Matthew's Pizza has been around since 1943! While I wouldn't call it a hole in the wall, it is a nice little place making great pizza! The servers will make you feel welcomed! When in Baltimore you have to be sure to visit and try their famous crab pie pizza! The pizza was delicious with its unique combination of flavors. The pie does fluctuate based on market price, but it was reasonable in cost. When in Baltimore I will for sure be coming back read more

See all

We tried many pizzas in Baltimore but this one takes the cake. Is it the best pizza outside NYC? Some might argue "yes." It's not just the pizza but the nostalgic, no nonsense experience. The best way I can describe it is if Pizza Hut pizza was actually life changing. On our first visit, I remember the waitress flipped a paper plate upside down on the table. I, being confused, flipped it right side up. She said sternly "flip that back over. It's the pizza stand." And the rest is history. In my mind, their core competencies lie in their house salad and cheese pizzas. The house salad and dressing is soooo good. We were most pleased with the three cheese pie. We got a pizza once with more toppings but it messed with the caramelization, we thought. Keep it simple and you'll understand. read more

The mozzerela stick was good! Nice crust and cheese. The caprese was good!! Like very good. The ingredients were fresh and they were a good size! The pizza was very enjoyable! The crust and bread is cooked PERFECTLY. Every bite has a beautiful texture. The bottom and edge are well done too. This really elevates the experience- the pizza itself isn't overly flavorful. It's a simple pizza flavor that you can tell was made with love. The combination of the perfect bread and the cohesive flavor makes this pizza a true joy to eat despite not being novel in taste. The margarita pie was good and the Thai pie was good too (the Thai pie was spicier but well flavored) I would definitely come here again- the pizza is so easy to eat and has a great crunch in the crust. I think it's the best crust I had on a pizza! read more

Matthew's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

See all

Unfortunately wanted to give a better rating, suffice to say the customer service has gone well down hill, even answering the phone and older lady when asked if they sell slices said "first off we dont sell slices, second we arent taking orders so bye" and hung up the phone, might be time I finally put my money elsewhere, slice is decent, as a new yorker its nothing to write home about, better slices around canton and downtown, just happened to be featured one time and it got to their head quickly. Loved supporting them for a while, try to watch your interactions guys! read more

The absolute worst pizza in Baltimore. Waiter and Waitress were not clean. The waitress opened the bathroom door then proceeded to grab the entrees and serve them to us without washing her hands. The waiter was digging in his beard. The Pizza was the last thing to come out and by far not worth the wait or price. Watered down sauce with fake cheese and a cardboard crust. The pizza was worse than a frozen pizza you would find at a grocery store. Do not go to this place ever. 0 stars. read more

Food was terrible the sauce on the pizza taste like water. The Italian sub was disappointing. The wings were bad the onion rings were freezer burnt. The pizza was the worse pizza I ever had in my life. The waiter had body Oder and his beard was out of control nearly touching the food as he walked it over to the table. The other female waiter was opening bathroom doors with her bare hands replacing rolls of toilet paper and then coming out the bathroom and refilling pitchers of water and grabbing our food and bringing it to our table. It was over all disgusting and dirty and the food was putrid. I wouldn't recommend this place to a sewer rat to go dine in. Place needs shut down immediately.. negative a trillion stars.... read more

I was looking for some pizza and happened upon this restaurant. I noticed that it had been in business since 1943, so I figured it would be good. I decided on the bbq chicken pizza. It was a 10" pie and there was a sign saying it would take about 25 minutes to make. When the pizza came out, it looked like a deep dish pizza, and was served piping hot. The flavor of the pizza was good, but the burnt crust was a little offputting. The other pizzas I saw served to other customers also had really burnt edges. I've had deep dish pizza and thin crust pizza, and this fell somewhere in between. The staff was super nice and attentive. I just wish the edges of the pizza weren't so burnt tasting. read more

Matthew's Pizza - Bbq chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Solid pizza place in Baltimore! I got a takeout of the spinach pie- it was ready fast within 15- 20 minutes! The service is good and everyone is friendly! Overall I enjoyed the pizza! the crust is great and so is the pie! It was easy to park by the place and pick it up. read more

