I admit, I stop here anytime I'm going up 17. The diner next door is great, and you can see that…read morereview. But the Twin Cone wins for the best ice cream place I've had roadside like this. Quality ice cream and even the small is massive. Excellent service and very nice folks. I've waited in line maybe 5 minutes but it's so nice outside I do not mind. Now, they took maple walnut off the menu. I always get that when I see it, since it's harder to find. Well now it's harder. Guess I need to go to Stewart's for it (iykyk). But I like Twin Cone so much, I can't even hold that against them. I'll get coffee Oreo instead. Goddess help me. Delicious.

One of the best, easy access, accessible parking seasonal ice cream shop. Well run shop with many…read morefriendly employees. Delicious ice cream with great servings. Multiple flavors available in hard and soft serve. Enjoyed by multi generations. Portions commensurate with price. One drawback is no indoor bathroom but they have portapotties. Great for after shopping or going out to eat as they're very close to Middletown off rt17

Good place to stop by and Pick up anything you may need. We…read morewere able to get firewood, and a fire starter and some toiletries we had forgotten. Clean and also quick service.

One of Zach's favorite places to go! I finally got to go too- they've got literally everything from…read moreice cream, to homemade snacks and to grocery goods. I got some non dairy mint chip ice cream was SO good- plus it's local from Saratoga. If your in the area I highly recommend it! 10/10

Great breakfast. Little luncheonette and ice cream establishment. Good eggs and bacon . . Nice…read moreservice. Beautiful ambiance with clean restroom.

What a beautiful place to have lunch with friends. The cozy atmosphere and feeling like home was…read moreexactly what we were looking for. To top it off our server, Logan, was the sweetest and really full of heart. I had the chicken sandwich which was excellent and the non-dairy ice cream was a treat. I'll be back for sure. Thanks, Hungry Goat!

Very clean and neat with plenty of indoor seating ice cream shop. I give a lot of credit to the…read moreworker here, since after I came in for ice cream, all the other customers came in talking on there cell phones rather than actually ordering and she was very patient and polite with them, despite all rude indecisive people walking in making her wait to serve them. This place also out of all ice cream places in Middletown has the largest and best selection for if you dairy ice cream or sorbet. I had cannoli ice cream it was good , but white chocolate raspberry Rocky Mountain ice cream was amazing, definitely never seen before and would recommend easily.

Why have I not found this place sooner! Wow! Upon walking in we were greeted by the two female…read morestaff who were so sweet. I got the banana ice cream which was DELICIOUS!!! We also got a soft serve vanilla ice cream which was also just as good. They are so generous with their portions. I would much rather give my business to a place like this as opposed to a commercial ice cream location. I will definitely be back soon and a plus is that they are open all year round! They accept cash/card and plenty of parking outside in their lot. Very cute decor and ambiance inside as well!

This was kind of an odd-ish experience in an odd-ish kind of place. Monticello seems like it has…read moreseen better days, and definitely has a very unique combination of inhabitants. We ended up here for a post-dinner treat, and it was quite busy. There is little to no room inside the place, so you're constantly trying to squeeze and shuffle around as the whole ordering process is a complete human free-for-all. We ended up with a gentleman who greeted us by saying "this is my first time working in three years!" Well OK then! He managed to get one of us a malted and vanilla twist soft serve on a cone, but the malted didn't really taste like anything other than an unpronounced chocolate flavor. The other one of us got a Snickers sundae that was so massive and just completely overtopped with Snickers pieces and fudge. Like, we're not complaining--all too happy to consume these thousands of calories!--but it was a bit of a wild mess. Kind of a surreal experience, but we're not necessarily mad about it and would probably even come back if we were ever in the area again. Be prepared to wait and to have a furrowed brow if you go.

Recently visited on our vacation and this place was cute and had so many options. The staff which…read morewas two young ladies were very nice and had great customer service. If we were visiting again I would definitely stop by a get another sweet treat.

I'm not a fan of strawberry Jam on my ice cream. I ordered a Sunday with strawberry syrup…read more Strawberry syrup usually is a watery-like substance filled with crushed strawberries. It's not an overly sweetened jam-like substance likened to that you would put in the middle of a sheet-cake. I was very unhappy when my husband brought that home to me. It def ruined it for me! I'll stick with ice cream shop at exit 116 in Wurtsboro next to Teek and Vee's. But they only take cash- so keep that in mind if you choose to go to that one.

