We were on our way down to Vero Beach and found this place close to the highway to stop for a bite to eat. The staff was super friendly when we went in and helped us to find a table since they were very busy. My husband and I shared a white pizza with mushrooms and spinach. It was cooked perfectly with a slightly crispy crust. My youngest decided to try the calamari and she really enjoyed it. The oldest had a small salad since she was not hungry. She said the dressing was good and the salad was crisp. The inside is small, but they do have a few tables and booths to sit and eat. There is some seating as well if you are waiting for a to go order. Again all the staff is super amazing and friendly. read more

Have just recently made the decision that I'm not messing around with ANY OTHER PIZZA JOINT except Michelli's from here on in. It simply is THE CLOSEST you can get to NY-LONG ISLAND style pizza in FL. The bite, the chew, that perfect density of the dough meeting hot and oily cheese....its just the best. We travel out of our way to eat a pie and some knots whenever we're in town for a movie at the AMC. It's easy to see why this place has a steady stream of customers all day long. Love it. read more

See all

Cozy, traditional pizzeria with lots of good-looking menu items. Hubby and I ordered two slices each. My favorite was the Meatball slice (on the server's recommendation). My hubby enjoyed the sausage and pepperoni. We really liked the crust, but the texture of the cheese was a little off. There was no cheese pull, and the slices were hot out of the oven. The service was very friendly and welcoming. I would definitely return to try other items on the menu. read more

Michelli's Pizzeria - Plain, meatball, pepperoni and sausage slices - Pizza Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

What happened to your crust? We are long time fans, but tonight's pizza was nothing like it was a few months ago? The crust is like cardboard. read more

We decided to order the New Yorker pizza with alfredo sauce tonight because we knew it was going to be delicious, and man were we blown out of the water. We keep ordering from here again and again because it's great every time!! Top tier 100/10, best Alfredo sauce in town (we chose to switch the actual pizza sauce to Alfredo) ! Thank you Michelli's Pizzeria! read more

See all

I was impressed from the start, as the woman who took my order over the phone was an absolute gem. Then when I went to pick up my order, the place was super clean, to the point where I couldn't even see the glass case, it was so clean! The staff was friendly, and helpful. And best of all, the pizza was delicious! We're new to the area, looking for our new go-to pizza place. We've tried others and now we have to look no further! Highly recommend! read more

We drove over to this restaurant because my husband wanted a meatball sub, and their reviews stated theirs were the best around. Sadly, the sub was a huge disappointment. It was small and the bread was burnt around the edges. Not only that, it was tasteless, except for being extremely salty. Also, beware that the menu on their website is seven years old, along with the prices. My husband couldn't finish half of it and said it was horrible and the worst sub he ever had in his life. read more

They make a Sicilian Pizza just as good as Brooklyn!! They make Italian food almost like Momma

Excellent quality food. One of the best restaurants in Brevard County! I love the eggplant parmesan and their buttery garlic rolls.

Winner winner: NY-style pizza. Cheese pie Finally, the real thing in the Melbourne area! read more

Food 4/5 super great. Never ready on time. Super great specials. Service: 5/5 everyone is kind. It's your neighborhood pizza shop. Ambiance 1/5 nothing to write home about. Better to get take out than to eat in. read more

Came back for a round two one the bbq chicken bacon pizza and some mozz sticks ! Everything is so amazing ! Def check them out sorry we destroyed the mozz sticks before I could get a full pic! read more

See all

My wife and I went to this establishment yesterday and we're greeted as soon as we walked in hospitality is great as well as the food. My wife had eggplant Parmesan with pasta which she greatly enjoyed and I got the spaghetti and meatballs, which is excellent. It comes with garlic knots, as well as a salad. We were also greeted by Michele who is a very gracious lady and I think the owner that always make you feel as if you're part of the family and you're always well treated as well as a service is always excellent locally they have some of the best Italian food you can have. I'd like to thank you Michele as well as your staff for all the great service and hospitality my wife and I will be back. read more