Matthew's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Ordered carryout from Matthew's for my first time and it was definitely a fun, delicious experience. The packaging made it a tad hard to carry everything and I was walking back to my friend's so it was tricky. The salad was a large portion for the price and very refreshing. The dressing was a little oily, but not a huge deal. The mozzarella sticks were breaded nicely and very crispy-- paired well with the marinara sauce. The onion rings were great, but there were a lot of little half pieces that were stuck together with the breading and it just became too greasy for those bites. The Margherita pizza was my favorite. I liked the added basil and tomatoes. The great white with veggies was also incredible-- it was packed full of veggies, which added different crunch and umami flavors. The thai chicken was good but I think it needed more onion or the sweet chili sauce or even an addition of chicken. It was just lacking a little for me. I will say that all the pizzas were superrrrr cheesy and had very crispy edges, which I love. A little pricey for the portion sizes overall but it's a fun variation of some classic pizza flavors and a nice neighborhood spot. **Apologies for the pizzas being half eaten in the pictures-- we were starving** read more

See all

Super cute maybe even a lil retro vibe pizza place! Definitely a B'more local staple! Service was great! Friendly, patient, and great recommendations! Good food for the price! read more

Matthew's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

See all

Did not care for the pizza nor the staff . Pizza had a strange spongy crust that was underdone on the bottom , but burnt around edges . Sauce was tasteless/ Wouid not return read more

very disappointed with the pizza and salad on a Saturday afternnoon , the crust was overdone and the pizza was favorless the salad dressing was mostly horse raddish. Pizza Crust was dry and tasteless. will not return to this establishment. read more

Stay away from this place if you like flavor, cleanliness, hygiene and your money. This place was sketch as soon as we walked in. There is about eight tables that apparently you have to wait to be seated for. The male waiter had a wild beard and smelled like body oder. Since I had hungry kids with us and it had good reviews I decided we would try it. The prices are so high for these tiny flavorless cardboard pizzas. I also had ordered an Italian sub to share with my husband. It was a horrid flavorless sub. The onion rings were freezer burnt. The pizza literally is like frozen pizza they heat up. It was disgusting. I mean the worst pizza I ever ate in my whole life. I didn't even eat it I left the whole thing minus a bite on the table. We also left the large size we got for the kids. The waiter brought our food with his beard almost touching it. He was wiping tables then going to get drinks, messing with cash and then handling food. The older lady waitress was changing toilet paper in the bathroom and then went and grabbed the fries we ordered and brought them to our table to help out the male waiter that smelled of BO and who had disappeared for like 20 mins. It took over an hour for our food to all come out. It was just a gross environment with dirty workers that don't wash their hands or have any type of personal hygiene. The food matches the whole atmosphere. Disgusting dirty flavorless and expensive for literal trash. The price also insanely expensive for dog food. Actually I would not even give this to my dog or any living creature. I just can't put into words how disgusting flavorless and horrible everything is at this place. How is it even in business?? Probably because they charge $16.99 for a personal pan cardboard pizza. I regret ever entering this place. With the people you can see being as dirty and disgusting as they were, I can't imagine what the cooks hygiene is in the back cooking there. I might end up with salmonella poisoning. Lord forgive me but this place needs shut down by the board of health. I wish I had my $200 back because the food wasn't worth $2. Please for your health, wallet and tastebuds STAY AWAY FROM THIS FILTHY DISGUSTING PLACE!!! read more

To celebrate National Pizza Day, I took my parents to check out Matthew's Pizza in the Highlandtown area. Luckily, there was no waiting time and we got a table right away. We started with mozzarella sticks, French fries, and Bone-in Buffalo wings; the wings were the perfect crispy texture and the buffalo sauce was mild and tasty. We ordered the 'Fiery Hawaiian' and 'The Great White Veggie' pizzas; watch out for the jalapeño peppers, they're spicy, but the pizza is so good! For a sweet finish, we had 'cannoli' and the star of the night, the 'limoncello cake,' which was very tasty, with great fluffy texture and the right amount of sweetness. They're very popular for their crab pie. Service was attentive and outstanding overall; we enjoyed the nostalgic vibe and the quiet atmosphere. read more

