There's a reason why this shop has all 5 star reviews, with the one exception being a guy that…read moredidn't even make it through the door because he didn't show up during their normal hours. The guys inside running this place: Alex, Frank and the hipster dude with huge holes in his ears... are all top notch. Professional, knowledgeable and very helpful! If they've got it, they'd love to sell it to you. If they don't, they'll get it for ya! I'm a new customer in a time that's unprecedented due to the widespread uncertainty and unease... and these guys make you feel welcome and at home. (That is... if you get through the door. Currently the line outside rivals a free BJ booth) You will not regret going here, they are the best in the area and I'm not surprised to have met many customers this week that returned from other parts of NY state (and beyond). Tip: Ask Alex for the patchouli gun oil for a secret discount

Somewhat over priced and very hectic in there but the guys are pretty helpful and knowledgeable…read more Parking is a PITA . Hard to see pricing the way the stores set up for the long guns . Good selection on pistols

Great experience for newbie pistol buyer. Took the time to explain different brands of pistols and…read moretheir characteristics and try handling different ones for comfort. Highly recommended.

I tagged along with my cuz who has purchased a pistol along with a few accessories but most…read more important was the training and advice he received that was key in understanding the importance of handling a firearm and the responsibility along with it . I am waiting for my carry permit but when I do receive it , it's vintage arms in Yonkers that will be the place for me as I asked the gentleman who helped my cuz some questions and he explained the whole process to me in simple English From A to Z. Will add and update my review when I get my permit that for years was harder to get then an invite to the White House .4.5 stars on my yelp meter .

Buy my guns only from this place, Miguel is well educated on all brands and calibers, process…read morepaperwork for the NYPD download, gets it done in a timely fashion, no Pressure sales, extremely accommodating, best deals around, ask for Miguel, you will be very impressed

Highly professional and knowledgeable...extremely helpful and authoritative in all aspects of…read morerequirements for legal carry in NY; highly and enthusiastically recommended...OUTSTANDING!!

People who left negative reviews on here expect people to do magic to meet their needs or something…read more. Best and friendliest place I've been to in years great people and nothing but positive energy at this place!!

Everything about them is perfect no complaints at all really nice people, the owner and his son are…read morevery helpful and knowledgeable! 100% going back to this guys

Just purchased 2 firearms from Ottomanelli's Sporting Arms. Walther PDP Pro Comp X and the HK CC9…read morein Tungsten. Dave Matusik was my sales rep and couldn't be more helpful and informative. This was my first purchase here and will now be my go-to for any firearms needs. The staff is great and the selection is even better. Thank you for making my day.

Everything went well. We visited this store back in Dec '25, and spoke to Kris. He gave us valuable…read moreinfo on how and where to apply for a handgun permit. I did so, and by Feb '26, we went back to buy a gun through him. He was not there, so we asked if they carry a particular gun. They did, and gave us further valuable info. They didn't have the one we wanted in stock, and we wanted Kris to help us anyway, but they were scheduled to have a shipment in 4 weeks. So we returned yesterday and this time Kris was there and he helped us buy the gun of our choice. To say that everyone who works there is extremely helpful and friendly, is an understatement. All the employees are active or retired law enforcement and it's a very safe-feeling store. I've never felt that secure anywhere. We are returning in a few days to pick it up, bc there's a background check waiting period, for which I'm grateful. Kris has so much information and is highly qualified to answer all our questions. We were very happy. You really can't find a better place to purchase any type of gun. Thank you Ottamanelli's!!!!

Very helpful and friendly staff. I have purchased several firearms from that shop, both by ordering…read moreonline and by choosing one right in the store. They've been helpful with advice on training, the law, safety and accessories. They are knowledgable, professional and courteous. A very safe environment. Some of the same staff works in the range downstairs and teaches at the school upstairs.

Great people working here and they were very helpful . Prices are fair and they work hard to…read moresatisfy their customers .

A small shop very knowledgeable very friendly always upfront with you have done business with them…read morenumerous times and will continue doug l

An absolute hidden 2A Gem in North Jersey! This shop is very welcoming with fair prices for…read moretraining, gunsmithing and all firearms needs. Leo is great and he bears wealth of experience and expertise in laws, self defense, ballistics and firearms! The bonus is he's right down the road from New Jersey's best diner!

I had an outstanding experience with Paul (Gunsmith @46) --true craftsmanship at its finest. The…read moreattention to detail, precision, and care put into the work was immediately noticeable, and the final result exceeded my expectations. Communication was clear and professional throughout the process. If you're looking for someone who takes pride in doing the job right, this is the place to go. He truly is second to none

Love my new concealed carry holster for my SIG P65 XL feels great thanks for shipping to NCread more