It's challenging to find trustworthy service, products and pricing. Mike is the real deal, great character, expertise, precise work with fair pricing for all. I have been dropping by for one or two things here and there, across 4-5 vehicles in the last decade, and he never disappoints. I can always get serviced within a reasonable timeframe, and expect work to be completed in a reasonable timeframe as well. I now own a Tesla, who would have towed my vehicle for free to one of their dealerships, to replace my tire for several hundred dollars... instead of expertly fixing a perfectly good tire, like Mike did. Worth the personal I arranged. I trust Mike with any and every vehicle we'll ever own! read more

Worst service ever! People are not friendly, no respectful, very rude! They sold me a wrong size of tires. I am an old woman and that place took advantage of my kindness. I am very upset. read more

Mighty Mike's is a great family-owned shop if you want great customer service professional installs I highly recommend they got me on the road with my F-250 got myself a brand new set of Cooper Tires excellent customer service. Mike Schilling is awesome read more

Mighty Mike's Tires - Tires Near Me - Saint John, Indiana

See all

Over a year ago we bought a new set of tires for our Toyota Rav because we were moving our daughter cross country. Otherwise we do not use this vehicle much. Mighty Mike's was recommended to us and we were happy with the service, the quality of the tires, and the price! Over a year later, we got a nail in our tire and had a slow leak. The owner fixed our tire and gave us a free tire rotation! We highly recommend this small but "mighty" business. read more

Went in to this small local business to get my tire plugged. I had a nail in the tire. I walked in and was helped right away. Within minutes my tire was plugged for 25$ and filled my tires with air and im on my way! Great job guys! read more

These folks are the best. Very helpful, great tires and pricing. This is the tire store you should consider.

VERY friendly, knowledgeable and efficient. The value is great and the service is 2nd to none. They are the go to for anything tires for sure. read more

I showed 20 minutes after closing time on a Saturday and a couple owner/employees wer still in office i asked if they could plug my tire and they wer very accommodating even after hours and i ended up enjoying conversation with them for awhile after tire was repaired great people ! Highly recommended read more

Quick, friendly, honest service at an affordable price. They are family owned so they perform as if their livelihoods depend upon it and it shows. Highly recommend this place. read more

Great service with excellent prices. Mike is a real good guy and takes care of his customers. I will be back in the future.

This tire shop is always busy and does great work. They repaired my flat and rotated my tires all for $25! And very fast too! I'll be a repeat customer. read more

We received the best customer service from Mighty Mike's Tires. They were able to replace the tire in a timely manner and their price was very reasonable. I highly recommend this family owned business. read more

My dad had been going here for years. Nothing but the best service and great staff. Mike is a great guy definitely takes care of his customers. I've recently went there to get my tpms sensor reprogrammed, they were super busy and said to come back. But then as I was leaving Mike came out and took care of me. Great place to go 100% satisfied. Its small businesses like these that we need more of and need to support. read more

Mike is one of the nicest guys I have ever met. Super friendly, wonderful service and very reasonable prices. This is a man who will never take advantage of another human being. Over the years I have purchased several sets of tires here for my car and my wife's and kids cars. Always the best service for the best price. Lastly the Mastercraft tires are a great bang for the buck. Made by Cooper right here in the USA. Support a great man and a great local business. You won't regret it! read more

Mighty Mike's Tires - Tires Near Me - Saint John, Indiana

I would give this place 10 stars if I could. Called early in the morning, within a few hours they picked up my car put four new tires on it and dropped it back off in my driveway all in less than an hour. He even brought my garbage cans back up my drive ! Great business ! Don't see that too often anymore ! Highly highly recommend ! read more

If Yelp had 7 stars I would give them to you. Recently had my 2001 Dodge repaired by your shop. It was done in a a quick timeframe and reasonably priced. Not only that- the car runs smoothly! I have had tires repaired at this shop before and the guys are pleasant and have great customer service. I plan on doing all my oil changes and routine maintenance at this place. Thank you read more

I decided to try mighty Mike's after reading the reviews on every website I checked. I'm very disappointed I can only give Mike five stars. If I could give him 10 stars I would have. I was in a Zoom meeting and I had a five minute break. I live in Saint John and I called mighty Mike's. Mike called me back and we agreed on a price and he said I can come get your car, and I can try to get your car aligned. I said sure. So he came back about five hours later with my car tires installed and my car aligned. When he came back he said, do you know you have a turn signal out? And he took the car back to the shop and replaced my light for me and only charged me an additional $10. And by the way, the tires are perfect. His recommendation was spot on. I will never shop at any other tire store While mighty mikes is in business. read more