Matthews is a Baltimore staple for good reason. The aroma of delicious, homemade sauce greets you as soon as you walk in and the atmosphere proclaims "We've been here a few decades, come on in and make yourself at home". The vibe inside is fun, casual and classic feeling. I am a huge fan of the Both Cheese Pie and the Roman Pie but honestly all of their pies are really good. Their crust is crisp, almost fried, and the cheese is fresh and sauce is so flavorful. I'm getting hungry just taking about it. read more

See all

Don't come here expecting the usual pepperoni or sausage pizzas. They have specialty pizzas such as crab pizza and chicken diavola and others. Do yourself a favor and try their appetizers as well. The gelato is a summer evening treat as well. The staff is friendly and efficient as well. read more

Recently rated the best pizza in Maryland, I decided to finally try the spot less than a mile from my house. The mozzarella sticks are THE BEST...squarish and crispy, with perfect sauce. I got the 4 cheese pizza with jalapeños and pineapples, and it's awesome. I love that it has both ricotta cheese and caramelized mozz. So good! read more

On the way back from a road trip I planned to try Matthew's after hearing about the crab pie. So I ordered the crab pie and the crab bruschetta. I was highly surprised that the bruschetta was so delicious only needed a few more bruschetta slices to scoop up the remaining crab bruschetta filling. It was a lot left after the bread was done. So the crab piece was not as great as I imagined. Lacked flavor and/or sauce. A bit dry and overcooked. Definitely expensive for the size and taste. read more

See all

Date of visit: 8/1/2024 GET THE CRAB PIE! And get the 10 inch one! You won't regret it! You're welcome! read more

See all

A Baltimore classic that serves their own twist on deep dish -esque pizza. We ordered the margherita and meatlover's. Both made fresh, taking about 20-30 min after we ordered. Some of the best tomato sauce I've had (savory, not too acidic). The 10" pizzas weren't large, but we ordered two of them for three people and still had some leftovers enough for one person. Located near Patterson Park if looking for a post meal stroll! read more

Matthew's Pizza - 10" Meatlovers - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

See all

I know this place has been noted as some of the best pizza in the city! I just wasn't fan of the crab pie. Too many onions, and there wasn't a sauce to help bring out the flavors (like an Alfredo or another creamy white sauce). It is a small pizza shop, but they have a dedicated area for "adults only," which was nice as there were families dining and some crying babies. Service was solid, although the pizza took quite some time to come out. We got an order of fries to snack on while we waited and the fries were delicious. I don't know if they were hand-cut, but they had a classic taste. I would come back again to try something else to try a classic pizza and see if that one does the trick. read more

See all

If you haven't heard yet, Matthew's is a classic Baltimore pizza shop and the pizza is delicious every single time, whether you're eating in, getting delivery, or picking up. Last night we picked up Buffalo Chicken and the Popeye and Olive Oil pizzas, both 10" and they were sooo good. read more

Matthew's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

See all

We read about the crab pizza and knew we had to try it. This is a very sweet restaurant-nice artwork on most of the tables and old menus and reviews on the wall. The food is fantastic. Service was friendly and everything was nicely timed. read more

Matthew's Pizza has been around since the early '40s, and they're known for their Crab Pie. We came here to check their pizzas out, and the place was cute and cozy. Note that there's many who calls in to place orders to go, and some ingredients may run out. We ordered: +the 3 Cheese Pie - with hand-grated mozzarella, reggianito, and ricotta; I think we should have gone for the simple 1- or 2-cheese pie, as the ricotta was just not good in here; there were just clumps of it that was not spread around and didn't seemed to be cooked all the way through +the Crab Pie - topped with backfin crab meat, hand-grated mozzarella, caramelized onions, and Old Bay seasoning; this looked great visually, as there was crab that covered all the surface area; however, not sure how fresh the crab was, as it did have a 'fishy' odor and taste to it The sizes of the pies seemed like personal pan pizzas; the crust, similar to a pan-style. It was stated that they come out 'well-done', but I felt that we should have requested 'extra well-done' or 'extra crispy'. There was only one staff member who was working, and she was on it! She was able to take orders on the phone, for carry-outs, and service all the tables. Street parking can be found around the area. +friendly staff read more

