Service with a Huge smile. FOOD- I scream and frozen treats only The creaminess of this soft serve is magnificent ~ just the right balance of custardy goodness and cocoa goodness. The ambiance is so nostalgic- stand a one of several swiftly moving lines-just enough time to reside between your flavor and size, TIP: small is three circles around the cone, medium is five and a large is seven. It's a whopper that could feed a family of four. And there is the kiddy size. Nondairy options are limited, but available read more

See all

Sooooo gooood! Super creamy delicious flavors. Generous and not overpriced like "CSC" ;) read more

Twistee Cone - Black Raspberry and Honey Lavender - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

The menu options are endless and hard to make a decision! I got the key lime pie flavor, which is tasted exactly like key lime pie and its tartness. The lavender honey flavor tasted great too. read more

Twistee Cone - Key lime pie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Paltz, New York

Twistee Cone is an ice cream stand with a few picnic tables to the side. They serve mostly soft serve ice cream but also has hard ice cream and milkshakes. They are open in the evening. Be warned, they are very popular. I went on a Thursday evening and there was constantly a line. I probably waited a good 15-20 minutes. The ice cream is delicious though and comes in different sizes. I had a large vanilla cone which tastes very rich, like Mister Softee ice cream. The large is huge! My fiancé had a mix of vanilla and coffee. I didn't expect much from the coffee flavor, but it was very good as well. Tastes just like coffee. The line was worth it. Definitely recommend! read more

Twistee Cone - Large cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Paltz, New York

So efficient and love a good ole fashion ice cream place! The gals were so attentive and worked fast. Price was very fair for what we got. They do have seating if you want to stay and eat your ice cream outside. read more

We took a walk tonight after eating too much at dinner and ironically ended up at this ice cream spot. I ordered the classic vanilla & chocolate soft serve swirl with rainbow sprinkles size small. The menu was nice with hard and soft ice cream, and Italian ice. The ice cream was thick and creamy and for that I'd give it 4 stars but it was the smallest small I may have ever seen... which was perfect as I was full from dinner but worth mentioning. The toppings good however were a bit skimpy compared to the ice cream shop I usually go to. I'd like to go back to try something else on the menu but I wouldn't get the small soft serve again. I will add that the girl at the window was so helpful and kind. read more

Twistee Cone - Small soft serve vanilla & chocolate twirl - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

Super delicious ice cream, and loads of different options. Be weary when ordering a medium soft serve cone.. it is actually gigantic! I am a lover of all ice cream and could potentially live off of it daily, but the last time I ordered a medium cone I had to bring half home with me. I am in no way mad about this as I had a nice dessert for the next day, but DANG I have never NOT finished ice cream, even after a huge meal. Great job twistee cone! read more

Im secretly making it my life's mission to find the best soft serve in New York! Super cute summer joint with picnic tables and beautiful flowers. Homemade hard ice cream and Italian ices. They have soft serve too. read more

Twistee Cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Paltz, New York

Super friendly staff! I had a marshmallow sundae and really enjoyed it. My friend had two scoops cookies and cream with caramel sauce and said it was super filling and he liked it. read more

Twistee Cone - Marshmallow sundae- so filling I should have gotten the small! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

It is so good!! My friend tried this place once when she visited new Paltz and she loved it. So we came again this time. I got a speciality sundae - s'mores. My fiends got Cookie Monster, mint chip and chocolate brownies and they loved those flavors as well. read more

Twistee Cone - S'mores sundae (it comes with whipped cream, cherry and sprinkles by default. I told them to only keep whipped cream$ - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Paltz, New York

If vegan don't go here. Though they have one or two vegan options, the staff is inconsistently aware of what is vegan and will sell you cows milk based ice cream and say it is vegan. This comes from unfortunate direct experience. read more

Lavender Honey, Pepper Mango, Huckleberry and Key Lime Pie?! How could you not love a place with ice cream flavors like these?! Nicest people, HUGE sizes so buy accordingly. Unfortunately this is a seasonal business, so get there between April and Sept. Wait on the line. It's worth it. read more

finally tried here after passing it a lot driving. like how its in a quite little niche on the side of the road. first thing I noticed the prices were very fair and well worth the price, plus a lot of selection. I ordered a smore large sundae, the girl behind the counter took my order politely and served me very quickly. fresh crushed graham crackers, warm chocolate fudge, with soft served vanilla. it was a great sugar fix. would like to try the other flavor sundaes and their milkshakes. plus first time I ever seen a ice cream place have ice cream treats for dogs. read more

See all

SorryYou didn't like my review but I think it's pretty unprofessional to verbally attack somebody/customer because you don't like their review.And I wasn't trying to get anything free I paid and then you're bringing up all this other stuff I did not park in the handicap parking I parked next to it nice try and you have to much time on your hands to write back a big huge long long text that's obviously public! You're trying to make me seem like a horrible person over a review wow feelings hurt a little too much LOL read more

That vegan soft serve vanilla was so good, thank you so much for having it, and the girl who served it was a lovely human as well, ice cream went all the way to the bottom of the cone as it should, way to be, thank you! read more

Twistee Cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

Delicious milk shakes that you can customize and wonderful homemade ice cream! I love that they have more than just the basic soft serve flavors. When we went the person serving couldn't have been more friendly. Love this place and highly recommend. read more

It's 2018. Time to accept debit and credit. I have driven past here a million times and decided to finally stop in and try it. The place is ALWAYS deserted and now I know why. THEY ONLY TAKE CASH, so be aware BEFORE you order!! In a town with thousands of college kids and tourists, this joint is losing revenue. The cash only sign is very, very tiny. Also, the guy behind the counter was a little snippy when asked if they only took cash. Disappointed and will not be back. read more

A good flavor selection of hard ice cream!! I really liked the lavender honey and key lime pie flavors

I have NO IDEA how someone can give this place 1 star!! if I could give it 10, I would! So what, they only take cash. Many local places only take cash. There is an ATM 5 steps from where you order. It doesn't get any more convenient than that! I have yet to taste anything there I don't like. The homemade ice cream is the best around. And the Italian ice is SO GOOD!!! The seating area is always clean. It's always pretty busy but they are like a well oiled machine there so the line goes pretty quick! I'm SO happy Twistee Cone calls New Paltz home because they really are the best in the Hudson Valley!! read more

Almost didn't stop for Twistee Cone because of the bad rating - had f read the reviews. Yes, I get they don't take credit cards, but my goodness is their ice cream delicious! We had soft serve with dips that took us back to childhood! Generous portions. Quality ice cream. Excellent - friendly & organized service! read more