You HAVE to have restaurant reservations on weekends, dinner, and holidays or the manager/hostess…read moreCarol will lecture you and correct you to call her Carol instead of Ma'am. Our waitress was so fast, friendly, and knowledgeable about everything on the menu. Very loud bar, but nice comfy old fashioned dining room separated from it. Great alcohol selection including non alcohol beer. Juicy perfectly cooked and seasoned steak over noodles with a cream sauce. Amazing creamy buffalo chicken over 3 cheese mac'n'cheese. Decent garlic bread stick. We promise to have reservations next time!

My husband and I went here for dinner over the summer, while camping in Allegany. I loved the small…read moretown charm so much. I rented a room upstairs in the Fall and joined my parents while camping on the red house side.

We selected Finnerty's Tap Room for an early Saturday evening dinner based on the promise that they…read moreGluten Free very seriously (I found this claim on their website). Finding any GF options when visiting small towns can be a challenge so I'm really thankful to have found Finnerty's! We ordered: - Jalapeño Poppers (for my gluten-consuming husband) - Stuffed Banana Peppers (Gluten Free) - Chicken Wings ordered well done with hot sauce (Gluten Free) - Smash Burger on Gluten Free Sesame Bun & Chips - Hamburg Carrot Cake Brown Ale (for my Gluten-consuming husband) There were only 3 Jalapeño Popper left so our server didn't charge us for them. They were your run-of-the-mill frozen poppers; nothing special. The Stuffed Banana Peppers were a special for the day and they were pretty delicious. They were cheesy, stuffed with sausage and topped with a delicious tomato red sauce. The Chicken Wings were well done, as we requested but were average which was a surprise considering all of the claims to be award winning. The Gluten Free Sesame Bun was one of the best GF buns I've had but the burger patties were average. The meat didn't seem like it was seasoned but the cheese and grilled onions helped add some flavor. Not worth $15.95, in my opinion especially because you have to pay $1.50 each for any additional toppings and it only comes with generic potato chips. The Hamburg Carrot Cake Brown Ale was listed on the draft beer list but was served in a can. Our server was attentive and had a kind/sweet personality. Here's a few highlights about the space: - Pool Table - Golden Tee Golf Video Game - Hockey Foosball Table Game - Old Arcade Video Game - 8+ TVs; I believe they're usually tuned into sports. - Music was really loud; it was somewhat difficult to hear our server. Overall, I would come here again when visiting Ellicottville and try other menu items - like the Gluten Free Pizza and whatever their daily special happens to be.

Drinks where good, staff was great! Unfortunately, the same can not be said for the owner. She was…read morerude, disrespectful, and had us carded 3 times for no apparent reason. Everything else about the place was great!

Come for the booze, stay for the Dolly. Easy pub-grub, good drinks. Everything you want after a day…read morehunting in the extreme elements. Ambiance: Rustic B+ Value: A Quality: B Service: A++++ Overall an amazing experience.

Our family went to dinner tonight and it was disgusting. The service was HORRIBLE! The food was…read moreworse. I ordered Chicken Alfredo and was served egg noodles with some sort of un edible Alfredo sauce. It is very sad what has come of that restaurant. I DO NOT RECOMMEND and we will never go back. We also had to turn the lights on in the entry way OURSELVES so we could see where we were walking. The place is a joke.

Walking in it is a Bar. Now after you get past the bar there is a lot of seating. It is very…read morewelcoming once you get by the bar. The waitress was the friendliest person I have seen in this area in a long time. The food was amazing. I got the pull my finger chicken and pulled pork sandwich. It was huge and a lot more than I could eat at one sitting. I also got the buffalo chicken dip and may have filled up a little before I got my sandwich. We will be back here again even if it's out of the way. Great food with great service is hard to find these days.

The Icelandic haddock scampi style was EPIC. If you love drawn butter, this is the meal for you…read more Also, the Friday beer battered fish was HUGE, with yummy sides. Both meals were so affordable. Best fish in the Southern Tier!! Thank You, Randy's for making our date night great!!!

Strange day in town with a power outage impacting nearly half the business district limiting dining…read moreoptions. Ended up here by default and it turned out not to be a bad thing. Decor is a throw back to the days of, well Gin Mills. Woody and cute. Service was quick and friendly with an extensive menu explained by our waitress. Went with the Gin Mill Special version of beef on weck and I would recommend you do the regular version instead. Found the cheese detracts from the beef, the onion strands not noticeable and it just makes things messier. Wings were good and crisp. The fried pickles were fabulous and everyone was more than satisfied with their meals.

We're there yesterday and problem the service very poor. No silverware on the table , no water…read moreoffered, order mix up, no coffee refill asked and no waitress follow to see how things were. Burger was good but service very poor. Busses answered our requests better and was hospitable and uo beat .

We need a break from the usual places in the city so we took a trip down to ski country…read more We walked in and noticed we were the first customers in there. We took a seat in the back with a view of the mountains and started to watch the skiers. The dining area was large and clean, and the waitress came and got our food and drink orders moving quickly. Our little yelper opted for none other than the children's tenders. She ate almost all of them and the fries, they got a thumbs up review. The waitress was even nice enough to hook our kid up with a nice helping of pickles too. The misses opted for the pulled pork melt, even with the mafia sauce she told me it was rather bland in the flavor department but the onion rings were sizable and crispy. I opted for the chicken Caesar salad, but there was some miscommunications in the kitchen and I wound up with steak (not a bad thing) but our waitress asked if it was ok. Steak was cooked perfectly and the salad itself was piled high. Overall, not a bad dining experience, it should be a 3 , but the awesome service took it up a notch. She really helped make the meal more enjoyable.

Terrible, unhappy I came here on my ski trip with kids-…read more Ordered Caesar salad and was served a bowl of lettuce. Plain lettuce. Weird and sad. Wings (12 in an order with celery) came with 10, no celery, no sauce, and overcooked. Do not recommend. We are leaving and are still hungry. Waste of 50 dollars. Dining area very cold. We had our coats on while eating.

The Scarlet Vetter says....This place is fabulous. I have been to a few events here now and had a…read moregreat time and delicious food at all of them. The bar is open and airy and the drinks generous. The artisian pizzas are mouth watering. At a recent event they served vegetarian and meat options and they just kept coming. Crisp and chewy crusts, wonderful flavors and visually stunning. Their craft beers are worth the trip alone. I wish this location was open more hours. I would definately make a special trip for this one, it will not dissapoint.

My husband and I came for our anniversary dinner and ordered fish fries. We remembered how amazing…read moreit was the last time we came and wished to relive the experience. It was an unfortunate choice. The fish was "small" at best and the fries tasted like generic frozen style fries that were way over salted. The waitress was attentive but the food was not worth the price or the visit. Will not return.

In town for a Christmas tree I ordered Petes to go. Awesome HUGE juicy burger with amazing cheese…read moremelting right off and the best Cajun mushrooms I can find above the mason Dixon line. The place is obviously a local hang out. Great price with awesome portions. This is seriously a no frill perfect the way it is monster burger. Will be back

Great Burger. The biggest and best Burger in Randolph great place owners ensure food it of high…read morequality