Phenomenal service. Great food. Hard workers! Love America! Right across from the fields so easy to get to. We were here for baseball at the dreams park. Did takeout. Was a great choice. read more

Food is average, service is terrible. Yes, this place is always crowded so you will have to wait for the food to come out but they bring it out piecemeal so you can't all eat together. We waited over an hour for a salad, mozzarella sticks and fries. The two slices of pizza came out in 20 mins and then we waited another 45 mins for the rest of the food. Makes no sense. Also the 10 year old girls who were with me wanted to trade pins one day. There was no line. They patiently waited for there to be no line after being denied pin trading another day. The blonde girl was nasty to them. You have to trade two pins for one and you get 5 seconds to put your hand in a bucket and pick one out. They were so disappointed and upset. I just had to explain to them that some people are nasty to kids and ignore them. If you can avoid - there are so many better places around to eat at. read more

Wait was horrendous, understandable for the crowds. Pizza was actually very very good. I split the chicken "club" with my wife. It was a piece of grilled chicken on a small hamburger roll like from walbaums or grand union or whatever the local supermarket is . For 18 dollars I expected more like double decker sandwich or something. It was just really really really skimpy . read more

Absolutely horrible customer service by one manager/employee despite everyone else being hardworking and kind. The food was very average tasting and overpriced, but the location to the baseball field, the heavy recommendations coming from the nearby Cooperstown umpires, and the pin trading make this restaurant tempting. However, the manager (not the owner) working the night our team arrived was incredibly rude and literally yelling insults at customers. Will never go here again. If your baseball team wants pizza, go elsewhere. read more

This place was in the perfect location, decent food, OUTRAGEOUS prices. We were stunned that an ice water was $2. It cost our family of four over $100 to eat a very average meal. Even Disneyland isn't this expensive. read more

Experience is the key to this review, food was decent and we brought a baseball team in and it was decently busy. We had a pizza order and the people in front of us who were on our team had their pizza for 25 minutes at least. I went up to ask the cashier about the order status; the key here is I was extremely polite and cordial. In fact we were all having a great time. When I asked the cashier, the guy who was making the pizza must have overheard the conversation and completely lost his mind and became threatening and got in my face. I asked this guy to calm down and it seemingly infuriated him more... What a disappointment, atmosphere and customer experience are keys to a customer experience and I would never spend a dollar in this place and encourage Everyone to never come here and potentially be treated like that. read more

Food was pretty good. It's right in front of the Cooperstown dreams park so it makes for quick access if the ballpark concession food isn't cutting it. They have a nice outside area sitting, big dinning room inside and looked like you could reserve tables. The walls are decorated with baseball memorabilia and also the walls have pins from teams that have visited Cooperstown, which is neat. The younger kids up front were nice, the food was pretty good. We went in for a quick lunch and didn't want to wait for a pizza but the sandwiches were good. The chicken sandwich was really good and the mozzarella sticks were nice and cheesy. read more

Maskots Pizza & Grill - Chicken sandwich, Italian sub, Motz sticks. - Pizza Near Me - Milford, New York

Quick place by the Cooperstown Dream park to grab dinner or lunch. Very no frills, can easily bring a baseball team here. Staff were all friendly. Food was okay. Nothing spectacular. The Italian sub was good. Not worth the $16 price. But for a quick lunch that is better than the Cooperstown Dream park concessions, this place is a worse a stop. They have plenty of onsite parking as well. read more

See all

Convenient location at the entrance to Dreams Park. Lots of pin trading history here , you pay for the convenience, but the pizza is good. Sandwiches are mid as are the salads. Staff was friendly. read more

Here is a pizza joint conveniently located directly across from Dreamspark. As soon as you go in (during the Summer I'm assuming), pin trading is always going on. Service was actually pretty quick considering how busy they were getting. We got there early to ensure we would check in to Dreamspark as soon as they opened. We just got a NY Style pie to hold us over until check ins began. The sauce had a nice taste to it. A subtle "tang" in the background. Slightly too thick for my preference but I'm more of a thin crust kind of person unless it's a Sicilian. read more

Maskots Pizza & Grill - NY Style Cheese Pie - Pizza Near Me - Milford, New York

Maskots is a mom/pop restaurant. The owners are taking the orders. They're really nice! So be nice to them :) They are located at the entrance to Cooperstown Dream Park. In other words, if you're here to play baseball, high probability you'll be dining here at some point. The food is good. Local beers on tap. There is a lot of space for big groups. It can get crowded. Kids loved the pizza. I had the chicken Caesar salad and the chicken was grilled nicely. I had a turkey sub another day.. it wasn't a big sandwich and the bread was fresh! Enjoy your time there between games :) read more

Pizza was great. Price is double what it should be. Beer wasn't cold. The line to order was unorganized chaos. read more

