Mia's in Tom's River is located right on Route 27 in a small strip lot. There's parking in the lot and along the side street that connects to 37. I got some takeout on a Friday night at prime time and was told my order would be ready in 30 minutes. It was. The staff inside are very friendly and pickup was a breeze. Prices here are quite affordable. If you're staying along the island strip for a vacation, I highly recommend driving across the bridge and getting your pizza here. You'll have a more reasonable wait time. The fried calamari considered of large pieces, which I liked, but others may not. No tentacles either. The breading wasn't crisp, but I got takeout so I can't hold that against them. My kids enjoyed their traditional pie, which I got with half pepperoni. Good pizza indeed. The real standout for me was the Grandma's Sicilian! It had the crispiest crust I've ever had on a pizza. The topping was delicious, balanced and I really loved it!!! I could order this every time, but unfortunately I don't live in the area. No credit card fee here either. Highly recommended! read more

See all

Food was really good. Love the breadsticks served with marinara sauce given when you sit down. Veal and chicken entrees were very good. The restaurant has a small dining room, perfect to enjoy a quiet meal. Service was good, friendly and competent. read more

Mia's Pizza 37 - Chicken - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

Great Pizza and Food Always Cooked Rite Super Fast Delivery Too!! Highly Recommend Family Dinners and Grandma's Pizza read more

Great food and service ! Portions are always great and the bread is delicious! It's a hidden gem

Plus 6 stars the pizza is the best in town fabulous I m very picky But this one omg is fantastic Great job read more

Our favorite! Have been getting our pizza here for years. Have tried other places every once in awhile and then regret it.

Great pizzas but even better slices! Very consistent and always busy. They have managed to separate themselves in a crowded market by being consistent. read more

I've only had their pizza - and it's great! And they are not skimpy if you ask for extra toppings. And - service with a smile. what's not to like? read more

This was my first time ordering here and I'm glad I did. Very great customer services. Gives that big Italian family energy. I had a broccoli and ham calzone and it was really good. They had tables to eat inside but it seemed like more of a takeout place, but it was cute. They had lights outside making it very inviting. I'm looking forward to trying other food from here. read more

See all

Everything about the place was ordinary. Quality just not there. Very plain very average. I am sure there are many other pizza places near this worth trying before you decide on this place. Save your money read more

Another spectacular meal at Mia's Pizza 37 in #tomsriver We've returned to this Mia's for years as the food is so good. I am vegan and there are many #vegan or can be vegan options on the menu. I get the Focaccia Bread on the appetizer menu. It's an amazing thick, bread crust topped with sun dried tomatoes, fresh garlic, olive oil, oregano, and Rosemary & basil. It appears very simple with few ingredients, but along with the great crust, the magic is in the marinara dipping sauce. I top mine with the sauce and sprinkle generously with homemade #veganparmesan I bring from home. Yep. I cart a container of vegan Parmesan from Ohio to New Jersey just to add to this wonderful meal. It's worth it. I also order extra containers of their marinara sauce to take home to Ohio. It freezes great! Thank you Mia's 37 for another great meal in New Jersey! My husband also loves their fried #calamari and their cheese pies. Consistently, year after year excellent good food! read more

Mia's Pizza 37 - Focaccia Bread Appetizer - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

There is no shortage of pizzerias to choose from on Rt 37 in Toms River, in the years I've lived here I've tried them all. Hands down the best pizza is Mia's ! I pop in at least once a week and pick up a few huge slices to take home for my son and I. They are huge like you get at the boardwalk but are half the price and twice as good! Just this Christmas Eve I made a late order, didn't realize they were closing early and they totally accommodated me, the pie was amazing! I got a hot sub too and it was delicious. I love supporting family owned businesses and Mia's is the best! read more

very good food. very fast service and delivery. always tasty pizza. garlic knots good too. :)