From the owner: Great specialty sandwiches and Barbeque brisket, chicken, ribs and more!read more

This is actually my first time here. A home away from home it feel very cozy being here and very…read morerelaxing. I loved how they had a maple syrup section where you can try all of them. They were a bit water downed tasting. I got the grilled cheese and I didnt know that I could had asked for a side salad I would've had gotten that instead. I also tried the waffles they were okay they were a bit bland. Other then that I would highly recommend coming here and checking them out.

Very cozy and away from dusty city streets and noise. They make good espresso drinks and their menu…read morejust started getting more interesting. There is nice outdoor seating , which allows you to relax and enjoy rich outside greenery.

We stopped in on a Monday night after finding this place on yelp and reading the reviews. The…read morecommon review is the price compared to the amount of ice cream you get or don't get, which we found to be true. Overall, the ice cream was good but nothing that blew our socks off. Also, the kid behind the counter just looked like he hated his job.

Gave this place 3 stars because the ice cream is good portions are below average and big upcharge…read morefor toppings we ordered 3 large cups one with sprinkles only one with hot fudge and dry walnuts and whipped cream and another with one topping it came out to 37.00 a bit pricey ... don't think we will be returning

Bellvale Farms Creamery is one of those places that instantly reminds you why simple summer…read moretraditions never get old. We came here for a refreshing treat on a cool Sunday evening, and it absolutely did not disappoint. Luckily, the weather kept the crowds manageable -- busy, but nowhere near the chaos of a hot summer afternoon. Nestled in the mountains of Warwick, NY, this creamery has such a charming, peaceful vibe. I first discovered it a few years ago after taking my nephew apple picking nearby, so I was excited to finally make my way back. The scenic drive alone is worth it. On this visit, they were serving customers inside only, but during peak summer days they also open the walk-up windows, which seems like a smart system for handling bigger crowds. Inside, the L-shaped counter setup helps keep the line moving efficiently even when there are multiple groups waiting. One thing I truly appreciated as someone with a gluten allergy was how clearly they labeled the gluten-free flavors on the menu. It made ordering stress-free and saved me from having to ask a million questions. Honestly, I wish every ice cream shop did this. Another huge bonus: they allow two flavors in a small size! I ordered the Great White Way and Calf Trax with rainbow sprinkles, and both flavors were absolutely delicious. After grabbing your ice cream, there are picnic tables outside overlooking breathtaking mountain views. It's the kind of place where you could easily sit for hours, relax, and just take in the scenery while enjoying your cone. The staff was friendly, parking was plentiful (always appreciated), and the overall experience was exactly what I hoped for. Bellvale Farms Creamery continues to live up to the hype, and I already can't wait to go back.

I ended up at Bellvale Farms Creamery after accidentally crashing my friend's bachelorette weekend,…read morewhich honestly feels very on brand for me. I had never been here before, so I went in completely blind, but the second I got out of the car, I understood why people come here. First of all: parking on BOTH sides of the street. Say less. Nothing ruins a cute little ice cream trip faster than circling for parking while your will to live slowly leaves your body. Then there's the smell. The scent wafting through the air should honestly be studied because it had me floating toward the building like a cartoon character following a pie cooling on a windowsill. I'm not saying the aroma dragged me in against my will...but I'm also not *not* saying that. Inside, the shop is set up in an "L" shape, and they have the flavors posted both outside AND inside, which I deeply appreciated because nobody needs the chaos of 14 people trying to read one tiny menu while pretending they're ready to order. They let you sample flavors before committing, which is dangerous for someone like me because suddenly I become an ice cream sommelier. I ended up getting Bellvale Bog and Calf Trax and let me tell you: absolutely worth it. 10/10. No notes. And somehow it gets even better once you walk back outside because there are picnic tables with a view that is genuinely stunning. Like, annoyingly picturesque. The kind of view that makes you stop mid-bite and rethink your life choices. For a completely spontaneous stop, this ended up being one of the highlights of the day. I will absolutely be back, and this time intentionally.