Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Maya's Pizzeria Restaurant

    3.9 (8 reviews)
    Closed 12:00 pm - 8:00 PM

    Order Maya's Pizzeria Restaurant Takeout or Delivery

    Maya's Pizzeria Restaurant Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Maya's Pizzeria Restaurant

    Recommended Reviews - Maya's Pizzeria Restaurant

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Cody O.
    285
    447
    1432

    3 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Maria S.
    53
    59
    42

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Zainaa W.
    151
    12
    8

    7 years ago

    omg addicted . Food is BOMB, Customer Service EXCELLENT. Like the owner came & brought my food to my car guys. love it

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of J W.
    0
    10
    0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Rahul M.
    170
    20
    2

    6 years ago

    Great food, the just do so many things really well. Ordered chicken parm and a taro bubble tea, both were good.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    I order a Large Pie & they give me Medium size, price is to spencer the people working in the back preparing the food they don't ware a mask

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Maya's Pizzeria Restaurant

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 15,397 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Luca's Ristorante - Porto Bianco White Port

    Luca's Ristorante

    4.4(730 reviews)
    3.5 mi
    $$$

    Absurdly good. This place has been a staple in the area for a long time, and they really make the…read moremost of their space. The strip mall itself isn't anything special, but the surrounding area is beautiful , and once you're inside, the restaurant feels warm and inviting. The food is fantastic, and the variety on the menu is impressive. The chef clearly knows what they're doing because every single dish we tried was genuinely delicious. It's the kind of spot where you can't go wrong: date night, dinner with friends, or anything in between. We brought our own bottle and had a great time. Our waiter was super knowledgeable, friendly, and patient. The staff even joked around with me when I forgot my to‑go bag, and yes, I absolutely took it home because the food is that good. I also appreciate that they don't act like offering takeout is beneath them; even the takeout bag was nice. I honestly wish my meals were this good every night. I hope everyone who works here is paid well and enjoys what they do, because they're running the place exactly how a restaurant should be run. It feels like a true community staple somewhere that transports you a bit and makes the whole experience feel special. Lovely all around.

    Celebrated my husband's birthday with dinner here. The spot is moody and dark. Service was fine, no…read morecomplaints. What we ordered: - POLETTE (pine nuts raisins beef meatballs, tomato sauce, melted cacio cavallo - CALAMARI (fried squid, spicy tomato sauce) - SALTIMBOCCA (veal tenderloin scaloppini, prosciutto, bufala mozzarella, spinach, crispy sage, brandy sauce, fingerling potatoes) - CINQUANTA (fifty layered lasagne, spinach pasta, veal tenderloin stew, cheese, mushrooms, marsala sauce) - NON-ALCOHOLIC SPRITZ - NON-ALCOHOLIC DRINK BELLINI The food was good. It was a good experience overall.

    Photos
    Luca's Ristorante
    Luca's Ristorante - Depth of Field Shot of the Polpette (Voted Best Meatballs in New Jersey)

    Depth of Field Shot of the Polpette (Voted Best Meatballs in New Jersey)

    Luca's Ristorante - Romolo Pasta

    See all

    Romolo Pasta

    Victoria's Tratta Italiano - Eggplant rollatini

    Victoria's Tratta Italiano

    4.2(105 reviews)
    1.1 mi
    Family-owned & operated
    Discounts available

    If you're driving down from anywhere to central NJ and Rutgers University area & want that "I found…read moremy spot" feeling -- Victoria's Tratta Italiano is "it". You walk into this warm amazing & friendly place on Church St, New Brunswick, smell that brick oven firing, and the owners themselves, might pop by your table to ask how the pasta & food is. Isn't that amazing & extraordinary!! You can truly enjoy this family own spot. The owners and staff "show up", and say how's the food, how are you doing? Not once's but multiple times!! Each time with an amazing attention, jokes that we could not stop laughing pleasantly. The waiter was also amazing, pleasant and very gentle. We came down to New Brunswick for our daughter graduation at Rutgers, and looked at various restaurants in the area and selected Victoria because they had a great variety of food for each member particular preference. We had: - Garlic Bread with Olive Oil. - Fried mozzarella calzone - Pepperoni Pizza - Fettuccini Alfredo Chicken - Wild Mushrooms Filet Risotto - Chicken Parmesan And I had the Papa Mango Salmon which was amazing. If you like Salmon I highly recommend it. To top it off limoncello and sambuca did its final touch. Thank you Victoria Tratta Italiano. It's a go-to before a show at State Theatre or Stress Factory, which I have been to before, because it's literally around the corner, parking's easy in the deck, and they won't rush you out. Service feels amazingly cool. Bring a date, bring your kids, bring your parents, bring the whole birthday crew. They do it all, and they'll make you feel like you are family at Home.

    The picture of the buffalo chicken pizza looked too good not to try. The sad part was that there is…read moretoo much stuff on the pie, and since they threw it in the box so hot and gave it to the driver like that, all the stuff slid over the edge of the pizza and into the corner. After doing some Dr. Frankenstein rearranging of cheese and chicken, we were able to eat this pie. The good part is they use Franks, which I love, so the pie was spicy and had a familiar taste. But the crust was bland and the chicken breast tasted like it had no seasoning. There was a ton of it, but it was just a chore to get through. So overall I say 3 for that pie, but I bet if I went in and ate it there and it wasn't such a mess it would be an easy 4.

    Photos
    Victoria's Tratta Italiano - Back dining room

    Back dining room

    Victoria's Tratta Italiano
    Victoria's Tratta Italiano

    See all

    Mangia Toscano - Arrabiata & cacio e Pepe  | #intenselypassionatephotography

    Mangia Toscano

    4.4(278 reviews)
    6.3 mi
    $$$

    I cannot explain why it took 7 years after Florence, Italy natives Alberto Buglione and Ivan…read moreGuarducci took over this restaurant for me to visit. It is outstanding! Over the years I have heard nothing but good from friends -- "Excellent" "Exactly like they make it in Florence!" "Best Italian food I've ever tasted." I went with a party of four. For appetizers we split the Polpo E Patate (grilled octopus & potatoes) and Patate Fritte (French fries). The octopus was amazing, tender almost like perfect scallops with a tasty pesto. The French fries with herbs, garlic bread crumbs and pesto were crunchy, tasty, delicious. For mains my companions had Branzino with eggplant carponata, an amazing 4-cheese Gnocchi, and swordfish. I tasted all, and all were spot on; everyone loved their main course. I had Linguini Vongole (clams and linguini); the clams were perfect - tender and tasty; but the star of the show was the homemade linguine, seasoned perfectly and cooked to al dente perfection. We finished with cappuccino and Tiramasu. The service was excellent. Attentive and quick, and our waitress, Merin, was able to answer every question about the menu with authority, and even about the ingredients and preparation. The ambiance is understated, relaxed, and what you hope for when enjoying a special meal. I am quite stingy in passing out 5-Star ratings; I reserve them for the best of the best, for restaurants where I'm confident readers will also enjoy an outstanding meal. Mangia Toscano is clearly 5-Star; it is *the* must-do restaurant in Metuchen.

    The food, service, and atmosphere were definitely a vibe! Everything about the experience was…read moreenjoyable from start to finish. I had the Salmon and the Gnocchi Al Pesto, and both dishes were delicious, savory, and full of flavor. The staff was attentive, the ambiance was great, and the overall experience made me want to come back again. Highly recommend!

    Photos
    Mangia Toscano
    Mangia Toscano - Panzanella & burrata | #intenselypassionatephotography

    Panzanella & burrata | #intenselypassionatephotography

    Mangia Toscano

    See all

    Civile Cucina Italiana - Salmone

    Civile Cucina Italiana

    4.3(240 reviews)
    6.1 mi
    $$

    Found this place for a birthday celebration. From outside we could not find the main entrance but…read moreonce inside we had a great experience from the service provided by Juan to the delicious food. We were a party of 8 and ordered from the family style menu (5 appetizers, salad, 2 pastas, 1 beef, 1 chicken, 1 fish, dessert). Everything was tasty especially the balsamic calamari and the anise mussels. We loved the 3 cheese gnocchi and the penne carbonara. There is a great selection to choose from. It was plentiful and we could not finish it all. Will definitely be back!

    Okay, I'll be honest: this place needs a serious overhaul. Robert Irvine, please help them out! We…read morewaited at the hostess stand while three men rushed around, taking orders, bringing food, clearing tables, and resetting them. It was clear they were severely understaffed, and we were largely ignored until one of them finally said, "I will check on your table." The food was okay. The bread? Their stock answer was humorous after hearing it recites by all three servers: "It's in the oven" I guess practice makes perfect. Standard salad with balsamic, same as every mid pizza/food place I have been before. Red snapper special was way tough on the outside, like chewing leather that you never would really want to eat?! Best thing here was the pork chop, sweet spicy peppers, with onions yummy brown sauce, although the pork was a tad overdone. Overall, this place is a pass.

    Photos
    Civile Cucina Italiana - Mural wall in the dining room

    Mural wall in the dining room

    Civile Cucina Italiana - Pork Chop Giambotta

    Pork Chop Giambotta

    Civile Cucina Italiana - Pancetta Fig Crostini

    See all

    Pancetta Fig Crostini

    Catherine Lombardi - House-Made Fresh Mozzarella -- prepared with heirloom Jersey tomatoes, pistachio and pesto!

    Catherine Lombardi

    3.7(376 reviews)
    1.1 mi
    $$$

    Clarissa & Kenny took care of our table . An impromptu visit for a light meal…read more Garlic bread - 10/10 Meatballs - was delicious Cheese burger medium well - one of the best I have had in a long time Apple cobbler with vanilla ice cream - warm and creamy perfect to share on a date night Intimate romantic dim lit . The perfect hangout spot to enjoy a good meal and great conversation

    The environment was the star of the show. Pretty dining room, classy and well-furnished without…read morebeing anything close to over-the top. The steak we ordered was very good, but overpriced. $10 for some sliced hot cherry peppers to accompany it did not help the restaurant's cause. The side plate of broccoli rabe was disappointing. Highly recommend the stuffed mushrooms appetizer - delicious and actually a good value. Nice wine list, but you'll struggle to find much that's affordable - I chose the bargain wine (Tannat from Uruguay) at $79, and it was very good. Service was attentive - excessively so. You might like this, but I had to hint, hint again, then pretty much say explicitly to stay away. I was on a date, you see. 'Nuff said? If you have lots of money and don't much care how you spend it, you'll adore this establishment. Lots of service, really nice environment, and very good food. If you're value-conscious, I think it'll be a coin-toss.

    Photos
    Catherine Lombardi
    Catherine Lombardi - The owners bring in many local cheeses. Be sure to sample them.

    The owners bring in many local cheeses. Be sure to sample them.

    Catherine Lombardi - Bar view

    See all

    Bar view

    Maya's Pizzeria Restaurant - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...