Son and I were looking for a place away from Main Street to eat and this place got decent ratings, so we decided to try it. It is located right across the street from Cooperstown Dreams Park, so I'm sure they get tons of business from travel baseball teams. They serve both beer and hard liquor. We ordered a large all meat pizza and mozzarella sticks. This was more than enough for us two big eaters. I'd consider the pizza as just average. It did have a good crust, but the flavor was uninspiring. Service was excellent and there is plenty of seating both inside and outside for large groups. I imagine a ball team of youth would think this place is great, but not the type of "New York" pizza I was expecting. read more

See all

This place is mobbed with baseball kids. We ordered two nights while in Cooperstown. First night I was amazed how many people were there at 11pm and how efficient they were cranking out pizzas. We ordered a large combo and it was okay, it lacked toppings. The second time we ordered a burger and a couple of pasta dishes. Burger was horribly cold. The pasta was warm but seemed like marinara sauce from a can. Work in a pinch but if I had a choice I would go somewhere else read more

Pros: - great location for Cooperstown baseball teams. - plenty of seating for the whole team. Cons: - the food is average at best. Very skimpy pizza toppings so just order a cheese pizza and save your dough. The garden salad was just a clump of iceberg lettuce with a couple pieces of sliced tomato and a few little slices of onion. - THEY CHARGE $2.00 FOR A CUP FOR TAP WATER SO BRING YOUR OWN CUP! With a limited amount of meals available during our stay, I would have much rather gone somewhere else with better food and less of a feeling of being taken advantage of. read more

Stopped for lunch in between games and was very satisfied! The pizza was amazing!!! The wings were wonderful as well. The staff is really friendly and greeted us with a smile. Great environment and clean! read more

Maskots Pizza & Grill - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milford, New York

We came from San Diego to play at Dreams Park and Maskots is right across from the entrance. A great place for some good food and drinks and A/C in-between or after games. We had the baby back ribs, which were surprisingly very good. Staff were friendly despite the crowds. Sal, the owner, is cool, making sure folks have what they need. read more

Maskots was tasty, fun, and entertaining. They did a fantastic job accommodating our team families with pizza, pitchers of soda, and pitchers of beer. They were awesome showing off trading pins and looking at our team pins. We can back a second time as a family and enjoyed the bbq wings and a Sicilian cheese pizza with a couple of fresh baked cookies. Delish! (Highly recommend) Even though they were very busy, they were friendly and fast! At one point my kiddo spilled a soda all over the table and before I blinked staff ran over to our table and helped clean it up even coming back a second time to wipe and make sure it wasn't sticky. If you're looking a for a great, tasty, fast, fun spot with terrific ambiance please check out Maskots! read more

Stop by after a game in cooperstown, the pizza is good the baked pasta was okay nothing special. The chicken wings are good and they have breaded chicken and it super good with the Buffalo sauce. The garlic knots are alright nothing special. They offer drinks and beer and it a good time if you hang out in the back they have picnic tables. They do pin trades for the boys and they pull out from a bucket. read more

I recently moved to the area and heading to Pizza in like three months. I have driven past Maskots several times and the place was packed! On my way home yesterday I stopped and ordered a slice of pizza and an order of wings. The pizza was not bad the crust was really crispy. I thought $18 for six wings was a little much I have to say I stopped in here for a second time I was wrong it was $16 for eight wings which is a lot to me. I ordered 2 slices to go extra crispy I waited 20 minutes it was absolutely horrible. Just to hang out for the rich who obviously have no palette at all Pizza was bland no sauce barely any cheese and it wasn't even extra crispy. Gold mine since it's across from dreamscape. The rich dad's like it because there's alcohol there while the kids eat crappy pizza. read more

The location is great if you are headed to Dreams Park because it's directly across the street. That's where my positively ends. I ordered Tuna on a Roll and it said it would come with pickles and chips for $15. I've attached what I received. No pickles, no chips, no lettuce, no tomato, no onion, no cheese. It's just literally tuna on a roll FOR $15. When I tried walking back up to the counter to ask, I waited behind someone ordering a pizza. The lady taking orders could see me and knew I'd already ordered and received my food but didn't ask what I might still need. The person in front of me proceeded to take the orders of EVERY member of her team as they arrived and cashing out with each person's card. People were line jumping to get their food fixed because it was all wrong and still the lady at the counter didn't ask me if I needed anything quick. A guy actually walked up to the side and bought a beer when there was a pretty long line very visible. Food didn't have flavor and service was pretty bad. The space is pretty big and the wrap around porch is large. So, if you don't care about price, food quality, or time, stop in. Otherwise, look elsewhere. read more

Maskots Pizza & Grill - Tuna on a Roll for $15 and this is exactly what that gets you...no toppings and no side. - Pizza Near Me - Milford, New York

See all

This place is always busy. The service counter girls were very pleasant and helpful. The food is pricey, and in my opinion based on portions, below value. It is comparable with other similar restaurants in this area of limited eateries. Simple takeout wait is 15-20 min. read more

