See all

Stopped here on a whim and there was a fairly lengthy line, even for a chilly evening at the end of September. They have a dizzying array of options (homemade hard ice cream, smoothies, cakes, etc.) but my kiddos were only interested in soft serve. A little close to the road so I would keep a tight grip on your toddlers, but they've got some outdoor seating and we got our ice cream wicked fast. read more

Mary Jane's Dairy Bar - Soft serve! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newburgh, New York

There's a menu on the window at Mary Jane's. It says that their onion rings cost $5.99. However, I was charged $7.27. I asked to speak to the manager, but the manager wasn't there. I don't think that this is a good business practice. By the way, $7.27 is way too much money for six and a half onion rings. I would not recommend this place! read more

Mary janes is the spot!! Their soft serve is delicious, and if you're not in the mood for ice cream they also have hot dogs and stuff. I live super close so im sure i'll be a regular! read more

Mary Jane's Dairy Bar - a golden retriever drinking milk - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Overall great food and great service. Hannah helped me decided on what order and I settled on a blender bender with m&ms and delicious cheese burger. read more

Stopped by after doing the Hudson Walkway with my husband, it was such a nice treat for the ride home! I got the pumpkin pie blender bender and it was delicious! Perfect for a fall day! read more

Mary Jane's Dairy Bar - Walk up, order, enjoy! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newburgh, New York

See all

Best ice cream in the area! There's always a lot of help so the lines move pretty fast. Plenty of parking.

Really good ice cream place, came by after coming back from Weed Orchards. Not packed, seems to have a more local vibe which is great, and they have seasonal ice creams like pumpkin and apple pie flavor which were great - creamy and flavorful but not oversweet. And probably my favorite aspect about this place is they give you nice big portions. Definitely will come back when in the area. read more

Great - so slow it's weird - the kids working avoid helping or coming to window, or mt stop Alavoid working. But product good and only horse in town. read more

I stopped by after a day trip to Catskill. I got a blender (chocolate) with Reese's cups. It was ok. Soft serve wasn't that good, so it made the whole thing kinda meh for me. I now wish I had just tried the ice cream, maybe that is better? Very cute, retro place though with fast service right off the main road. read more

Decided to try the food from this location. I ordered a chicken sandwich with lettuce tomatoes and onion and receive a chicken tender sandwich with no lettuce no tomato and I don't know what the hell this is called onions it looks like little Pieces of something. Once I decided to eat sandwich half the bun fell apart part soggy wet and for $12 this was not worth it's worth the sandwich or The Onion rings that I ordered as well I got 4 pieces of onion rings . Their ice cream used to be good but has declined within the last couple of years I choose not to come here again to eat or to get ice cream but they have plenty of customers and they don't need me. But it only takes one person to write a review for another person not to go or not a bad experience for another person I'm pretty soon they're not gonna have alarm a large Clientel. One last thing she didn't went to KFC... read more

We saw this place on the way to a nearby orchard. We had to make a mental note to check it out on Yelp as soon as we could get service and consider going there after our time at the orchard. It really doesn't take much to convince me to get some ice cream (especially soft serve). I really love local ice cream spots and supporting small businesses. I got vanilla chocolate swirl soft serve in a cone with peanut butter dip shell (because I went during the fall, I unfortunately cannot remember the price but I think it was between $3-4 including the dip). I was excited that there was a peanut butter shell option because usually isn't many option for the flavor of dip, but they had 4-5 options, from my memory, which include: chocolate, peanut butter, a red one which I think is cherry and a blue one which I think is blue raspberry. I can only vouch for the peanut butter dip and I really enjoyed it with my ice cream. It really doesn't have a strong flavor, but if you're craving a dipped cone and love peanut butter I would consider trying the peanut butter dipped cone. I really cannot complain about any type of soft serve in general and I also really enjoyed the soft serve here as well. I can't say that it's the creamiest or most delicious soft serve that I have ever had, but it is a solid choice to curb your cravings! It was creamy and soft and not icy at all. We also had an order of french fries and although they did take a longer to get, but it was also worth the wait. It was thicker cut fries, freshly fried (although the oil that it was fried in tasted a little old) and nicely salted. It was very crispy and a good complement to cold creamy soft serve. The person who took our order was very friendly and made sure to check in on us to let us know that our fries would take a little longer. All in all, I would definitely love to start a tradition of going here after hitting up the orchard. read more

