Great people, great service. Now called Steve Shannon…read more I mostly go for tires, but they are fully equipped to handle whatever you've got going on.

Matt was friendly on the phone and we met the next day he was very helpful and added lots of humor!…read moreThank you again!

Summary: Dave's Service Center is an automobile repair, used car sales, car rental, and U-Haul…read morebusiness. I've only used their auto repair services before, so my review only reflects upon that. Cost: Very very fair. I never ever feel like I'm being charged extra for either parts or labor. I don't know what kind of parts are used to repair cars here, but I don't ever feel like I'm getting shoddy quality parts either. In fact, and I'm not saying they do this all the time, I've went to get my fluids checked before and they've done it for free AND topped off a couple of them free of charge. How many places do that? Experience: I have nothing negative to say about Dave's. Dave and his son (and the other employee's I've encountered) are absolutely fantastic. They've been really friendly and informative the entire time to by myself and my fiancee. I've learned quite a bit about my car and as mentioned above, never feel like I've gotten ripped off. I do all my oil changes here and repairs (I've had a couple exhaust repairs and a couple wheel repairs) and am always quoted with costs consistent with low prices on car forums online. Overall: If you're in Geneva, NY and need auto repair done, go to Dave's. Don't mess around with Monroe or other chains that always find more things they want you to pay to repair. Dave's will let you know how your car looks and tell you what they think about your car and if anything does look on the verge of failing they'll let you decide if you want to do it now, down the road, somewhere else, or at not all. Completely pressure-free and a great experience all around. Going to miss it when we move out of state.

Dave's is a trustworthy garage. I feel safe going there, and know that any issues repaired or…read morediscovered will be handled in an appropriate manner. I don't feel overcharged which is one issue with many garages. They get the work done in a reasonable amount of time. The only issue I've had is there are no appointments, so you just drop your car off the night before or in the morning and they call you when it is done. This could be inconvenient if you work outside of the area. Dave, the owner is a nice guy and seems to remember you after a few visits and remembers your car. The garage also does used car sales, and rents U-Hauls. I would definitely recommend this garage to anyone in the area that needs work done on their vehicle.

These guys are easy to communicate with, and go above and beyond to provide service to customers…read moreneed automotive repairs. Go here for your tires, inspections, brakes, etc. Thanks!!

Very honest and helpful service when we were in a tough situation with our car after the Lodi…read moreFlood. They checked it out for us and cleaned out the undercarriage and made sure the car was safe for us to drive back to CT. Very reasonable price for all the work they did and the service was very prompt. I highly recommend!!

I had not previously believed that it was possible to have a good time while enduring an oil…read morechange. Wonderful and efficient staff who contagiously enjoy their work.

Completely unreliable and service has gone downhill. It's very overpriced versus competitors. I was…read moreturned away for a NYS safety inspection 4 different times this past week and received multiple excuses: staffing, the system, printer cartridge. The have turned into a last resort option for me based on my experiences.

I searched tires on the website, found the size needed and set an appointment for Sunday morning…read more got there right at 9am and was told they did not have them they only had 1...acted as if maybe his computer was wring and never going in to the shop, informed us they won't be there until Wednesday! we called the Geneva location and spoke with the asst manager who said they have acc to the hub and could get tires in today and would call us back about 11:30. well, the call never came, called them back at 1:30 to get some rude kid on the phije who didn't want to be bothered helping "we can't track the driver" he said; as if I'm some kind of idiot. finally the asst manager calls back, it's now almost 3pm only to say they won't be there until tomorrow. sooooo we wasted the entire day thanks so much! I would never do business with them or recommend them if you are one who cares for good service. the pricing was also not all that competitive

I would give Mavis Discount Tire zero stars if that were an option…read more In late June, I purchased four new tires, an alignment, brakes, and rotors from this location. Less than 17,000 miles later, my front tires had cords showing on the inside, and the rear tires were nearly bald. These tires were rated for 40,000-50,000 miles and were completely destroyed in under half that time. This was caused by a bad alignment done by Mavis. Their own employees acknowledged the uneven wear and confirmed the alignment was clearly off. I was also told by both a front desk employee and a mechanic that I was "sold a sh*t tire that doesn't belong on a full-size truck," which is unbelievable to hear after paying for new tires from a professional shop. Despite acknowledging the issue, they refused to take responsibility without the store manager's approval. The store manager, Ryan, told me he would contact corporate and promised an update by the end of the week. He never called. I had to repeatedly follow up, only to be told there was "no answer yet." Before any resolution was reached, one of the failing front tires blew out while I was driving to work, leaving me stranded on the side of the road with no drivable vehicle and no way to earn income. As a result of the unsafe condition of these tires, my truck later slid off the road and ended up in a ditch, where I was stuck for over six hours and missed an entire day of work. At that point, this situation had gone far beyond inconvenience and became a serious safety issue. After all of this, corporate's solution was to offer 25% off another set of tires, meaning I'm expected to pay again after only getting about 43% of the tire life I paid for, and I would still have to pay for another alignment--despite them acknowledging the original alignment was bad. To make matters worse, Mavis tried to blame the failure on "lack of tire rotation" and claimed vehicles should be realigned every 3-6 months, which is completely unrealistic and clearly an excuse to avoid accountability. No missed rotation causes cords to show or tires to fail this catastrophically in under 17,000 miles. I gave this shop every opportunity to do the right thing. Instead, I was ignored, misled, and left with hundreds of dollars in losses and a vehicle I no longer felt safe driving. If you value your safety, your money, or a shop that stands behind its work, do not go to Mavis Discount Tire in Newark.

Was not able to get the dealership to uphold their promise of fixing the broken windshield they…read moredeliverd my 25k dollar car with like they said they would very disappointed i wouldn't recommend them and don't believe their promises to make fix their mistakes manager bud just plays games and so does David who moved to the Ford dealer down the road

Can not express my gratitude of your service for my car. Always present and everything is taken…read morecare of. Thank you

I recently had a check engine light come on in my 2020 VW Altas Cross Sport (Event July 9, 2025)…read more My dealership couldn't get my car in until the end of August. I called Select Euro Cars that same day and they were able to get my car in that afternoon and diagnosis the issues. They brought me back to my car and showed me all the issues that were found, they explained all the next steps and what I could expect for cost. Three days later I was able to pick up my car all fixed (Running beautifully). July 21st, another issue came up with my car. I called them first thing in the morning and had my car towed to them. They inspected my car found the issue resulting from the original issue and took care of it cost free. I already have my car back (What a Stress free Experience) The staff is great, from the owner, management, to leader technician, and all other staff they came in contact with during experiences. 10/10 recommend

Bought a truck from their website, site unseen. They were very supportive - lots of pictures…read moresupplied, free Carfax, what repairs/service they did, good price and held for 30 days me to get there to pick up on a Sunday ! ! ! Joel (owner) was actual person I dealt with. Would buy again from them and highly recommend them.

Staff is very friendly and easy to talk to, our part came in good condition and on time. They made…read morethe process easy an was really helpful in finding all parts I needed

We are new to the area. I have a Jeep Cherokee that needed service. Dave got right back to me and…read morewithin a day called and let me know what needed to be fixed. Dave was great in that he was completely transparent if we had further questions or wanted to come in and he could give us a better understanding of what needed fixing. We felt the price while not a small fix was very appropriate for the work that was done. We will be using First Choice Auto for any further mechanical needs!! Thanks Dave!