Great service, in a family atmosphere. Salad was perfectly cold and crisp. Veal Marsala was plentiful and delicious. It's a BYOB. Getting food was a little slow but you know it's freshly cooked, especially when you hear them pounding your veal. A definite must try, prices are very reasonable. read more

Fantastic pizza. Love these people. My favorite is the buff chick pie. They know how to take care of their customers

I've been looking for good pizza and I found my place! Everything I have gotten on the menu is good and fresh

Food is great and the staff is very nice. We also love the Wednesday nights pizza special

Always yummy! Our favorite items are the white pie (ordered "thin with extra garlic"), the meatball Parmesan sub, the chicken, California sandwich, and the pepperoni calzone. Always good! read more

Too much cheese on the pizza. Not enough sauce. It was floppy and not cooked enough. We ordered large pie half pep half plain. Could barely eat one slice without the cheese choking you. read more

The margarita pie is disgusting Mia's in seaside heights is great other than that everything's the same

Best pizza and the best Mia's !!! The one in ortley is nothing like Ry 37 ! The staff is so friendly the food is always amazing the pizza is made perfectly I highly suggest taking the ride to Mia's in Tom's river read more

Never had an issue. Pizza is great but they can not get their orders straight. Forgot our garlic knots so we called and they went out of their way to deliver more to us. Turns out they got the order WRONG again and the girl was nasty to me on the phone as I was trying to explain to her what had happened. She hung up on me. Not a great sign for business. We will give it another try because we love their pizza and the delivery driver was extremely nice. read more

ALWAYS comes in clutch with great food and fast delivery !! Grilled chicken roasted red peppers and mozzarella cheese sub .. 10/10 recommend

So far I've had the regular cheese pizza was really good. Then last night we ordered the White Clams Casino pizza and a large Antipasto. The pie was slamming, just the right amount of toppings and I even think their dough is good. Salad was filled and so worth it. To be honest looking at their prices and so far what we have gotten their prices are great. Well worth it!!! read more

I get their special lg pie on weds with extra cheese and it's only 10.65 with lots of cheese... Good pizza, but all I've eaten there... read more

We used to order here a lot from my old job, and i LOVED the creamy chicken and potato soup. However, beware during the summer, we would find FLIES in our soup. We contacted the business to advise the 2nd time this happened, and his response was that it was hot so they leave the door open. He would NOT dump the soup because he did not think it had been compromised. Eat at your own risk... read more

Delivery took nearly 2 hours on a Wednesday night. Ordered at 630 pizza arrived cold must have been sitting in the car! Usually good food not tonight! read more

The best pizza around. The location may be difficult to spot, but the food more than makes up for it.

We ordered our pizza around 5:50 and were told via their email to expect it around 6:30. We ended up getting the pizza around 35 minutes late. When we called the store around 6:50 to see where it was, we were told it had just left about 10 minutes ago. We were suspicious as we live about 5 minutes away, 7 if you hit a red light. When we got the pizza, it was obvious it had sat while they either talked and waited to deliver it, the delivery driver dillydallied or they just waited for them to get back because the cheese was solidified on the pizza and was easy to peel off and was slightly above room temperature. read more

I like this place! They have nice family deals..for those nights you need to get dinner on table in no time! Pizza's are great, and delivery usually pretty quick - ordering online is available to make it even easier! read more

First time I every tried this place. I have to say the pizza is great!!! Clam casino pie was the favorite!!! Calamari was ok but probably better if eaten there. Hard to keep crisp on delivery. Wings were just ok. The Anita's salad... Ordered a small but boy was it packed!!! Plenty of chicken,fresh mozz,& roasted peppers. Overall we all loved it!!! Definitely our new pizza place of choice. read more

Wednesday, Pizza special... first time ordered here, and unfortunately the last. The bottom crust fell into pieces like a puzzle & hard as a rock... it was very salty and shaped like a football in the box. I guess it's the ,you get what you pay for. When I walked in to pick it up, not a soul said hello, nor thank you when I left. There is so much competition on Rt. 37, going to try some place else next time. read more