Mighty Mike's Tires offers the absolute best deal you can ever find anywhere anytime. He easily saved me about $150+ on my set of 265/75R truck tires which were made in the USA and got me an additional $50 manufacturer rebate. He picked up my car at my home and had it back in about 3 hours fully serviced. Additionally, I had two tire rims missing caps but he found some and replaced them for me for no extra charge. Mike and his staff are committed to their customers' satisfaction. If there is any problem they work with you to resolve it. This local business is on my speed dial now!! Best customer experience ever!! read more

I'm so glad a friend of mine recommended Mighty Mike's! My car slid on some ice a few days ago and hit a curb, tearing up my front passenger hubcap. Mighty Mike's assured me that there was no damage to my wheel/rim and even went the extra mile to check all my tires and offer advice on replacing my hubcap should I ever decide to do so. I'm grateful for the fast, friendly and honest customer service I received and would most definitely recommend Mighty Mike's! read more

Great service great price. I highly recommend using this station for fixing vehicles.

I pulled into Mikes shop with a nail in my tire and within 10 mins I was out the door with it fixed! Such a kind and helpful man! Thank you!

I took my wife's Escape to Mighty Mikes this morning to have her winter tires installed . Mike started on it just a few minutes after I arrived . He was done in less than an hour. Did an outstanding job at a very fair price. Offered some great tire advice . Very nice man excellent friendly service. Very impressive service. read more

We've lived in St John for 5 years. I stumbled upon this place by accident a few months after moving here at 6pm on a Saturday, a flat tire on 41, three sleeping babies in the car and to top it off - in the pouring rain. I pulled in and saw they were closed but Mike came walking out smiling and said he was going to make sure we were taken care of right then and there. We've been back several times since then and have always received the best possible service and have never been overcharged. Mike is a friendly guy with great stories about his life and travels and he treats everyone who walks through his doors like family. read more

go here for tires!! owner Mike will go out of his way to get you the best tires for your truck or car!! He goes the extra mile. Has a great car repair shop also!! read more

I've been there a few times now. This guy is gold! He won't do an upsell and won't do a thing without considering the age of your vehicle, your driving requirements, etc. Like old-fashioned actual customer care, something we're without nowadays. He's friendly and can actually relate to people. Amazing! I'm a customer for life. read more

I needed 6 tires for my Silverado dually, I shopped around at all the usual places like tire barn, discount tires etc. stumbled across Mighty Mikes tires. He beat all the other places prices by $300 or more. And they weren't tires from Japan or who knows where. Mastercraft tires made in the USA by cooper. He doesn't try to upsell or have any fancy gimmicks like nitrogen filled tires. I also had Chimos auto repair ( they are in the same building as mighty mikes) change 2 serpentine belts on my truck after Mike was done with the tires. They didn't try selling me stuff I didn't need. They ordered the belts, installed them and that was it. I am 60 years old and have been to a lot of tire stores and mechanical shops in my day. These two places put ALL the others to shame. These days it's not commonplace to find truthful and honest businesses, but Mighty Mikes and Chimos are exactly that. I just wish I had found them years ago. They will be getting by business from now on. read more

I had a slow leak in my tire. I was actually just looking for a place to air it back up until I could get it fixed the next day since I had all of my children in the car and it was already late in the day. I pulled into Mighty Mikes not even realizing it was a TIRE place... I had actually seen the gas tanks in front and was praying that there would be an air pump. I was glad that I pulled in by accident though because I got the royal treatment!!! Mike walked out and was super friendly. I knew it was past his closing time (6:30 and he closed at 6 according to the sign on the door) and asked him what time I could drop by the next day to get my tire repaired. He told me to stop right where I was, stay in the car, keep the kids in the car, that he would fix it right there. I told him I could come back the next day and his kind response was "Why? You are here now and you need a tire fixed." I asked if I should pull the car into the garage and he said no, that he would bring everything to me. He jacked the car up, took the tire off, repaired it and put it back on in a very short amount of time. He brought pink suckers out for each of my girls and talked a little about his own grandchildren and how much he enjoyed children before telling me how much the service was. His price was sooo low that I felt bad only paying him that much. I will definitely go back the next time I have a tire problem. He told me to remember him the next time I need gas, too. He said he is a full service station. I haven't seen one of those since I was a little girl. I haven't been there for gas though because I don't drive by there very often. By the way,he doesn't take credit cards but does accept cash or check so remember if you go there! read more