See all

The pizza here was very good. The crust is cheesy and midway between a thin crust and a traditional thick crust style. The service was friendly enough but definitely underwhelming and insufficiently attentive. They were not busy when we were there today but both servers acted as if they were overloaded with work. The restaurant is small, with colorful walls and tabletops. I would definitely eat here again if I happened to be nearby but wouldn't go out of my way to get their food. read more

My wife, my sister-in-law, and I made a long special trip to get Matthew's pizza on New Year's Eve at 4:20 p.m. My sister-in-law was visiting from Delaware and we talked up this business to her because our previous experiences with Matthew's have been great. In fact, last time we were out for lunch, I purchased one of their shirts and regularly wear it to the gym. People ask me about it and I recommend that people try Matthew's. We were all looking forward to enjoying some pizza today. We entered and a white older female behind the register asked, "You eating in?" I noticed that a customer was sitting at a table near the front and a man near the main register, while the white female was on the telephone. We grabbed a seat since we saw that she was busy and we planned on eating in. We waited patiently for nearly 10 minutes as the female worker answered the telephone and handled carry-out orders , so I decided to grab some menus, which were on the wall near the main counter to help the woman out, since she was busy. We also were hungry, so we were looking to order as soon as someone was available to take our order. She YELLED and SCOLDED me for taking some menus. I let her know that I was simply trying to help out because she was busy. She did not respond. My wife and sister-in-law were shocked by this treatment. We were so uncomfortable that we decided to leave. I hope the owner addresses this problematic employee. I'm highly doubtful that we will make the trip ever again nor will I recommend this business. read more

Matthew's Pizza - Photo of awful experience on 12/31/25 at 4:20 PM. - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

This local pizza spot truly shines! Fresh, flavorful ingredients, perfectly cooked crust, and exceptional service make it a must-visit. Already planning my next order! read more

Matthew's Pizza - 10" The Roman - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

See all

Y'all!!! I don't know what took me so long to get to Matthew's pizza but I'm so glad I went. This place was super cozy with authentic pizza joint vibes written all over it. The nice lady that took care of us while we were there recommended the meat lovers and I am so happy I listened. The pizza was kind of deep dish style which is my favorite with crispy edges. It came out piping hot with ingredients so fresh it will make you want to cry. Every table was full by the time we left. The prices were reasonable and the pizza was amazing. If you love pizza like myself, you have to try Matthews pizza. It actually lived up to the hype. I'll be back very very soon. Plenty of street parking available. Just be ready to parallel park and you're all set. read more

See all

I feel like I've been a pretty decent Yelp Elite representative for Baltimore but that I've also been fraudulent bc there are so many staples in the area that I've just not made the trek to try. Take Matthew's Pizza for example. Baltimore's oldest Pizzeria. How have I not tried them? The good? The pizza, and the service. The folks at Matthew's are extremely nice. I ordered mine to go; I had a sausage and pepperoni 8 inch and the wife had a 10 inch with olives, broccoli, ham, and a bunch of other stuff that I just couldn't bring myself to try. That said, we both LOVED our meals. Matthew's is tiny on the inside so it runs the risk of not having enough space to seat you, so keep that in mind. They also have a tiny little bar on the lower level, that I think is a neat touch. In the words of the famous War Robot from the future: I'll be back. read more

See all

Get the crab pizza. Now stop reading this review and get that asap. If you're looking for the best of both worlds - Maryland crab and pizza, this is it. This sauceless pizza rocks just a few ingredients, the best being a melty mozzarella, Maryland crab, and onions. It's all topped with Old Bay seasoning. I highly recommend ordering it at the restaurant and eating it there! They make it fresh and this is best eaten fresh. Please make note that it does take 30 minutes to make! It will blow you away like it blew me away. So much flavor packed into a personal pizza. Price is market price, but ours was around $25 when we got it in January 2023. read more

