Omg. What a find. A little shop in a strip mall. We were walking to another store when we saw people carrying out HUGE cookies. We knew what our next stop would have to be. The aroma was wonderful as was the greeting. The owner had no problem walking us through all the choices. Turns out just limiting ourselves to one each was tough. I won't say what we got for we feel there would have been no bad choice. And as predicted the cookies only make it a few miles down the road. read more

The cookies are good and I've been paying significantly less than the regular price because they give me a two dollar coupon every time I go in so I pay around 30% less than the regular price every time. I'm not sure if that works out for them mathematically if they're actually making a profit selling me a cookie and a drink for four bucks and change. The indoor seating is nice. read more

Friendly. Unfortunately the cookies taste like dust and crisco. No flavor. Get the chocolate chip or the "Reese's" cookie. Close your eyes, take a bite. You won't taste any chocolate. It tastes like crisco. I had high hopes for this. Sorry, 3 "gourmet" cookies for $12 and they stink doesn't work for me. I'll consider the $12 a donation to their retirement. read more

I've gone twice now. The first time I got a blueberry cookie which was good! Definitely a unique flavor and reminded me of a blueberry scone. Then tonight I split a chocolate chip cookie and a brownie with my husband. The chocolate chip cookie was good, but nothing outstanding. Like you could get some nestle dough, and make chocolate chip cookies at home and those would suffice. The brownie was just not my favorite. It was just a more cakey brownie, and I prefer a gooey brownie. I'm giving it 4 stars because -based on my first experience I would have given 5 stars. -based on my second experience I'd give it 3. I don't know if I'll try it out again. read more

Their "8 cookies for the price of 6" deal is hard to pass up! My husband agonizes over flavor choices, and the staff member who helped us was happy to explain each and every cookie in the shop. We bought a lot, and not a single one disappointed. I especially loved the Orange Doodle, which they don't always offer, and that there are small and large sizes, as well as cream filled options. We didn't try it, but they also offer an edible cookie dough (with a proprietary super secret ingredient instead of eggs). Next time! read more

Colorado is doing and exceptional job at keeping safe. While on a girls trips we stopped at Mary's for something sweet. I had the chocolate chip cookie & fudge caramel chunk sandwich, girl 2 had 2 scoops of mint chocolate chip on a waffle cone, and girl 3 had a sandwich with snickerdoodle cookie - AMAZING! The staff was very friendly and doing their very best staying safe! If you're in the area, stop here! Thank you, 3rd Coast Girls read more

Mary's Mountain Cookies - Ice cream and cookies! - Bakeries Near Me - Loveland, Colorado

Like their cookies better than Crumbl. The oatmeal raisin is my favorite. However, almost all of their cookies are very tasty.

This place is perfect for a delicious treat, their cookies are quite large for a great price. Staff is friendly and place is clean! Not to mention it smells heavenly when you walk in! read more

I love cookies and I've tried Mary's a couple of times and they cookies are just ok. I think for $2.75 a cookie, the cookie needs to be amazing, which unfortunately they are not. I tried again yesterday, but again I left disappointed. I'll get my cookies at Eileen's in Greeley exclusively from now on. read more

We reached out to Mary's Mountain Cookies as our dessert vendor for our February wedding and had a great experience working with Robert and Bev (the owners). They were very personable and friendly and their cookies were amazingly delicious. They worked with us to meet our creative needs and delivered quality. We would highly recommend Mary's Mountain Cookies at Centerra to anyone looking to host a large gathering (conference, weddings, events, etc...) or just to pop in for a quick sweet snack! read more

This place is great only reason for low rating is because there is only 8 reviews. Cookies are great place is clean don't be shy you will like this place for a good dessert. read more

I wish they would bake their cookies more. I've gotten sick a few times from them. And they do seem awfully raw. I've tried several kinds as well and all seem to have the same raw factor and effect. read more

These cookies are large and in charge of my tummy now. So good tasty and moist. I would come back time and time again to taste all the cookies. YUMMMM read more

I love the cookies here! And the customer service at this location id say is the best out of all there locations. I recommend the s'mores cookie and the almond glaze cookie they're both amazing! But all the cookies a great! I recommend this place and it's really cheap for great cookies!!! read more

Best cookies and friendly staff! The only reason I gave it a 4 is because the selection seems to be a bit less than the main one in downtown FoCo. read more

These cookies are quite expensive and don't have a lot of flavor. We got a chocolate chip and a snickerdoodle. The chocolate chip didn't taste like anything. How can you mess up a chocolate chip cookie? The snickerdoodle was OK, but not great. Drive north to Fort Collins or East to Greeley for Eileen's Colossal cookies. Much better flavor and value. read more

I am certainly not disappointed with the delicious cookies! Yummo! I was so excited to learn that Mary's Mountain Cookies had a Loveland location, as I have been a big fan since my first bite of their amazing cookies and brownies. I have since bought a few dozen cookies for my Veterinarian after my pup had surgery, my post natal nurse team after having my first baby, and even my little brothers classroom. Needless to say, I wanted to spread the word on how tasty these treats are. My only complaint is that I nearly paid $50 for a dozen cookies to later find out that each of the 3 times that I ordered in bulk I could have been gifted 4 additional cookies FREE with the buy 6 get 2 free program. I am so bummed to have missed out on that and questioned why the staff never offered that to me. I will obviously speak up next time I order larger quantities, since each cookie is nearly $3 and I would love to enjoy one while gifting others at the same time. Bottom line...these cookies are spendy but delicious! read more

I needed to send some sweets to a client and the order needed to be delivered the next day. All the online sources were charging a fortune for the one day turnaround so I knew I had to find someone local to get the job done. Robert at the Loveland location of Mary's Mountain Cookies provided the best customer service! Not only was he patient with the order taking, and dictation of the message to accompany the order, he will be personally delivering the order! AND if that isn't enough: the cookies will be baked fresh for the order. I could not have asked for a better deal or experience. Thank you! read more

Tried for the first time today. The salted caramel cookies were nearly raw. Very disappointed since we spent $22 for 6 cookies.

Some of my friends were visiting family at the Medical Center of the Rockies. I asked Mary's Mountain Cookies to send over some cookies to the waiting room as a pick me up for everyone. They were extremely helpful (I think I had to call them 6 times to coordinate because of changes on my end!) and they happily helped me get the group a tasty surprise. Everyone raved about how wonderful the cookies were and I couldn't be more thankful for how nice the staff was. The best of the best in my eyes! read more

This place not only has amazing cookies, but also incredible customer service! Robert, the owner, went out of his way to fix my order when the dough I bought was the wrong kind. He not only drove me the correct dough, but also gave me a gift certificate for the mix-up. I go there every time I'm in Loveland and will continue to do so! Be sure to stop by and get some cookies or their yummy dough read more

Amazing cookies! These are some of the best cookies in town, but they are quite pricey.

I called and placed a telephone order for same day delivery with no problem. Robert was incredibly friendly and accommodating, and my family raved about the cookies! read more