Since I have moved down from the north, I have been trying to find good New York style pizza. Most places are "ok". But I have recently tried Michelle's pizza in Melbourne. I don't usually leave reviews unless the food and service were terrible or excellent. Michell's was definitely excellent. I finally found a place that meets my northern expectations. Lol. I highly recommend them. read more

The calzone, meatballs and garlic knots were EXCELLENT! Loved the Alfredo and Marinara - both full of flavor and perfect consistency! Definitely will order again and would certainly recommend! read more

We order from michelli's pretty often for a few years now and they've always been fantastic! Recently they got our food to us so fast that we hadnt even made it home yet! Eileen went above and beyond to make sure our pizza stayed hot and fresh and got to us immediately after we arrived home! the food is great but the service is even better!!!! read more

The two pizzas were very good. Friendly service or a busy pre holiday day. It would be great if it was a full service restaurant. read more

I really love Michellis! As soon and you walk in, you are always greeted with a hello and a smile! It's got a very hometown feel and the server is always ready to walk you through the menu if you have any questions. They have daily specials and their pizza is pretty amazing! You have to try a cannoli or two! read more

Some of the best take out Italian in town. Prices are fair and portions are huge making it well worth the cost. Their specials are great deals. They are so busy you need to order early and be patient for service. No eat in available so not much to be said about ambiance but staff are always friendly. read more

Great pizza, wings are awful. I make better wings at home with a deep fryer and frozen wings from Costco.

I love this place. Cheese bread is amazing, and the Alfredo sauce is out of this world! who am I kidding everything is great.

Food was good but not great. Disappointed to find out we were shorted two salads in our pickup order. Too late to do much after you get home and find out. read more

Great pizza. Avoid ordering online if you want it ready when they say it will be. Otherwise it won't start until you arrive to pick up

The best in Brevard everyone is so sweet!! service is quick and the food is Absolutely delicious!!! thank you read more

Michelli's Pizzeria - Baked Ziti and fried ravioli - Pizza Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

I am an original Brooklyn NewYorker. I know delicious pizza wherever I go. Michelli's is the place for me. The entrees on the menu are all excellent choices dinner or lunch. If they only sold zepollis! Baked ziti is also my go to meal especially on the weekends. Keep up the great service. I'll always come back for more. Thanks read more

Great pizza and friendly staff. I order through pick-up and wait times are decent + accurate. Highly recommend and worth a visit. Pic attached was a really good 20" read more

Michelli's Pizzeria - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

First time ordering from here and won't be in a rush to order again. I ordered the small Stromboli with a side greek salad. The salad should be called a micro salad. This portion did not fit the price point. The stromboli was mediocre and the pepperoni was more like beef jerky. My girlfriend ordered the pepperoni calzone and the ricotta was the consistency of milk and ran out of it when she cut it in half. Her pepperoni was the same as mine. Overall, the value was just not there for the quality of the order. For the price, it should have been better. It seemed like it was thrown together with not much care. The food was mediocre at best. read more

Anything you get from here is quality! Service and delivery is super... ambiance is good but not really a done in place... couple of tables... but truly food is great! read more

Ordered wings , pizza and stromboli wings well sauced best wings ever .Stromboli is huge awesome good.pizza is excellent to.

This has become our number one go-to for excellent pizza. I don't order from the other places anymore because Michelli's has checked off every box when it comes to the ultimate pizza! The crust- oh, so crispy, not doughy or heavy, with a nice flavor. The sauce is perfectly seasoned and there's just the right amount to coat the dough, but not too much to make it soggy. Same with the cheese- just the right amount to give you a great bite without choking. I know, I know, the cheese-lovers may want to order extra, but I believe there needs to be a balance iall of the ingredients to make for the "just right" pizza experience. Yes, I'm getting technical about my pizza! If you've never tried Michelli's for their pizza, then you're missing out. They blow away the competition, in my book. read more