See all

It was on my must try Baltimore pizza list so I visited shortly after moving to the city. Since then I have been back a few times for a few variations but have yet to dine inside. The dining area is small but looks cozy enough to sit for a meal. The pizza is good and even better, for me, a little closer to well done. Ingredients are plentiful and fresh, the customer service has been consistent, and I always seem to find a space close by to run in and grab my pie. Solid pie. read more

See all

We all love pizza ... OMG !!! This place is the best I have eaten here before on a past visit to Baltimore and on a recent visit had the opportunity to dine here again I had pizza at other places in Baltimore, but this is the place for THE PIZZA !!!! read more

See all

Matthews in Baltimore on Eastern Ave, the BEST pizza ever, not your usual pizza. I think they've been in business since 1944. Small restaurant. It's really what you would call a real pizza pie, different from the norm. Try the original with grated cheese. Get a frozen one to take home. I'm not close now, but relatives bring me some when they visit. They do have other toppings, but my favorite, the original! Salute to my old hometown, Highlandtown!!!!! read more

Literally my favorite pizza place in the city! It's so good that I always forget to take a picture before eating the pizza but I remembered this time haha. They are very friendly and if I am not dining in I'll call in and order my food. It's a small and quaint space which fills up especially on the weekends so call ahead to see if they have any seating available. Make sure you try the crab pizza or the supreme pizza w/anchovies! Chefs kiss! read more

Matthew's Pizza - 10" Crab Pie and 10" Spinach Pie - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

OMG! Who knew there was a crab pizza?!! Actually they call it a crab pie and it's aMaZiNg!!! My girlfriend ordered the crab pie and I ordered the everything pie. They were both delicious! ...but that crab pie is what's up!! I don't recall the actual measurement, but they're all the size of a personal pan pizza. Which means...... you can eat the whole thing! That crust tho! I read other reviews and I suppose everybody has their preferences, but the crust was both crispy and doughy at the same time. I can't explain it but I can say I LOVE IT! I'm so glad I found this local spot. I can't wait to order again. Go check it out. you must! read more

See all

I was recently visiting Baltimore and I'm addicted to pizza and luckily I found this place online when I was looking for a crab pizza... I'm beyond glad I found it! Long story short I came back here twice within three days just to eat the delicious and generous crab portioned pizza Highly recommended and the employees were very welcoming as well read more

Matthew's Pizza - 10" Crab Pie - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

I decided to try this place out after I saw a video on YouTube. Let me tell you, it was definitely a wonderful experience! I ordered our pizzas via delivery and the pizzas tasted fresh and homemade. They actually remind me a lot of the old school Pizza Hut pizza that we have all been craving for the past 30 or so years. This pizza is however, much less greasy, and the veggies on the vegetable pizza are also fresh and delicious. The only negative is that the chicken on the pizza is quite bland. Other than that, no complaints. I'll definitely be ordering from here again. read more

Super delicious, 3 cheese pie and meatball sub, we are used to New York deep dish pizza and this is very close. read more

Matthew's Pizza - Could only eat half, for now! Meatball Parmesan Sub - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Another visit to the "mecca of pizza" in the city. My family and I went there last Saturday afternoon, on the spur of the moment. I got my usual, the two cheese 10" pizza and the girls shared a 10" white pizza (edited to include tomato sauce). Having been to Matthew's more than 20 times in the past 6+ years, the two cheese pie was not as flavorful as usual - maybe due to weather, timing, my taste... but it was good! The white pizza - with the caramelized onions - was SO DANG GOOD!! I'd go back now if I wasn't at work. Definitely will try that next time. And yes - Matthew's is as good as people say! read more

In my recent visit to Baltimore I have been told by my friends that Mathew's 3 cheese pizza is a must try.. Initially I thought they're over exaggerating as 3 cheese pizza is quite common in every pizza places..But when I tried it I got the difference , it basically made of hand grated mozzarella & imported reggianito & ricotta cheeses.Ricotta cheese in pizza is something new for me and I absolutely loved it now while writing thus review am craving for it and trying to find a place in Scottsdale.. read more

Matthew's Pizza - 3 cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland