Had an egg salad sub, which reminded me of the kind of sandwich my grandma would make. Subs are a good size. Service is fast. There are clean tables to eat there, but it seemed like many people were getting this ga to go. Looks like they have a lunch special. They have a minimart-style selection of drinks and chips. It is worth stopping in and giving this place a try. read more

Haven't been here in 20 years! It was good then, and it's good now! They have a good amount of food here, but I really wanted a sub this day, but didn't want the usual place I go or chains and since we were up the street from here, came on in. Service is still as friendly as it was then. Food was still as good too. I had the turkey sub and my son had the steak sub. They may not look exciting for a picture, but they were excellent! I wish it were closer to my house because I could go for another one today! There is a conscience store in here too with plenty of choices of snack and drinks. There's seating. There's a shelf if you want to place an order to go. You can order online too! If you decide to sit and eat there, they'll bring you your food and then you'll cash out at the register when you're done (they'll have a slip with your order already). read more

See all

Pretty decent sub. The place has a weird atmosphere like a gas station combined with a deli. Took about 10 minutes to prepare my sub. read more

Mayback's Deli - Reuben Sub - Delis Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

Favefavefave. Love a breakfast sandwich + crispy hash brown inside. Staff are awesome and I love this homey establishment. read more

If you have never been here, you're really missing out. A little bit of a store that has killer sandwiches. The seating area has expanded over the years as the store has shrunk which is fine. Ordered a breakfast sandwich this morning and it never disappoints. It took under 10 minutes and was delicious! I've had many of their items but, the breakfast sandwich is always on spot. read more

Kicking myself for not coming in sooner. Service was cordial and efficient. Barb was awesome. There were regulars there that could spot that I was new there. They were very nice to point out some really good sandwiches. Could not count the varieties of drinks that lined the 2 walls. They have a few tables and chairs for convenience. Parking is available read more

See all

Classic. My husband always craves their chicken finger sub when we're back in town. I used to frequent for their fish fry when we lived in Buffalo. We always grab a sub when we're back in WNY. It's hefty, fresh and a decent value for the price. It's a standby for a reason and if you want food without any frills, this is for you. read more

What a hidden gem, amazing sandwich shop we got a sausage egg and cheese and a chicken finger sandwich both were excellent!! Freshness and quality and bang for your buck. Friendly staff you can either get it to go or dine in small dinning room atmosphere. Highly recommend read more

See all

Great hidden gem right on the boulevard. I've driven past this place a bunch, but this is the first time I've stopped in. Small deli with a little seating area to eat. Friendly staff and they were quick making the food. Both the chicken tender salad and sub were great! Would definitely recommend. read more

See all

I had been anxiously awaiting sinking my teeth into a Mayback sandwich and sub. The order was easy to place over the phone. I just used old pics of the menu from Yelp to see what options are available - didn't see that they had a website. Chicken finger sub (mini) - Classic. No complaints. Plenty of fingers. Steak breakfast sandwich - I recommend adding a hash brown patty. Unfortunately there wasn't much flavor - maybe just needed a touch of salt; but regardless, it was inhaled. Hope to be back to try more! read more

See all

Absolutely love this place! The food here is not your typical food. Somehow it's always delicious every single time!!!! Reasonable prices for outstanding quality food! The staff are amazing and friendly! They do have seating inside in case you wanted to really enjoy the experience! I look forward to dining with you guys again... read more

See all

I'm originally from Western New York & moved back here last Thanksgiving (2025). Mayback's had the BEST Subs in 1980 (when I moved away), and nothing has changed in 46 years. They still have THE BEST SUBS in WNY. Great sub roll & they are generous with the meat. read more

The food is wholesome. The prices are very reasonable. It is a popular location and they do a very brisk take out business. But they also have a cozy place to sit in house if you want to take a break!! I love Maybecks! read more

The Mecca for cheap, quality eats. L Fish Fry dinner is served daily, and is exceptional compared to most places. Stop in for a square meal, and enjoy a crisp Sprite while you wait. read more

See all

I've been going to Mayback's since I was little. Our family LOVES it and friends always enjoy it when I introduce them to the deli. I will never turn down a trip to Mayback's read more

The breakfast sandwiches are to die for!! Plus add the hashbrown on top, yum!! Service is always quick and it's the bodega vibe that you know will give you the best food! read more

Mayback's has great subs and sandwiches for a reasonable price. It can get a little busy at times but generally it is pretty quick in and out. I almost always get a turkey sandwich which comes with chips and a pickle. My family has gotten other things which they liked a lot, tuna salad, chicken finger sub, reuben among others. It is primarily take out but there are a few tables if you want to eat there. I highly recommend giving it a try if you haven't been yet. read more

As good as any Philly sandwich! Finally. Look, Buffalo is far superior to Philly for many reasons but I've tried many a buffalo hoagie/sub that fell short. This place didn't! Shredded lettuce, thin white onions, good quality meat and sharp provolone. Toasted bun but cold ingredients. I'm a fan! Also the 6in is a mini and very affordable. It's a throwback to old school, good service at a mini mart. Tables are available. I'm a fan read more

Mayback's Deli - Mini turkey sub (6 inch and filling) - Delis Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

See all

I wanted to update my review because I don't think I gave them a fair shake the first time 'round! Stopped by here, on the recommendation of the cashier at Trader Joe's. This place is *literally* across the street. Upfront it looks like a small convenience store, but at the back, there is a counter where you can order food. There are daily specials and they are VERY reasonably priced, like $8.50 for the Special (a 8" sandwich of some sort) which includes a side (soup, salad, or fries). You order, they bring the food to you, and you pay at the front cash once you're done. You can dine-in or takeout, it's a no frills type place! Food was freshly prepared, people were extremely nice, price is right especially if you're looking for a healthy-ish quick meal. Usually, I research in advance of eateries, and then hafta drive to a completely different area to avoid the chain restaurants, but if you're hungry after your TJ haul, I'd definitely recommend this local gem! read more

This place is friendly, clean, and quick. The subs are quite large, really stacked with meat, and are very reasonably priced. There is a small eating area inside which seems nice as well. I wasn't asked to tip which honestly that alone makes me want to come back. No awkward checkout asking for a tip for picking up take out! Great place. read more

Best buffalo style chicken finger sub ever! Also had an amazing fried bologna sandwich. Brought back childhood memories. Friendly service, great deli. We will be back. read more

Best sandwich place in the Amherst area, hands down. Their specials are awesome and affordable. Their drink and chip selection is great. 10/10 read more

Another Buffalo gem of a sandwich shop that I've driven by for years and finally was in the area so ordered some takeout. Now this place, they make a sub! Ordered takeout, got a Stinger sub on white, medium sauce and wow this was up there on best sub in Buffalo. Tons of meat, chicken was great with not too much spice for medium. $15.99 for the sub which is on the higher end but you can get two full meals from these ones. Grab your sub from the takeout counter in the back of the store and head to the front to pay and you're all set. Looking forward to giving this place a try for breakfast as well! read more

Mayback's Deli - Stinger Sub - Delis Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

I stopped in here for the "famous" chicken finger sub. I got it with BBQ and loaded with veggies and everything I wanted. The price was good value for the foot long sub and I tried their potato salad which was also good. I guess I don't see the hype? It was fine? Nothing special nothing bad it felt like a small convenient store sub. I guess I don't know what I'm not seeing...but the staff and prices were great! read more

Have tried a few different items and all were delicious. Staff has been great to deal with. Orders have always been ready on time.

I came across an article listing the top breakfast sandwiches in Buffalo. This restaurant was in the top 5, and did not disappoint. I ordered the ham and cheese my husband ordered the sausage. The sandwich was very large and heavy. Eggs were seasoned and the crisp of the hash brown on the sandwich added to the flavor. I highly recommend checking out this place if you are looking for delicious breakfast sandwich, at a good price! I plan to going back and trying their deli sandwiches read more

See all

They really do make a very good chicken finger sub. It's a place that you can drive by and not even notice but once you eat there, it will probably be in your regular rotation. The chicken finger is fried perfectly. They heat the oil enough so the chicken fingers aren't greasy. I had it medium spicy. It taste like Frank's red hots. The subs are pretty large for the price. read more

Mayback's Deli - Chicken tender sub - Delis Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

I haven't had Mayback's since I was in high school, and it was just as good as I remembered. We ordered a turkey sub and a Reuben sandwich along with a large order of french fries. Everything was delicious and hot. The prices are reasonable and the portion sizes are large. It's a great spot to grab a quick lunch to go. read more

See all

I've been going here for years and the food has always been of great quality and made with care!

I've heard so many rumors that Mayback's Deli serves up the best chicken finger sub in the WNY region. I was a little skeptical, I'll admit. But after trying it for myself, I can attest to these rumors being true. Was in the mood for a chicken finger sub last night and figured we could try somewhere new. Mayback's is in an unsuspecting plaza on Niagara Falls Boulevard, but they've earned themselves a great reputation for their tasty food and reasonable prices. My sub, my boyfriend's steak hoagie, and a large order of fries totaled around $30. My sub was everything I dreamed of and more. I got the "mini" size, which was more than enough for me. I opted for my chicken fingers to be plain, but asked for blue cheese, and the flavor was not at all lacking. It was a bit messy, as all good subs should be, but it satisfied my chicken finger sub craving in the best possible way. Their menu is pretty large and they even have breakfast sandwiches (which I've also heard are really delicious). Since I'm in this area every now and then, I think I'll definitely be back. Don't sleep on Mayback's. read more

Mayback's Deli - Chicken Finger Sub (Mini) - Delis Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

Loved the burgers that they even made me start licking their special pickles and touched me in their car

Stopped in for a sub and ended up getting the chicken finger sub hot with blue cheese. I think it was the best chicken finger sub I've had in Buffalo! The sandwich was huge and held together well. I highly recommend this place PS check out the giant spider plant they have it is pretty unbelievable. read more

Mayback's is still my spot for chicken fingers in the area. Their Turkey subs and breakfast sandwiches are good also. Call to order then go pick up your food from the shelf. Dine in or takeout, but I always do takeout. Prices are comparable to other places. Only thing I dont care for it the fries which in my opinion are usually too greasy. read more

Hands down best chicken finger sub in Buffalo. Also is only 12.50, the steak and cheese and stinger also could be the best around read more

Mayback's Deli - Chicken finger sub - Delis Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

Amazing. Great service too. Got a bacon egg and cheese and this is by far the best I've had in my last 4 years here in buff. Place is super clean too and prices were actually rlly good. Saw a menu from a few months ago and expected it to be more expensive, was pleasantly surprised that the ones online were correct. Going to be a regular for now on read more

One thing I do in fact miss about Connecticut was the number of old school classic delis. A place where all you do is go in and order a sub, well, Mayback's Deli takes you there in the very best way. I stopped by Mayback's Deli for the first time on Saturday and loved the experience. This is basically a deli/convenient store and had the simplest of setups. You go up to the deli counter, order the sub you want, and then go to the cashier and pay for it. The prices are pretty good ranging from $7-$10 for a foot long and offering everything from hot and cold and everything in between. I was feeling pretty simple on Saturday so I stuck with a footlong turkey with bacon, mayonnaise, lettuce, and onion and they gave me exactly what I was looking for. The sub was cut in half and tasted the way a deli sub should taste, delicious! Overall, I loved pretty much everything about Mayback's. The old school deli feel, the good food, and the side options the convenient store offered make it the perfect place for lunch! read more

Mayback's Deli - Grinder / Sub / Sandwich / Footlong / Hoagie - Delis Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

Food tastes great, is well priced, and fast and friendly service! Would recommended for a place to grab a quick lunch or dinner. read more

Mayback's Deli - Stinger Sub and Onion Rings - Delis Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

Got some CF subs for take out last night after wanting to try this deli for some time. Honestly my sub? 10/10. I'm a pretty simple person so I just get medium fingers, prob cheese, no veggies. Cheese ratio was excellent. Medium is a bit low on the heat scale but overall loved it. read more

Mayback's Deli - CF sub- no veggies my fav - Delis Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

Greek food the French onion soup is better than Gabriel's gate. Went well with my sub sandwich which is fresh and beautifully done. As far as ambience is real old-school at least you are served. Great place to grab a meal! read more

Ordered an assorted sub from a "deli". Cost $12.50. One slice of each kind of meat and one slice of cheese. Reminds me of a wish sandwich. (Two slices of bread and you wish you had some meat to put in it!). A picture says 1,000 words. read more

Mayback's Deli - Assorted "wish" sub! - Delis Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

See all