Mary Jane's Dairy Bar - Vanilla and Chocolate swirl soft served dipped in peanut butter shell- healthy serving and tasty ice cream! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Stopped by today for the first time. There was a long line, but it didn't take very long to be waited on; apparently it's a popular place. I had a waffle cone with black raspberry and pistachio ice cream. I'm not a connoisseur by any means, but this is the best ice cream I've ever had. The black raspberry had actual raspberries in it, and it should come as no surprise the pistachio also had real pistachios. both were exceptional as well as the cone Itself. Ice cream places always brag about hone made ice cream but this is the real deal. I don't remember what I paid, but it doesn't matter because I'm sure I've been charged more for inferior goods or services and this was certainly not one of those occasions. FIVE STARS! Dan M read more

My family and I went here last weekend as it was their last Saturday open before closing for winter. As usual, the experiences was great. It was super clean, the servers were super helpful and polite and their products are super fresh. And...the variety of offerings is astounding. Between the four of us we had a Walnut Sundae (with velvety vanilla soft serve, wet nuts, whipped cream and a cherry; a Marshmallow Sundae with Toasted a Coconut; a slice of frozen Cheesecake on a stick dipped in chocolate and a cup of home made Apple Pie ice cream. All were out of this world. Almost forgot to mention they have a huge selection of fresh made burgers, fries, shrimp or clam boats, chili dogs....you name it. Since this was our last trip here for the season we started with fresh, hot fries. Delicious!!!......(As Always) Don't miss this place if you are visiting the Hudson Valley. My goal for next season is to sample each one of their numerous favors of home made ice cream. Somebody's gotta' do it. read more

Eden and jillian are the best employees mary janes has ever seen. I have been. owing here my entire life and it's only gotten better! Ms. Meg is the best owner ever! Definitely come here!!!!- read more

Mary Jane's Dairy Bar - Eden one of the workers - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Really great ice cream. I came here on a recommendation from a friend and I'm so glad I did. The service was great with a smile and was very fast. Only thing is the only have one flavor that's sugar free and they were out of it. Like you have only one and it was gone. I was upset with that but overall a great place for ice cream. read more

Service is always amazing and I love when they tell me about new flavors #kahlua almond chocolate

This ice cream cake was amazing for my 30th Birthday! From the look to the taste, I couldn't be happier with the outcome. With real cake on the bottom and cookie crunch mixture in the middle, the taste was so good. This was by far the best ice cream I have ever had!! read more

Mary Jane's Dairy Bar - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Best around. We usually get root beer floats or sundaes. Always a great experience!

In all the years I lived in this area I never knew it existed until recently. I only learned about it when looking up ice cream on Yelp and this place came up in the search. I had the cookie monster ice cream and wow was that great! Hubby had a large blue raspberry dipped cone and it was huge and delicious. Admittedly they had so much to choose from that I stared at the menu for a bit. I really want to go back to try some of their other flavors and some of their food items also. I appreciate when a place has stuff out of the ordinary and this place didn't disappoint. read more

I used to visit Mary Jane's more frequently in years past, when I had friends living locally. It was a treat to return, and I had forgotten just how good their hard ice cream is (though I also am very fond of their milkshakes). I think the price you pay is a bit higher than average (I paid $4.53 for a medium cone), but the amount of ice cream you get for that makes it worthwhile. And the hard ice cream remains creamy without being mushy. Their soft-serve is also quite good and popular, and I believe a bit less expensive, with lots of toppings. As far as their food, I can't see why you'd want to go to an equivalent chain for items prepared "the chain way," when you have options just as good and fresh here. read more