Horrible customer service. Fish dinner came with sea food when not specified and my son is deathly allergic, when I called back to ask for something else OFFERING TO PAY FOR IT the woman answering the phone copped an attitude. Then they brought us one wrong meal so we asked them to correct it and she said "well what do you want us to do about it" horrible horrible we will never go here again read more

Great place to stop at between or after games at Cooperstown Dreams park! Tasty pizza and pitchers of beer. Nice covered patio also. Some people from our group weren't fans of the mixed drinks. read more

Fantastic venue for team party. We played at All Star Village and drove 30 or so minutes and was well worth it! Kelly and her staff were extremely accommodating with our party of 40! Maskot's has a really cool pavilion behind the main building that is perfect for team & family parties. The staff was very busy the night we went there yet the service was awesome! Food was very good. Highly recommend Maskot's! read more

Really good pizza. Free refill sodas....can't go wrong when you're with the kids!!!! Waiting to get into Cooperstown .....grrrrrr

Hey Team Mom-- are you looking for a convenient and good place for a team party? LOOK NO FURTHER. Literally. STOP, because this place is across the street from the vehicle gate entrance of Cooperstown Dreams Park. Our Team Mom made arrangements prior to our arrival and had it so that we could eat outside in the shaded area near the grassy field. IT WAS ABSOLUTELY PERFECT!!! The boys played whiffle ball in between bites of pizza and sips of soda. The staff was really accommodating and the food was good!!! Secure it, Team Mom!!! read more

The staff is extremely rude and the food is disgusting and overpriced. Only thing they have going for them is the location, as they are right outside dreams park. Please review their health inspections so you can save yourself a week of diarrhea. read more

This was the best restaurant in Cooperstown! Not only amazing food, but the atmosphere was the epitome of a family owned business that took care of there guests! We came there daily in between or after games for the best baked pasta and pizza! The pasta dishes tasted like my Italian grandfathers, very authentic. The owner and his daughter were so wonderful to the kids as well. Pin trading at the end of the week is a must! Highly recommend as a must while in Cooperstown! read more

I thought this place was great. The staff is super friendly. We had our game family dinner here. The package includes 8 pizzas, a tray of baked ziti, garden and Caesar salad, and garlic knots! Plenty of food for our 50 hungry people! If my sons had their wash we would have eaten there every day. After the third time I just wanted to try something else. Definitely worth a try. read more

We ate here a couple time during our week. Food was very good and priced about the same as all the other restaurants in the area

Prices advertised are not what you are charged. Most expensive beer anywhere near Cooperstown Dreams Park. Price gouging at its finest with the excuse the menu's are pre-Covid. Last I checked, Covid is over two years old. Update: Kids Pasta $14. Listed for $8 on the paper menus, but kids meals prices have been taped over (hidden) on the large display menus. read more

Wow! Legit NY pizza. Made from scratch using the best of ingredients! The dough was amazing, the marinara was spiced just right and the cheese wasn't too greasy. Great crust and crunch. The wings were well done for a pizza joint. The staff is awesome, just talk to them. It was a great time! read more

I was so hesitant bc the previous star ratings. This place was fantastic. The staff offered fast and very friendly service, the atmosphere was as you would expect - loud/family friendly/celebratory- just what you'd want for families attending the ball tournaments, and the food - fantastic! Best of all, the GLUTEN FREE crust was so so so good and my son never felt sick after eating it! Huge win!!! read more

Been there twice. Food is average. Prices are on the high side. Can't say anything good about the service. I think location is the only great thing about this establishment because there are not many places to eat in the area. read more

We had a team lunch here my son's baseball team after we toured the Hall of Fame. Sal, the owner, was so accommodating. We had a game change which delayed everything, but he worked with me and had everything set up and ready for the boys when we arrived. Tray of baked ziti, garlic rolls, chicken wings, and pizza. Devoured. The wiffle ball is back and sal getting in on the pin trading with the boys was a really personal touch. If in the area, check them out! Support the local mom and pop businesses! read more

If you're looking for something close to the park, this is it! The pizza is good. The beer is COLD! Salads & meatball subs are generous and look really good. (Our party was pleased.) Maskots has just enough variety & great service for a great, casual outing. read more

Really good pizza and subs at this place not to mention the wings were really good too! We ordered pizzas for the team to be had back at the campground and everyone enjoyed the food. We were also grateful that this place keeps some pretty late hours because some nights the baseball games didn't get over until quite late, and there are not many places open to get food that late at night. Great friendly staff and good food. We will be back again next Summer when we return for more baseball at Cooperstown Dreams Park across the street. read more

Pretty decent place. Prices were a bit much. Service was super friendly. I recommend it! read more

Maskots Pizza & Grill - Pizza Near Me - Milford, New York

Powell says he is not impressed with the baked ziti. Needs some protein cesear salad was soggy !