Cancel

Open app

Search

Montauk Catering

5.0 (1 review)
Closed • 7:00 am - 11:30 pm

Request a quote

Response time

6 hours

Response rate

100%

Services - Montauk Catering

Catering

Personal chefs

Montauk Catering Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Montauk Catering

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

4 years ago

Helpful 60
Thanks 0
Love this 62
Oh no 1

Ask the Community - Montauk Catering

You might also consider

Silver Spoon Specialties

Silver Spoon Specialties

(16 reviews)

We had to replan our entire June wedding due to Covid so we went with an intimate backyard wedding…read moreand the one thing we knew was extremely important to us was the food and service options. When we came across Silver Spoon and spoke to the owner Jeanine, I knew we wanted to use their service for our special day. She was kind and comforting on the phone while being the upmost professional. Not to mention how many emails we exchanged (large part from myself being a bride) just made the experience leading up to the big day that much more appreciated. As for the food everything was wonderful we did a menu more like a bbq and added lobster rolls to the mix (I love lobster & husband loves bbq) but the number one thing on their menu that I still crave is their jalapeño honey butter corn bread! Seriously need to try it if you can. The Team! I cannot say enough about the team they were so sweet and so accommodating, flexible and just made you really feel like we hired the right people to do the right job. I am in the customer service industry and I was beyond pleased with each and every one of them. We hired a Bartender, two wait staff and a chef all of them have the best personalities and just made you feel the way you need to at your wedding. Jeanine - one thing to never let go of is your team with how wonderful the food was they really took the cake on presenting your company and services on a very special day. All in all I would book Silver Spoon for any event small or large in the future without hesitation!

FABULOUS food and a seamless transition when we had to move the party indoors due to rain. The team…read morewas incredibly professional and willing to do anything to help -- they were on time and even cleaned up without me even noticing! Highly recommend Silver Spoon Specialties for any event! A+++

Stuart's Seafood Market

Stuart's Seafood Market

(89 reviews)

$$

There are still a few things that remain as good as before, but my favorite award winning Stuart's…read moreNew England Clam Chowder is NOT one of them. It is tasteless and watery. No creamy lusciousness. No herby clammy umami. They sell clam juice. They should use it. I bought it, tasted it, added everything I could think of to make it taste like something but nada. Didn't mention It's watery? Zero clam taste? There are clams for sure, but I doubt they are fresh. Ps I hate potatoes in my soup. It's a cheap lazy way to add bulk, but red potatoes??? After tasting it, I was so mad that I thought to go back and nicely tell them to stop cutting corners as this will only lead to the closure of yet another failed biz, but instead I threw it out. These owners own a few places out here. Why would u mess with tried and true recipes? You have to spend money to make money. Sell less junk! Keep the good stuff we loyal patrons come back for over and again! Hey guys, read the room! We r a beach community filled with local fisherman and seafood lovers. Don't mess with perfection. It won't end well!

Friends wanted to have a clam bake experience and being a novice, I got a great recommendation to…read moreuse Stuart. Krystal was great! She helped me navigate how much we would need and the best part- they cook we eat! The lobsters were delicate and not overcooked and the clams; I'm not a big clam person but I devoured more than my fair share for sure. We also got a container of their garlic butter OMG. By the end of the meal we were all doing butter shots! Thank you Stuart's for a fab experience.

Catering by A Small Affair - Our reception, A Small Affair designed this look for our wedding at Bedell Cellars (Floral design by Karen Lenahan)

Catering by A Small Affair

(7 reviews)

John & Nikki.. I honestly don't know where to begin. First and foremost, with all the choices that…read morewe made during the process of planning our wedding on the North Fork, choosing our caterer was easy. We were deciding between a few caterers and had a tasting with the Perry's that just sealed the deal. My (now) husband and I walked out of there saying it felt like we just had lunch with our aunt & uncle, it felt like we had known them that long! They are two amazingly warm people -- of course it helps that John is incredibly organized and good at his job and that Nikki makes the most delicious bites. We devoured every little last bite at that tasting.. Nothing went to waste! John was so helpful with everything leading up to the day of as well, from picking out rentals, to working out our timeline. We decided to have a different format (cocktail stations as opposed to a formal sit-down dinner) and working together, John helped us make sure we'd have a smooth flow and that everything would go off without a hitch. As we were working out the details with the rentals, I never felt like he was pushing me one way or the other -- even when he put together the list of kitchen items they'd need (my venue did not provide any set-up), I knew he was being careful about not over-ordering. I really felt like he had my best interests in mind at all times. Having him to coordinate all the details made me feel at ease.. I knew I was in good hands! On our actual wedding day, we were so well taken care of. The staff made sure we were eating (haha, doesn't always happen at weddings!) and everything ran so smoothly. Later in the evening, a very traumatic family emergency happened during the reception that put a frightening pause on the celebration. John was a rock and I really felt like I looked to him for the "What now?" John & Nikki were different from some of our other vendors with whom we'll probably not be in touch again. I feel like we'll be sending John & Nikki Christmas cards for years to come.. :) They embraced us and made us feel like family, and I'm certain they will you too.

Wonderful from start to finish. John and Nikki were the perfect hosts for our wedding. When I first…read moresaw the lovely way that they had transformed the loft space into a welcoming/beautiful environment - I knew that all would be well- and it was. John, Nikki, and the staff of A Small Affair are professional, attentive, and easy to work with. My guests and my husband and I were thrilled with the whole "affair". Food was delicious, well prepared and presented. Staff were helpful and considerate. Call these people- you will be happy with your choice.

Montauk Catering - catering - Updated June 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...