Great ice cream ! Quick service even when busy! Food is always hot & ready. They have all types of different flavors. Good location and sitting area outside. read more

First time here and I can't believe I've lived in the Hudson valley so long without having one of the greatest brownies sundays in the state. They have the over the top cookie shake and unicorn freak shake that bit taste great and are visually awesome. I love weirs but my mother loves more than one grandkid so I now love more than one ice cream spot. Creamiest soft serve I've ever had. You'd swear it was the best you've ever had and you'd be right. read more

Salted Carmel salted pretzel ice cream is my favorite and they even have puppy cones! The burgers and cheese fries are great as well however they are run by a bunch of teenagers who need summer jobs and they do get super busy. A little bit of patience goes a long way when ordering here read more

I honestly have to say, After seeing what the city had to offer, I had high expectations for the rest of New York. Trying to settle in to this area hasn't been easy when every place that is recommended to me hasn't really met my expectations. Mary Jane's is right off one of the main roads, they have a few little outside benches to enjoy your ice cream on a hot summer day. They have what is called down here "hard" ice cream and a soft serve. I purchased the "hard" which I am assuming is just the term they use because they scoop it out of a container instead of it coming from a machine. so the texture is a bit different. but I purchased Cherry Vanilla and Rum Raisin... I have to say they were just O K, I didn't find it to be anything special and they seemed to be missing something. for example Id but a spoon full in my mouth and it was full of flavor but then the next spoon full wasn't so flavorful almost as if the ice cream wasn't mixed well. i don't know, i guess I can try again.... read more

Delicious homemade ice cream. Raspberry is my favorite because it has raspberries in it! Go before they close for the season!

Great ice cream stand good location also have burgers hot dogs etc. Prices are a bit steep compared to years ago but it's still a great value and worth the stop. read more

I grew up going here all the time..one of my family's favorites as a kid. So, its a huge disappointment now that new owners have completely ruined this place for us. After multiple order screw ups, there has never been an offer to rectify the situation, or even an attempt at a sincere apology. Last mistake, before today, was only about a month ago. We were approached with an accusatory and very defensive women (the owner), who refused to take responsibility for her errors. At that point, we insisted on receiving a free 8 in. cake for a future order. Today, we were told not to place orders with them anymore after once again having an issue with the owner. We placed an order for 2 cake rolls a week ago and were told we could pick them up as early as 10 am, before they open at 11. We showed up today around 12 to bring them to a party, only to be informed that the owner had not made it in to make the cakes and they would not be ready for another 2 hrs! The server was very polite and informed us that this happens ALL OF THE TIME! She lives in the back of the parking lot sooo, I'm not sure why it should be a problem to simply walk over and fill the orders in a timely manner. People tend to place such orders for events. The orders not being prepared at agreed upon time of pick-up, therefore, causes an issue! So, rather than apologizing and gladly giving us the order for free, we were told that she was offended that we did not like the cake she had made for us a month prior (it was lovely, if it was the cake that we had actually ordered!) and now had an issue with them again (yes! our order was not even made!) so she gave us the 2 sloppily prepared, badly cracked, cakes at no cost, telling us that was in replacement of the originally promised 8 in. cake. And to top it off, we are no longer welcomed to place any further orders with them! Who runs a business like that! Sad, but we will gladly no longer be giving them any of our business after 35+ years. Horrible. read more

Mary Jane's Dairy Bar - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Been here a few times but have to give a thumbs down to the Cookie Monster freak cup thing. $8 for a scoop of ice cream and marshmallow with a cookie crunch you can't eat? Waste of $. Stick to normal stuff. read more

This place is your typical, roadside ice cream and burgers/fries joint. My husband and I stopped here with our daughter in August 2015, and got some small twist soft serve, chili cheese hot dogs and fries. The entire meal was pretty good and I have no complaints about that - the wait was pretty long but unless you want old, stale fries and food, you have to live with them making the food fresh (and a long wait time). I've heard their cakes and such are delicious - just wish they have a better seating area away from the road. read more