Ordered short notice for our Managers meeting.. the food was fresh & hot .. everyone raved about my choice for restaurant and hopefully you've gained a few new customers! Thank you! read more

This has become our number one go-to for excellent pizza. I don't order from the other places anymore because Michelli's has checked off every box when it comes to the ultimate pizza! The crust- oh, so crispy, not doughy or heavy, with a nice flavor. The sauce is perfectly seasoned and there's just the right amount to coat the dough, but not too much to make it soggy. Same with the cheese- just the right amount to give you a great bite without choking. I know, I know, the cheese-lovers may want to order extra, but I believe there needs to be a balance in all of the ingredients to make for the "just right" pizza experience. Yes, I'm getting technical about my pizza! If you've never tried Michelli's for their pizza, then you're missing out. They blow away the competition, in my book. read more

Michelli's Pizzeria - Half & half. Double mushroom & pepperoni, onion & bacon. Mmmmm - Pizza Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

The best pizza, I'm telling you it's just like Pennsylvania pizza. The sauce and the dough is amazing. The cheese is to die for. I order from there once a week and it always so good read more

It's usually hard coming from New York and not getting the pizza you really want in this area however Michellis is the closest you can get to New York! They did deliver what I asked. I got the menu in the mail and yes it worked I tried you guys out and I definitely enjoy the pizza. I got 6 garlic knots rolls for 3.95$ and the large crispy pizza cost me about 13.95$ and the soda . Very affordable and really good. In this area I always asked for a crispy pizza and I could never get it but I ordered Michellis on a busy Friday night and they did what you asked them how you want your so thank you for that I really appreciate you guys! read more

Michelli's Pizzeria - Crispy pizza Large 13.95$so good - Pizza Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

See all

Just tried this place last weekend. The margarita pizza and garlic knots are delicious! The service was great as well. We will definitely be going back to try another pizza! read more

Great people and good food and service. Need to try. When I'm up in Melbourne I always plan to eat there

Not sure how long Michelli's has been around, but for some reason it's gone completely under our radar, at least until we got the flyer in the mail (hey- it worked!). There are very few pizza places in Brevard that I think are worth going back to again -- all are no less than 25 minutes from our home in south West Melbourne -- and I thought we'd exhausted them all. Side note, we're originally from Indiana and while you wouldn't think of it as some sort of pizza Mecca, it kind of is... think Arni's, Bazbeaux, Pizza King, Noble Romans-- and of course close access to some of the best Chicago pizza around. Anyway, we've been jonesing for something close to some of the kinds I just listed and we always come up short. At the very least, we'd love for a chain like Jets to come closer bc we grew up on the deep dish style (which reminds me... I miss Garcia's!) but Brevard doesn't seem to care about that style. Too many east coast folks, I guess. Back to Michelli's. I'm was excited to see Sicilian style in the menu and more than willing to give it a shot. I was also excited to see some toppings and styles reminiscent of Bazbeaux, like artichokes, broccoli, Quattro formaggio, etc. I ordered a Sicilian with a bunch of weird toppings. Maybe not a "typical" Sicilian but it still worked. The flavor was good. It tasted fresh and the sauce was delicious. It was also one huge pizza! For $40, I suppose I would expect it to be (I did order a bunch of toppings, of which at least half were premium, and that's really what shot up the price). My only complaint -- and it's kind of a big one, but bc it was good otherwise I'm more than willing to overlook as a one-time thing -- is that the crust was overcooked to the point of being black in many spots on the bottom. The result was a super chewy and somewhat dry crust. Next time I order I will point this out -- based on everything else being so good, I expect that this is not the norm. read more

Honestly they have the besttttttttt calzone in town hands down!! The little dust that they sprinkle on top gets me every time

Nothing beats authentic Italian food and that's exactly what you get at Michelle's. Friendly workers who are eager to please. A+++

Excellent food Great service , friendly staff . Walgreens store 3090 W. New Haven , W. Melbourne 32904 . MGMT staff and Customer Associates we love you all read more